Secondary Logo

Journal Logo

BRIEF COMMUNICATION

Quality of newspaper reporting of suicide in Odisha, India, against the World Health Organization guidelines

Kar, Sujita Kumar; Padhy, Susanta Kumar1; Bhoi, Rosali1; Pattnaik, Jigyansa Ipsita2; Menon, Vikas3,

Author Information
doi: 10.4103/indianjpsychiatry.indianjpsychiatry_398_21
  • Open

Abstract

INTRODUCTION

The latest data from the National Crime Records Bureau reveals that more than 150,000 individuals died by suicide in India in 2020,[1] with a devastating impact on their families, friends, and communities. Given this scenario, experts have argued for a coordinated public health approach to suicide prevention in India. Responsible and balanced media reporting is an essential component of a public health approach to preventing suicide; it promotes awareness and prevents subsequent suicides, whereas sensationalized reporting may trigger suicidal behavior among vulnerable individuals.[23]

The literature on media reporting of suicide in India remains limited. Further, available studies have assessed quality of media reporting against the World Health Organization (WHO) reporting guidelines;[4] none evaluated adherence to the recent reporting guidelines issued by the Press Council of India (PCI) in 2019.[5] Given this scenario, we planned the present study to evaluate the quality of media reporting in print newspapers of the state of Odisha against both international[4] as well as local[5] media reporting guidelines. We chose the eastern state of Odisha because the suicide rate in the state is pegged at 12.2 per 100,000 population, which is above the national average of 11.3 per 100,000 population.[1]

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Study setting and data collection

A team of two bilingual psychiatrists independently reviewed all suicide news reports published in the printed versions of the two most widely read English (TheTimesofIndia and TheNewIndianExpress) and local language (Odia) newspapers (Sambad and Samaj) across 1 year from October 1, 2019, to September 30, 2020. The selected newspapers figure among the most widely read newspapers in the state.[6] The search was performed retrospectively, in person, and printed newspapers were sourced from physical libraries. Before study initiation, both the investigators were explained the selection and coding of reports by a team of senior investigators with prior experience in such research.[7] We included all news articles reporting a suicide event (both suicide and attempted suicide) within the geographical boundaries of the state of Odisha during the study; reports of suicide that occurred outside the state boundaries were excluded.

Data extraction

Relevant data were extracted using a Google form, which was prepared apriori based on the checklist for media reporting of suicide by the WHO[4] and the PCI.[5] We chose the WHO reporting guidelines as the measure of quality assessment because it is the most widely employed measure in media reporting studies from India[78] and Asia.[910]

The initial part of the questionnaire collected necessary descriptive information about the report such as name and date of the publication, language of the news report, the position of the news report (main section or supplement of the newspaper), and length of the news report (<11 sentences, 11–20 sentences, and more than 20 sentences). Subsequent information from the report was extracted under the following headings:

Content in the title of the report

The following variables were coded in this section: mention of the person’s name, age, gender, occupation of the person, method of suicide, the reason for suicide, location of suicide, and triggering life events.

Content in the body of the report

Here, we coded all the above information. Moreover, we also coded mentioning detailed description of steps involved in committing suicide (operationalized as mentioning any two sequential steps of suicide),[8] relevant life events, mono-causal explanations, mention of suicide note, effects on the family, interview of bereaved family members, information on warning signs and association of the event with mental health issues, and other helpful reporting practices elucidated in the WHO reporting guidelines.[4]

In addition, items based on the PCI reporting guidelines which were not covered by WHO guidelines were also coded; this included the presence of repeating stories, use of sensationalized language, normalization of suicide (as a constructive way to deal with life’s issues), explicit description of method used (operationalized as including a description about the suicide method but without mentioning sequential steps of suicide), usage of sensational headlines, inclusion of links to relevant video footage or social media.

Each of the above variables was coded as yes or no based on the presence or absence of the item in the news report. After completing data entry, all fields were independently checked by the first author; any missing data were corrected at this stage.

Statistical analysis

Descriptive statistics (frequencies with percentages) were used to depict the data extracted. Quality assessment of media suicide reports was described under potentially harmful characteristics and potentially helpful characteristics as per the WHO reporting guidelines and summarized using descriptive statistics.

Ethical approval

As the study involved analysis of secondary data available in the public domain, no formal approval of an independent ethics committee was sought for carrying out the present work.

RESULTS

A total of 248 relevant news reports of suicide were identified during the search. Of these news reports, 130 (52.4%) were local language (Odia) news reports, and the remaining (n = 118, 47.8%) were English news reports. The break-up of news reports in the individual newspapers was as follows: TheNewIndianExpress (n = 67), Sambad (n = 67), Samaj (n = 63), and TheTimesofIndia (n = 51).

Descriptive characteristics of the reports

The majority (n = 246, 99.2%) of the news articles were published in the newspaper’s central section, with 26.2% (n = 65) having a highly prominent placement. Approximately one in five news articles (n = 54, 21.8%) were lengthy and occupied more than 20 sentences. The majority of the news reports (n = 233, 93.9%) were about suicide decedents, and 76.6% (n = 190) of the articles discussed a single suicide case.

Quality assessment of suicide reporting against World Health Organization reporting guidelines

More than half of the news reports mentioned gender (83.5%), method of suicide (60.9%), and location of suicide (52.0%) in the title of the news reports. Similarly, the majority of the news reports discussed the personal details [name (74.2%), age (60.9%), and gender (98.4%)], and details of the suicidal act [method of suicide (87.5%), location of suicide (84.3%)] in the body of the news report. More than half of the news reports mentioned inciting life events (61.7%) and proposed a monocausal explanation (54.8%) for suicide.

Potentially helpful reporting characteristics such as mentioning the effects on the bereaved (8.1%), warning signs of suicide (5.2%), associated mental health issues (10. 9%), suicide research data (2.4%), or statistics (2.0%), and including educational and preventive information (0.40%) were relatively less common. None of the news reports mentioned the contact details of support services [Table 1].

T1-11
Table 1:
Potentially harmful and helpful reporting characteristics according to the World Health Organization media reporting guidelines

Quality assessment of suicide reporting against Press Council of India reporting guidelines

The most common reporting infringement mentioned details about the suicide site or location (48.8%) followed by explicit descriptions of the suicide method used (46.8%) [Table 2].

T2-11
Table 2:
Reporting characteristics according to Press Council of India media reporting guidelines for suicide

DISCUSSION

Our findings show that media reporting of suicide in Odisha is imbalanced and poorly adherent to international[4] and the PCI’s reporting guidelines.[5] Harmful reporting practices were very prevalent; in contrast, there was little focus on helpful reporting practices. Readers were commonly exposed to lengthy, prominently placed, and sensationalist portrayals of suicide stories.

Our findings are consistent with prior studies from India[7811] and South East Asia[910] which assessed the quality of media reporting of suicide against international guidelines. The use of explicit language to describe the identity of the person was highly prevalent in the reports; observed figures were much higher than a previous study from India[7] though lower than some others[1112] and much higher compared to studies from developed nations.[1314] Likewise, reporting of suicide methods and steps involved in suicide were common transgressions, comparable to other studies from India[78] and South East Asia.[9] A detailed description of suicide methods can trigger imitative suicides by providing a model to those vulnerable;[15] accordingly, there is a need to curb this practice.

Crucially, amidst these reporting infringements, there was little focus on reporting practices that provide hope and help to readers. A little more than a tenth of the reports discussed association with mental health issues, very few reports included any information on suicide-related warning signs, expert opinions, suicide-related statistics, or research findings, and, rather strikingly, none of the reports included any information on suicide support services, such as suicide helplines. These represent clear violation of reporting guidelines and are in line with reporting trends from India,[8] Asia,[91016] and elsewhere.[13]

Given the weight of evidence on the sub-optimal quality of media reporting of suicide in India and Asian countries, we propose a few recommendations such as framing national guidelines for responsible media reporting, commissioning of a national media monitoring agency[17] and greater collaboration and engagement with media professionals to improve the scenario on media reporting of suicide.

The present study had two key limitations. First, we covered only four newspapers from a single state in India over a 1-year time period. Second, our findings may not generalize to other forms of print media such as tabloids or evening newspapers.

CONCLUSIONS

Media reporting of suicide in Odisha, India, is poorly adherent to PCI and WHO reporting guidelines. These findings point to the need for greater engagement and collaboration with media professionals to promote balanced and responsible suicide reporting.

Financial support and sponsorship

Nil.

Conflicts of interest

There are no conflicts of interest.

REFERENCES

1. National Crime Records Bureau Accidental Deaths &Suicides in India – 2020 2020 Available from: https://ncrb.gov.in/sites/default/files/adsi2020_Chapter-2-Suicides.pdf Last accessed on 2021 Dec 04
2. Hawton K, Williams K Influences of the media on suicide BMJ 2002 325 1374–5
3. Niederkrotenthaler T, Braun M, Pirkis J, Till B, Stack S, Sinyor M, et al Association between suicide reporting in the media and suicide:Systematic review and meta-analysis BMJ 2020 368 m575
4. World Health Organization Preventing Suicide:A Resource for Media Professionals –Update 2017 Geneva, Switzerland International Association for Suicide Prevention (IASP):World Health Organization. Department of Mental Health and Substance Abuse  2017
5. Press Council of India Guidelines Adopted by the PCI on Mental Illness/Reporting of Suicide Cases 2020 Available from: http://presscouncil.nic.in/WriteReadData/Pdf/PRtennineteentwenty.pdf Last accessed on 2020 Jul 02
6. Media Research Users Council Indian Readership Survey 2019 Available from: https://mruc.net/ Last accessed on 2020 Dec 10
7. Menon V, Kaliamoorthy C, Sridhar VK, Varadharajan N, Joseph R, Kattimani S, et al Do Tamil newspapers educate the public about suicide? Content analysis from a high suicide Union Territory in India Int J Soc Psychiatry 2020 66 785–91
8. Armstrong G, Vijayakumar L, Niederkrotenthaler T, Jayaseelan M, Kannan R, Pirkis J, et al Assessing the quality of media reporting of suicide news in India against World Health Organization guidelines:A content analysis study of nine major newspapers in Tamil Nadu Aust N Z J Psychiatry 2018 52 856–63
9. Arafat SM, Khan MM, Niederkrotenthaler T, Ueda M, Armstrong G Assessing the quality of media reporting of suicide deaths in Bangladesh against World Health Organization Guidelines Crisis 2020 41 47–53
10. Brandt Sørensen J, Pearson M, Andersen MW, Weerasinghe M, Rathnaweera M, Rathnapala DGC, et al Self-harm and suicide coverage in Sri Lankan newspapers Crisis 2019 40 54–61
11. Chandra PS, Doraiswamy P, Padmanabh A, Philip M Do newspaper reports of suicides comply with standard suicide reporting guidelines? A study from Bangalore, India Int J Soc Psychiatry 2014 60 687–94
12. Kar SK, Shukla S, Rai S, Sharma N, Roy D, Menon V, et al Assessing the quality of suicide reporting in online newspapers in Uttar Pradesh, India, according to World Health Organization Guidelines Crisis 2021 1-7 Online ahead of print
13. McTernan N, Spillane A, Cully G, Cusack E, O'Reilly T, Arensman E Media reporting of suicide and adherence to media guidelines Int J Soc Psychiatry 2018 64 536–44
14. Pitman A, Stevenson F Suicide reporting within British newspapers'arts coverage Crisis 2015 36 13–20
15. Fink DS, Santaella-Tenorio J, Keyes KM Increase in suicides the months after the death of Robin Williams in the US PLoS One 2018 13 e0191405
16. Kamboh SA, Ittefaq M Newspaper suicide reporting in a muslim country:Analysis of violations and compliance with international guidelines J Media Ethics 2019 34 2–14
17. Menon V, Kar SK, Ransing R, Arafat SY, Padhy SK National media monitoring agency for reporting of suicide: An idea whose time has come? Asian J Psychiatr 2021 55 102516
Keywords:

India; media; suicide; suicide prevention; Werther effect

© 2022 Indian Journal of Psychiatry | Published by Wolters Kluwer – Medknow