Eric Rosenthal Reports

Thoughts and observations about issues, trends, and controversies in the cancer community.

Sunday, April 13, 2014

AACR Presents First ‘Junior Champion in Cancer Research Award’ to High School Student for Work Investigating Her Own Cancer

SAN DIEGO -- The American Association for Cancer Research, which has long supported young cancer researchers, honored an even younger one, a high school senior, with its first “AACR Junior Champion in Cancer Research Award” at this year’s Annual Meeting here.


Elana Simon, an 18-year-old survivor of fibrolamellar hepatocellular carcinoma, was recognized for her role in studying her own rare cancer that resulted in a paper she coauthored in Science (2014; 343:1010-1014).


Diagnosed at age 12 after more than a year of frustrating misdiagnoses including lactose intolerance, Crohn’s disease, appendicitis, and stress, Simon was successfully treated through surgery at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center by Pediatric Surgical Service Chief Michael P. La Quaglia, MD, another coauthor of the study that found a gene flaw involved in the rare liver cancer, which is diagnosed in only about 200 young adults worldwide each year.


The genetic flaw she helped discover was a break that fused part of one gene to part of another one, causing a chimeric RNA transcript and protein. This abnormal protein was found in all 15 tumors studied, but not in normal liver tissue, suggesting that it might fuel cancer growth, according to the paper.


The team that studied the genetic flaw was spearheaded by Simon, now a senior at the Dalton School in New York, who had been inspired by a sophomore year internship at a laboratory at Mount Sinai Hospital that used her computer science skills to help sort genetic mutation data for pancreatic cancer.


The team included Simon; La Quaglia; gene specialists from the New York Genome Center (NYGC); her father, Sanford M. Simon, PhD, Professor and Head of Rockefeller University’s Cellular Biophysics Laboratory; members of his lab; and another survivor who preferred not to be identified.


Elana Simon was “co-first” author with Joshua N. Honeyman, MD, a pediatric oncology surgery fellow from MSKCC working in the Simon lab, and NYGC’s Nicolas Robine, PhD, with Sanford Simon serving as senior author.


During an interview at the AACR meeting I met with Elana, as well as her father and mother, Rachael Migler, a writer.


Her older brother Joel did not travel west from Carnegie Mellon, where he is an undergraduate, but when he was just 15 he apparently posed some interesting insights into approaching Elana’s treatment, and will be a coauthor with his father and others on another scientific paper.


Elana was keynote speaker at AACR’s “Special Program for High School Students: The Conquest of Cancer and the Next Generation of Cancer Researchers.”


She received her AACR Junior Champion award at the conference’s opening plenary session, which featured a video of her story.


She said that when she applied to work in the Mount Sinai lab to sequence genes she did not let anyone there know that she was a cancer survivor or that her father was a scientist.


Nor did her father or mother have any idea that their daughter was involved in cancer research. It turned out that since she was so busy with various extracurricular activities she was able to use dance as a cover for her cancer research.


Sanford Simon said when a teacher told him how well his daughter was doing on her school project, he immediately assumed it involved her dancing, and only learned then of her time in the lab. “I was so proud,” he said, adding that he wanted to respect his daughter’s space.


Elana said that she was initially reluctant to work in her dad’s lab at Rockefeller University because she didn’t want to appear to be there because of familial ties. But when she thought about using her computer skills to sequence the rare cancer she began working in the Simon Laboratory, as well as with La Quaglia and colleagues from NYGC, who genetically mapped the samples.


She said she reasoned that it would be easier to identify genetic mutations in the tumors of young patients rather than older ones since the genome would be altered by years of aging and environmental factors. Since no cancer registry was available for fibrolamellar hepatocellular carcinoma, La Quaglia provided samples from other patients and Elana used social media to reach out to other patient groups.


Funding was provided by the Fibrolamellar Cancer Foundation (FCF) as well as individual donors touched by the disease, with additional support from the Howard Hughes Medical Institute, NYGC, Rockefeller University’s Center for Clinical and Translational Science, and through an anonymous gift to Rockefeller University. Sanford Simon now serves as Chairman of FCF’s Scientific Advisory Board.


Research is continuing at the Simon lab to test the effects of the chimera on human liver cells and mouse livers. The Simons are also setting up a patient registry, and Elana and another young survivor are featured in a video explaining why they are involved in recruiting patients.


The Simons said that within 36 hours after the Science article was published they received confirmation of the same sequence from researchers at Washington University, and later from the University of Washington and Stanford University.


“I’m totally thrilled with the cancer research community’s cooperation,” Sanford Simon said. “It had the feeling of a community of people.”


He said that earlier this year he received a call from AACR 2013-2014 President Charles L. Sawyers, MD, whose lab at Sloan Kettering is across the street from Rockefeller. “Charles said that he saw Elana’s interview on Wall Street Journal Live and thought she’d be a good role model for other kids. He called me first because he didn’t want to overwhelm her or seem as if he were taking advantage.”


When Sawyers called Elana he asked if she would be interested in talking in front of a large audience about research and the importance of investing in it, according to Elana, who said there was no mention of a special award at that time.


Elana told OT that for years following her diagnosis and surgery she had pushed being a cancer survivor out of her life. “When people asked about my big scar I’d tell them it was from a shark bite because I didn’t want them to pity me,” she said. “I wanted the scar to go away and bought as much scar tape as I could.”


But a summer at Camp Simcha, a Jewish-run camp for children with cancer and other hematologic illnesses helped transform her into a proud survivor.


“I no longer felt like a victim and came to accept my scar,” she said, writing her college essay about how the camp helped her accept her scar.


And that essay contributed to her acceptance at Harvard University, where she will start in the fall, expecting to major in computer science.


San Diego, CA - The AACR 2014 Annual Meeting -  Award Presentations During Opening Ceremony at the American Association for Cancer Research Annual Meeting here today, Sunday April 6, 2014. More than 18,000 physicians, researchers, health care professionals, cancer survivors and patient advocates are expected to attend the meeting at the San Diego Convention Center. The Annual Meeting highlights the latest findings in all major areas of cancer research from basic through clinical and epidemiological studies.  Photo by © AACR/Todd Buchanan 2014 Technical Questions:
Photos: AACR 2014/Todd Buchanan