Secondary Logo

Journal Logo

Review Article

Challenges of the Deaf and Hearing Impaired in the Masked World of COVID-19

Garg, Suneela; Deshmukh, Chetana Prakash; Singh, Meghachandra M.; Borle, Amod; Wilson, Blake S1

Author Information
Indian Journal of Community Medicine: Jan–Mar 2021 - Volume 46 - Issue 1 - p 11-14
doi: 10.4103/ijcm.IJCM_581_20
  • Open

Abstract

INTRODUCTION

The difficulties of the 466 million deaf and hearing-impaired persons in the world to adjust as per their needs have now increased due to the overwhelming COVID-19 pandemic.[1] They face a dual struggle to accommodate themselves in the world designed around hearing, compounded by COVID-19, leading to lack of inclusiveness along with breakdown of their mental, physical, and social health.

Disabling hearing loss refers to hearing loss >40 decibels (dB) in better hearing ear in adults and hearing loss >30 dB in better hearing ear in children. People who are hard of hearing usually communicate through spoken or sign language, and can benefit from assistive devices such as hearing aids, cochlear implants, and technology such as captioning, m-health, and loop system.[123]

This review was done to find out the challenges faced by the deaf and hearing-impaired people during the COVID-19 pandemic. It also highlights strategies which should be undertaken to make these deaf and hearing-impaired more inclusive in the currently masked world of COVID-19.

METHODS

The literature was searched using the following keywords: “challenges” OR “barriers” AND “COVID-19” OR “Deaf” OR “Hearing Impaired” OR “sign language” OR “Mask” OR “Communication” on PubMed and Google Scholar from November 2019 to June 2020. Open-access national and international health agency websites were searched for relevant information related to statistical data of hearing disability, hearing aids, and the COVID-19 pandemic. These websites include World Health Organization, Lancet Commission to address the global burden of hearing loss, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, and the Department of Empowerment of Persons with Disabilities in the Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment.

RESULTS

Challenges and strategies for addressal of the hearing impaired during the COVID pandemic

Lack of information

Hearing impaired and deaf persons are deprived of accurate and reliable information on COVID-19 due to lack of availability of sign language specialists during lockdown and inability to comprehend lip reading due to masks in direct communication. The public should be aware of recognition, reporting, and containment of COVID-19 to bring the pandemic under control.

Lack of proper sign language

A universal signing vocabulary does not exist for the new SARS-CoV-2 virus. Sign language is the first language understood by the deaf community. As per different levels of understanding, written language does not convey information and can perpetuate misinformation leading to misguided actions.[4] Fifteen or more different sign languages, without scientific validity, are currently used to explain novel coronavirus in COVID-19-affected countries. During the COVID-19 era, touching the face and the mouth is discouraged to prevent the transmission of coronavirus. Due to this, the essence of sign language is lost, missing important information.[4] The general population dealing with the deaf community is unaware of the sign language except for few close contacts and instructors. The frontline warriors providing essential services do not have time to learn a new language for helping the deaf community.[56]

Sign language interpreters, familiar with the new vocabulary for the SARS-CoV-2 virus, should be there at all press releases and official government announcements regarding the pandemic. This will help the deaf and hearing-impaired population to understand the current scenario of the pandemic and preventive measures against the disease.

The sign language interpreter at press conferences is often the only person without a face covering because he/she uses his/her lips and facial expression when signing for the deaf and the hard-of-hearing community.[7891011] It is recommended that a transparent screen may be provisioned for ensuring safety and providing unobstructed view to the hearing impaired to facilitate understanding of lip reading.

Deaf leaders and skilled interpreters approved by the deaf community can work together to provide “live interpretations” of news on their personal social media platforms.[121314]

Lack of communication with deaf children at home

In the Indian setting, deaf children from residential deaf schools were sent home due to the lockdown amid the COVID-19 pandemic. Majority of the parents are unable to fully communicate with their deaf children because they are not fluent in sign language. It is likely that these children are experiencing confusion, anxiety, and depression due to the coronavirus scare and the absence of familiar environment due to the lockdown.[12]

Appropriate arrangements should be made for deaf instructors and sign language interpreters in schools who can conduct sign language classes on weekends for parents. They can provide guidance to the children's parents and children on how they could be prepared mentally and emotionally to deal with the pandemic. This can help the deaf students to continue the study at home. Instructors can train parents for using additional visual resources with their deaf children such as reading storybooks or doing hands-on activities using sign language.[13]

Facemask – a challenge for communication

The new norm in the COVID-19 pandemic is wearing facemasks to prevent disease transmission. As a result of this preventive measure, the deaf and hearing-impaired people feel excluded from the world. Deaf people who rely on sign language still need facial expressions for full understanding of what is being communicated, and those with hearing aids or cochlear implants during rehabilitation rely on lip reading to better understand what is being heard. Anyone with hearing impairment will have difficulty with muffled speech due to facemask.[15] Thus, covering of face by mask can cut down on the ability to connect, especially with the hearing-impaired or deaf community.[789]

Facial masks worn by essential service workers, health functionaries, and public service providers pose a barrier for the hearing impaired in getting essential services such as groceries, health care, and essential public services.[15]

People should be made aware of the availability of surgical masks with see-through window panel showing the wearer's mouth. Innovations are being provided through YouTube channels to create do-it-yourself masks with clear windows. These masks should be monitored for cost-effectiveness by the government.[15]

Social distancing – a barrier for physical and mental health

The 6-feet recommendation for physical distancing during the pandemic poses a problem for the hard-to-hear population due to inaudible voice, resulting in social isolation and mental health implications.

The deaf and hearing impaired may not understand the verbal communication by the next person and hence may not reply to them, thereby creating a feeling of social isolation.[5] A companion or a family member, familiar with the sign language, should be there as much as possible who will help in required situations to act as a mediator.

Mental health counselors should provide online mental health counseling along with captions and without mask for lip reading by the deaf and hearing impaired patients.

To avoid confusion on telephonic conversations due to hearing impaired and deaf persons used to schedule necessary appointments, shop for grocery and attend important meetings in person to avoid confusion through telephonic conversations due to hearing impairment. However, due to the lockdown and social distancing in the COVID-19 era, all activities need to be done through phones or online, which is affecting the social, mental, and work profiles of the deaf and hearing impaired.[58]

Stigma and discrimination as a barrier

Hearing-impaired individuals are often isolated on the grounds of old age, lack of hearing, hearing aid use, and sign language. They are unable to participate in conversations due to stigma, making them feel lonely, unexpressed, and socially marginalized. This results in chronic stress and depression.[1617] During the pandemic, lack of information, using face mask, and inaccessible health care for the hearing impaired can add on to the preexisting stress, making their mental health more vulnerable.

Barriers related to health-care system

Hearing-impaired and deaf population face challenge due to lack of consultation with health-care providers, including testing for hearing as facilities are overwhelmed with COVID-19 and other emergency conditions, which leads to least priority given to the problems of addressing the hearing impaired. Further, there are restrictions on getting an interpreter or a family member to accompany them to health facility due to the lockdown measures. All these can lead to confusion and stress on the hearing impaired.

Assistive devices used by the deaf and hearing-impaired need constant maintenance. Many people who wear hearing aids have damaged their devices or lost them because most masks are worn behind the ears.[78] The lack of availability of services for fitting and maintaining these devices and lack of batteries are preexisting barriers in many low-income settings.[1] Due to the stringent lockdown imposed during the COVID pandemic, these services are shut, causing extreme inconvenience to the users.

Donning and doffing for personal protective equipment (PPE) kits worn by health-care workers has standard protocols, which makes it difficult for health-care workers to doff the PPE for communication to address the problems of the hearing impaired. The long waiting hours in health-care facilities dissuade the hearing-impaired from seeking consultations.[6]

Policy implications

The government should come up with guidelines for communication with the health-care workers during the COVID-19 pandemic. A list of COVID-19 resources that are available for deaf and hearing-impaired individuals should be provided including linkage to health-care facilities for emergency consultations.[9]

Videos regarding basic information, signs, symptoms, preventive and control measures of COVID-19 at home should be published in sign language by the government for hearing-impaired and deaf population.[1819]

A COVID-19 hotline should be started for the deaf community by telephonic and user-friendly links on the Internet for obtaining appropriate and timely information from health-care workers.[9]

There has been no preparation to provide accessible services to deaf patients in hospitals or during doctor visits. Deaf leaders and interpreters have to work together to create a community list of interpreters who are willing to volunteer their interpreting services. Through this effort, the interpreters can interpret video calls between medical staff and deaf consumers.[5]

The global production of hearing aids meets <10% of the global need and <3% of developing countries' needs.[1] Efforts should be made by national governments in increasing the production and maintenance of assistive devices. Governments along with welfare associations should work upon to start some centers for pickup and repairs during the lockdown due to the pandemic so that the deaf community can have their device in working order.[4]

Newer innovations such as video conferencing, an interface to connect people through the internet along with m-health, are emerging as potential measures for communication and these have to be tailored to the needs of the hearing impaired. Captioning services are often lacking during video meetings which need to be incorporated as an integral part of communication.

Use of technology where an operator transcribes the calls or texts of the hearing impaired can help them to communicate with the outer world.[56]

In 2017, the 70th World Health Assembly adopted a resolution on the prevention of deafness and hearing loss. This resolution calls upon the Member States to integrate strategies for ear and hearing care within the framework of their primary health-care systems, under the umbrella of universal health coverage.[2021] This resolution can serve as a platform during the pandemic for the reforms related to deaf and hearing-impaired people.

CONCLUSION

Compassion, empowerment, and inclusiveness are the need of the hour in these times. In this pandemic, system strengthening, tele-medicine, policy amendments, and capacity building can be the pillars to build up the support system for the deaf and hearing impaired to protect them from COVID-19. Now the time has come to tie up technology, humanity, health, and the hearing disabled together to combat the COVID-19 pandemic.

Financial support and sponsorship

Nil.

Conflicts of interest

There are no conflicts of interest.

REFERENCES

1. Deafness and Hearing Loss.Last accessed on 2020 Jul 03 Available from: https://www.who.int/newsroom/fact-sheets/detail/deafness-and-hearing-loss
2. A Lancet Commission to Address the Global Burden of Hearing Loss – The Lancet. Last accessed on 2020 Jul 02 Available from: https://www.thelancet.com/pdfs/journals/lancet/PIIS0140-6736(19)30484-2.pdf
3. Alexander A, Ladd P, Powell S. Deafness might damage your health Lancet. 2012;379:979–81
4. Castro HC, Lins Ramos AS, Amorim G, Ratcliffe NA. COVID-19: Don't forget deaf people Nature. 2020;579:343
5. Opinion | How Keeping us all Safe from Coronavirus Shut me off from the Hearing World. NBC News. Last accessed on 2020 Jul 03 Available from: https://www.nbcnews.com/think/opinion/keeping-people-safe-covid-19-limits-deaf-people-saccess-ncna1207371
6. Detail Question and Answers on COVID-19 for Public.pdf. Last accessed on 2020 Jul 03 Available from: https://www.mohfw.gov.in/pdf/FAQ.pdf
7. Face Covering Requirements Amid COVID-19 Pandemic Pose Challenges to the Deaf Community, Hearing and Speech Agency CEO Says. 2020Last accessed on 2020 Jul 03 Available from: https://baltimore.cbslocal.com/2020/05/15/face-covering-requirements-coronavirus-pandemic-deaf-community/
8. MentalHealthIssuesCOVID19NIMHANS.pdf. Last accessed on 2020 Jul 03 Available from: https://www.mohfw.gov.in/pdf/MentalHealthIssuesCOVID19NIMHANS.pdf
9. Trecca E, Gelardi M, Cassano M. COVID-19 and hearing difficulties American journal of otolaryngology. 2020;41:102496 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.amjoto.2020.102496
10. Rafferty R COVID-19 Presents New Challenges for People with Hearing Loss.Last accessed on 2020 Jul 03 Available from: https://www.wxxinews.org/post/covid-19-presents-new-challenges-people-hearing-loss
11. Hidden Behind Masks: People with Speech, Hearing Disabilities Struggle to Communicate in COVID-19 ti-Edexlive.Last accessed on 2020 Jul 03 Available from: https://www.edexlive.com/news/2020/jun/18/hidden-behind-maskspeople-with-speech-hearing-disabilities-struggle-to-communicate-incovid-19-times-12723.html
12. Ch A, Ani. How can Deaf Indians call up Covid-19 Helplines? Modi Government Must take these Steps Immediately The Print. 2020Last accessed on 2020 Jul 03 Available from: https://theprint.in/opinion/deaf-indians-covid-19-modigovt-must-take-these-steps/393514/
13. Disabilities Affairs.Last accessed on 2020 Jul 03 Available from: http://disabilityaffairs.gov.in/content/page/contact-us.php
14. New Sound Resolves the Challenges COVID-19 Represents to the Hearing Impaired. 2020Last accessed on 2020 Jul 03 Available from: https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20200421005302/en/NewSound-Resolves-Challenges-COVID-19-Represents-Hearing-Impaired
15. De Hahn P. Face Masks are Excluding the Deaf and Hard of Hearing Community Quartz.Last accessed on 2020 Jul 03 Available from: https://qz.com/1839479/covid-19-face-masks-exclude-the-deaf-and-hard-of-hearing/
16. Mousley VL, Chaudoir SR. Deaf stigma: Links between stigma and well-being among deaf emerging adults1 J Deaf Stud Deaf Educ. 2018;23:341–50
17. Wallhagen MI. The stigma of hearing loss Gerontologist. 2010;50:66–75
18. Deaf and Hard of Hearing COVID-19 Resources-Coronavirus (COVID-19)-University of Rochester Medical Center.Last accessed on 2020 Jul 03 Available from: https://www.urmc.rochester.edu/coronavirus/more-resources/deaf-hard-ofhearing.aspx
19. COVID-19: A Social Project to Empower the Hearing-Impaired. The Hindu; Jun 21. 2020Last accessed on 2020 Jul 03 Available from: https://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/chennai/covid-19-a-social-project-to-empower-the-hearingimpaired/article31881876.ece
20. Prevention of Deafness and Hearing Loss.pdf.Last accessed on 2020 Jul 03 Available from: https://apps.who.int/gb/ebwha/pdf_files/WHA70-REC1/A70_2017_REC1-en.pdf#page=27
21. Chadha S, Cieza A, Krug E. Global hearing health: Future directions Bull World Health Organ. 2018;96:146
Keywords:

Challenges; COVID-19; hearing impaired

© 2021 Indian Journal of Community Medicine | Published by Wolters Kluwer – Medknow