Secondary Logo

Institutional members access full text with Ovid®

Share this article on:

Nonoperative Treatment of Herniated Lumbar Intervertebral Disc with Radiculopathy: An Outcome Study

SAAL, JEFFREY A., MD; SAAL, JOEL S., MD

Original Article: PDF Only

The functional outcome of patients with lumbar herniated nucleus pulposus without significant stenosis was analyzed in a retrospective cohort study. Inclusion criteria were as follows: 1) a chief complaint of leg pain, primarily; 2) a positive straight leg raising (SLR) at less than 60° reproducing the leg pain; 3) a computed tomography (CT) scan demonstrating a hemiated nucleus pulposus without significant stenosis by a radiologist's reading, which was also confirmed by the authors; 4) a positive electromyogram (EMG) demonstrating evidence of radiculopathy; and 5) response to a follow-up questionnaire. All patients had undergone an aggressive physical rehabilitation program consisting of back school and stabilization exercise training. Of a total of 347 consecutively identified patients, 64 patients with an average follow-up time of 31.1 months met the inclusion criteria and constituted the study population. They were sent questionnaires that inquired about activity level, pain level, work status, and further medical care. The patients with neurologic loss, extruded discs, and those seeking a second opinion regarding surgery were identified and subgrouped. Results for the total group included 90% good or excellent outcome with a 92% return to work rate. For the subgroups with extruded discs and second opinions, 87% and 83% had good or excellent outcomes, respectively, all (100%) of whom returned to work. Sick leave time for these subgroups was 2.9 months (±1.4 months) and 3.4 months (±1.7 months), respectively. These results compared favorably with previously published surgical studies. Four of six patients who required surgery were found to have stenosis at operation. There was no statistically significant difference in outcome in the patients with neurologic weakness or with extruded discs from the total study population. This study demonstrates that herniated nucleus pulposus of a lumbar intervertebral disc with radiculopathy can be treated very successfully with aggressive nonoperative care. Surgery should be reserved for those patients for whom function cannot be satisfactorily improved by a physical rehabilitation program. Failure to respond to nonoperative care should suggest the presence of stenosis.

From the San Francisco Spine Institute at Seton Medical Center, and the SpineCare Medical Group, Daly City, California

© Lippincott-Raven Publishers.