Secondary Logo

Journal Logo

Letters to Editor

Barrier enclosure device

One size does not fit all

Sehgal, Inderpaul Singh; Dhooria, Sahajal; Prasad, Kuruswamy Thurai; Muthu, Valliappan; Aggarwal, Ashutosh Nath; Agarwal, Ritesh

Author Information
doi: 10.4103/lungindia.lungindia_20_21
  • Open


We read with interest the correspondence by Thangakunam and Christopher about the use of barrier devices during bronchoscopy,[1] where they reference our article.[2] Our article was regarding the barrier enclosure device during patient preparation, which is not the focus of what Thangakunam and Christopher are trying to discuss. However, it provides an opportunity to discuss the role of such barrier devices in the era of COVID-19. The authors emphasize the need for a larger trial before adopting a change in practice regarding the use of a barrier device for performing bronchoscopy.[1] The authors also refer to a simulation study where the authors demonstrated higher airborne particles at 300 s with the aerosol box use.[3] They cite another study, which increased the time to airway intubation.[4]

We have described three different barrier devices, each specifically designed to perform airway intubation,[5] patient preparation before bronchoscopy,[2] and for performing bronchoscopy.[6] Each of these devices was modified to facilitate the ease of performing a specific procedure, ensuring the protection of the operator and the equipment. While designing the barrier device for performing bronchoscopy, we had three objectives: operator safety, equipment safety, and patient comfort. For the ease of bronchoscopic procedures, we made the circular holes in the device's posterior aspect (through which the operator inserts his/her hands) as oblong. Also, to prevent damage to the bronchoscope, we used cushioning around the circumference of the aperture used for inserting the bronchoscope through the barrier device. The height of the barrier device was designed to adjust for the height of the thoracic cage so as not to compromise the reach of the bronchoscope to the lower lobe segments. We made side holes for the bronchoscopy assistant's safety, to avoid direct exposure to the aerosol jet, if the patient coughed during the procedure. We kept the front of the barrier box open, which improves patient comfort and avoids claustrophobia. The front open system also provides the path of least resistance for the airborne particles, thereby moving the aerosol jet away from the operator.

Thus far, we have performed 323 bronchoscopic procedures [Table 1], including 71 endobronchial ultrasound procedures. We have also performed bronchoscopy in three patients with COVID-19. None of our health-care workers involved in the bronchoscopy suite have tested positive for COVID-19 antibodies. Notably, at the time of reporting, we have not encountered any damage to our equipment. Also, none of our patients reported any feeling of claustrophobia. In our experience, we have found that the enclosure device works as intended. However, more evidence from other centers is required for the widespread use of such enclosure devices.

Table 1:
Our experience of performing bronchoscopy using the barrier enclosure device (n=323)

Financial support and sponsorship


Conflicts of interest

There are no conflicts of interest.


1. Thangakunam B, Christopher DJ. Barrier enclosure device: More scientific evidence is required Lung India. 2021;38:104
2. Sehgal IS, Dhooria S, Prasad KT, Muthu V, Aggarwal AN, Agarwal R. Barrier enclosure device during patient preparation for flexible bronchoscopy Lung India. 2020;37:463–4
3. Simpson JP, Wong DN, Verco L, Carter R, Dzidowski M, Chan PY. Measurement of airborne particle exposure during simulated tracheal intubation using various proposed aerosol containment devices during the COVID-19 pandemic Anaesthesia. 2020;75:1587–95
4. Begley JL, Lavery KE, Nickson CP, Brewster DJ. The aerosol box for intubation in coronavirus disease 2019 patients: an in-situ simulation crossover study Anaesthesia. 2020;75:1014–21
5. Sehgal IS, Yaddanapudi LN, Dhooria S, Prasad KT, Puri GD, Muthu V, et al Barrier Protection during Airway Intubation Indian J Crit Care Med. 2020;24:485–6
6. Sehgal IS, Dhooria S, Prasad KT, Muthu V, Aggarwal AN, Agarwal R. Experience with Barrier enclosure device during flexible bronchoscopy J Bronchology Interv Pulmonol. 2021 In press
© 2021 Lung India | Published by Wolters Kluwer – Medknow