The 44 remaining studies were filtered according to the aforementioned inclusion criteria. The following were identified:
- 7 RCT
- 4 studies of cohort.
After this second phase, these studies have been admitted to the final phase of the review.
The evidence provided concerned 2 aspects of CMT rehabilitation: physiotherapy and orthotic treatment.
Five studies in total, 4 of them experimental and 1 of cohort, met the inclusion criteria; Table 3 resumes the main characteristics of included trials.
The first trial11 is aimed at assessing a home exercise program the patient will follow for 12 weeks, as well as drafting a series of endurance exercises based on the activities of daily living (ADL). The 20 patients received a detailed video on physiotherapy techniques to be performed at home. The results of the study showed an increase of the muscular strength, and a shorter ADL execution time following the therapy recommended to both groups.
Likewise, the Ramdharry study12 investigated the effects of a home endurance training lasting 16 weeks, aimed at the recovery of the hip flexor muscles. The 32 participants were divided into training and control group; the study included 16 weeks of intervention and 8 of rest and periodic checks. The patients were monitored through an exercise diary, weekly calls, and monthly check-ups. The authors registered an increase of the flexors force in the left hip, whereas no significant improvement has been registered in the draft resistance and walking speed.
The third study13 analyzed was aimed at determining whether muscular strength training is effective, on a short-term basis, to improve impairments (loss of strength), disability (decrease of functionality), and handicaps (well-being) of patients with a neuromuscular pathology. Sixty-two patients were selected, 33 with myotonic dystrophy and 29 with HSMN (CMT), and were divided into a training group and a control group. The results showed a substantial neutrality of the effects in patients with myotonic dystrophy, whereas patients with CMT showed a moderate recovery of leg strength, as well as a better ADL performance.
In his study, Lindeman et al,14 who were also involved in the previous trial, repeated the same study and compared patients with polyneuropathy and patients with myotonic dystrophy.
Studied population, suggested exercises, and stages recommended were the same as the previous study, as well as the progression and duration of the follow-up. As for the outcome, the authors also introduced surface electromyography techniques (SEGM) to assess the activation of each muscular ventral part during isometric contractions. The results show an increase of the isometric force in the muscular ventral parts of the quadriceps; this increase was initially due to neural factors, then to hypertrophy from exercising.
The last study analyzed, conducted by El Mhandi et al,15 sought to investigate the effects of a rehabilitation program on the variation of the cardiac frequency in patients with CMT.
The 16 participants were divided into 2 groups: affected by CMT and healthy ones. The program included a cycle-ergometer training, 3 times a week and for 24 weeks; this training led to an improvement of the cardiac frequency, especially at night.
Six studies, 3 RCT and 3 of cohort, were admitted to the review; Table 4 details main trials characteristics.
The first study16 verified the hypothesis that ankle-foot orthosis (AFOs) improve posture and walking control in CMT. The authors recruited 26 patients for this purpose, and divided them into 3 groups, wearing, respectively, ordinary shoes (control), plastic AFOs (P-AFO), and elastic AFOs (E-AFO). Gait analysis and Youden Index showed plastic AFOs to improve both the posture control and walking, whereas elastic orthosis influenced the dynamic control of deambulation. The results showed that AFO prescription is relevant for improving walking balance and performance.
Rose study17 is aimed at verifying whether applying a night support over 4 weeks, as well as undertaking an equal period of stretching of the gastrocnemius and soleus muscles, can lead to an improvement in the ankle dorsi-flexion range. Thirty children and teenagers affected by CMT took part in the study, divided into control and intervention group. The authors report that night orthosis improved the dorsiflexion of the ankle by 4 degrees; after 4 weeks of stretching, the dorsiflexion improved by 3 degrees than the original range.
The Refshauge study18 investigated the effect of a night splint for plantar flexor's extension on the articulation range of the ankle in a patient affected by CMT. There were 14 participants, aged between 7 and 30. A support was applied in a condition of maximum dorsiflexion on 1 leg overnight and for 6 weeks; subsequently, the same treatment was applied on the other leg. The results showed that, by wearing the night splint, there were no significant differences in the range of motion (ROM) or strength of inversion/eversion movements.
The fourth study19 investigated the effect of the different AFOs on the distal control of the leg and proximal compensatory actions. The 14 participants were tested while wearing 3 types of AFOs or normal shoes. The first AFO was a “Footup splint,” a cuff worn around the ankle with a detachable elastic strap and a plastic flange at 1 end to tie into the laces of a shoe. The second, instead, was a “Push brace,” designed as a support for ankle instability following ligament injury. The main brace was made of preformed foam covering the medial, posterior, and lateral aspects of the ankle and extending under the calcaneum. The Multifit Achilles drop foot orthosis, finally, is a variant of the posterior leaf AFO made of plastic polymer with a half foot plate, a cut-out heel section and an adjustable back stem that extends to the calf. No significant differences were registered in the speed and step length of patients wearing AFOs and patients wearing standard shoes. The authors pointed out a significant influence of the AFOs on hip flexion at the oscillating stage of the step, and on the dorsiflexion of the ankle; this prevented the foot from falling and reduced the tripping frequency.
The Videler study20 assessed the effectiveness and tolerance level of a splint for thumb opposition on manual dexterity, functionality of the upper limbs, and occupational performance. Thirteen patients were provided with a neoprene splint for the thumb of the dominant hand, and trained to use it as long as possible, over a 5-week period. The results show that splinting significantly increases functionality in daily activities as well as occupational performance.
The Uygur study21 has been conducted on 55 pediatric patients. The children had to wear a support to ensure a neutral position and a 90° ankle overnight; no outcome or follow-up data were provided in this case. The conclusion was that children should avoid any risk related to a non-necessary orthosis treatment.
This review complies with the document issued by the PRISMA group regarding meta-analysis drafting and systematic reviews.22 In the following section, we will analyze the possibilities for comparison of detailed evidence.
As for the physiotherapy treatment of CMT, attention must be drawn to the following aspects:
- Physiotherapy is similar in some of the evidence: the muscular training focused on the strength13,14 or endurance.11,12
- Despite the verisimilitude of the objectives, a wide range of methods were used to measure the outcome of the evidence: muscular strength, the only common measurement, was evaluated through different methods (QMA, 1RM, myometre), so it does not allow any comparison.
- As for the results, all evidence points to the effectiveness of physiotherapy in CMT, as it is associated with an increase of the strength.11–14 The muscles involved are different in different trials: the muscles of the arm,11 the pelvic girdle and thigh (hip flexors and quadriceps),12–14 and the knee.11,13,14 The evidence agrees on the improvement in timing of execution of ADLs,11,13 and only 1 case did rehabilitation prove ineffective with regard to walking speed;12 in another isolated case, physiotherapy proved effective as regard the modulation of the parasympathetic system.15
These findings only partially tally with the data present in the literature; a recent document by Cochrane group23 shows that training programs for CMT increase the deambulation speed, but do not significantly increase ADLs. On the other hand, comparing these results with another systematic review,24 they match: a clear improvement in strength is shown, as well as absence of side effects after physiotherapy, as postulated in the trials considered.11
As for the orthosis treatment of CMT, and regarding the possibility of comparison, the following can be observed:
- As for the intervention suggested, many studies16–19 adopted a support on the lower limbs, while just 1 study suggested a device on the upper limbs;20 only 121 discussed the possibility of both.
- The outcome varies considerably from 1 study to another: articular excursion,17,18 strength,18–20 balance,17 walking kinematics,16,19 restrictions on functionality.17,20 For ankle excursion in dorsiflexion, which is the most common outcome, the measurement method varies: questionnaires,20 dynamometric tests,18–20 functional tests.16–18,20
- In addition, different studies showed different results; if a little evidence is found in the increase of the ankle dorsiflexion,17,19 each study also reports an improvement in balance,16 a better walking performance,16 time reduction when walking small distances (10 m),17 a decrease in hip flexion and in tripping.19 Just 1 trial18 failed to find significant differences in ROM and dorsiflexion strength. As for the upper limbs, the authors of the study20 report an improvement in daily life functionality, in occupational performance and satisfaction.
Comparing these results with the reviews in the literature25–27 opposite views can be observed on the orthosis treatment of patient with CMT: a paper by the Cochrane group,25 unlike 2 trials,17,19 indicated that there is no evidence of significant benefits for the articular excursion of the ankle. On the other hand, another paper26 focuses on the pediatric population with CMT, and demonstrates that orthotics are suitable in case of hollow feet, foot ache, and/or mild balance alteration, whereas AFOs are suitable for falling feet, general weakness of the feet muscles, severe balance alterations, and/or deambulation difficulties. This conclusion partially tallies with the present paper, particularly for the prescription of AFOs.16,19 Another review,27 in accordance with the results of one of the trials considered,21 suggests customization of the product (shoes, orthotics, orthosis) provided to the CMT patient.
RISK OF BIAS
The systematic revisions of the scientific literature are exposed to a double risk of systematic errors: bias on each study and comparison bias. Given the fact a comparison bias is impossible, and given the variety of the outcomes, the Downs and Black checklist was used, in the attempt to identify all possible bias.28 Such a tool allows effectively assessing the methodology quality of the random controlled and nonrandom studies, through a score from 0 to 31. For the present review, the scores vary from 19 to 23, with a predominance of the 22 to 23 score. It is so possible to say the studies included in the review have a medium-high scientific accuracy. Table 5 shows the scores obtained by each study according to the checklist.
Several considerations about physiotherapy management of CMT derived from this review:
- With regard to rehabilitation, this review proved to be a mainstay in the therapeutic approach. In particular, individual training programs contributed to the improvement of muscular strength in both upper and lower limb in various trials.
- Orthosis role in CMT management has to be further studied: isolated data showed it as associated with a significant improvement of the ROM in the ankle dorsiflexion, thus allowing a better walking kinematic. These conclusions, however, cannot be considered evidence based. Also hand orthosis must be studied and tested more in depth, as just 1 RCT showed its benefits.
- Unfortunately, it must be stressed that the scientific literature available to date focuses only on the purely clinical aspects of CMT, neglecting the useful and innovative aspects of the rehabilitation; due to the lack of data and to the limited comparison between trials, an evidence-based protocol cannot be, to date, established. The hope for future is that new clinical trials will be conducted on the rehabilitation of patients with CMT, including more case studies, and defining the gold standards in the rehabilitation management of such patients.
1. Newman CJ, Walsh M, O'Sullivan R, et al. The characteristics of gait in Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease types I and II. Gait Posture
2. Militerni R. Infant neuropsychiatry. 4th edition2009; Naples, Italy: Edizioni Idelson-Gnocchi, 160–171.
3. Horacek O, Mazanec R, Morris CE, et al. Spinal deformities in hereditary motor and sensory neuropathy: a retrospective qualitative, quantitative, genotypical, and familial analysis of 175 patients. Spine
4. Kars HJJ, Hijmans JM, Geertzen JHB, et al. The effect of reduced somatosensation on standing balance: a systematic review. J Diabetes Sci Technol
5. van der Linden MH, van der Linden SC, Hendricks HT, et al. Postural instability in Charcot-Marie-Tooth type 1A patients is strongly associated with reduced somatosensation. Gait Posture
6. Sevilla T, Jaijo T, Nauffal D, et al. Vocal cord paresis and diaphragmatic dysfunction are severe and frequent symptoms of GDAP1-associated neuropathy. Brain
7. Désarnaud F, Do Thi AN, Brown AM, et al. Progesterone stimulates the activity of the promoters of peripheral myelin protein-22 and protein zero genes in Schwann cells. J Neurochem
8. Eldridge CF, Bunge MB, Bunge RP, et al. Differentiation of axon-related Schwann cells in vitro. Ascorbic acid regulates basal lamina assembly and myelin formation. J Cell Bio
9. Jerath NU, Shy ME. Hereditary motor and sensory neuropathies: Understanding molecular pathogenesis could lead to future treatment strategies. Biochim Biophys Acta
10. Mutani R, Lopiano L, Durelli L, et al. Bergamini's neurology. Torino, Italy: cortina library editions; 2012.
11. Chetlin RD, Gutmann L, Tarnopolsky M, et al. Resistance training effectiveness in patients with Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease: recommendations for exercise prescription. Arch Phys Med Rehab
12. Ramdharry GM, Pollard A, Anderson C, et al. A pilot study of proximal strength training in Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease. J Periph Nerv Syst
13. Lindeman E, Leffers P, Spaans F, et al. Strength training in patients with myotonic dystrophy and hereditary motor and sensory neuropathy: a randomized clinical trial. Arch Phys Med Rehab
14. Lindeman E, Spaans F, Reulen J, et al. Progressive resistance training in neuromuscular patients. Effects on force and surface EMG. J Electromyogr Kinesiol
15. El Mhandi L, Pichot V, Calmels P, et al. Exercise training improves autonomic profiles in patient with Charcot –Marie–Tooth disease. Muscle Nerve
16. Guillebastre B, Calmels P, Rougier PR. Assessment of appropriate ankle-foot orthoses models for patients with Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease. Am J Phys Med Rehab
17. Rose KJ, Raymond J, Refshauge K, et al. Serial night casting increases ankle dorsiflexion range in children and young adults with Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease: a randomised trial. J Physiother
18. Refshauge KM, Raymond J, Nicholson G, et al. Night splinting does not increase ankle range of motion in people with Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease: a randomised, cross-over trial. Aust J Physiother
19. Ramdharry GM, Day BL, Reilly MM, et al. Foot drop splints improve proximal as well as distal leg control during gait in Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease. Muscle Nerve
20. Videler A, Eijffinger E, Nollet F, et al. A thumb opposition splint to improve manual dexterity and upper-limb functioning in Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease. J Rehabil Med
21. Uygur F, Bek N, Kuklu B, et al. Orthotic management of the lower limb in children with hereditary motor sensory neuropathy (HMSN). Prosthet Orthot Int
22. Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, et al. PRISMA Group. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. Int J Surg
23. Sackley C, Disler PB, Turner-Stokes L, et al. Rehabilitation interventions for foot drop in neuromuscular disease. Cochrane Database Syst Rev
24. Forrest G, Qian X. Exercise in neuromuscular disease. NeuroRehabilitation
25. Rose KJ, Burns J, Wheeler DM, et al. Interventions for increasing ankle range of motion in patients with neuromuscular disease. Cochrane Database Syst Rev
26. Scheffers G, Hiller C, Refshauge K, et al. Prescription of foot and ankle orthoses for children with Charcot–Marie–Tooth disease: a review of the evidence. Phys Ther Rev
27. Pareyson D, Marchesi C. Diagnosis, natural history, and management of Charcot–Marie–Tooth disease. Lancet Neurol
Copyright © 2016 The Authors. Published by Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. Health, Inc. All rights reserved.
28. Downs SH, Black N. The feasibility of creating a checklist for the assessment of the methodological quality both of randomised and non-randomised studies of health care interventions. J Epidemiol Community Health