First responder performance in pediatric trauma: A comparison with an adult cohort* : Pediatric Critical Care Medicine

Journal Logo

Online Clinical Investigations

First responder performance in pediatric trauma: A comparison with an adult cohort*

Bankole, Sunday MD; Asuncion, Arsenia MD; Ross, Steven MD; Aghai, Zubair MD; Nollah, Laura MS; Echols, Heather MS, MPH; Da-Silva, Shonola MD, MBA

Author Information
Pediatric Critical Care Medicine 12(4):p e166-e170, July 2011. | DOI: 10.1097/PCC.0b013e3181f36f6e



Is the prehospital care of injured children comparable with adult standards? This question has been asked repeatedly by many clinicians, yet there are no definite answers.


To evaluate the prehospital care provided by first responders to pediatric patients (<12 yrs of age) with head injury compared with the adult group (>12 yrs of age) to determine whether the emergency medical services providers are able to adequately assess the children and provide emergency services comparable with adult standards.

Patients and Methods: 

A retrospective 4-yr review of pediatric (n = 102) and adult (n = 99) patients with head injury and Glasgow coma scale score <15 who were treated at a level 1 trauma center. Emergency medical service interventions such as intravenous access, endotracheal intubation, and fluid resuscitation were reviewed. Patients who required further intervention on arrival at the trauma center either from nonperformance of a required procedure or complications arising from such procedures were documented.

Main Results: 

There were 102 pediatric and 99 adult patients included in the final analysis. Injury severity based on Glasgow coma scale score was not different between the groups. A total of 91 patients, 52 adults (52.5%) and 39 children (38.2%), needed endotracheal intubation at the scene. Significantly more pediatric patients had problems with intubation, 27 children (69.2%) vs. 11 adults (21.2%), p < .001.

Intravenous access was successfully established in 85.9% of adults compared to 65.7% in children at the scene (p = .001). Consequently, on arrival at the trauma center, more children required intravenous access, 80.4% compared with 63.6% for adults (p = .011). As a result, more children (25.5%) required initial or additional fluid bolus at the trauma center compared with adults (9.1%, p = .003).


Prehospital care of children is suboptimal compared with adults in areas of endotracheal intubation, establishment of peripheral intravenous access, and fluid resuscitation.

©2011The Society of Critical Care Medicine and the World Federation of Pediatric Intensive and Critical Care Societies

Full Text Access for Subscribers:

You can read the full text of this article if you:

Access through Ovid