Secondary Logo

Maternal Adverse Childhood Experiences, Family Strengths, and Chronic Stress in Children

Condon, Eileen M.; Holland, Margaret L.; Slade, Arietta; Redeker, Nancy S.; Mayes, Linda C.; Sadler, Lois S.

doi: 10.1097/NNR.0000000000000349
FEATURE ARTICLES
Free

Background Researchers have demonstrated that maternal adverse childhood experiences (ACEs), such as abuse and neglect, are associated with prenatal risk factors and poor infant development. However, associations with child physiologic and health outcomes, including biomarkers of chronic or “toxic” stress, have not yet been explored.

Objectives The purpose of this study was to examine the associations among past maternal experiences, current maternal posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) symptoms, and children's indicators of exposure to chronic stress in a multiethnic sample of mothers and children at early school age (4 to 9 years).

Methods This cross-sectional study included maternal–child dyads (N = 54) recruited from urban community health centers in New Haven, Connecticut. Mothers reported history of ACEs, family strengths, and current PTSD symptoms. Child measures included biomarkers and health and developmental outcomes associated with chronic stress. Correlational and regression analyses were conducted.

Results Childhood trauma in mothers was associated with higher systolic blood pressure percentile (ρ = .29, p = .03) and behavioral problems (ρ = .47, p = .001) in children, while maternal history of family strengths was associated with lower salivary interleukin (IL)-1β (ρ = −.27, p = .055), salivary IL-6 (ρ = −.27, p = .054), and body mass index z-scores (ρ = −.29, p = .03) in children. Maternal PTSD symptoms were associated with more child behavioral problems (ρ = .57, p < .001) and higher odds of asthma history (ρ = .30, p = .03).

Discussion Results indicate that past maternal experiences may have important influences on a child's health and affect his or her risk for experiencing toxic stress.

Eileen M. Condon, PhD, APRN, FNP-BC, is Postdoctoral Fellow, Yale School of Nursing, Orange, Connecticut.

Margaret L. Holland, PhD, MPH, MS, is Associate Research Scientist, Yale School of Nursing, Orange, Connecticut.

Arietta Slade, PhD, is Clinical Professor, Yale Child Study Center, New Haven, Connecticut.

Nancy S. Redeker, PhD, RN, FAHA, FAAN, is Professor, Yale School of Nursing and Yale School of Medicine, New Haven, Connecticut.

Linda C. Mayes, MD, is Professor and Chair, Yale Child Study Center, New Haven, Connecticut.

Lois S. Sadler, PhD, RN, FAAN, Professor, Yale School of Nursing and Yale Child Study Center, New Haven, Connecticut.

Accepted for publication September 11, 2018.

The authors would like to thank Andrea Miller for her assistance with recruitment and data collection and the Yale School of Nursing Biobehavioral Laboratory for providing necessary resources.

The authors also thank the families who participated in this study for contributing their time and expertise.

The research reported in this publication was supported by the National Institute of Nursing Research of the National Institutes of Health under award number F31NR016385. This work was also supported by the NAPNAP Foundation, the Connecticut Nurses Foundation, the Jonas Nurse Leaders Scholars Program, and the Alpha Nu chapter of Sigma Theta Tau International.

The Yale University institutional review board approved all research reported in this manuscript.

The authors have no conflicts of interest to report.

Corresponding author: Eileen M. Condon, PhD, APRN, FNP-BC, Yale School of Nursing, 400 West Campus Drive, Orange, CT 06477 (e-mail: Eileen.Condon@yale.edu).

Adverse childhood experiences (ACEs), including abuse, neglect, and household dysfunction, are alarmingly common. Almost half (45%) of all children in the United States have experienced at least one ACE, and the prevalence is even higher among Black (61%) and Hispanic (51%) children (Sacks & Murphey, 2018). Adverse childhood experiences not only disrupt childhood and adolescence but are also associated with increased health risks across the lifespan, including obesity, diabetes, smoking, substance abuse, cancer, and heart disease (Felitti et al., 1998; Hughes et al., 2017).

To further add to these concerns, researchers have recently demonstrated that the effects of ACEs may extend to subsequent generations. For example, maternal experiences of childhood maltreatment are associated with prenatal risk factors, including depressive symptoms and psychosocial difficulties, increased risk for entering pregnancy with a chronic health condition, and increased risky behaviors during pregnancy like smoking, alcohol use, and illicit drug use (Chung et al., 2010; McDonnell & Valentino, 2016; Racine, Madigan, Plamondon, McDonald, & Tough, 2018). Maternal ACEs are associated with poor outcomes among children, including decreased birth weight and gestational age; developmental, physical, and emotional health problems during infancy; and developmental concerns during toddlerhood (Folger et al., 2018; Madigan, Wade, Plamondon, Maguire, & Jenkins, 2017; Racine et al., 2018; Smith, Gotman, & Yonkers, 2016; Sun et al., 2017).

The mechanisms linking maternal ACEs with pregnancy and child outcomes remain unclear but may involve biological or psychosocial risk pathways (Madigan et al., 2017). This aligns with the literature on toxic stress and allostatic load, which suggests that exposure to chronic stressors over time may lead to altered development of the brain and multiple physiologic systems and, ultimately, poor mental and physical health throughout the lifespan (Shonkoff et al., 2012). The ecobiodevelopmental model also provides a framework for understanding the connections among a child's ecology (social and physical environment), biology, and health/development (Shonkoff et al., 2012). Primary caregivers represent a critical component of the child's social environment, and thus, caregiver stress related to ACEs may become a source of environmental stress for the child. On the other hand, positive experiences in a caregiver's childhood may protect against the adverse effects of maternal ACEs. For example, childhood family strengths, such as support and cohesion, are associated with less caregiver depression, posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) symptoms, and fewer stressful life events, which may in turn reduce stress experienced by children (Benzies & Mychasiuk, 2009; Narayan, Rivera, Bernstein, Harris, & Lieberman, 2018).

Despite growing evidence of the long-term and intergenerational effects of early childhood experiences, a number of gaps remain in the literature. To our knowledge, with the exception of the birth outcomes discussed above (Smith et al., 2016), associations between maternal ACEs and child physiology and health outcomes have not yet been examined. Maternal PTSD symptoms, which may reflect current manifestations of childhood or cumulative lifetime trauma, have likewise not been examined in association with child physiologic outcomes. Although family strengths are associated with positive psychosocial outcomes, associations with child biology also have not yet been explored.

While stress responses may play a key role in linking maternal history with child health, the best biological indicators of chronic stress in children have not yet been defined (Condon, 2018). Indicators of stress may include primary mediators of the stress response, such as glucocorticoids or cytokines; secondary outcomes of the stress response, including disruptions to immune, metabolic, or cardiovascular functioning; and tertiary endpoints that represent the downstream effects of chronic stress, such as behavioral problems or chronic disease (Condon, 2018). In the current study, we examine feasible, noninvasive measures to represent primary, secondary, and tertiary outcomes across a range of physiologic systems in an effort to encompass the complexity of the stress response and gain insight into the biological pathways linking maternal history with child health.

Back to Top | Article Outline

PURPOSE

In this study, we examine data drawn from a larger exploratory study designed to examine risk and protective factors for toxic stress among low-income, multiethnic families (Condon, Sadley, & Mayes, 2018). The purpose of the current study is to examine associations among past maternal experiences (ACEs and family strengths), current maternal PTSD symptoms, and child indicators of exposure to chronic stress in a multiethnic sample of mothers and children (4 to 9 years old; Figure 1). Little is known about the extent to which maternal history influences children's development beyond the prenatal and infancy periods; thus, an examination of the early school age period may provide insight into the long-term effects of exposure to maternal ACEs and family strengths (Condon et al., 2018). With this exploratory approach, our goal is to determine effect sizes and generate hypotheses that will inform future research studies on the intergenerational transmission of stress and protective factors among vulnerable families.

FIGURE 1

FIGURE 1

Back to Top | Article Outline

METHODS

Design, Sample, and Setting

In this cross-sectional study, we recruited participants from the control group arm of Minding the Baby (MTB), a randomized controlled trial (RCT) (ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT01458145) of a home visiting intervention for first-time mothers with risk factors including poverty, history of trauma, or young maternal age (Ordway et al., 2014; Sadler et al., 2013). Participants were eligible for inclusion in the current study if (a) the child was between 4 and 9 years of age at the time of data collection, (b) the child's mother had custody or regular contact with the child, (c) the dyad was residing within the state, and (d) the dyad participated in the control group arm of the MTB RCT. Of 83 families eligible for participation, we recruited 65% (N = 54) and enrolled them in the study. Others could not be reached (n = 13), declined to participate (n = 2), did not meet inclusion criteria (n = 7), or expressed interest but never scheduled a visit (n = 7). For the complete study protocol, see Condon et al. (2018).

Back to Top | Article Outline

Procedures

We obtained institutional review board approval from Yale University prior to data collection. Parents provided informed consent and permission to talk with the child, and children ages 7 to 9 years provided assent (Committee on Bioethics, 1995). Consistent with the original MTB study, dyads were compensated $50 for their time.

Back to Top | Article Outline

Variables and Measures

Maternal History of Childhood Trauma and Family Strengths

We measured past maternal history with the Childhood Trauma Questionnaire (CTQ), a retrospective self-report measure used to identify childhood history of abuse and neglect. The 28-item CTQ includes a total score and five subscales: sexual abuse, physical abuse, emotional abuse, physical neglect, and emotional neglect (Bernstein et al., 1994). Following the methods used by Hillis et al. (2010), an additional subscale assessing family strengths was created by using seven items on the CTQ related to family protective factors (e.g., “I felt loved” and “I had someone to take me to the doctor”). Although this subscale has not yet been validated, it was successfully used to examine protective factors for adolescent pregnancy within the original ACE cohort (Hillis et al., 2010). Internal consistency of the CTQ was high (α = .83–.96).

Back to Top | Article Outline

Maternal PTSD Symptoms

We measured maternal PTSD symptoms with the PTSD Checklist–Civilian Version (PCL-C), a 17-item self-report instrument used to evaluate the presence of PTSD symptoms over the past month (Weathers, Litz, Herman, Huska, & Keane, 1993). Internal consistency of the PCL-C was high (α = .94).

Back to Top | Article Outline

Children's Indicators of Exposure to Chronic Stress

Primary mediators of the stress response
Cortisol

Hair cortisol is a noninvasive indicator of long-term hypothalamic–pituitary–adrenal (HPA) axis activity and neuroendocrine functioning (Meyer, Novak, Hamel, & Rosenberg, 2014). We cut a 3-cm sample of hair from the posterior vertex of the child's scalp to represent systemic cortisol exposure from the past 3 months. Information on hair color, product use, frequency of hair washing, and corticosteroid use was recorded. Hair cortisol was analyzed using a high-sensitivity enzyme immunoassay kit (Meyer et al., 2014).

Back to Top | Article Outline
Inflammatory cytokines

We measured a panel of four proinflammatory cytokines (interleukin [IL]-1 beta, IL-6, IL-8, and tumor necrosis factor-alpha [TNF-α]) with saliva to assess children's immune functioning (Haddad, Saadé, & Safieh-Garabedian, 2002). Saliva was primarily collected using a passive drool device (n = 47), but oral swabs were used when necessary based on developmental capabilities (n = 7). A gross oral exam was conducted prior to saliva collection by the principal investigator (PI), an advanced practice nurse, and notable findings (sores, dental caries, and loose/missing teeth) were recorded (Riis et al., 2016). The cytokine panel was analyzed using a 4-plex electrochemiluminescence immunoassay, and intra-assay coefficients of variability were acceptable (2.8–6.9%).

Back to Top | Article Outline
Secondary outcomes of the stress response
Cardiovascular

Salivary C-reactive protein (CRP) and systolic (SBP) and diastolic (DBP) blood pressure were measured to assess cardiovascular functioning (Cook et al., 2000; Muntner, He, Cutler, Wildman, & Whelton, 2004). Salivary CRP was collected according to the saliva collection methods described above and analyzed via enzyme immunoassay. Blood pressure was measured by the PI with a calibrated manual sphygmomanometer after 5 minutes of rest. Three seated measurements were taken at least 1 minute apart and percentiles were calculated based on age, height, and gender (Bird & Michie, 2008). Efforts were made to obtain salivary and blood pressure measurements at the same time of day for each child to account for diurnal variation.

Back to Top | Article Outline
Anthropometric measurements

Children's height and weight were measured with a calibrated stadiometer and scale. Body mass index (BMI) percentiles and z-scores were determined based on age- and gender-appropriate Centers for Disease Control and Prevention growth charts (Kuczmarski, 2002).

Back to Top | Article Outline
Tertiary endpoints of the stress response
Physical health

Mothers reported on children's health history and healthcare utilization, including chronic illnesses, medication use, and frequency of emergency department visits, injuries/accidents, and hospitalizations.

Back to Top | Article Outline
Behavior and school performance

Child behavior was assessed using age-appropriate parent-report versions of the Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL), a 99-item questionnaire designed to assess total, internalizing (anxious and depressive) and externalizing (aggressive and hyperactive) behavior problems (Achenbach & Ruffle, 2000). Mothers reported on children's school performance using the CBCL academic background section. Cronbach's alpha was high in the current study (α = .90–.95).

Back to Top | Article Outline

Laboratory Procedures

Hair and saliva samples were deidentified and stored in a secure location immediately after collection. Hair samples were stored at room temperature and saliva samples were stored in a subzero freezer at -80 degrees celsius. See Condon et al. (2018) for more information on collection and storage procedures.

Back to Top | Article Outline

Data Analysis

We analyzed all data using SAS 9.4. Data were normally distributed for child BMI, DBP percentile, total behavior problems, and internalizing behaviors. Natural log-transformations were applied to improve the normality of the distributions of salivary cytokines, hair cortisol, and externalizing behavior problems. Distributions of the remaining variables did not improve with transformations.

For all child indicators of toxic stress, two-sample t tests were used to compare differences by child gender, age group, and race/ethnicity. We dichotomized child age into two groups (4–6 years and 7–9 years) based on developmental stage and data distribution. Race/ethnicity was categorized as Hispanic, non-Hispanic Black, and other/mixed race; however, we did not use the other/mixed race group for comparison analyses due to small sample size (n < 5).

Back to Top | Article Outline

Biomarker Analyses

We examined biomarkers for factors that may confound results, such as local oral inflammation or hair-care routines. We used two-sample t tests to compare salivary biomarker levels for children with and without missing teeth, loose teeth, unfilled caries, recent dental work (past 1 week), and other mouth issues (crowns, fillings, and braces). Using two-sample t tests or analysis of variance tests, we compared hair cortisol levels for differences by hair shape (curly, wavy, or straight), color, style, washing frequency, product use, length (if hair <3 cm), and corticosteroid use. Factors associated with significantly different biomarker levels were controlled for in regression analyses.

Back to Top | Article Outline

Missing Biomarker Data

One family chose not to participate in the biomarker portion of the study. We excluded salivary biomarkers for one child due to a diagnosis of streptococcal pharyngitis within 2 days of the research visit, and the laboratory reported that saliva quantity was not sufficient for one child on all salivary biomarkers and for another child on CRP only. Hair samples were not obtained on eight children due to shaved hairstyles and on one child due to parent refusal, and four hair samples were excluded for reported corticosteroid use.

Back to Top | Article Outline

Correlation and Regression Analyses

We used Spearman's rank coefficient (ρ), a nonparametric measure of correlation, to examine associations between the maternal and child variables. Due to the exploratory nature of the study, we did not adjust for multiple hypothesis testing due to the risk of missing an association. For all correlations with a p value of less than .1, regression analyses were conducted with maternal history and PTSD symptoms as the independent variables and child measures as the dependent variables. Simple linear regressions were conducted for continuous dependent variables (biomarkers, BMI, blood pressure, and CBCL), and simple logistic regressions were conducted for dichotomous dependent variables (health history). For dichotomous health and school outcomes, post hoc power analyses indicated a frequency of 25% (n > 13) was necessary to detect associations using logistic regression. Thus, analyses were not conducted where the absolute numbers were very small and calculated effect sizes unlikely to be meaningful; this excluded some health history, healthcare utilization, and academic history variables.

Back to Top | Article Outline

Sample Size and Power

The relationships in this study have not previously been examined, and thus, there was little information from which to estimate effects and statistical power for the sample. On the basis of previous findings of correlations between maternal depression and hair cortisol (r = .22) in a multiethnic sample of young children (n = 297) (Palmer et al., 2013), we expected our correlation analyses to be underpowered (power = .39–.45), based on the available sample. However, the goal of this exploratory study was to examine the size of the correlational effects, rather than to obtain statistically significant effects. Although we considered a p value of .05 to be the significance level for this study, correlations with p values between .05 and .1 are also highlighted, as these effect sizes may be useful for future research.

Back to Top | Article Outline

RESULTS

Fifty-four maternal–child dyads completed data collection (Table 1). Approximately half identified as Hispanic, with Puerto Rican as the most frequently reported ethnic group (n = 21), and half identified as Black or mixed race. Mothers ranged in age from 19 to 33 years, with a mean of 26.8 years (SD = 3.3 years), and mean child age was 6.7 years (SD = 2.1 years). Most mothers were single (68%), and all reported receiving some form of public assistance.

TABLE 1

TABLE 1

Back to Top | Article Outline

Child Indicators of Exposure to Chronic Stress

Descriptive statistics for child indicators of exposure to chronic stress are presented in Table 2. Very few measures were significantly different by child sex, age, or race/ethnicity; of these, none were included in correlations that met criteria for conducting regression analyses (p < .1). For this reason, as well as the small study sample size, we did not adjust for these characteristics in the regression models.

TABLE 2

TABLE 2

Back to Top | Article Outline

Biomarker Confounders

Analyses of salivary biomarkers revealed no significant differences in IL-1β, IL-8, TNF, or CRP levels for children with missing teeth (n = 13), loose teeth (n = 18), unfilled caries (n = 6), recent dental work (n = 5), or other mouth issues (n = 6) compared with children who did not have these characteristics. Significant differences in IL-6 levels were noted in children with unfilled caries (t = 2.34, p = .02) when compared with the rest of the sample, and this was subsequently adjusted for in regression analyses. Hair cortisol levels differed by hair shape (F = 9.49, p = .001) and frequency of hair washing (F = 4.15, p = .008), but correlations including this measure did not meet criteria for conducting regression analyses (p <.1).

Back to Top | Article Outline

Maternal Characteristics

Descriptive statistics for maternal self-report measures are reported in Table 2. For ACEs, mean CTQ subscale scores are presented in Table 2, but this instrument can also be used to evaluate ACEs according to standardized cutoff scores (see Bernstein et al., 1994). Using this method, 18% of mothers reported low to moderate levels of childhood trauma, 22% reported moderate to severe levels, and 15% reported severe to extreme levels. By type of abuse, 28% of mothers reported a history of sexual abuse, 52% reported physical abuse, 48% reported emotional abuse, 33% reported physical neglect, and 43% reported emotional neglect. On the PCL-C, 28% of mothers met Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders criteria for PTSD (Weathers et al., 1993).

Back to Top | Article Outline

Correlations Among Study Variables

Maternal ACEs and Child Indicators of Exposure to Chronic Stress

Higher maternal childhood trauma (CTQ total score) and emotional abuse scores were associated with significantly higher systolic blood pressure percentiles in children (ρ = .29, p = .03 and ρ = .28, p = .04, respectively). Small to moderate effect sizes were detected for associations between maternal childhood trauma (all types) and child total (ρ = .29 to 0.52, p < .001 to .03), internalizing (ρ = .18 to 0.51, p < .001 to 0.2), and log-transformed externalizing (ρ = .23 to .43, p < .001 to .09) behavioral problems.

We found other associations with small but notable effect sizes, including between maternal childhood sexual abuse and log-transformed child IL-6 levels (ρ = .24, p = .09), maternal childhood physical abuse and child history of allergies (ρ = .25, p = .06), and maternal emotional abuse history and child asthma history (ρ = .25, p = .06). Child systolic blood pressure percentiles were associated with higher maternal history of childhood physical abuse (ρ = .25, p = .07) and emotional neglect (ρ = .23, p = .09), and increased child diastolic blood pressure percentiles were associated with higher maternal CTQ total score (ρ = .27, p = .054) and childhood sexual abuse history (ρ = .23, p = .09). Correlations are presented in Table 3 and regression models are presented in Table 4.

TABLE 3

TABLE 3

TABLE 4

TABLE 4

Back to Top | Article Outline

Maternal History of Family Strengths and Child Indicators of Exposure to Chronic Stress

Maternal history of childhood family strengths was associated with significantly lower BMI (ρ = −.29, p = .03) and lower odds of eczema (ρ = −.36, p = .007) in children. Although not statistically significant, greater history of family strengths in mothers was also correlated with lower log-transformed IL-1β (ρ = −.27, p = .055) and log-transformed IL-6 (ρ = −.27, p = .054) levels in their children. Of note, the association between family strengths and log-transformed IL-6 levels became significant when controlling for unfilled dental caries (β = −.87, p = .02) (Table 4).

Back to Top | Article Outline

Maternal PTSD Symptoms and Child Indicators of Exposure to Chronic Stress

Maternal PTSD symptoms were associated with significantly higher CBCL total (ρ = .57, p < .0001), internalizing (ρ = .64, p < .0001), and log-transformed externalizing (ρ = .41, p = .002) behavior scores in children. Maternal PTSD symptoms were also associated with higher odds of child asthma history (ρ = .30, p = .03).

Back to Top | Article Outline

DISCUSSION

The results of this exploratory study suggest that past maternal experiences may influence a child's risk for experiencing toxic stress, as maternal ACEs were associated with higher blood pressure levels and behavioral problems in children, while family strengths were associated with lower BMI and inflammatory markers in children. While the effect sizes detected were generally small, this is consistent with effects detected in other pediatric biomarker studies and reflects the complexity of factors that influence developing physiology (Condon, 2018). Although additional research is needed, these findings indicate that immune and metabolic pathways may be important physiologic mechanisms linking past maternal experiences with child health. Here, we discuss some potential psychosocial pathways through which maternal ACEs and trauma history may lead to increased stress and disrupted physiological development in children.

The results of this study suggest that the influence of maternal ACEs is not limited to the prenatal or infancy period but may continue through preschool and the early school-age years. Maternal history of trauma is associated with use of corporal punishment and hostile-intrusive and frightening parenting behaviors (Chung et al., 2009; Jacobvitz, Leon, & Hazen, 2006); thus, in some cases, mothers with a history of ACEs may themselves become a source of stress for their child. In this way, negative or unpredictable parenting and disrupted maternal–child relationships may be important pathways through which maternal ACEs lead to increased risk for toxic stress responses in children.

Prevention of the negative effects associated with toxic stress requires the presence of a supportive, nurturing caregiver to help buffer stressful experiences for the child (Shonkoff et al., 2012). However, this parental buffering may be very challenging for mothers with unresolved trauma stemming from childhood experiences. Mothers with a history of ACEs may be emotionally unavailable, experience more parenting stress, and exhibit less sensitive parenting and therefore may have difficulty providing a nurturing environment and secure base to encourage healthy child development (Pereira et al., 2012). As these mothers likely experienced toxic stress during their own childhood, they also may be poorly equipped to protect their children from stressful experiences or teach effective coping skills in the presence of stressors.

When pregnant women are exposed to stressful environments, child exposure to toxic stress can begin as early as the prenatal period. However, recent evidence suggests that this may not be limited to only mothers' current stressors; in a study of pregnant women (N = 185), Bublitz, Parade, and Stroud (2014) found that maternal history of severe childhood sexual abuse was associated with increased cortisol awakening response between 25 and 35 weeks of gestation. This suggests that maternal history of ACEs may not only affect children through risky maternal behaviors or a disrupted maternal–child relationship, but through prenatal exposure to mothers' disrupted stress-response systems and altered epigenetic programming (Glover, O'Connell, & O'Donnell, 2010).

Finally, the results of this study also suggest an intergenerational transmission of protective factors in families at risk for toxic stress. Sometimes referred to as “angels in the nursery,” positive childhood experiences may help caregivers to interrupt the cyclical nature of trauma (Lieberman, Padrón, Van Horn, & Harris, 2005). The benefits derived from positive parenting role models or family support may in turn enhance mothers' capacities to help their own children cope with environmental stressors (Benzies & Mychasiuk, 2009). Family strengths may also indicate that mothers experienced less toxic stress during their own childhoods, suggesting less maternal physiological disruption and a healthier prenatal environment for their child's early development.

Future studies that aim to uncover the mechanisms underlying the intergenerational transmission of stress and protective factors will be a critical focus of inquiry with important implications for intervention development (Woods-Jaeger, Cho, Sexton, Slagel, & Goggin, 2018). Examination of extended family members, particularly grandparents, will be an important area of research. Research is also necessary to understand the influence of family strengths and protective factors in the presence of ACEs or trauma, as these may often co-occur within families (Narayan et al., 2018). As research in this area continues to emerge, it is imperative for clinicians and interventionists to consider the influence of maternal ACEs and family strengths on child health and take a two-generation approach when working with vulnerable families (Biglan, Van Ryzin, & Hawkins, 2017). The feasibility and acceptability of screening for parental ACEs have been demonstrated in primary care settings; therefore, routine screening for caregiver ACEs and associated sequelae, as well as referral to interventions that promote family strengths, will likely be a vital approach to preventing intergenerational transmission of trauma, maltreatment, and toxic stress (Gillespie & Folger, 2017).

Back to Top | Article Outline

Strengths and Limitations

This study was strengthened by the use of both subjective and objective indicators of exposure to chronic stress and is one of the first studies to measure hair cortisol and salivary cytokines in ethnic minority children living in stressful environments. As there are currently no standardized pediatric reference ranges for the hair and salivary biomarkers explored in this study, the results of this study make a valuable contribution to biomarker science, especially regarding levels in ethnic minority children with whom biomarker research has been very limited (Gray et al., 2018; Riis et al., 2016). Our limited sample size prevented more complex modeling, such as including multiple measures of stress in a single-regression model; such models could provide additional insight and should be considered in future research with sufficient power.

It is notable that hair cortisol, a measure of chronic HPA axis functioning over time, did not yield any meaningful correlations in this sample. Hair cortisol is thought to offer an advantage over salivary cortisol, as salivary cortisol is sensitive to diurnal rhythms and the oral environment and requires collection of multiple samples over time (Condon, 2018). While other studies have detected relationships between child hair cortisol levels and other psychosocial exposures (Karlén et al., 2015), associations with maternal history are unknown. As several children were unable to provide hair samples due to short hair length, it may be that our sample size was too small to detect significant associations amidst complex maternal–child relationships. Given the age range of our sample, it is also possible that stressors related to peers, school, or other aspects of the social environment may have a greater influence on school-age children than caregiver-related stressors did. Future research involving larger samples of ethnic minority children living in stressful environments is necessary to better understand the role of hair cortisol as a useful indicator of exposure to chronic stress in children (Gray et al., 2018).

Finally, this study is limited by the use of self-report measures to evaluate child health and behavioral history. Future research would be strengthened by the inclusion of more objective measures, such as medical record review for health history or teacher-reported child behavior, as well as the use of validated measures of family strengths, such as the Benevolent Childhood Experiences scale (Narayan et al., 2018). Future investigations accounting for the influence of maternal mental health symptoms are also necessary to better understand these complex relationships.

Back to Top | Article Outline

CONCLUSION

The results of this exploratory study suggest that maternal ACEs and PTSD symptoms may contribute to physiological disruptions and health outcomes associated with exposure to chronic stress in children. Our findings can be used to design future studies to better understand the complex interplay among biologic, epigenetic, and psychosocial factors that contribute to the intergenerational transmission of trauma and toxic stress, as well as protective factors that may help prevent the transmission of trauma in vulnerable families.

Back to Top | Article Outline

REFERENCES

Achenbach T. M., & Ruffle T. M. (2000). The Child Behavior Checklist and related forms for assessing behavioral/emotional problems and competencies. Pediatrics in Review, 21, 265–271. doi:10.1542/pir.21-8-265
Benzies K., & Mychasiuk R. (2009). Fostering family resiliency: A review of the key protective factors. Child & Family Social Work, 14, 103–114. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2206.2008.00586.x
Bernstein D. P., Fink L., Handelsman L., Foote J., Lovejoy M., Wenzel K., … Ruggiero J. (1994). Initial reliability and validity of a new retrospective measure of child abuse and neglect. American Journal of Psychiatry, 151, 1132–1136. doi:10.1176/ajp.151.8.1132
Biglan A., Van Ryzin M. J., & Hawkins J. D. (2017). Evolving a more nurturing society to prevent adverse childhood experiences. Academic Pediatrics, 17, S150–S157. doi:10.1016/j.acap.2017.04.002
Bird C., & Michie C. (2008). Measuring blood pressure in children. BMJ, 336, 1321. doi:10.1136/bmj.a150
Bublitz M. H., Parade S., & Stroud L. R. (2014). The effects of childhood sexual abuse on cortisol trajectories in pregnancy are moderated by current family functioning. Biological Psychology, 103, 152–157. doi:10.1016/j.biopsycho.2014.08.014
Chung E. K., Mathew L., Rothkopf A. C., Elo I. T., Coyne J. C., & Culhane J. F. (2009). Parenting attitudes and infant spanking: The influence of childhood experiences. Pediatrics, 124, e278–e286. doi:10.1542/peds.2008-3247
Chung E. K., Nurmohamed L., Mathew L., Elo I. T., Coyne J. C., & Culhane J. F. (2010). Risky health behaviors among mothers-to-be: The impact of adverse childhood experiences. Academic Pediatrics, 10, 245–251. doi:10.1016/j.acap.2010.04.003
Committee on Bioethics (1995). Informed consent, parental permission, and assent in pediatric practice. Pediatrics, 95, 314–317.
Condon E. M. (2018). Chronic stress in children and adolescents: A review of biomarkers for use in pediatric research. Biological Research for Nursing, 20, 473–496. doi:1099800418779214
Condon E. M., Sadler L. S., & Mayes L. C. (2018). Toxic stress and protective factors in multi-ethnic school age children: A research protocol. Research in Nursing & Health, 41, 97–106. doi:10.1002/nur.21851
Cook D. G., Mendall M. A., Whincup P. H., Carey I. M., Ballam L., Morris J. E., … Strachan D. P. (2000). C-reactive protein concentration in children: Relationship to adiposity and other cardiovascular risk factors. Atherosclerosis, 149, 139–150. doi:10.1016/S0021-9150(99)00312-3
Falkner B., Daniels S. R., Flynn J. T., Gidding S., Green L. A., Ingelfinger J. R., … Rocchini A. P. (2004). The fourth report on the diagnosis, evaluation, and treatment of high blood pressure in children and adolescents. Pediatrics, 114(2 III), 555–576.
    Felitti V. J., Anda R. F., Nordenberg D., Williamson D. F., Spitz A. M., Edwards V., & Marks J. S. (1998). Relationship of childhood abuse and household dysfunction to many of the leading causes of death in adults: The Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACE) Study. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 14, 245–258. doi:10.1016/S0749-3797(98)00017-8
    Folger A. T., Eismann E. A., Stephenson N. B., Shapiro R. A., Macaluso M., Brownrigg M. E., & Gillespie R. J. (2018). Parental adverse childhood experiences and offspring development at 2 years of age. Pediatrics, 141, e20172826.
    Gillespie R. J., & Folger A. T. (2017). Feasibility of assessing parental ACEs in pediatric primary care: Implications for practice-based implementation. Journal of Child & Adolescent Trauma, 10, 249–256. doi:10.1007/s40653-017-0138-z
    Glover V., O'Connor T. G., & O'Donnell K. (2010). Prenatal stress and the programming of the HPA axis. Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews, 35, 17–22. doi:10.1016/j.neubiorev.2009.11.008
    Gray N. A., Dhana A., Van Der Vyver L., Van Wyk J., Khumalo N. P., & Stein D. J. (2018). Determinants of hair cortisol concentration in children: A systematic review. Psychoneuroendocrinology, 87, 204–214. doi:10.1016/j.psyneuen.2017.10.022
    Haddad J. J., Saadé N. E., & Safieh-Garabedian B. (2002). Cytokines and neuro immune-endocrine interactions: A role for the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal revolving axis. Journal of Neuroimmunology, 133, 1–19. doi:10.1016/S0165-5728(02)00357-0
    Hillis S. D., Anda R. F., Dube S. R., Felitti V. J., Marchbanks P. A., Macaluso M., & Marks J. S. (2010). The protective effect of family strengths in childhood against adolescent pregnancy and its long-term psychosocial consequences. The Permanente Journal, 14, 18–27.
    Hughes K., Bellis M. A., Hardcastle K. A., Sethi D., Butchart A., Mikton C., … Dunne M. P. (2017). The effect of multiple adverse childhood experiences on health: A systematic review and meta-analysis. The Lancet Public Health, 2, e356–e366. doi:10.1016/S2468-2667(17)30118-4
    Jacobvitz D., Leon K., & Hazen N. (2006). Does expectant mothers' unresolved trauma predict frightened/frightening maternal behavior? Risk and protective factors. Development and Psychopathology, 18, 363–379. doi:10.1017/S0954579406060196
    Karlén J., Ludvigsson J., Hedmark M., Faresjö Å., Theodorsson E., & Faresjö T. (2015). Early psychosocial exposures, hair cortisol levels, and disease risk. Pediatrics, 135, e1450–e1457. doi:10.1542/peds.2014-2561
    Kuczmarski R. J. (2002). 2000 CDC growth charts for the United States: Methods and development (Vital & Health Statistics: Series 11). Atlanta, GA: CDC Stacks.
    Lieberman A. F., Padrón E., Van Horn P., & Harris W. W. (2005). Angels in the nursery: The intergenerational transmission of benevolent parental influences. Infant Mental Health Journal, 26, 504–520. doi:10.1002/imhj.20071
    Madigan S., Wade M., Plamondon A., Maguire J. L., & Jenkins J. M. (2017). Maternal adverse childhood experience and infant health: Biomedical and psychosocial risks as intermediary mechanisms. Journal of Pediatrics, 187, 282–289.e1. doi:10.1016/j.jpeds.2017.04.052
    McDonnell C. G., & Valentino K. (2016). Intergenerational effects of childhood trauma: Evaluating pathways among maternal ACEs, perinatal depressive symptoms, and infant outcomes. Child Maltreatment, 21, 317–326. doi:10.1177/1077559516659556
    Meyer J., Novak M., Hamel A., & Rosenberg K. (2014). Extraction and analysis of cortisol from human and monkey hair. Journal of Visualized Experiments, 24, e508862. doi:10.3791/50882
    Muntner P., He J., Cutler J. A., Wildman R. P., & Whelton P. K. (2004). Trends in blood pressure among children and adolescents. JAMA, 291, 2107–2113. doi:10.1001/jama.291.17.2107
    Narayan A. J., Rivera L. M., Bernstein R. E., Harris W. W., & Lieberman A. F. (2018). Positive childhood experiences predict less psychopathology and stress in pregnant women with childhood adversity: A pilot study of the benevolent childhood experiences (BCEs) scale. Child Abuse & Neglect, 78, 19–30. doi:10.1016/j.chiabu.2017.09.022
    Ordway M. R., Sadler L. S., Dixon J., Close N., Mayes L., & Slade A. (2014). Lasting effects of an interdisciplinary home visiting program on child behavior: Preliminary follow-up results of a randomized trial. Journal of Pediatric Nursing, 29, 3–13. doi:10.1016/j.pedn.2013.04.006
    Palmer F. B., Anand K. J., Graff J. C., Murphy L. E., Qu Y., Völgyi E., … Tylavsky F. A. (2013). Early adversity, socioemotional development, and stress in urban 1-year-old children. Journal of Pediatrics, 163, 1733–1739. doi:10.1016/j.jpeds.2013.08.030
    Pereira J., Vickers K., Atkinson L., Gonzalez A., Wekerle C., & Levitan R. (2012). Parenting stress mediates between maternal maltreatment history and maternal sensitivity in a community sample. Child Abuse and Neglect, 36, 433–437. doi:10.1016/j.chiabu.2012.01.006
    Racine N. M., Madigan S. L., Plamondon A. R., McDonald S. W., & Tough S. C. (2018). Differential associations of adverse childhood experience on maternal health. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 54, 368–375. doi:10.1016/j.amepre.2017.10.028
    Riis J. L., Granger D. A., Minkovitz C. S., Bandeen-Roche K., DiPietro J. A., & Johnson S. B. (2016). Maternal distress and child neuroendocrine and immune regulation. Social Science and Medicine, 151, 206–214. doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2015.12.043
    Sacks V., & Murphey D. (2018). The prevalence of adverse childhood experiences, nationally, by state, and by race or ethnicity. Retrieved from https://www.childtrends.org/publications/prevalence-adverse-childhood-experiences-nationally-state-race-ethnicity
    Sadler L. S., Slade A., Close N., Webb D. L., Simpson T., Fennie K., & Mayes L. C. (2013). Minding the Baby: Enhancing reflectiveness to improve early health and relationship outcomes in an interdisciplinary home-visiting program. Infant Mental Health Journal, 34, 391–405. doi:10.1002/imhj.21406
    Shonkoff J. P., Garner A. S., Siegel B. S., Dobbins M. I., Earls M. F., McGuinn L., … Wood D. L. (2012). The lifelong effects of early childhood adversity and toxic stress. Pediatrics, 129, e232–e246.
    Smith M. V., Gotman N., & Yonkers K. A. (2016). Early childhood adversity and pregnancy outcomes. Maternal and Child Health Journal, 20, 790–798. doi:10.1007/s10995-015-1909-5
    Sun J., Patel F., Rose-Jacobs R., Frank D. A., Black M. M., & Chilton M. (2017). Mothers' adverse childhood experiences and their young children's development. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 53, 882–891. doi:10.1016/j.amepre.2017.07.015
    Weathers F. W., Litz B. T., Herman D. S., Huska J. A., & Keane T. M. (1993, October). The PTSD checklist (PCL): Reliability, validity, and diagnostic utility. In Annual Convention of the International Society for Traumatic Stress Studies (Vol. 462). San Antonio, TX.
    Woods-Jaeger B. A., Cho B., Sexton C. C., Slagel L., & Goggin K. (2018). Promoting resilience: Breaking the intergenerational cycle of adverse childhood experiences. Health Education & Behavior, 45, 772–780. doi:10.1177/1090198117752785
    Keywords:

    child health; mothers; mother–child relations; physiological; stress

    Copyright © 2019 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved