PERCEPTION OF FEMALE STUDENTS OF KING SAUD UNIVERSITY TOWARDS PREMARITAL SCREENING : Journal of Family and Community Medicine

Secondary Logo

Journal Logo

Medical Education

PERCEPTION OF FEMALE STUDENTS OF KING SAUD UNIVERSITY TOWARDS PREMARITAL SCREENING

Alam, Awatif A. MD, ABCM

Author Information
Journal of Family and Community Medicine: May–Aug 2006 - Volume 13 - Issue 2 - p 83-88
  • Open

Abstract

INTRODUCTION

Genetic disorders are very common and highly prevalent in the general population of KSA. After years of effort in prevention and care, the third Royal Decree was issued in 1/1/1425H; 21/2/2004G, for the compulsory application of pre-marital screening as means of preventing the most common genetic diseases in KSA. The Saudi national program for pre-marital screening was approved by a Royal Decree in (4/1/1423H; 18/3/2002A.D.). It affirmed the necessity to arrange over a period of three years, health awareness programs with the help of the media and other agencies to explain the benefits of medical pre-marital screening to the public and make them aware of the serious consequences of infectious and genetic diseases.1 A National Working Group (NWG), a voluntary body, was established in 1990 to coordinate the various activities and services related to blood disorders in the KSA. Its remit includes the improvement of public awareness, the conduct of continuing education and training, promotion of research and assessment of prevention and care programs. The NWG is also to encourage links between local, national, regional and international peer groups.1

According to the World Health Organization (WHO), approximately 240 million people are heterozygous for inherited haemoglobinopathies including thalassaemia and sickle-cell disease. Moreover, at least 200,000 lethally affected homozygotes, almost equally divided between sickle-cell anemia and thalassaemia are born annually.2 The WHO has repeatedly recommended several measures for the prevention of genetic diseases including health education and the improvement of community knowledge and attitude towards the control of hereditary genetic diseases.2 Various ethical, legal and cultural issues have to be taken into account, and preventive campaigns adapted to the needs of each culture.3 In Saudi Arabia, extensive investigations conducted over several years in the different provinces have revealed a high rate of gene occurrence for both sickle-cell anemia and thalassaemia.45

Legislation of the Saudi premarital screening program for all Saudi couples is expected to have an effective impact on the prevention of inherited haemoglobinopathies, to reduce the financial burden on individuals and the government and to minimize the social and psychological problems resulting from having affected children. A recent report from Saudi Arabia expressed the hope that the premarital screening program would include screening for other hereditary blood diseases as well as for sexually transmitted diseases.6

This study aims at investigating the perception of the female students of King Saud University on the application of premarital screening.

METHODS

A KAP survey was conducted by designing a close-ended questionnaire that included enquiries about the content, nature and ways of applying the premarital screening. It also included questions on the perception of the compulsory application of PMS. The given choices were “Yes”, “No” and “Don’t know”. Participants were also allowed to express their opinion about the expected benefits and disadvantages of PMS. An open health education lecture on “the role of PMS in preventing hereditary blood disorders” was attended by 140 female students from various colleges including the Arts and Social Sciences of King Saud University. This was done during the annual awareness week of the university, which coincided with the end of two months of the compulsory enforcement of PMS in Saudi Arabia 1/1/1424H.

The same designed closed-ended questionnaires were distributed twice, before and after the lecture. The first set was collected before the start of the lecture. The second was distributed and collected at the end of the lecture and before the discussion. Students were reassured of the confidentiality of their opinions by ensuring that the responses were anonymous.

About seven months after the first lecture, there was a request to give the female students enrolled in special education and other humanities at the university, a lecture similar to the first one with special emphasis on the preventive benefits of PMS. At the end of the second lecture, the audience was encouraged to complete the distributed open-ended questionnaire asking for a feedback on the information given and their perception of the content, nature and the means of conducting PMS in Saudi Arabia. The collected forms were summarized into a signed consensus statement. As requested by the students, the signed format was mailed to legislative authorities.

RESULTS

The response rate of the first close-ended pre and post lecture questionnaires was 132 (94.3%) and 128 (91.4%) respectively. The age of the participants ranged from 20-25 years. A total of 112 out of 132 (84.8%) students in the pre test and 111 out of 128 (86.7%) students in the post test were single. Of the married students 7/20 (35.0%) in the pre test and 7/17 (41.2%) in the post test had previously had PMS.

Table 1 portrays students’ attitude towards PMS and the reasons for it. It shows that the majority of the students (81.8% in the pre test and 85.9% in the post test) saw the importance of PMS in controlling the commonest hereditary diseases. However, a smaller percentage supported the compulsory application of the test (69.7% and 75.0% in pre and post test respectively).

T1-7
Table 1:
Students’ attitude towards PMS and reasons behind it

As regards the reasons for their attitude, Table 1 also reveals that all students (100.0%) in pre and post test were anxious about the confidentiality of the test results. Similarly, all of them believed that abnormal test results would create social and psychological problems.

Also, a considerable proportion of students were not confident that the test result would be accurate (35.6% and 12.5% respectively) as shown in Table 1. Moreover, 9.1% and 20.3% of the students in the pre and post tests respectively, expected to have social problems if they would undergo PMS in the future.

All responses from the pre and post questionnaires expressed the need to improve the community's awareness of the relationship between consanguineous marriages and hereditary blood diseases and the preventive value of PMS.

The second lecture was attended by 319 Saudi female university students, 298 (93.4%) of whom were from the College of Special Education and the rest from other Humanities Colleges. They had not attended the first lecture. Their ages ranged from 20-24 years; 50 (15.7%) of the students were married, and out of these 18 (36%) had undergone PMS.

The analysis of the collected open-ended questions revealed an overall positive attitude towards the importance of the topic of the lecture. A total of 250 (78.4%) students did not know that PMS covered only hereditary blood disorders. Owing to the similarity of the responses, they were summarized into a consensus statement which was signed by all participants. They suggested that the issues they raised be forwarded to the responsible authority.

The statement spoke of their concerns, as future mothers, about the health of their future partners and off-spring. They asked that the scope of the pre-marital examination be broadened to investigate and screen for other diseases that would adversely affect individuals and the community as a whole, and which may constitute a significant burden and strain on their marriages. They suggested screening for psychological and personality disorders, sexually transmitted diseases, drug addictions, viral hepatitis and human immunodeficiency syndrome. Accordingly, the signed statement was directed to the responsible authorities in the Ministry of Health for consideration.

DISCUSSION

The health and well-being of people is determined by a wide range of economic, social and environmental influences. Activities in many sectors beyond the health sector impact on these determinants of health.

Health impact assessment (HIA) is a participatory approach that encourages people from multiple sectors to work together.7 This study was done in order to investigate the perception of female university students towards the compulsory premarital screening in KSA. Although the included sample, a group of university students, is not representative of the Saudi population, their perception of and insights into PMS should not be spurned. A previous extensive study had shown that through health education, population screening and genetic counseling of carriers, as well as the prevention of marriages between carriers, it was possible to reduce the homozygous affected births from 53 per 8594 births in 1974 to 0 per 10752 in 1988 and 2 per 10830 in 1990.8 University students can serve as advocates of awareness in their own communities. The majority of the students were < 25 years old and single. The information provided could assist in making them better aware of the dangers and more selective of their future partners. Religious and ethical considerations in the prevention and management of genetic disorders were extensively reviewed before compulsory PMS was initiated in Saudi Arabia.9

The present study revealed that 75.0% supported the compulsory application of PMS. Similarly, in assessing the attitudes of university students in Abha, KSA, in 2002 towards premarital counseling, 70% accepted its application while 17% gave neutral response. However, 13% rejected the idea of premarital counseling. The majority of those who rejected it believed that it interfered with God's will. It was accordingly concluded that this negative attitude was the result of religious misunderstanding, and the respondents could benefit from intensive religious health education.10 An earlier study in Riyadh in the year 2000, had findings and implications similar to the previous study.11

The results of the present study showed different influences in their attitude towards application of PMS. The students indicated that though they had no fear about the investigations, they were apprehensive of the maintenance of confidentiality of results and also felt that abnormal results would create both social and psychological problems. These students can be reassured on the envisaged negative impact of abnormal test results by weighing the adverse effects against the many advantages of PMS including the alleviation of the burden of preventable disorders, would improve their future perception. All respondents asked that the awareness of the general public be raised about the benefits of PMS in KSA, where the rate of consanguineous marriages is high. Previous studies estimated that the rate of consanguineous unions in KSA constituted more than 50% of all marriages in KSA.1214

As the second health education lecture was called for by coordinators from special education and humanities departments in King Saud University, more students attended than in the first lecture. The interaction of the audience showed their interest in the subject. The passage of time usually increases people's perception of the benefits of a compulsory legislation that was meant to improve the quality of life of future generations. Nevertheless, a participatory approach that takes on board the views of the community should be encouraged.

The students in the present study demanded the extension of PMS to investigate and screen for other diseases especially sexually transmitted diseases likely to adversely affect the health of individuals and the community. Their anxiety and interest in screening for other diseases may be due to the fact that the majority of the study group were unmarried and may reject proposals of marriage on account of anxiety about the health of their offspring. In addition, it may reflect their knowledge of the effect of globalization on the spread of diseases.

As a matter of fact, premarital screening has now been included in the curriculum of special education, which is a very progressive and encouraging approach. The Health Impact Assessment as defined by the World Health Organization (WHO), calls for the identification of the relevant stakeholders at the initial stage of an assessment. During this process a framework is designed for meaningful consultations, with various responsible authorities and the promotion of the ideas. Female university students were used as study population because women have a stake in this issue. Others with vested interests include the local community (particularly vulnerable groups), planners, local/national Government, health workers at various levels, and decision makers.7 As future beneficiaries, students were encouraged to express their opinion on the nature, content and how premarital screening is performed in Saudi Arabia. It was hoped that the consensus statement which had the views of all 319 students, who had signed it would reach the responsible authorities. The statement made no reference to the compulsory status of the policy. It however, asked that the scope of the battery of tests be extended to include the screening of other diseases that they thought likely to undermine their marriages. This view has also been expressed by Al-Swaidi.6 The values of health impact assessment include democracy, equity, sustainable development and ethical use of evidence. Democracy dictates that people be allowed to participate in the development and implementation of policies, programmes or projects that impact on their lives.7 Because of the lack of adequate quantitative and qualitative evidence, it is hoped that consideration is given to the issues raised when developing future large-scale premarital screening. More analytic and qualitative studies should be encouraged to bring in views of more representative groups of the community. To influence the decision-making process on issues under discussion, it is advisable that recommendations reach the decision-makers before legislations are made.

CONCLUSION

This study highlights in general, the positive views of female university students on compulsory premarital screening in Saudi Arabia. However, the results do not reflect the views of the entire Saudi population because of the selective nature of the study. The reservations that few students had on this issue can be addressed by improving the health awareness on certain related issues. In this regard, a concerted effort and the cooperation of the educational, health and social agencies is required. However, appropriate measures could only be taken when the decision-makers are supplied with the necessary evidence from community-based studies.

REFERENCES

1. El Hazmi MAF. The natural history and the national pre-marital screening program in Saudi Arabia Saudi Med J. 2004;25(11):1549–1554
2. . Hereditary anemia: genetic basis, clinical features, diagnosis and treatment Bull Wrld Hlth Org. 1982;60(5):643–60
3. Al-Bar MA. Ethics of medical practice and genetic counseling in Islamic communities Health and Life Journal. 2003(Special Issue):10–16
4. El Hazmi MAF, Warsy AS. Frequency of Sickle-cell Gene in Saudi Arabia Gene Geography. 1996;10:87–91
5. El Hazmi MAF, Warsy AS. Appraisal of Sickle-cell and thalassaemia genes in Saudi Arabia Eastern Med Hlth J. 1999;5(6):1147–1153
6. Al Swaidi F. Premarital testing screening in KSA Saudi Epidem Bull. 2004;11(2):13
7. . World Health Organization (2005) Health Impact Assessment (HIA). www.who.int
8. Angastiniotis MEl Hazmi MAF. Social or community response to national control programme for thalassaemia Proceedings of the symposium on blood genetic disorders. 1994 Riyadh KACST Press:154–9
9. Albar MA. Ethical considerations in the prevention and management of genetic disorders with special emphasis on religious considerations Saudi Med J. 2002;23(6):627–632
10. Al-Khaldi YM, Al-Sharif AI, Sadiq AA, Ziady HH. Attitudes to premarital counseling among students of Abha health sciences college Saudi Med J. 2002;23(8):986–90
11. Al-Kahtani NH. Acceptance of premarital health counseling in Riyadh City, 1417H Journal of Family & Community Medicine. 2000;7(2):27–34
12. Al-Abulkareem AA, Ballal SG. Consanguineous marriage in an urban area of Saudi Arabia: Health effects on the offspring J community health. 1998;23:75–83
13. Al-Hussain M, Al-Bunyan M. Consanguineous marriage in Saudi population and the effect of inbreeding on prenatal and postnatal mortality Ann Trop Paediatr. 1997;17:155–160
14. El-Hazmi MAF, Al-Swailem AR, Warsy AS. Consanguinity among the Saudi Arabian population J Med Genet. 1995;32:623–626
Keywords:

Premarital Screening; Health Education; Kingdom of Saudi Arabia

© 2006 Journal of Family and Community Medicine | Published by Wolters Kluwer – Medknow