Secondary Logo

Journal Logo

Institutional members access full text with Ovid®

Evaluation of gastroenterology and hepatology articles on Wikipedia: Are they suitable as learning resources for medical students?

Azer, Samy A.

European Journal of Gastroenterology & Hepatology: February 2014 - Volume 26 - Issue 2 - p 155–163
doi: 10.1097/MEG.0000000000000003
Original Articles: Hepatitis
Buy

Background With the changes introduced to medical curricula, medical students use learning resources on the Internet such as Wikipedia. However, the credibility of the medical content of Wikipedia has been questioned and there is no evidence to respond to these concerns. The aim of this paper was to critically evaluate the accuracy and reliability of the gastroenterology and hepatology information that medical students retrieve from Wikipedia.

Methods The Wikipedia website was searched for articles on gastroenterology and hepatology on 28 May 2013. Copies of these articles were evaluated by three assessors independently using an appraisal form modified from the DISCERN instrument. The articles were scored for accuracy of content, readability, frequency of updating, and quality of references.

Results A total of 39 articles were evaluated. Although the articles appeared to be well cited and reviewed regularly, several problems were identified with regard to depth of discussion of mechanisms and pathogenesis of diseases, as well as poor elaboration on different investigations. Analysis of the content showed a score ranging from 15.6±0.6 to 43.6±3.2 (mean±SD). The total number of references in all articles was 1233, and the number of references varied from 4 to 144 (mean±SD, 31.6±27.3). The number of citations from peer-reviewed journals published in the last 5 years was 242 (28%); however, several problems were identified in the list of references and citations made. The readability of articles was in the range of −8.0±55.7 to 44.4±1.4; for all articles the readability was 26±9.0 (mean±SD). The concordance between the assessors on applying the criteria had mean κ scores in the range of 0.61 to 0.79.

Conclusion Wikipedia is not a reliable source of information for medical students searching for gastroenterology and hepatology articles. Several limitations, deficiencies, and scientific errors have been identified in the articles examined.

Department of Medical Education, Curriculum Development and Research Unit, College of Medicine, King Saud University, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia

All appendices are available directly from the corresponding author.

Correspondence to Samy A. Azer, MD, PhD (USyd), MEd (UNSW), FACG, MPH (UNSW), Department of Curriculum Development & Research Unit, College of Medicine, PO Box 2925, King Saud University, Riyadh 11461, Saudi Arabia Tel: +966 542 307 075; fax: +966 114 699 174; e-mail: azer2000@optusnet.com.au

Received July 5, 2013

Accepted September 12, 2013

© 2014 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins