The recent change in the maternal mortality narrative in the United States likely surprised many obstetricians, epidemiologists, and public health experts. For more than a decade, several articles and publications from reputable organizations documented temporal increases in maternal mortality rates, and maternal mortality rates in the United States that were higher than those in many other countries.1–5 More recently, detailed reports published by the National Center for Health Statistics have contradicted these assessments.6–8 The latter reports showed that there had been no temporal increase in overall maternal death rates in the United States; the rising trend in maternal mortality rates was entirely an artifact of changes in maternal death surveillance.
This Commentary provides the background to the National Center for Health Statistics reports, summarizes their findings, describes temporal trends and the current status of maternal mortality in the United States, identifies surveillance and clinical concerns, and discusses issues related to the prevention of maternal death. These topics merit consideration especially because the current literature9–12 fails to recognize the full import of the National Center for Health Statistics reports.
BACKGROUND TO THE NATIONAL CENTER FOR HEALTH STATISTICS REPORTS
Studies carried out before 2003 showed that identification of maternal deaths based solely on death certificate information resulted in substantial numbers of missed maternal deaths.13–16 These studies led the National Center for Health Statistics to introduce a standard pregnancy checkbox on the revised 2003 death certificate. Individual states began using this pregnancy checkbox at different times,6 and the National Center for Health Statistics discontinued its official publication of the national maternal mortality rate from 2007 to 2019.8 The staggered implementation of the pregnancy checkbox by the states resulted in a progressive increase in the number of reported maternal deaths (Fig. 1A17). The identification of late maternal deaths (International Classification of Diseases, Tenth Revision [ICD-10] code O96, O97) increased substantially as did maternal deaths from some less clearly defined causes of death, such as “Other specified pregnancy-related conditions” (ICD-10 O268; Fig. 1B).
The discontinuation of authoritative National Center for Health Statistics reports on maternal mortality rates in the United States in 2007 resulted in many publications on maternal mortality that did not adequately address the surveillance implications of the newly introduced pregnancy checkbox. Journalists and researchers implicated diverse factors as the cause for the temporal increase in maternal mortality rates, including rising cesarean delivery rates,18,19 excessive use of ultrasonography,19 systemic racism,20 reduced access to abortion services, and lack of funding for Planned Parenthood.21
SUMMARY OF THE NATIONAL CENTER FOR HEALTH STATISTICS REPORTS
The National Center for Health Statistics reports6–8 were based on detailed studies of original death certificates and included recoding and reclassification of the underlying cause of death both with and without information from the pregnancy checkbox. These investigations showed that there was no temporal increase in maternal mortality rates. When pregnancy checkbox information was not used, maternal mortality rates were 8.9 per 100,000 live births in 2002, 8.7 in 2015, 8.7 in 2016, 11.5 in 2017, and 8.7 in 2018.8
The pregnancy checkbox led to an increase in maternal mortality rates by about 9.6 maternal deaths per 100,000 live births between 2003 and 2017.7 However, the effect of the checkbox differed by maternal age, race and Hispanic origin, and underlying cause of death.7 The contribution of the pregnancy checkbox was negligible for several cause-of-death categories, though death rates within some such categories increased or decreased due to unrelated factors.7 On the other hand, the pregnancy checkbox profoundly increased the identification of some less informative causes of death (eg, “Other specified pregnancy-related conditions” [ICD-10 O268] and “Other obstetric conditions not elsewhere classified” [ICD-10 O99]) and late maternal deaths.
Although the pregnancy checkbox improved the detection of some maternal deaths, it also incorrectly identified some deaths to nonpregnant women as maternal deaths or late maternal deaths. The most egregious checkbox errors occurred among older women; for example, in 2013, 187 women aged 85 years or older were identified by the checkbox as pregnant at the time of death or within 1 year of death.8 For 2018 data, the National Center for Health Statistics addressed such false positive maternal deaths by restricting use of pregnancy checkbox information for determining the underlying cause of death to women aged 10–44 years.8
TEMPORAL TRENDS IN MATERNAL MORTALITY RATES
The National Center for Health Statistics investigation showed that maternal mortality rates did not increase significantly between 2002 and 2015–2016 and 2018 when all rates were estimated without using information from the pregnancy checkbox.6–8 In fact, between 2000 and 2018, maternal mortality rates (calculated without checkbox information) showed a significant 21% decline after adjustment for maternal age (standardized mortality ratio 0.79, 95% CI 0.72–0.87; Appendix 1, available online at http://links.lww.com/AOG/C281).
The finding by the National Center for Health Statistics that some cause-of-death categories were not affected by the pregnancy checkbox7 permits a cautious assessment of the temporal trends in the unaffected categories (note: some such unaffected categories showed changes due to unrelated factors). This assessment reveals significant declines in maternal deaths from abortive outcomes and labor and delivery complications; significant increases in maternal deaths from other maternal disorders, mental and central nervous system disorders, and respiratory diseases; and stable patterns in maternal deaths from hypertensive disorders, conditions related to the fetus, amniotic cavity, and complications related to the puerperium (Appendix 2, available online at http://links.lww.com/AOG/C281).
Temporal trends in the above-mentioned underlying cause-of-death categories conceal some unexpected changes in cause-of-death subcategories. Figure 2A shows increases in deaths from chronic hypertension, declines in preeclampsia–eclampsia deaths, and low, stable rates of deaths from gestational hypertension. Figure 2B shows a rise and fall in maternal deaths due to diabetes mellitus, an increase in maternal deaths due to liver disorders, and a small absolute increase in deaths from adherent placenta. Figure 2C shows declines in maternal deaths from amniotic fluid embolism, a small increase in maternal deaths from blood-clot embolism, and larger increases in maternal deaths from mental and central nervous system disorders. Discrepant patterns in related subcategories of maternal death (eg, preeclampsia–eclampsia vs chronic hypertension; amniotic fluid embolism vs blood clot embolism) may be indicative of misclassification problems (see below).
Other noteworthy temporal changes in cause of death subcategories included significant declines in maternal deaths from medical abortion and unspecified abortion; complications of anesthesia, malpresentation–disproportion, intrapartum hemorrhage, and other complications; and significant increases in maternal deaths due to other (incomplete) abortion, unspecified hypertension, genitourinary tract infections, malnutrition, other disorders of the amniotic fluid, placental disorders, and antepartum hemorrhage (Appendix 3, available online at http://links.lww.com/AOG/C281).
The National Center for Health Statistics reported 658 maternal deaths, 277 late maternal deaths, and 3,791,712 live births in 2018, yielding an maternal mortality rate of 17.4 per 100,000 live births and a late maternal mortality rate of 7.2 per 100,000 live births.8 There was a strong age-mortality gradient between age 20 and 44 years but no difference in death rates between women aged 40–44 compared with those aged 45–49 years (Appendix 4, available online at http://links.lww.com/AOG/C281). Maternal mortality rates were 2.5 times higher among non-Hispanic Black women compared with non-Hispanic White women and lowest among Hispanic women (37.1, 14.7, and 11.8 per 100,000 live births, respectively8).
A majority of maternal deaths occurred due to direct obstetric causes (77.4%8). Figure 3A shows maternal deaths in 2018 by cause-of-death category. Less informative categories, namely, “Other specified pregnancy-related conditions” (ICD-10 O268) and “Other maternal diseases not elsewhere classified” (ICD-10 O99), were responsible for a large fraction of deaths, and hypertensive disorders, circulatory system diseases, and amniotic fluid and blood clot embolism were the most common clearly specified causes (Fig. 3A and B).
Misclassification of Deaths Among Women Aged 10–44 Years
There are several reasons to suspect continuing misclassification of some nonmaternal deaths (as maternal deaths) among women aged 10–44 years in 2018, including the lack of difference in maternal mortality rates between women aged 40–44 years compared with those aged 45–49 years (Appendix 5, available online at http://links.lww.com/AOG/C281). Discrepant temporal trends between related causes of death (Fig. 2A), and the high proportion of maternal deaths due to less informative causes of death are other indicators suggesting misclassification. Although obstetric causes of death on a death certificate (eg, preeclampsia and amniotic fluid embolism) would be unaffected by the incorrect use of the pregnancy checkbox, nonobstetric causes of death among nonpregnant women (eg, chronic hypertension and pulmonary embolism) would be misclassified as maternal deaths if the pregnancy checkbox was ticked erroneously. Nonmaternal deaths from hypertensive diseases among reproductive age women far exceed maternal deaths from chronic hypertension so that a small misclassification of nonmaternal deaths from hypertensive diseases (due to checkbox errors) would have a significant effect on maternal deaths from chronic hypertension (Appendix 5, http://links.lww.com/AOG/C281).
Evidence of misclassification of nonmaternal deaths as maternal deaths is also seen in multiple causes-of-death information. A large proportion of deaths due to chronic hypertension, liver disease, other specified maternal conditions (ICD-10 O268), and late maternal death in 2018 were identified as maternal deaths based solely on the pregnancy checkbox (without other indication of a pregnancy-related complication; Appendix 6, available online at http://links.lww.com/AOG/C281).
Several recent studies22–27 support the need for introducing corrective measures aimed at minimizing the misclassification of nonmaternal deaths among women aged 10–44 years. Potential remedies include requiring the specification of at least one pregnancy-related cause of death for all cases where the pregnancy checkbox is ticked, and a manual review of the causes of death listed on the death certificate or on the corresponding medical record in a hospitalization database (“database autopsy”28). A related issue pertains to physician education regarding the “underlying cause of death” concept and the need for accurately completing death certificates.
Less Informative Causes of Death
The high rates of maternal death from less informative causes of death such as “Other specified pregnancy-related conditions” (ICD-10 O268) and “Disease of the circulatory system complicating pregnancy, childbirth and the puerperium” (ICD-10 O994) need to be addressed: Preventive insights can only be obtained with greater specificity in cause-of-death information. This concern, which also applies to late maternal deaths, may be addressed by requiring less informative pregnancy-chapter ICD-10 codes to be accompanied by codes from other chapters; for example, in cases of aortic dissection, the I chapter code for this condition (namely, ICD-10 I710) should accompany the less informative O chapter code (ICD-10 O994).
Figure 3 shows the frequency of all cause-of-death categories in 2018, and highlights the importance of hypertensive disorders of pregnancy, diseases of the circulatory system, obstetric embolism. The significant declines in deaths from preeclampsia–eclampsia (Fig. 2A), medical and unspecified abortion, complications of anesthesia, intrapartum hemorrhage, and amniotic fluid embolism (Appendix 3, http://links.lww.com/AOG/C281) are highly encouraging.
Despite the significant temporal increase in deaths due to adherent placenta, the absolute rate of such deaths was low, suggesting that obstetric care is addressing the rising frequency of this condition.29,30 Increases in maternal deaths from chronic hypertension, genitourinary tract infection, diabetes mellitus, malnutrition, liver disorders, mental and central nervous system disorders and diseases of the respiratory system could represent true increases or (more likely) an increase in the misclassification of nonmaternal deaths from these conditions due to checkbox errors.
Concerns regarding the reported temporal increase in maternal deaths led the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists and others to support the creation of state-based Maternal Mortality Review Committees.31,32 Reports from such committees show that about half of all pregnancy-related deaths were caused by hemorrhage, cardiovascular and coronary conditions, cardiomyopathy, and infection, and that more than 60 percent of pregnancy-related deaths were preventable.33 Patient-related factors, such as a lack of knowledge about warning signs (38%), health care professional-related issues including misdiagnosis (34%), and system-related factors, such as a lack of coordination between health care professionals (22%), were the most commonly identified contributors to such deaths.33
Systematic reviews of maternal death are important because they can identify pertinent and emerging issues of concern. Some of the recent caveats emerging from the Confidential Enquiry into Maternal Deaths in the United Kingdom are notable, including the need for heightened awareness of cardiovascular diseases among women with chest pain, orthopnea or persistent tachycardia, and the unexpected number of deaths due to undiagnosed aortic dissection.34
SOCIAL DETERMINANTS OF MATERNAL MORTALITY
Racial differences in the maternal mortality rate in the United States indicate longstanding health disparities. However, maternal mortality rate differentials by race are not exclusive to the United States; recent reports from England reveal maternal death rates among Black women that are fivefold higher than those among White women.35 This comparison highlights the role of nonmedical determinants of maternal mortality—race-based maternal mortality rate differences in England persist despite the National Health Service’s providing free, high-quality medical care to all.
Racial disparities in maternal mortality rates reflect many factors arising from racism36 including closely connected social determinants of health such as income, social status, education, access to health care, housing, the physical environment, social supports, health behaviors, and culture.12,37–39 The strong correlations and synergism between these factors ensure that vulnerable populations experience disproportionately high risks of outcomes such as maternal death.
Vulnerable segments of the population, especially non-Hispanic Black women, need to be supported through comprehensive and sustained public health programs that address preconceptional health and chronic conditions (at the individual level), implicit racial bias among health care professionals (at the interpersonal level), quality of care in hospitals predominantly serving non-Hispanic Black women (at the community level) and paid parental leave and extended health insurance (at the societal level).36 Such initiatives are also required to support vulnerable women and address social determinants of health across the entire population. This need is highlighted by the distribution of maternal deaths in 2018: 287, 205, and 105 deaths occurred among non-Hispanic White, non-Hispanic Black and Hispanic women, respectively.8
Seminal studies by the National Center for Health Statistics show that previously documented temporal increases in maternal mortality rates in the United States were an artifact of changes in maternal mortality surveillance. Although the pregnancy checkbox improved the identification of maternal deaths, there remains a need to address continued misclassification of nonmaternal deaths, and the proliferation of noninformative causes of death. Strengthening routine maternal death reviews at the hospital, state, and national level will lead to more informed and optimized obstetric practice, and diverse public health initiatives targeting the social determinants of health will reduce racial disparities. Although the state of maternal health in the United States is not as dire as portrayed until recently, there is substantial scope for preventing avoidable maternal death.
1. WHO, UNICEF, UNFPA, The World Bank and the United Nations Population Division. Trends in maternal mortality: 1990 to 2013. Estimates by WHO, UNICEF, UNFPA, The World Bank and the United Nations Population Division. Geneva: Accessed November 1, 2020. http://www.who.int/reproductivehealth/publications/monitoring/maternal-mortality-2013/en/
2. WHO, UNICEF, UNFPA, World Bank Group and the United Nations Population Division. Trends in maternal mortality: 1990 to 2015. Estimates by WHO, UNICEF, UNFPA, World Bank Group and the United Nations Population Division. Accessed November 1, 2020. http://www.who.int/reproductivehealth/publications/monitoring/maternal-mortality-2015/en/
3. WHO, UNICEF, UNFPA, World Bank Group and the United Nations Population Division. Maternal mortality: levels and trends, 2000 to 2017. Accessed November 1, 2020. https://www.who.int/reproductivehealth/publications/maternal-mortality-2000-2017/en/
4. Hogan MC, Foreman KJ, Naghavi M, Ahn SY, Wang M, Makela SM, et al. Maternal mortality for 181 countries, 1980-2008: a systematic analysis of progress towards Millennium Development Goal 5. Lancet 2010;375:1609–23. doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736(10)60518-1
5. Kassebaum NJ, Bertozzi-Villa A, Coggeshall MS, Shackelford KA, Steiner C, Heuton KR, et al. Global, regional, and national levels and causes of maternal mortality during 1990-2013: a systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2013. Lancet 2014;384:980–1004. doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736(14)60696-6
6. Hoyert DL, Uddin SFG, Miniño AM. Evaluation of the pregnancy status checkbox on the identification of maternal deaths. Natl Vital Stat Rep 2020;69:1–25.
7. Rossen LM, Womack LS, Hoyert DL, Anderson RN, Uddin SFG. The impact of the pregnancy checkbox and misclassification on maternal mortality trends in the United States, 1999–2017. National Center for Health Statistics. Vital Health Stat 3 2020;44:1–61.
8. Hoyert DL, Miniño AM. Maternal mortality in the United States: changes in coding, publication, and data release, 2018. Natl Vital Stat Rep 2020;69:1–18.
9. Chinn JJ, Eisenberg E, Artis Dickerson S, King RB, Chakhtoura N, Lim IAL, et al. Maternal mortality in the United States: research gaps, opportunities, and priorities. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2020;223:486–92.e6. doi: 10.1016/j.ajog.2020.07.021
10. Verma N, Shainker SA. Maternal mortality, abortion access, and optimizing care in an increasingly restrictive United States: a review of the current climate. Semin Perinatol 2020;44:151269. doi: 10.1016/j.semperi.2020.151269
11. Balayla J, Lasry A, Badeghiesh A, Volodarsky-Perel A, Gil Y. Mode of delivery is an independent risk factor for maternal mortality: a case-control study. J Matern Fetal Neonatal Med 2020 Jun 4 [Epub ahead of print]. doi: 10.1080/14767058.2020.1774874
12. Collier AY, Molina RL. Maternal mortality in the United States: updates on trends, causes, and solutions. Neoreviews 2019;20:e561–74. doi: 10.1542/neo.20-10-e561
13. Atrash HK, Alexander S, Berg CJ. Maternal mortality in developed countries: not just a concern of the past. Obstet Gynecol 1995;86:700–5. doi: 10.1016/0029-7844(95)00200-b
14. Berg CJ, Atrash HK, Koonin LM, Tucker M. Pregnancy-related mortality in the United States, 1987–1990. Obstet Gynecol 1996;88:161–7. doi: 10.1016/0029-7844(96)00135-4
15. MacKay AP, Rochat R, Smith JC, Berg CJ. The check box: determining pregnancy status to improve maternal mortality surveillance. Am J Prev Med 2000;19:35–9. doi: 10.1016/s0749-3797(00)00171-9
16. Horon IL, Cheng D. Enhanced surveillance for pregnancy-associated mortality—Maryland, 1993–1998. JAMA 2001;285:1455–9. doi: 10.1001/jama.285.11.1455
17. Joseph KS, Lisonkova S, Muraca GM, Razaz N, Sabr Y, Mehrabadi A, et al. Factors underlying the temporal increase in maternal mortality in the United States. Obstet Gynecol 2017;129:91–100. doi: 10.1097/AOG.0000000000001810
19. Martin N, Montagne R. The last person you'd expect to die in childbirth. Accessed November 1, 2020. https://www.npr.org/2017/05/12/527806002/focus-on-infants-during-childbirth-leaves-u-s-moms-in-danger
20. Taylor J, Novoa C, Hamm K, Phadke S. Eliminating racial disparities in maternal and infant mortality: a comprehensive policy blueprint. Accessed November 1, 2020. https://www.americanprogress.org/issues/women/reports/2019/05/02/469186/eliminating-racial-disparities-maternal-infant-mortality/
21. Hawkins SS, Ghiani M, Harper S, Baum CF, Kaufman JS. Impact of state-level changes on maternal mortality: a population-based, quasi-experimental study [published erratum appears in Am J Prev Med 2020;59:305–7]. Am J Prev Med 2020;58:165–74. doi: 10.1016/j.amepre.2019.09.012
22. Tran T, Roberson E, Borstell J, Hoyert DL. Evaluation of pregnancy mortality in Louisiana using enhanced linkage and different indicators defined by WHO and CDC/ACOG: challenging and practical issues. Matern Child Health J 2011;15:955–63. doi: 10.1007/s10995-010-0564-0
23. Mitchell C, Lawton E, Morton C, McCain C, Holtby S, Main E. California pregnancy-associated mortality review: mixed methods approach for improved case identification, cause of death analyses and translation of findings. Matern Child Health J 2014;18:518–26. doi: 10.1007/s10995-013-1267-0
24. Davis NL, Hoyert DL, Goodman DA, Hirai AH, Callaghan WM. Contribution of maternal age and pregnancy checkbox on maternal mortality ratios in the United States, 1978–2012. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2017;217:352.e1–7. doi: 10.1016/j.ajog.2017.04.042
25. Creanga AA. Maternal mortality in the United States: a review of contemporary data and their limitations. Clin Obstet Gynecol 2018;61:296–306. doi: 10.1097/GRF.0000000000000362
26. St Pierre A, Zaharatos J, Goodman D, Callaghan WM. Challenges and opportunities in identifying, reviewing, and preventing maternal deaths. Obstet Gynecol 2018;131:138–42. doi: 10.1097/AOG.0000000000002417
27. MacDorman MF, Declercq E, Thoma ME. Trends in Texas maternal mortality by maternal age, race/ethnicity, and cause of death, 2006–2015. Birth 2018;45:169–77. doi: 10.1111/birt.12330
28. Boutin A, Cherian A, Liauw J, Dzakpasu S, Scott H, Van den Hof M, et al. Database autopsy: an efficient and effective confidential enquiry into maternal deaths in Canada. J Obstet Gynaecol Can 2020;43:58–66.e4. doi: 10.1016/j.jogc.2020.06.026
29. Belfort MA. Placenta accreta. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2010;203:430–9. doi: 10.1016/j.ajog.2010.09.013
30. Placenta accreta spectrum. Obstetric Care Consensus No. 7. American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. Obstet Gynecol 2018;132:e259–75. doi: 10.1097/AOG.0000000000002983
31. American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. ACOG statement on maternal mortality. Accessed November 1, 2020. https://www.acog.org/news/news-releases/2015/05/acog-statement-on-maternal-mortality
32. DiVenere L. Targeting US maternal mortality: ACOG's recent strides and future action. MDEdge OBG Manag 2019;31:31–2, 34.
33. Building U.S. Capacity to Review and Prevent Maternal Deaths. Report from nine maternal mortality review committees. Accessed November 1, 2020. http://reviewtoaction.org/Report_from_Nine_MMRCs
34. Knight M, Bunch K, Tuffnell D, Shakespeare J, Kotnis R, Kenyon S, et al editors. Saving lives, improving mothers' care - lessons learned to inform maternity care from the UK and Ireland confidential enquiries into maternal deaths and morbidity 2015-17. Accessed November 1, 2020. https://www.npeu.ox.ac.uk/assets/downloads/mbrrace-uk/reports/MBRRACE-UK%20Maternal%20Report%202019%20-%20WEB%20VERSION.pdf
35. Knight M, Bunch K, Kenyon S, Tuffnell D, Kurinczuk JJ. A national population-cohort study to investigate inequalities in maternal mortality in the United Kingdom, 2009-17. Paediatr Perinat Epidemiol 2020;34:392–8. doi: 10.1111/ppe.12640
36. Noursi S, Saluja B, Richey L. Using the ecological systems theory to understand Black/White disparities in maternal morbidity and mortality in the United States. J Racial Ethn Health Disparities 2020 Jul 27 [Epub ahead of print]. doi: 10.1007/s40615-020-00825-4
37. Marmot M, Allen J, Bell R, Bloomer E, Goldblatt P. WHO European review of social determinants of health and the health divide. Lancet 2012;380:1011–29. doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736(12)61228-8
38. Marmot M. Commission on Social Determinants of Health. Achieving health equity: from root causes to fair outcomes. Lancet 2007;370:1153–63. doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736(07)61385-3
39. United Nations Development Programme. A social determinants approach to maternal health: roles for development actors. Accessed November 1, 2020. https://www.undp.org/content/undp/en/home/librarypage/democratic-governance/a-social-determinants-approach-to-maternal-health.html