We also investigated whether aluminum content is affected by the reconstitution procedure. Specifically, aluminum was determined in formula milks reconstituted with aluminum-free water under laboratory conditions, in commercially available ready-to-use formulas, and in formulas reconstituted in our hospital's infant-feeding unit. The results are summarized in Figure 1. Aluminum content in milks reconstituted with aluminum-free water was significantly lower (p < 0.001) than in ready-to-use formulations and milks reconstituted in the infant-feeding unit. There was no significant difference between aluminum contents in the latter two sample groups.
With the goal of further investigating the effects of aluminum content in the water on the final concentration of this element in reconstituted formula milk, we monitored the aluminum content in tap water and in reconstituted milk from the infant-feeding unit daily over a 1-week period. The results (Fig. 2) clearly show that final concentration varied considerably depending on aluminum concentration in the tap water supply.
Considering all 80 samples together, mean aluminum concentration was 70.1 µg/l (Table 6). Mean aluminum concentration was 69.0 µg/l in the 53 samples of whole milk, 58.7 µg/l in the 10 samples of semiskim milk, 64.8 µg/l in the 15 samples of skim milk, and 152.5 µg/l in the two samples of soy milk. aluminum content did not differ significantly between any pair of sample groups, although content in the soy milk was more than double that observed in the other groups.
We also investigated possible effects of type of packaging on aluminum content (results not shown). Tetrabrik-packaged milk showed a mean concentration of 74.7 µg/l, versus 57.5 µg/l for milk sold in plastic bags and 42.6 µg/l for milks sold in plastic bottles; none of these differences was statistically significant. Mean aluminum content in ultra-high temperature milks (73.5 µg/l) was significantly higher than in pasteurized milks (49.9 µg/l; p < 0.01; Fig. 3).
The results of the present study indicate that the aluminum content in human milk (mean, 23.9 ± 9.6 µg/l) was significantly lower (p < 0.001) than in commercially available cow's milk (mean, 70.1 µg/l) and infant formulas (mean, 225.9 µg/l; Fig. 4). The difference between the cow's milk mean and the infant formula mean was likewise significant (p < 0.001).
In addition, investigators have found that human milk has the lowest aluminum content: For example, a report by the Committee on Nutrition of the American Academy of Pediatrics (17) states that the mean aluminum content of human milk has ranges from 4 to 65 µg/l in different studies. In a previous study in Spain, Ballabriga et al. (18) obtained even lower values (mean, 6.5 ± 5.0 µg/l; range, 0.9-19.8 µg/l) than in the present study. To date, the only workers to find high aluminum levels in human milk are Coni et al. (12) and Mandic et al. (19), who reported means of 167 µg/l and 380 µg/l, respectively.
In general, trace element concentrations in human milk decline with time after birth. This pattern was observed in the present study (colostrum mean, 25.7 µg/l; intermediate-stage mean, 23.3 µg/l; mature-stage mean, 21.6 µg/l), although the differences in question were not statistically significant. In 1983, Feeley et al. (20) reported that aluminum levels were higher in early and intermediate human milk than in late milk. However, Tanaka et al. (14) found no significant difference between milk samples taken 1 week and 1 month after birth.
In the present study, the mean aluminum content in commercially available cow's milk (70.1 µg/l) was about 3 times higher than in human milk. UHT milk had a higher aluminum content (mean, 73.5 µg/l) than pasteurized milk (mean, 49.8 µg/l). These differences were probably caused by the sterilization procedure, because in the preparation of UHT milk some polyphosphates are added as a stabilizer. The product used in several milks studied was the Turrisin ST (BK Giulini Chemie GmbH Co. OAG, Ladenburg, Germany), and the aluminum level found in this product was 31 µg/g (n = 11, mean, 31.0 ± 1.2 µg/g). This amount produced an increase of 31 µg/l (Fig. 3). Previous studies have reported mean aluminum contents of 27 µg/l (15), 40 µg/l (18), and 95 µg/l (21) in pasteurized cow's milk.
We did not detect significant effects of packaging on aluminum content in commercially available cow's milk, although packaging materials with high aluminum content can clearly be expected to have such effects (22). Previous investigators have indicated that aluminum levels in bottled albumin for perfusion are affected by the aluminum content of the glass (23).
Similarly, we did not detect a significant variation in aluminum content in whole, semi-skim, and skim cow's milk. However, aluminum content was markedly higher in vegetable-fat milks (mean, 152 µg/l), possibly because of the relatively high aluminum contents of the vegetable oils used.
As in previous studies, we found aluminum content to be highest in infant formulas: Depending on the manufacturer, mean aluminum content was between 3 and 23 times higher than in human milk and up to 8 times higher than in cow's milk. If we assume daily milk ingestion of 200 ml/kg, the mean value determined in the present study (225.9 µg/l) implies a daily aluminum intake of approximately 0.045 mg/kg per day, considerably lower than the provisional World Health Organization-recommended daily maximum intake of 1 mg/kg per day (24). Indeed, even considering the very high aluminum content in one of the infant formulas milk samples (1149 µg/l), daily aluminum intake would still only be approximately 0.23 mg/kg per day. Nevertheless, it is clearly appropriate to take a conservative approach when estimating maximum permissible daily intake.
Our results regarding aluminum contents in infants formulas are almost in agreement with those of previous studies (12,16,21,25-27). However, mean aluminum contents were particularly high in the Blemil, Adapta, and Modar milks (see Table 5). We thus investigated whether this might be because of contamination during packaging of the product. However, we detected no significant difference in aluminum contents before and after packaging in these milks (results not shown). We then attempted to identify the components of the milk responsible for the high aluminum content. The results (Table 7) show that the fat concentrate, lactose, and mineral mix all made a major contribution, and that total aluminum content in the finished product could be reduced by 72% by replacing these components with low-aluminum equivalents.
Formula milks prepared in the infant-feeding unit of our hospital and ready-to-use formula milks had higher aluminum concentrations than milk prepared with aluminum-free water under laboratory conditions. In the case of milk prepared in the infant-feeding unit, this appears to have been largely because of the high aluminum content of the tap water (see Fig. 2). Similar results were obtained by Semmekrot et al., (16) who found that aluminum concentration in formula milk prepared under noncontrolled conditions was 3 to 100 times that in milk prepared with aluminum-free water under laboratory conditions.
In conclusion, the results of the present study support the recommendations of the Committee on Nutrition of the American Academy of Pediatrics (17) regarding the need for infant formula manufacturers to strive to reduce aluminum concentration in their products and the desirability of printing the maximum aluminum content on the package, stating the possible dangers particularly in nursing infants with renal insufficiency or other in disorders or characteristics that might favor accumulation of this element.
1. Alfrey AC. The physiology of aluminum
in man. In: Gitelman HJ, ed. Aluminum and health.
New York: Marcel Dekker, 1989;101-24.
2. Bishop NJ, Robinson MJ, Lendon M, Hewitt CD, Day JP. Increased concentration of aluminum
in the brain of a parenterally fed preterm infant. Arch Dis Child
3. McLaughlin AIG, Kazantzis G, King E, Tearm D. Pulmonary fibrosis and encephalopathy associated with the inhalation of aluminum
dust. Br J Ind Med
4. Kerr DNS, Walls J, Ellis H, Simpson W, Uldall PR, Ward MK. Bone disease in patients undergoing regular hemodialysis. J Bone Joint Surg (Br)
5. Sedman AB, Wilkening GN, Warady BA, Lum GM, Alfrey AC. Encephalopathy in childhood secondary to aluminum toxicity
. J Pediatr
6. Baluarte HJ, Gruskin AB, Hiner LB, Foley CM, Grover WD. Encephalopathy in children with chronic renal failure. Proc Dial Transplant Forum
7. Foley CM, Polinsky MS, Gruskin AB, Baluarte HJ, Grover WD. Encephalopathy in infants and children with chronic renal disease. Arch Neurol
8. Sedman AB, Miller NL, Warady BA, Lum GA, Alfrey AC. Aluminum
loading in children with chronic renal failure. Kidney Int
9. Federal Drug Administration (FDA). Federal Register.
10. Tsou VM, Young RM, Hart M, Vanderhood J. Elevated plasma aluminum
levels in normal infants receiving antiacids containing aluminum
11. Freundlich M, Zilleruelo G, Abitbol C, Strauss J. Infant formula as a cause of aluminium toxicity
in neonatal uraemia. Lancet
12. Coni E, Bellomonte G, Caroli S. Aluminium content of infant formulas. J Trace Elem Electrolytes Health Dis
13. Sedman AB, Klein GL, Merrit RJ, et al. Evidence of aluminium loading in infants receiving intravenous therapy. N Engl J Med
14. Tanaka T, Maeda T, Imai S, Hayashi Y, Funakawa K, Nose T. Aluminum
levels in breast milk and infant formulae in Japan. Trace Elem Electrolytes
15. Koo WWK, Kaplan L, Kirug-Wispe SK. Aluminum
contamination of infant formulas. J Parenter Enteral Nutr
16. Semmekrot BA, Monnens LAH, Baadenthuysen H. Levels of aluminium in infant formulae. Lancet
17. Committee on Nutrition
, American Academy of Pediatrics, Toxicidad por aluminio en lactantes y niños. Pediatrics
18. Ballabriga A, Moreno A, Dominguez C. Aluminio. Anales Nestlé
19. Mandic ML, Grgic J, Grgic Z, Seruga M, Hasenay D. Aluminium levels in human milk. Sci Total Environ
20. Feeley RM, Eitenmiller RR, Jones JB Jr, Barnhart H. Manganese, cobalt, nickel, silicon and aluminum
in human milk during early lactation (abstract). Fed Proc
21. Weintraub R, Hams G, Meerkin M, Rosenberg R. High aluminum
content of infant milk formulas. Arch Dis Child
22. Trapp GA, Cannon JB. Aluminum
pots as a source of dietary aluminum
(letter). N Engl J Med
23. Köpel C, Baudisch H, Ibe K. Inadvertent metal loading of critically ill patients with acute renal failure by human albumin solution infusion therapy. Clin Toxicol
24. World Health Organization. Evaluation of certain food additives and contaminants: Thirty-third report of the joint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives. WHO Tech Rep Serv
25. McGraw M, Bishop N, Jameson R, et al. Aluminium content of milk formulae and intravenous fluids used in infants (letter). Lancet
26. Baxter MJ, Burrell JA, Massey RC. The aluminum
content of infant formulas and tea. Food Addit Contam
27. Dabeka RW, McKenzie AD. Graphite-furnace atomic absorption spectrometric determination and survey of total aluminum
, copper, manganese, molybdenum, and tin in infant formulas and evaporated milks. Journal of the Association of Official Analytical Chemists
Keywords:© 1999 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Inc.
Aluminum; Nursing infants; Nutrition; Toxicity