Letter to Editor:
Facial expressions of pain facilitate social communication and are often incorporated in clinical pain assessments, including in patients with acute and chronic pain,4,23 infants,25 critically ill nonverbal patients,20 and cognitively impaired patients.19 Researchers have begun using criteria such as the Facial Action Coding System8 to systematically measure facial responses to pain in the laboratory and clinic. Kunz et al.15 recently performed a much-needed systematic review of this field, which highlights a promising consistency across published data sets. The authors comprehensively reviewed facial movements based on Facial Action Coding System and identified 4 main clusters of action units that occur most frequently and move more in pain conditions compared with baseline in acute and chronic pain: AU4 (brow lower), AU6_7 (cheek raise/lid tighten), AU9_10 (nose wrinkle/lip raise), and AU25_26_27 (opening of the mouth). This provides key regions of interest for medical providers and future studies to analyze when assessing pain. Importantly, the authors also acknowledge variability in the coactivation of these units across studies, and ultimately advise that doctors evaluate pain expression on an individual basis.
The systematic review also highlights a more unfortunate area of consistency within the field of facial expression research, which is potential sample homogeneity and omission of important demographic information. Eighty-seven percent of the articles in the review were conducted in either Canada or Germany. Although most articles reported the age and sex of their samples, nearly all articles omitted information on race and ethnicity, leaving open the question of whether the findings reflect facial expressions of pain in White males and females from Canada and Germany, or people in general. Only 3 articles mentioned anything pertaining to ethnic or cultural background5,21,22 or socioeconomic status21 and none evaluated the potential influence of these factors or intersectional identity in statistical analyses. It is particularly important to consider the role of ethnicity in clinical and basic research because ethnic minorities experience increased pain in laboratory14 and clinical settings,1,3 increased postoperative pain,18 and receive decreased care.17,24 For example, Black American patients experience increased pain and receive less opioid treatment compared with White Americans after motor vehicle collisions.2 If pain researchers do not include sample demographics in publications, we run the risk of perpetuating disparities and building a science of pain based on homogeneous samples.
Although researchers have begun to look for mechanisms underlying health inequities in pain,6,12,16 a lack of diverse samples and over‐reliance on White stimulus sets has limited researchers' ability to evaluate whether facial expressions or their assessment contribute to disparities in pain. One recent study found that White participants require more evidence to recognize pain in Black American faces compared with White American faces.16 This in-group bias parallels a large literature on biased emotion perception in the United States9 and directly links with the pain disparities mentioned above. Furthermore, it is still unknown if there are cultural or ethnic differences in the expression of pain. Recent evidence indicates cultural differences in the association between facial responses and basic emotions,13 despite long-held assumptions that emotional expressions are universal.7 Pain researchers should increase efforts to include ethnically and culturally diverse samples to evaluate whether similar variations are seen in pain expressions.
We feel that the review by Kunz et al.15 highlights the need for pain researchers to (1) collect diverse samples in studies of facial responses and other pain assessments, (2) report sample demographics, and (3) formally consider ethnic and cultural influences on pain and pain-related responses. If we continue to use homogeneous samples, we are likely to introduce further biases in pain assessments, particularly as we become more dependent on automated technology and algorithms.11 Such biases have already been documented in image-based assessments in other fields,26 including medical decision-making,10 and we fear it is only a matter of time before they are identified in automated tools for pain. However, if we train these new algorithms with diverse samples, then we have the opportunity to create machines that exhibit less bias than humans. This is a critical period and we urge the research community to note these gaps, report sample demographics, and avoid homogeneous studies that may further the crisis of health disparities in pain.
Conflict of interest statement
The authors have no conflict of interest to declare.
This work was supported by the Intramural Research Program of NIH's National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health.
. Anderson KO, Green CR, Payne R. Racial and ethnic disparities in pain: causes and consequences of unequal care. J Pain 2009;10:1187–204.
. Beaudoin FL, Gutman R, Zhai W, Merchant RC, Clark MA, Bollen KA, Hendry P, Kurz MC, Lewandowski C, Pearson C, O'Neil B, Datner E, Mitchell P, Domeier R, McLean SA. Racial differences in presentations and predictors of acute pain after motor vehicle collision. PAIN 2018;159:1056–63.
. Campbell CM, Edwards RR. Ethnic differences in pain and pain management. Pain Manag 2012;2:219–30.
. Chapman CR, Casey KL, Dubner R, Foley KM, Gracely RH, Reading AE. Pain measurement: an overview. PAIN 1985;22:1–31.
. Craig KD, Hyde SA, Patrick CJ. Genuine, suppressed and faked facial behavior during exacerbation of chronic low back pain. PAIN 1991;46:161–71.
. Drwecki BB, Moore CF, Ward SE, Prkachin KM. Reducing racial disparities in pain treatment: the role of empathy and perspective-taking. PAIN 2011;152:1001–6.
. Ekman P, Friesen WV. Constants across cultures in the face and emotion. J Pers Soc Psychol 1971;17:124–9.
. Ekman PE, Friesen WV. Facial action coding system. Palo Alto: Consulting Psychologists Press, 1987.
. Elfenbein HA, Ambady N. Is there an in-group advantage in emotion recognition? Psychol Bull 2002;128:243–9.
. Esteva A, Kuprel B, Novoa RA, Ko J, Swetter SM, Blau HM, Thrun A. Dermatologist-level classification of skin cancer with deep neural networks. Nature 2017;542:115–18.
. Hammal Z, Cohn JF. Automatic, objective and efficient measurement of pain using automated face analysis. In: Vervoort T, Karos K, Trust Z, Prkachin K, editors. Social and interpersonal dynamics in pain. Cham: Springer, 2018. pp. 121–46.
. Hoffman KM, Trawalter S, Axt JR, Oliver MN. Racial bias in pain assessment and treatment recommendations, and false beliefs about biological differences between blacks and whites. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 2016;113:4296–301.
. Jack RE, Garrod OG, Yu H, Caldara R, Schyns PG. Facial expressions of emotion are not culturally universal. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2012;19:7241–4.
. Kim HJ, Yang GS, Greenspan JD, Downton KD, Griffith KA, Renn CL, Johantgen M, Dorsey SG. Racial and ethnic differences in experimental pain sensitivity: systematic review and meta-analysis. PAIN 2017;158:194–211.
. Kunz M, Meixner D, Lautenbacher S. Facial muscle movements encoding pain—a systematic review. PAIN 2019;160:535–49.
. Mende-Siedlecki P, Qu-Lee J, Backer R, Van Bavel JJ. Perceptual contributions to racial bias in pain recognition. J Exp Psychol Gen. Available at: https://psyarxiv.com/xkufm/
. Accessed 21 February 2019.
. Mossey JM. Defining racial and ethnic disparities in pain management. Clin Orthop Relat Res 2011;469:1859–70.
. Ng B, Dimsdale JE, Rollnik JD, Shapiro H. The effect of ethnicity on prescriptions for patient-controlled analgesia for post-operative pain. PAIN 1996;66:9–12.
. Oosterman JM, Zwakhalen S, Sampson EL, Kunz M. The use of facial expressions for pain assessment purposes in dementia: a narrative review. Neurodegener Dis Manag 2016;6:119–31.
. Payen JF, Bru O, Bosson JL, Lagrasta A, Novel E, Deschaux I, Lavagne P, Jacquot C. Assessing pain in critically ill sedated patients by using a behavioral pain scale. Crit Care Med 2001;29:2258–63.
. Prkachin KM, Solomon PE. The structure, reliability and validity of pain expression: evidence from patients with shoulder pain. PAIN 2008;139:267–74.
. Rahu MA, Grap MJ, Cohn JF, Munro CL, Lyon DE, Sessler CN. Facial expression as an indicator of pain in critically ill intubated adults during endotracheal suctioning. Am J Crit Care 2013;22:412–22.
. Teske K, Daut RL, Cleeland CS. Relationships between nurses' observations and patients' self-reports of pain. PAIN 1983;16:289–96.
. Todd KH, Samaroo N, Hoffman JR. Ethnicity as a risk factor for inadequate emergency department analgesia. JAMA 1993;269:1537–9.
. von Baeyer CL, Spagrud LJ. Systematic review of observational (behavioral) measures of pain for children and adolescents aged 3 to 18 years. PAIN 2007;127:140–50.
. Zou J, Schiebinger L. AI can be sexist and racist—it's time to make it fair. Nature 2018;559:324–6.