Journal Logo

Research Article: Observational Study

Effects of progressive muscle relaxation training on negative emotions and sleep quality in COVID-19 patients

A clinical observational study

Xiao, Chun-Xiu MSa; Lin, Yan-Juan MSa; Lin, Ren-Qin MSb,∗; Liu, An-Na MSc; Zhong, Gui-Qin MSb; Lan, Cai-Feng MSd

Editor(s): Dwivedi., Atul

Author Information
doi: 10.1097/MD.0000000000023185
  • Open

Abstract

Key Points

  • Progressive muscle relaxation training interventions in isolated COVID-19 patients significantly improved sleep quality.
  • Progressive muscle relaxation training interventions in isolated COVID-19 patients significantly improved negative mood and reduced anxiety and depression.
  • Our findings can be used to improve both sleep and psychological care through nursing staff action and sleep and psychological conditions in COVID-19 patients.

1 Introduction

In December 2019, a new coronavirus pneumonia (COVID-19) outbreak started in Wuhan, Hubei Province, quickly spreading to other parts of China and countries around the world.[1] COVID-19 is a new infectious disease that can be transmitted from person to person by means of varying transmission routes, high morbidity, strong infectivity, and a considerable mortality rate.[2] In China, when practicing isolation treatment, patients need to perform a nucleic acid test for efficacy. However, since various factors affect the accuracy of the test and the results are repetitive, multiple examinations are required. This uncertainty can cause the patient to have sleep issues and such uncertainty worsens since some witness the death of other patients in the same ward due to ineffective treatment. In addition, due to the particularity of the disease, patients are separated from relatives and friends.

There is still uncertainty about how the disease will be treated and when the outbreak will be contained. Patients suffer both physically and mentally, as fear, anxiety and other psychological reactions are common. From our experience in nursing COVID-19 patients, we observed their difficulties in falling asleep, waking up easily, along with other sleep problems. Sleep quality is especially important for the human body. It is fundamental for the physiological activity and the system of organs. Poor sleep affects memory, learning, emotions, behavior, immune response, metabolism, hormone levels, digestive processes, and many other physiological functions.[3] Thus, sleep eventually affects the prognosis and outcome of COVID-19 patients.[4] Therefore, the problem of improving sleep quality in COVID-19 patients needs to be solved urgently.

2 Background

Progressive muscle relaxation training is a type of therapy that involves gradually relaxing muscles in a sequence. It was originally a self-management relaxation technique developed by Jacobson.[5] Progressive muscle relaxation techniques have now become an independent training method, which has been used in various fields of psychology.[6,7] Related studies have shown that progressive muscle relaxation training as a non-pharmacological intervention, through the use of systematically tension and relaxation of the muscles to reduce muscle strain, ensure mental relaxation, increases exercise tolerance, functional capacity, and quality of life in patients.[8] Further, some studies have pointed out that progressive muscle relaxation training can improve sleep.[9] Therefore, this study aims to investigate the effects of an intervention on negative emotions and sleep quality of COVID-19 patients through progressive muscle relaxation training, so as to promote recovery.

3 Materials and methods

Participants were 79 COVID-19 patients admitted to a designated hospital in Wuhan from February to March, 2020. The patients were divided into an observation group (39 cases) and a control group (40 cases) according to their wishes.

Inclusion criteria included:

  • (1) patients diagnosed with COVID-19 according to the standard of prevention and control plan of COVID-19, released by the National Health Commission[10];
  • (2) conscious patients with at least a minimum ability of communication and understanding, able to complete the training according to a verbal guide;
  • (3) patients who informed consent;
  • (4) and those hospitalized for more than 7 days.

On the other hand, exclusion criteria were:

  • (1) patients suffering from mental illness, or those taking anti-anxiety, sedation, and other drugs before admission to the hospital; and those
  • (2) patients with severe cardiovascular disease or malignant tumors.

All 79 patients not required additional ventilator or hemodynamic support thereby. And no patients drop out of the study due to decline in their COVID status.

3.1 Ethical approval

This study has been approved by the Ethics Committee of Fujian Medical University Union Hospital. All enrolled patients or their family members provided written and signed informed consent to participate in the study.

3.2 Study design

Patients in both groups received clinical treatment and nursing care in accordance to the coronavirus pneumonia diagnosis and treatment plan issued by the National Health Commission.[11]

Patients in the observation group received the further treatment of progressive muscle relaxation training for 1 week. At the same time, nurses instruct patients in the control group to perform body movements in bed. The 4 researchers in the observation group were all support nurses in the designated hospital, with the qualification of nurse in charge. Before the study, participants were trained in progressive muscle relaxation techniques and assessment tools.

3.2.1 Progressive muscle relaxation training

Patients in the observation group received progressive muscle relaxation training in bed 30 minutes before getting up early and 30 minutes before going to bed. The researchers recorded a video beforehand. The 15-minute video, produced by team members themselves, details each step of the training and is accompanied by audio. Along with the video, team members taught patients the relaxation training method. The details were given as follows: first, force tension with the muscles, and concentrate on the feeling of tension; try to hold this feeling of tension for 3 to 5 seconds, and then relax for 10 to 15 seconds. Afterward, the patient should experience the sensation of muscle relaxation.

Next, patients were taught the order of relaxation: foot, leg, hip and waist, chest, arm, shoulder, and face. The foot relaxation training had the following instructions: “focus on your feet, tense the muscles in the feet and ankle, bend your toes toward your head, and slowly tighten the muscles; then relax and imagine your feet getting heavier and more relaxed.”

The leg relaxation training was instructed as follows: “focus on the calf and push your feet forward as hard as you can, tension the calf muscle group, and then relax; concentrate on your thighs and pull them as close together as possible, tensing those muscles, and then letting them relax and go back to their position.”

The hip relaxation training was as follows: “try to align your hips, tense the hip and waist muscles, and hold this position for a while; then relax your muscles in the hips and waist letting them go back to their original state.”

The chest relaxation training was instructed as follows: “take a deep breath, hold it, and feel the tension; feel your chest muscles become tense and rigid, maintain this feeling for a while, then slowly exhale and relax your muscles.”

As for the arm relaxation training, instructions were: “extend your hand, clench your fist, force the forearm muscle group to tension, then relax; do it once on each hand; straighten your arms, clench your fists in both hands, tense your hands and arm muscles, then relax.”

Shoulders and rear relaxation training: “hunching your shoulders, feeling it from the neck to the ear, with the back slightly inclined, tension neck muscles, holding it for a while; then begin to relax your shoulders, hanging your head down forward, letting your shoulders go down, feeling your muscles become consciously relaxed and heavier, while the neck feels weak, the shoulder should feel heavy.”

Finally, there was also a facial relaxation training: “wrinkle your forehead muscles, then relax; frown, then relax; pucker your nose and cheeks, keeping your teeth clenched, so that the corners of your mouth are turned as far to the sides as possible.”

Each session lasted 15 minutes for 1 week. The patients followed a recorded audio to carry out the training. In the training process, if the patient felt discomfort, or if their condition was not fit to continue the training, researchers immediately stopped, and handled the issue accordingly. Anyhow, all patients in this study cooperated well in the training process, no special intervention was necessary.

3.3 Instruments

3.3.1 General demographic questionnaire

The general demographic questionnaire was designed by the research group after consulting the experts. It was used to evaluate the demographic and disease-related data of the patients, including age, education level, marital status, occupation, family residence, family economic status, and whether family members had been infected.

3.3.2 The Pittsburgh sleeps quality index scale (PSQI)[12]

The PSQI was used to evaluate sleep quality before and after the intervention. There were 19 self-report problems and 5 sleep partner rating problems in the PSQI scale. In this study, only 19 self-assessment scores were included, and the scores ranged from 0 to 3: “0” referring to no difficulty, and “3” to very difficult. The sum of all factor scores consisted of the total score of the scale ranging from 0 to 21. According to the total score, a global PSQI score of 8 or greater is indicative of poor sleep quality.[13]

3.3.3 The generalized anxiety disorder (GAD-7)

The GAD-7, prepared by Spitzer et al,[14] was used to assess the anxiety status of patients. There are 7 items in the scale. Each item is scored from 0 to 3 points, and the total score is 21 points. High scores indicate the frequency of symptoms is high. Having a GAD-7 score ≥5 indicates anxiety.

3.3.4 The patient health questionnaire (PHQ-9)

The PHQ-9 prepared by Kroenke et al[15] was used to assess the depression status of patients. The content consists of 9 items, each of which is rated from 0 to 3 points, summing up a total of 27 points. High scores indicate the frequency of symptoms is high. A PHQ-9 score ≥5 indicates depression.

3.4 Data collection

Subjects were instructed to complete the general information questionnaire and PSQI before the intervention. After the intervention, GAD-7, PHQ-9, and PSQI scales were distributed once again. After receiving the scales, the completeness and key information was checked timely, and participants were instructed to fill in missing items. For those unable to fill in the form, the investigators read and filled in the form on their behalf, with their consent.

3.5 Data analysis

SPSS21.0 was used for the statistical analysis. Count data use case, percentage description, and X2 test were used for comparison. The measurement data conforming to the normal distribution were expressed as mean ± standard deviation, and the t-test was used for comparison. The rank data were tested by the rank sum test. P < .05 was considered statistically significant.

4 Results

No significant difference between the 2 groups was found in gender, age, and other general information (P > .05). The specific content is shown in Table 1.

Table 1 - Comparison of general demographic data between the 2 groups
(X¯±S)
.
Variables Experimental(n = 39) Control (n = 40) Statistical value P-value
Age (yr, 58.45 ± 11.08 59.33 ± 12.19 –0.573 .568
Sex [n (%)]
 Male 21 (53.85) 23 (57.50) 0.107 .744
 Female 18 (46.15) 17 (42.50)
Marital status [n (%)]
 Married 30 (61.22) 33 (82.50) 0.380 .537
 Divorced or widowed 9 (38.78) 7 (17.50)
Education background [n (%)]
 Primary school 4 (10.26) 3 (7.50) 766.000 .885
 Junior high school 15 (38.46) 16 (40.00)
 High school 10 (25.64) 11 (27.50)
 College 10 (25.64) 10 (25.00)
Occupation [n (%)]
 Farmer 3 (7.69) 4 (10.00) 773.000 .944
 Worker 12 (30.77) 11 (27.50)
 Independent professional 10 (25.65) 11 (27.50)
 Public institution 8 (20.51) 6 (15.00)
 Retired 6 (15.38) 8 (20.00)
Family residence [n (%)]
 Countryside 9 (23.08) 8 (20.00) 0.111 .739
 City 30 (76.92) 32 (80.00)
Financial state [N (%)]
 No difficulty at all 9 (23.08) 7 (17.50) 736.500 .638
 A little difficult 20 (51.28) 22 (55.00)
 Difficult 10 (25.664) 11 (27.50)
Family members infected [N (%)]
 Yes 25 (64.10) 30 (75.00) 1.109 .292
 No 14 (35.90) 10 (25.00)
t-value.
X2-value.

Before the intervention, there was no statistically significant difference in GAD-7, PHQ-9, and PSQI scores between the 2 groups (P > .05). After the intervention, the scores of GAD-7, PHQ-9, and PSQI in the observation group were all lower than those in the control group (P < .05), with statistically significant differences. See Table 2 for details.

Table 2 - Comparison of GAD-7, PHQ-9, and PSQI data between the 2 groups.
Variables Control (n = 40) Experimental (n = 39) t -value P-value
GAD-7 Before the intervention 5.72 ± 3.71 5.38 ± 5.25 −0.333 .740
After the intervention 5.77 ± 3.72 3.69 ± 2.99 −2.736 .008
PHQ-9 Before the intervention 5.20 ± 2.88 5.05 ± 4.86 −0.166 .869
After the intervention 6.02 ± 3.74 3.69 ± 3.93 −3.040 .003
PSQI Before the intervention 10.08 ± 5.43 10.25 ± 2.75 −0.177 .860
After the intervention 9.72 ± 5.08 7.41 ± 2.42 −2.570 .012

5 Discussion

COVID-19 is a newly emerging infectious disease with strong infectivity. At the moment, although symptomatic treatments are used and results are obtained, there is no definitive treatment. Patients still have doubts about whether they can truly recover, whether there would be sequelae, whether they would relapse or infect others. This can cause physical and mental damage to hospitalized patients.

During the SARS epidemic in 2003, patients also had serious psychological problems in the face of the sudden outbreak.[16,17] In this study, GAD-7 and PHQ-9 were greater than 5 points before the intervention. This indicated COVID-19 patients had anxiety and depression.

Previous studies have also confirmed that patients’ emotional stress state is related to individual immune function, and good psychological nursing can improve patients’ immune injury to a certain extent and promote recovery.[18] In addition, with the increase of patients’ anxiety and depression, and affected by factors such as medical environment and treatment, patients were prone to stress insomnia symptoms such as difficulty in falling asleep, tossing and turning, and sometimes not sleeping through the night.[19] In this study, the PSQI score before intervention in both groups was greater than 8 points, indicating poor sleep quality. Therefore, in assistance to conventional treatment, relevant interventions can be carried out in patients with negative emotions and sleep quality.

Progressive relaxation exercises allow patients to experience 2 different states of feeling by tensing and relaxing muscles in a sequence. This can promote muscle relaxation and leave the whole body in a relaxed state, which can effectively relieve negative emotions such as tension, fear, and anxiety.[20]

Park et al conducted progressive muscle relaxation therapy for 4 weeks in 35 dental patients, and evaluated them after intervention, and then again 3 months after intervention, and found that progressive muscle relaxation therapy can effectively regulate the peripheral and central nervous system, thus reducing the tension and anxiety of dental patients.[21] In addition, other studies have pointed out that progressive relaxation training could improve mood by relieving pain in patients, which is considered an effective adjuvant to relieve pain in patients with advanced cancer,[22] and can also reduce the frequency of migraine patients.[23]

The results of this study showed that there was no statistically significant difference in the scores of GAD-7 and PHQ-9 between the 2 groups before the intervention (P > .05). After the implementation of progressive muscle relaxation training, the GAD-7 and PHQ-9 of the observation group decreased, and the scores were lower than those of the control group. The differences between the 2 groups were statistically significant (P < .05). This suggests that progressive muscle relaxation training can improve the negative emotions of COVID-19 patients. However, the effect of progressive relaxation training on pain and blood oxygen saturation in patients has not been studied in this study, which needs to be further discussed.

Progressive relaxation exercises help to balance the sympathetic nervous system by relaxing the body, lowering blood pressure, stimulating blood circulation, and ensuring muscle relaxation. Although the function of sleep is not fully understood, it is a basic human need, functioning to maintain body energy and help regulate this process.[8] In this study, no statistically significant difference in PSQI scores between the 2 groups were found before the intervention (P > .05), and the PSQI of the observation group was lower than that of the control group after the implementation of progressive muscle relaxation training (P < .05). This suggests that progressive muscle relaxation training can help patients fall asleep and improve the sleep quality of COVID-19 patients.

Aksu[8] conducted a single blind prospective randomized controlled trial on 26 patients undergoing open-heart surgery, and their results showed that progressive muscle relaxation training could improve the sleep and quality of life of patients after pneumonectomy. A study conducted a progressive relaxation training intervention in 45 patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, and the results of their study showed that progressive relaxation training is an effective intervention to relieve related fatigue and sleep quality.[9] In this study, the patients pointed out that during the training, they concentrated on the contraction and relaxation of skeletal muscle group, temporarily reducing their attention to the disease and the stress level of the body. Further through relaxing their bodies they also reached psychological relaxation, successfully calming down and falling asleep. Therefore, progressive relaxation training can effectively improve the sleep quality of COVID-19 patients.

6 Limitations

Results of this study are limited by the small sample and short evaluation period. Results may thus not apply to all COVID-19 patients in different areas of China or other populations. Patients were also from a single institution, which may cause a location bias. Although our results suggest the effectiveness of this progressive muscle relaxation training in improving negative emotions such as anxiety and depression and sleep quality in Covid-19 patients, further multicentered studies with longer application of the intervention are needed to confirm our results.

7 Conclusions

In summary, with the change of medical model from the biomedical to the biopsychosocial, increasing attention has been paid to the importance of patients’ psychological problems in the treatment and prognosis of diseases. As a non-drug intervention therapy, progressive muscle relaxation training has the advantages of being economical, easy to operate, safe, and comfortable. The results of this study showed that progressive muscle relaxation training significantly improved negative emotions such as anxiety and depression and sleep quality in COVID-19 patients during isolation treatment, which has positive significance in improving the treatment effect of patients, being worthy of clinical attention.

8 Relevance to clinical practice

The significant improvement in sleep quality and psychological condition suggest that progressive muscle relaxation training could be developed as an intervention to improve both sleeping and psychological care by nursing staff and sleep and psychological conditions in patients with covid-19.

Author contributions

Conceptualization: Yan-Juan Lin, Renqin Lin.

Data curation: Chun-Xiu Xiao, Yan-Juan Lin, Renqin Lin.

Formal analysis: Chun-Xiu Xiao, Yan-Juan Lin.

Investigation: Chun-Xiu Xiao, Yan-Juan Lin, An-Na Liu, Gui-Qin Zhong, Cai-Feng Lan.

Methodology: Chun-Xiu Xiao, Yan-Juan Lin, Renqin Lin.

Project administration: Chun-Xiu Xiao, Yan-Juan Lin.

Supervision: Chun-Xiu Xiao, Yan-Juan Lin, Renqin Lin.

Validation: Chun-Xiu Xiao, Yan-Juan Lin.

Writing – original draft: Chun-Xiu Xiao, Yan-Juan Lin, Renqin Lin, An-Na Liu, Gui-Qin Zhong, Cai-Feng Lan.

Writing – review & editing: Chun-Xiu Xiao, Yan-Juan Lin, Renqin Lin, An-Na Liu, Gui-Qin Zhong, Cai-Feng Lan.

References

[1]. Hui DS, I Azhar E, Madani TA, et al. The continuing 2019-nCoV epidemic threat of novel coronaviruses to global health-the latest 2019 novel coronavirus outbreak in Wuhan, China. Int J Infect Dis 2020;91:264–6.
[2]. Li Q, Guan X, Wu P, et al. Early transmission dynamics in Wuhan, China, of Novel Coronavirus Infected Pneumonia [J]. N Engl J Med 2020;382:1199–207.
[3]. Acosta MT. Sleep, memory and learning. Medicina (B Aires) 2019;79: (Suppl 3): 29–32.
[4]. Kai L, Ying C, Duozhi W, et al. Effects of progressive muscle relaxation on anxiety and sleep quality in patients with COVID-19. Randomized Controlled Trial 2020;39:101132.
[5]. Meyer B, Keller A, Müller B, et al. Progressive muscle relaxation according to Jacobson for migraine prophylaxis: Clinical effectiveness and mode of action. Schmerz 2018;32:250–8.
[6]. Liao J, Wu Y, Zhao Y, et al. Progressive muscle relaxation combined with Chinese medicine five-element music on depression for cancer patients: a randomized controlled trial. Chin J Integr Med 2018;24:343–7.
[7]. Noruzi Zamenjani M, Masmouei B, Harorani M, et al. The effect of progressive muscle relaxation on cancer patients’ self-efficacy. Complement Ther Clin Pract 2019;34:70–5.
[8]. Aksu NT, Erdogan A, Ozgur N. Effects of progressive muscle relaxation training on sleep and quality of life in patients with pulmonary resection. Sleep Breath 2018;22:695–702.
[9]. Seyedi Chegeni P, Gholami M, Azargoon A, et al. The effect of progressive muscle relaxation on the management of fatigue and quality of sleep in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: a randomized controlled clinical trial. Complement Ther Clin Pract 2018;31:64–70.
[10]. General Office of the National Health Commission, Office of the National Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine. Prevention and control of the novel coronavirus pneumonia (6th edition) [Z]. 2020-03-07.
[11]. General Office of The National Health Commission, Office of the National Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine. Prevention and control of the novel coronavirus pneumonia (Trial edition 7th) [Z]. 2020-03-07.
[12]. Buysse DJ, Reynolds CF, Monk TH, et al. The Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index: a new instrument for psychiatric practice and research. Psychiatry Res 1989;28:193–213.
[13]. Carpenter JS, Andrykowski MA. Psychometric evaluation of the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index. J Psychosomatic Res 1998;45:5–13.
[14]. Spitzer RL, Kroenke K, Williams JB, et al. A brief measure for assessing generalized anxiety disorder: the GAD-7. Arch Intern Med 2006;166:1092–7.
[15]. Kroenke K, Spitzer RL, Williams JB. The PHQ-9 validity of a brief depression severity measure. J Gen Intern Med 2001;16:606–13.
[16]. Maunder R, Hunter J, Vincent L, et al. The immediate psychological and occupational impact 0f the 2003 SARS outbreak in a teaching hospital. Can Med Assoc J 2003;10:1245–51.
[17]. Cheng SK, Tsang JS, Ku KH, et al. Psychiatric complications in patients with severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) during the acute treatment phase: a series of 10 cases. Br J Psychiatry 2004;184:359–60.
[18]. Nan KJ, Wei YC, Zhou FL, et al. Effects of depression on parameters of cell-mediated immunity in patients with digestive tract cancers. World J Gastroenterology 2004;10:268–72.
[19]. Gao CY, Gan JL, Duan HF, et al. Effects of cognitive emotion regulation strategies on susceptibility to stress insomnia. J Int Psychiatry 2016;43:83–6.
[20]. Li MF, Ji HJ, Liang HJ. Effects of progressive muscle relaxation training on sleep in patients without convulsion. Chin Gen Pract Nurs 2018;16:1607–9.
[21]. Park ES, Yim HW, Lee KS. Progressive muscle relaxation therapy to relievedental anxiety: a randomized controlled trial. Eur J Oral Sci 2019;127:45–51.
[22]. De Paolis G, Naccarato A, Cibelli F, et al. The effectiveness of progressive muscle relaxation and interactive guided imagery as a pain-reducing intervention in advanced cancer patients: a multicentre randomised controlled non-pharmacological trial. Complement Ther Clin Pract 2019;34:280–7.
[23]. Meyer B, Keller A, Wöller B, et al. Progressive muscle relaxation reduces migraine frequency and normalizes amplitudes of contingent negative variation (CNV). J Headache Pain 2016;17:37.
Keywords:

COVID-19 patients; negative emotions; progressive muscle relaxation training; sleep quality

Copyright © 2020 the Author(s). Published by Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc.