For the first time, a team of international researchers have mapped the family trees of cancer cells in acute myeloid leukemia (AML) to understand how this blood cancer responds to a new drug, enasidenib (Nat Med 2018; doi:10.1038/s41591-018-0115-6). The work also explains what happens when a patient stops responding to the treatment, providing important clues about how to combine enasidenib with other anti-cancer drugs to produce longer-lasting remissions and to prevent relapse.
AML is the most common and aggressive blood cancer in adults and is incurable in most patients. About 12-15 percent of AML patients have a mutation in the IDH2 gene that stops bone marrow cells from differentiating, or maturing, into blood cells that are required for life. Instead these immature cells accumulate in the bone marrow and blood, which is a hallmark of AML. Previous research from the same team showed that enasidenib prompts blood cell differentiation and restores normal blood cell production (Science 2013; doi:10.1126/science.1234769).
A phase I/II clinical trial showed that the drug was effective in 40 percent of AML patients with an IDH2 mutation who had failed previous treatments. and this led to the FDA giving approval for enasidenib in 2017. However, after an average of nearly 9 months, the cancer returned in these patients.
“Enasidenib is an important new treatment. However, the initial studies did not show which AML cells responded to enasidenib and started to differentiate again. It was also unclear how the cells become resistant to therapy,” said Stéphane de Botton, MD, a physician in the Haematology Department at Gustave Roussy. “We wanted to answer these questions.”
Using samples from 37 patients in the trial who had responded to enasidenib, the team looked at markers on the surface of the bone marrow cells to identify the different populations of bone marrow cells from the immature, undifferentiated cells, called progenitor cells, through to mature, differentiated cells.
“You can imagine the bone marrow as an assembly line that constantly needs to produce mature blood cells,” said co-author Lynn Quek, MD, MRC clinician scientist and consultant hematologist at the MRC Weatherall Institute of Molecular Medicine. “In a patient before treatment, this assembly line becomes blocked. Using specialist techniques, we studied bone marrow cells from patients to find out how the bone marrow assembly line becomes blocked and how enasidenib helps to promote differentiation to unblock the assembly line.”
As AML is caused by errors in DNA sequence, or mutations, in blood cells, the team studied the genetic makeup of AML cells. They found that AML cells from the same patient can be grouped into families which share genetic mutations, called clones. Cells belonging to the same clone or family come from the same ancestor cell. Understanding how clones relate to each other is important as they provide information as to how the AML started in the first place.
“When an AML patient has a bone marrow test, we are taking a snapshot of the family tree of leukemia cells,” noted Quek. “As we treat the AML, there are shifts in the family dynamics as some clones will die and others will grow. In every cancer, there are several families or clones of cancer cells. In AML, we were able to see how these responded to enasidenib. We used techniques to study genetic mutations on a cell-by-cell basis and re-constructed the family tree of a patient's AML. We then tracked changes in the family of AML cells as they responded to enasidenib and as patients lost response to the drug. This is the first time that anyone has done such a detailed study at a single cell level. As enasidenib is a new anti-leukemic drug, it was vital to understand the effects of the drug on leukemic cells.”
Co-author, Virginie Penard-Lacronique, MD, Research Director and team leader at the Inserm unit at Gustave Roussy, noted: “We have provided genetic proof that enasidenib was able to differentiate cancer cells so that some of their normal functions were restored, even though they still contained the IDH2 mutation. This is important because unless we can track these clones, we don't know whether the mature cells in a patient are coming from normal cells after all the cancer cells have been killed or from leukemic cells that are now able to mature. In this paper, we show that in four out of five cases, the mature cells are coming from leukemic bone marrow cells that can be induced to differentiate by this new drug.”
The cancer returned in almost all the patients in the clinical trial, and the team was able to show for the first time that the leukemic cells stop responding to enasidenib when some of the clones develop additional mutations. These new sub-clones are resistant to enasidenib, providing clues about the mechanism of drug resistance. This may help in designing future therapy trials to overcome therapy resistance. It may also mean that enasidenib needs to be combined with other anti-cancer drugs to prevent relapse, and clinical trials have already started investigating whether patients respond to these combinations, for how long, and whether they are likely to relapse.
“Enasidenib a very good example of a modern cancer therapy that specifically targets principally cancer cells, sparing normal cells, and in this regard is very safe and has limited side effects,” de Botton concluded. “Now that we have shown that it needs to be combined with other drugs to stop the cancer returning, we think that it's important that the combination therapy should be given to AML patients early on in their disease. International trials are now taking place comparing combinations of enasidenib and other drugs with the normal standard of care.”
Paresh Vyas, MD, Professor of Haematology and lead of the Oxford team, pointed out: “The approach we have implemented can be applied to any cancer and to any therapy to understand how any drug attacks each clone in a cancer and how different clones respond to therapy. This makes it a very powerful approach to improve our understanding of how to achieve better outcomes from cancer therapy.”