Recent studies in general surgery and internal medicine have shown that female physicians may have improved morbidity and mortality compared with their male counterparts. In the field of orthopaedic surgery, little is known about the influence of surgeon gender on patient complications. This study investigates patient complications after hip and knee arthroplasty based on the gender of the treating surgeon.
Using a risk-adjusted outcomes database of 100% Medicare data from a third party, an analysis of outcomes after primary hip and knee arthroplasty based on surgeon gender was performed. This data set, which provided risk-adjusted complication rates for each surgeon performing at least 20 primary knee or hip arthroplasties from 2009 to 2013, was matched with publically available Medicare data sets to determine surgeon gender, year of graduation, area of practice, and surgical volume. Confounding variables were controlled for in multivariate analysis.
Of the 8,965 surgeons with identified gender, 187 (2.0%; 187 of 8,965) were identified as women and performed 21,216 arthroplasties (1.4%; 21,216 of 1,518,419). Overall, female surgeons averaged fewer arthroplasties (total knee arthroplasty: 87.0 versus 124.9 [P < 0.001]; total hip arthroplasty [THA]: 62.8 versus 78.8 [P = 0.02]) and were earlier in their practice (20.6 versus 25.0 years; P < 0.001) compared with their male counterparts. Male and female surgeons had similar adjusted complication rates for THA (2.78% versus 2.84%) and total knee arthroplasty (2.24% versus 2.26%). Multivariate analysis found that the predictors of increased complications were decreased surgeon volume, THA, increased surgeons' years in practice, and geographic region.
Overall, female orthopaedic surgeons performed fewer arthroplasties and were earlier in their career. This, however, did not a have a negative impact on their surgical outcomes. Rather, complication rates were dependent on surgeon volume, surgeon experience, and region.
Level of Evidence:
Level III–prognostic retrospective case-control study.