Horner's syndrome, characterized by upper eyelid ptosis, miotic pupil, anhydrosis, and ipsilateral facial flushing, secondary to sympathetic pathway disruption, is an important differential diagnosis in unilateral ptosis. Epidural anesthesia is widely used for pain relief during childbirth. The incidence of Horner's syndrome is rare with epidural anesthesia but increases to 0.4–2.5% in the setting of childbirth and to 4% in Caesarean sections. This association has been commonly reported as transient in nature in the anesthesiology, obstetric, and neurologic literature. We report a case of persistent unilateral Horner's syndrome in a healthy female following epidural anesthesia and Caesarean section.
A Medline literature search was performed using the following terms: Horner's syndrome, epidural, spinal anesthesia, delivery, childbirth, caesarean, and pregnancy. One hundred and six articles containing these terms were identified. Of these, 31 articles described Horner's syndrome occurring in obstetrics epidural anesthesia, and only 11 were following Caesarean section. The remaining cases were described in the setting of normal labor, early labor pain, and forceps delivery. Only one article describing Horner's syndrome during normal labor was published in the ophthalmology literature. All of the other articles were found in the anesthesia, obstetrics, and neurology journals.
A healthy 33-year-old primigravida presented with persistent droopy right eyelid following Caesarean section 9 weeks prior. During a difficult labor, an epidural block (fentanyl 2 mcg/ml, bupivicaine 0.125%) was administered in the sitting position, with immediate right-sided back pain. She did not recline to either side. Eight hours later, she underwent Caesarean section in a dorsal supine and leftward tilt position. The ptotic eyelid was noticed postoperatively, approximately 12 h following the administration of the initial epidural, although its exact onset following epidural anesthesia was not known by the patient. The precise onset of ptosis was difficult to determine as the patient was given the spinal anesthesia while in labor and grimacing with contractions. Within 2 h, she was urgently taken to the operating room for Ceasarian section. Following surgery, she slept for several hours, and only when she awoke did a nurse comment on the droopy eyelid. Throughout the time of labor, surgery, and postoperative recovery, there was no mirror at the bedside for her to notice the onset herself.
Neurological exam and other cranial nerves were normal. The diagnosis of right Horner's syndrome was also confirmed by the Neurology service. There was no history of anhidrosis and no sensory loss, facial numbness, neck pain, swelling, history of brachial trauma, diplopia, or diurnal variation was reported. Examination revealed a right upper eyelid ptosis of 1 mm (marginal reflex distance [MRD1]: right eye – 4.5 mm, left eye - 5.5 mm) and a miotic pupil prominent in both light and dark illumination [Fig. 1]. The installation of 2% cocaine showed no pupillary response on the affected right side. Hertel exophthalmometry revealed 2 mm of proptosis on the same side. Levator function, motility, thyroid levels, and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)/magnetic resonance angiography (MRA) of the head, neck, and chest were normal without masses. At a subsequent follow-up 8.5 months later, the ptosis was unchanged. Surgery was offered but declined at this time by the patient.
Horner's syndrome is a rare and unpredictable side effect of lumbar epidural anesthesia and was first reported in 1972. It is rarely seen with epidural anesthesia with an incidence of 0.4–2.5%, but increases in pregnancy to 4%. Several theories have been proposed for this association. The most commonly accepted theory is that anatomical changes in pregnancy lead to decreased capacity of epidural space and increased epidural venous engorgement. Further epidural vein enlargement occurs with increased intra-abdominal pressure and valsalva with uterine contractions, resulting in local anesthetic traversing a higher cephalad than expected. This cephalic spread of the local anesthetic disrupts the oculosympathetic pathway at the level of second-order neurons exiting the spinal cord (C8- T4) in transit to the superior cervical ganglion. Unilaterality may be secondary to septation within the epidural space, and/or the patient's positioning and effect of gravity during injection. Injection in the lateral recumbent position tends to produce more anesthesia on the dependent side. In some reports, laterality was secondary to dural puncture and subarachnoid injection of the anesthetic solution. In vitro studies have demonstrated differential sensitivity of the preganglionic sympathetic fibers and sensory fibers in the epidural space to the anesthetic solution, explaining the high sensitivity of relatively thinner fibers of the sympathetic pathway which can result in sympathetic blockade even several spinal segments above the level of injection.
The Horner's phenomenon is typically transient with an average onset of 25 min, and a mean duration of 215 min (range: several minutes-24 h) until spontaneous resolution. One case report described Horner's syndrome lasting 6 months in a 12-year-old female undergoing spinal fusion surgery. A delayed onset of Horner's syndrome developing 115 min after epidural injection for Caesarean section has also been reported.
This case differs slightly from previous reports due to its delayed onset, laterality to the elevated rather than dependent side, mild proptosis, and persistent duration of over 8 months. The exact pathophysiology is unclear, but this case demonstrates that a persistent Horner's syndrome may occur in the absence of any systemic associations and complications following epidural anesthesia for Caesarean section.
This uncommon presentation of Horner's syndrome following Caesarean section and epidural anesthesia, although reported in the anesthesiology and obstetric literature, is relatively unknown within the ophthalmic literature. Only one article was published in 1995 in the ophthalmology literature documenting Horner's syndrome, but during normal labor and delivery. Although the majority of the literature describes a transient phenomenon, rarely it may persist and require consideration of surgical intervention for ptosis. This highlights the need to include recent epidural anesthesia within the differential diagnosis of acute Horner's syndrome in a postpartum female. It also suggests the need to monitor the patient for autonomic complications postinjection due to possible high-level sympathetic blockade.
1. Clayton KC. The incidence of Horner's syndrome
during lumbar extradural for elective Caesarean section and provision of analgesia during labour Anaesthesia. 1983;38:583–5
2. Jeret JS, Mazurek AA. Acute postpartum Horner's syndrome
due to epidural anesthesia Arch Ophthalmol. 1995;113:560
3. Biousse V, Guevara RA, Newmann NJ. Transient Horner's syndrome
after lumbar epidural anesthesia Neurology. 1998;51:1473–5
4. Lynch JH, Keneally RJ, Hustead TR. Horner's syndrome
and trigeminal nerve palsy following epidural analgesia for labor J Am Board Fam Med. 2006;19:521–3
5. Chandrasekhar S, Peterfreund RA. Horner's syndrome
following very low concentration bupivacaine infusion for labor epidural analgesia J Clin Anesth. 2003;15:217–9
6. Hered RW, Cummings RJ, Helffrich R. Persistent Horner's syndrome
after spinal fusion and epidural analgesia: A case report Spine. 1998;23:387–90
7. Hertz R, Chiovari CA, Marx GF. Delayed Horner's syndrome
following obstetric extradural block Anesth Analg. 1980;59:299–300