Clinical and diagnostic color-coding in ophthalmology - An indispensable educational tool for ophthalmologists : Indian Journal of Ophthalmology

Secondary Logo

Journal Logo

Review Article

Clinical and diagnostic color-coding in ophthalmology - An indispensable educational tool for ophthalmologists

Mishra, Deepak; Kaur, Kirandeep1,; Gurnani, Bharat2; Heda, Aarti3; Dwivedi, Kshama4

Author Information
doi: 10.4103/ijo.IJO_442_22
  • Open

Abstract

Documentation is merely a requirement in every job, however, in healthcare, it forms a vital part of each member’s role.[1] Schematic documentation has been a cornerstone of clinical science from the days of Hippocrates.[2] This has helped in not only standardizing the records but has also assisted us in understanding the disease process over time, maintain records, and at the same time, helped in easy cross-referrals across the globe. There are many vital moments during the treatment of any ocular pathology.[3] Proper documentation can help the practitioners to recall those moments and plan treatment accordingly. No or poor documentation reduces the value of any clinical records. Moreover, inaccurate or incomplete documentation is a threat to patient safety and hampers the defense of a medical malpractice lawsuit.[4]

Documentation is a simple but effective tool that can help any practitioner in unveiling clinical patterns. It can help track the progression or regression of any ocular pathology on subsequent follow-ups.[5] It also helps in understanding patterns of clinical presentation and also any associated unhealthy behaviors like contact lens use.[6] Documentation is often the sole way of communication whenever treatment protocol changes among practitioners. For patients, documentation ensures the delivery of safe, precise, consistent, and quality healthcare.[7] In this digital era, the introduction of the Electronic Medical Record (EMR) system was a landmark attempt to improve the documentation and allow easy access to old records of the patient. King et al.[8] in their study found that the physicians reported the use of Electronic Health Records (EHR)-enhanced patient care overall. Clinical benefits were most likely to be reported by physicians having longer EHR experience.

The history of standardizing color-coding in Ophthalmology dates back to 1969 when Schepens described the graphic documentation of retinal disorders.[9] This was followed by an article in 1973, where for the first time, a scheme for documenting corneal diseases was described.[10] This was improvised by Waring et al.[11] in 1977 wherein they described fontal and slit sketches for documentation of corneal pathologies. Bühren et al.[12] in 2006 described the colored standardized drawing scheme to document corneal changes following refractive surgery. It is very important to inculcate the habit of proper documentation from the beginning of our medical career. This is extremely vital in the field of Ophthalmology, where the eye being a small and compact structure has innumerable microscopic findings for which documentation with standardized color-coding becomes vital for quality patient care.[13]

Color-coding is particularly more important in the current COVID-19 pandemic, as there are delayed presentations by patients secondary to lockdown and fear of acquiring COVID-19 infection in the hospital settings.[14] Schematic documentation of the anterior and posterior segment findings, particularly in cases of corneal ulcers, diabetes, or hypertensive retinopathy will help in correlating the clinical findings even after delayed follow-ups. COVID-19 has come with a lot of challenges for postgraduate training.[15] But it is important to understand that training in proper documentation with illustrative standardized diagrams is as important as a wet lab[16] and surgical training to bring out competent ophthalmologists. As per the detailed literature review, this is the first article related to Ophthalmology documenting the color-coding for schematic documentation in detail. In this article, we have attempted to summarize the standardized color-coding systems in ophthalmology. We believe this will be very useful not only for trainees in ophthalmology but also for established ophthalmologists to recollect the old knowledge and ensure proper documentation of the clinical findings

Why is Schematic Documentation Important in Ophthalmology?

The need for diagrammatic representation has been long emphasized. Dvorak et al.[17] described drawing as a lost art of medicine and emphasized the role of mapping retinal tears, detachments, and landmarks before surgical detachment repair. The sketch of the eye allows the ophthalmologist to accurately describe the size, depth, and location of the lesion. Proper clinical documentation at each visit ensures better management of the patient as it allows comparison with the previous records.[18] The information becomes furthermore valuable when a patient is from a rural distant place and cannot follow-up at a major center for close follow-ups.[19] A trained ophthalmologist in a rural setting can document findings at each visit and maintain regular records till he feels the patient needs a referral to a higher center.[20] Thus, it creates a standardized method of documentation and helps not only in proper management, but also comes as a savior from medico-legal issues as well.[21] Documentation with schematic diagrams also helps in educating the trainee in ocular anatomy along with the use of slit-lamp and binocular indirect ophthalmoscope.[22] It helps to document the pathology in a more detailed manner as compared to clinical photographs. It is less expensive, allows standardization of documentation, is easy to follow-up, is a useful teaching modality, and presents a total picture at a glance.[23]

Color-Coding in Clinical Ophthalmology

Anterior segment

The requisites for drawing include six colored pencils or pens such as black, blue, brown, red, green, and yellow and an eraser to allow modifications of drawing. There are some stencils available commercially which aid in the quick reproduction of cornea and retina diagrams, front of eye, and slit shape outlines. First, we need to sketch the major landmark and then details should be filled in. Corneal pathologies are documented on a frontal plane and a cross-sectional or slit plane. The cornea is depicted in plain view by a circle. Vessels drawn inside the circle are, therefore, pathological. To depict the vessels of the limbal palisades, these must be drawn outside the circle, as must, other limbal features such as limbal infiltrate and follicles.

A corneal cross-section is drawn as two parallel arcs with freehand in a black outline. This allows a more accurate representation of the variation in corneal thickness, such as anterior ulceration, the posterior bulge of stromal edema, or diffuse thinning. Another wavy line along the anterior corneal surface represents the epithelium. The clinical findings like epithelial defects, microcysts, edema, bullae, opacities, and discontinuity are depicted on this wavy line. A single black line represents the endothelium and Descemet’s membrane. In the presence of a dense stromal opacity, the posterior corneal surface is represented by a dotted line with appropriate annotation. The depth of corneal pathology can be depicted in the slit diagram.

Following color-coding is generally used to document the findings of the anterior segment. Black color is used to represent limbus, scars, degenerations, dystrophy, foreign bodies, sutures, contact lens, and band-shaped keratopathy. The blue color is used to represent the stromal edema, epithelial edema, Descemet’s membrane folds, and epithelial bulla. The brown color is used to represent epithelial iron lines, epithelial melanosis, pupil and iris, iridodialysis, iris nodules, old keratic precipitates, and Kruckenberg’s spindle. The red color is used to depict blood vessels. The superficial vessels are drawn starting outside the limbal line while the deep vessels arise at the limbal line. Further, the subepithelial vessels are depicted as wavy lines and begin outside the limbal circle. While the stromal vessels are depicted as straight lines and begin at the margin of the limbal circle. Other findings depicted in red include ghost vessels, ciliary or conjunctival congestion, hemorrhages, and hyphema. The green color is used to depict filaments (line), punctate epithelial keratopathy (dots), epithelial defect (shades), dendrites, lenticular changes, and vitreous strands in the anterior chamber. The yellow color is used to depict hypopyon, infiltrates and fresh keratic precipitates. The details of the anterior segment color-coding are described in Table 1. Detailed anterior segment drawing with commonly encountered clinical findings has been illustrated in Fig. 1.

T1
Table 1:
Showing detailed color-coding guidelines for anterior segment schematic representation
F1
Figure 1:
(a and b) Detailed anterior segment pictorial representation of commonly encountered clinical findings along with a cross-sectional slit segment

Posterior segment

The prerequisites for fundus drawing include an examination table, indirect ophthalmoscope, +20 D lens, scleral depressor, colored pencils (red, blue, green, yellow, black, and brown), an eraser, and a fundus drawing chart. The standard fundus drawing chart called as Amsler–Dubois chart contains three concentric circles. The innermost circle on the chart represents the equator, the middle circle represents the ora serrata, and the outer circle represents the junction between the pars plana and the pars plicata.[24] The optic nerve head is represented as a small circle. The macula is drawn in the center, and the optic nerve head is located nasal to the macula. The radial Roman numerals on the outer circle of the chart are useful to explain the location and also the extent of the lesions in clock hours.

During the examination, the patient should be lying down comfortably with a well-dilated pupil. The peripheral retina should be examined first as it is less sensitive to light than the posterior pole. To trace the lesion, the disc is first focused and followed along the blood vessel to the periphery. To replicate the clinical examination findings on Amsler’s chart, the bottom right-hand corner of the chart is kept next to the patient’s right shoulder. This is especially important in the early training period and helps to overcome the difficulties due to the inverted and reversed images perceived by the observer during indirect ophthalmoscopy.

The following color-coding is used to describe the findings of the posterior segment. The red color is used to depict the retinal arterioles, elevated neovascularization, vascular abnormalities\ anomalies, vascular tumors, vortex veins, attached retina, hemorrhages (pre-retinal and intraretinal, subhyaloid), the open interior of retinal breaks (tears, holes), the open interior of outer layer holes in retinoschisis, normal macula, macular edema (blue/red cross with four adjacent blue dots), open portion of a giant retinal tear, retinal holes, large dialyses, inner portions of thinned retinal areas, and the open part of retinal holes in the inner layer of retinoschisis. The blue color is used to depict areas of a detached retina, retinal veins, outlines of retinal breaks, outline of ora serrate, meridional, radial, fixed and circumferential folds, traction tufts, retinal granular tags and tufts, the outline of flat neovascularization, the outline of lattice degeneration, the outline of thin areas of the retina, and intraretinal cysts, the inner layer of retinoschisis, white with or without pressure, detached pars plana epithelium anterior to the separation of ora serrate, rolled edges of retinal tears, cystoid degeneration, and areas of the detached retina. The green color is used to depict opacities in the media, vitreous hemorrhage, vitreous membranes, hyaloid ring, intraocular foreign body, retinal operculum, cotton wool spots, and outline of elevated neovascularization, asteroid hyalosis, snowflakes on cystoid degenerations, retinoschisis, or lattice degeneration.

The brown color is used to represent uveal tissue, pars plana cysts, ciliary processes, striae ciliaris, pigment beneath the detached retina, the outline of chorioretinal atrophy beneath the detached retina, pigment epithelial detachment, the outline of posterior staphyloma, malignant choroidal melanomas, edge of buckle beneath the detached retina, and choroidal detachment. The yellow color represents intraretinal edema, intraretinal subretinal hard exudate, deposits in the retinal pigment epithelium, detached maculae, retinal separations, post-cryotherapy or laser retinal edema, drusens, long and short ciliary nerves, venous sheathing, and drusens. The black color is used to represent the edge of the buckle beneath the attached retina, the outline of chorioretinal atrophy, hyperpigmentation as a result of the previous treatment with cryotherapy or diathermy, naevi, sclerosed vessels, the outline of long and short post-ciliary vein and nerve, the pigment in the choroid, or pigmented epithelial hyperpigmentation in areas of the attached retina, the pigment in the detached retina, pigmented demarcation lines at the attached margin of a detached retina or within the detached retina.

The choroidal tumors are drawn in brown color and retinoblastomas are outlined with blue and colored in yellow color. For retinoschisis, the inner layer is outlined and cross-lined using blue color. While the open retinal holes within the inner layer are outlined in blue with the inner portion cross-lined in red, the holes in the outer layer are outlined in blue and the inner layer is colored red. The details of the posterior segment color-coding are described in Table 2. Detailed posterior segment drawings with commonly encountered clinical findings have been illustrated in Fig. 2a and b.

T2
Table 2:
Showing detailed color-coding guidelines for posterior segment schematic representation
F2
Figure 2:
(a and b) Detailed posterior segment pictorial representation of commonly encountered clinical findings

Color-Coding in Diagnostic Ophthalmology

Glaucoma

Clinically, for depicting optic nerve head changes in glaucoma, the disc is drawn as a circle with black color, the cup is shaded in yellow, the dichotomous arterial branching is depicted with red color, and the veins in blue color. The splinter or Drance hemorrhage as observed in normal-tension glaucoma is drawn with red and the retinal nerve fiber layer defect in green.

Ophthalmic imaging techniques such as optical coherence tomography (OCT) allow objective, quantitative evaluation of ocular structures. OCT has been shown to correlate well with histological retinal measurements[25] and to allow direct visualization and quantification of the structures of the retina and optic nerve head. This device is a valuable tool for detecting glaucoma[262728] and monitoring its progression.[29] The retinal nerve fiber layer thicknesses and optic nerve head in the normal range are represented by green backgrounds, those that are abnormal at the 5% level (borderline) are represented by yellow backgrounds, and those that are abnormal at the 1% level (below normality) are represented by red backgrounds.[30] The white color code refers to values above the normality range, and the grey color indicates that normative data are not applicable.

Cornea

Color-coded topographic maps

In Schiempflug imaging systems like Pentacam and Orbscan, the color-coded topographic maps display the contour and give valuable information regarding varied corneal pathologies like corneal ectasia (keratoconus, pellucid marginal degeneration, terrain marginal degeneration), thinning, thickening, astigmatism, post LASIK ectasia, etc.[31] The hot colors like red and its various shades represent the steep areas in the cornea. The cool colors like blue and its various shades indicate the flat portion of the cornea. Hence, the colors from red- orange- yellow- green- purple- blue progressively denote the lesser refractive power.[32]

Color-coded scales

These scales are a must-know before interpreting a color map. If the scales are different, two similar-looking color-coded maps will reveal different information. There are two types of color-coded scales: absolute and normalized scales. In an absolute scale, each color denotes an interval of 1.5 D starting from 35 to 50 D, where the higher and lower than this range represent an interval of 5 D. This scale is commonly used in preoperative screening with the only demerit that it does not denote subtle changes in the curvature. In a normalized scale, the cornea is split into 11 equal colors considering the eye’s total dioptric power. This scale gives the advantage of depicting minute topographic changes and a more intricate description of surface changes. The disadvantage is that the color of two different maps are not comparable directly and need keratometric values for comparison.

Color-coding for ophthalmic drops

With almost 400,000 drug-related injuries occurring each year in the US hospitals, medical errors continue to increase at an alarming rate with significant morbidity and mortality.[33] For patients in the hospital setting, it is estimated that one medication error happens at least once a day.[34] The American Academy of Ophthalmology (AAO) has been attempting to reduce errors in ophthalmic drops since the mid-’90s with the advocacy of a uniform color-coded system for topical ocular medications.[35] This standardized color-coding is expected to help patients and the healthcare providers identify medications correctly and thus reduce errors both inpatient and outpatient.[35] The details of color-coding as per the AAO have been listed in Table 3.

T3
Table 3:
Showing details of color coding for eye drops vial caps

Though this color-coding is widely accepted and adopted in developed nations like the USA, we are yet to adopt this coding system in our country.[5] With proper utilization of the color-coded system, an appropriate judgment about which ophthalmological medications a patient utilizes can be made.[36] This would help the emergency physicians obtain a better understanding of their current presentation and prevent iatrogenic harm. But, this color-coded system is not foolproof and the potential for error in medication administration still exists.[37] Therefore, a good clinical judgment and familiarity with the active ingredient in each topical medication should always be maintained.[38]

Conclusion

To conclude, schematic representation of ocular findings is a skill, which should be acquired and practiced by all from the early days of training itself. Recording of corneal and retinal findings following the standard scheme of color-coding will allow better communication between ophthalmologists, enhance the understanding of the disease course, and improves the observation with slit-lamp by accurately sketching what he/she observes. This is particularly even more important in the present COVID-19 times, as there are reported delayed presentations by patients.[39] Schematic representations of the anterior and posterior segment findings can help ophthalmologists correlate the clinical status in a better way. Further, this is non-expensive, needs no extra expensive cameras, and allows a glance of the past findings and the course of the disease. We together should make efforts to inculcate the habit of schematic representations of all clinical examination findings and make a system of proper documentation on subsequent visits for generations to follow.

Consent for publication

The article does not involve any data from subjects. Hence exempted from prior patient consent.

Financial support and sponsorship

Nil.

Conflicts of interest

There are no conflicts of interest.

References

1. Mathioudakis A, Rousalova I, Gagnat AA How to keep good clinical records Breathe (Sheff) 2016 12 369 73
2. Grammaticos PC, Diamantis A Useful known and unknown views of the father of modern medicine, Hippocrates and his teacher Democritus Hell J Nucl Med 2008 11 2 4
3. Stevens S, Pickering D Keeping good nursing records:A guide Community Eye Health 2010 23 44 5
4. Lorenzetti DL, Quan H, Lucyk K, Cunningham C, Hennessy D, Jiang J, et al. Strategies for improving physician documentation in the emergency department:A systematic review BMC Emerg Med 2018 18 36
5. Tobore I, Li J, Yuhang L, Al-Handarish Y, Kandwal A, Nie Z, et al. Deep learning intervention for health care challenges:Some biomedical domain considerations JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2019 7 e11966
6. Bui TH, Cavanagh HD, Robertson DM Patient compliance during contact lens wear:Perceptions, awareness, and behavior Eye Contact Lens 2010 36 334 9
7. Hardavella G, Aamli-Gaagnat A, Frille A Top tips to deal with challenging situations:Doctor-patient interactions Breathe (Sheff) 2017 13 129 35
8. King J, Patel V, Jamoom EW, Furukawa MF Clinical benefits of electronic health record use:National findings Health Serv Res 2014 49 392 404
9. Schepens CL 'Techniques of examination of the fundus periphery', in “Symposium on Retina and Retinal Surgery,” Transactions of the New Orleans Academy of Ophthalmology 1969 St. Louis Mosby 39
10. Bron AJ A simple scheme for documenting corneal disease Brit J Ophthal 1973 57 629 34
11. Waring GO, Laibson PR A systematic method of drawing corneal pathologic conditions Arch Ophthalmol 1977 95 1540 2
12. Bühren J, Kohnen T A standardized drawing scheme to document corneal changes following refractive corneal surgery J Refract Surg 2006 22 166 71
13. Muir R Medicine's core values. Profession needs to open itself up BMJ 1994 309 1658 doi:10.1136/bmj.309.6969.1658a
14. Freckelton Qc I COVID-19:Fear, quackery, false representations and the law Int J Law Psychiatry 2020 72 101611 doi:10.1016/j.ijlp.2020.101611
15. Gurnani B, Kaur K Comments on:COVID-19 pandemic-Testing times for postgraduate medical education Indian J Ophthalmol 2021 69 1965 6
16. Mishra D, Bhatia K, Verma L Essentials of setting up a wet lab for ophthalmic surgical training in COVID-19 pandemic Indian J Ophthalmol 2021 69 410 6
17. Dvorak L, Russell SR Retinal drawing:A lost art of medicine Perm J 2011 15 74 5
18. Abràmoff MD, Garvin MK, Sonka M Retinal imaging and image analysis IEEE Rev Biomed Eng 2010 3 169 208
19. Syed ST, Gerber BS, Sharp LK Traveling towards disease:Transportation barriers to health care access J Community Health 2013 38 976 93
20. Pons J Improving patient flow through an eye clinic Community Eye Health 2012 25 31 3
21. Raveesh BN, Nayak RB, Kumbar SF Preventing medico-legal issues in clinical practice Ann Indian Acad Neurol 2016 19 Suppl 1 S15 20
22. Grover AK, Honavar SG, Azad R A national curriculum for ophthalmology residency training Indian J Ophthalmol 2018 66 752 83
23. Bargaje C Good documentation practice in clinical research Perspect Clin Res 2011 2 59 63
24. Valappil S, Jayan A Retinal drawing Kerala J Ophthalmol 2019 31 251 4
25. Swindale NV, Stjepanovic G, Chin A, Mikelberg FS Automated analysis of normal and glaucomatous opticnerve head topography images Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 2000 41 1730 42
26. Mardin CY, Horn FK Influence of optic disc size on the sensitivity of the Heidelberg Retina Tomograph Graefes Arch Clin Exp Ophthalmol 1998 236 641 5
27. Artes PH, Crabb DP Estimating normative limits of Heidelberg Retina Tomography optic disc rim area with Quantile Regression Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 2010 51 355 61
28. O'Leary N, Crabb DP, Mansberger SL, Fortune B, Twa MD, Lloyd MJ, et al. Glaucomatous progression in series of stereoscopic photographs and Heidelberg retina tomograph images Arch Ophthalmol 2010 128 560 8
29. Budenz DL, Anderson DR, Varma R, Schuman J, Cantor L, Savell J, et al. Determinants of normal retinal nerve fiber layer thickness measured by Stratus OCT Ophthalmology 2007 114 1046 52
30. FDA Guidance for Industry:Safety Considerations for Product Design to Minimize Medication Errors;” Food and Drug Administration:Drug Safety December 2012
31. Aref AA, Sayyad FE, Mwanza JC, Feuer WJ, Budenz DL Diagnostic specificities of retinal nerve fiber layer, optic nerve head, and macular ganglion cell-inner plexiform layer measurements in myopic eyes J Glaucoma 2014 23 487 93
32. Wu AW, Pronovost P, Morlock L ICU incident reporting systems J Crit Care 2006 17 86 94
33. Abdelmotaal H, Mostafa MM, Mostafa ANR, Mohamed AA, Abdelazeem K Classification of Color-Coded Scheimpflug Camera Corneal Tomography Images Using Deep Learning Transl Vis Sci Technol 2020 9 30
34. Dave P, Villarreal G, Friedman DS, Kahook MY, Ramulu PY Ability of bottle cap color to facilitate accurate patient-physician communication regarding medication identity in patients with glaucoma Ophthalmology 2015 122 2373 9
35. Color Codes for Topical Ocular Medications Available from: https://www.aao.org/about/policies/color-codes-topical-ocular- medications Last accessed on 2022 Feb 13
36. Does color-coded labelling reduce the risk of medication errors? Can J Hosp Pharm 2009 62 154 6
37. Yousef N, Yousef F Using total quality management approach to improve patient safety by preventing medication error incidences* BMC Health Serv Res 2017 17 621 doi:10.1186/s12913-017-2531-6
38. Karthikeyan G, Pais P Clinical judgment and evidence-based medicine:Time for reconciliation Indian J Med Res 2010 132 623 6
39. Babu N, Kohli P, Mishra C, Sen S, Arthur D, Chhablani D, et al. To evaluate the effect of COVID-19 pandemic and national lockdown on patient care at a tertiary-care ophthalmology institute Indian J Ophthalmol 2020 68 1540 4
Keywords:

Anterior segment diagram; color-coding; retinal diagram; schematic diagram

Copyright: © 2022 Indian Journal of Ophthalmology