Secondary Logo

Journal Logo

Pathways between urbanization and harmful substance use

Morgan, Nirvanaa; Mall, Sumayab

Current Opinion in Psychiatry: May 2019 - Volume 32 - Issue 3 - p 218–223
doi: 10.1097/YCO.0000000000000488
THE IMPACT OF URBANISATION ON MENTAL HEALTH: Edited by Christopher P. Szabo
Free
SDC

Purpose of review Epidemiological literature suggests that urbanization is potentially linked to a number of stressors that could be associated with harmful substance use and mental disorders. This may vary by country. This review gives attention to emergent literature examining the pathways between urbanization and harmful substance use.

Recent findings Studies examining the links between urbanization, mental health and substance use suggest complex pathways between urbanization and substance use as well as a range of modifying variables that could contribute to these associations. Such variables include increased supply of illicit and licit substances brought about by economic development, globalization and technology as well as an increased demand for particular substances. Rural areas may also have unique factors associated with harmful substance use but these are beyond the scope of this review.

Summary We have presented evidence to suggest potential associations between urbanization and harmful substance use. We acknowledge that data are limited because of a paucity of longitudinal studies elucidating these relationships.

aDepartment of Psychiatry

bDivision of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, Faculty of Health Sciences, School of Public Health, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, South Africa

Correspondence to Nirvana Morgan, MBBCh, MMed, FCPsych, Department of Psychiatry, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of the Witwatersrand, 7 York Road, Parktown 2193, Johannesburg, South Africa. Tel: +27767538051; e-mail: Nirvana.morgan@wits.ac.za

Back to Top | Article Outline

INTRODUCTION

The term urbanization has no universal definition. Broadly, urbanization refers to movement of people from rural areas to cities but can also refer to the expansion of urban boundaries and the development of new urban centres [1]. Definitions of what constitutes an ‘urban’ area also vary. Countries may use criteria such as population density (e.g. a population of more than 50 000), facilities (e.g. higher level schools) and infrastructure (e.g. street lighting) in their classification [1]. Urbanization in industrialized western countries has been ongoing and relatively well managed for the past 200 years. In resource poor regions such as Africa, South East Asia and South America accelerated mass urbanization over the last 50 years has often overwhelmed the city infrastructure and resulted in people living in adverse conditions [2,3].

Urbanization and its relationship to poor health including mental health have been well documented in the literature [2,4–6]. Health problems associated with urbanization are contingent upon various factors and there are complex pathways in the relationship between urbanization and mental health. Some of these are the pull and push forces driving migration, the economic status of the region and the adequacy of the urban infrastructure to cater for internal and external migrants [2]. Adverse climates, natural disasters and civil war are common push factors for urbanization. Economic influences such as job opportunities, desire for education and better housing pull rural dwellers towards urban areas [2]. However, the reality faced by migrants is often that of unemployment, homelessness, social isolation and cultural disintegration all of which could act along a pathway to a range of mental health conditions [4,5].

The Global Burden of Disease Study suggested that in 2013 alcohol and illicit drug use combined were the seventh largest risk factors for burden of disease. Alcohol and illicit drug use were associated with 3.163 million deaths globally, an increase of 51% since 2000. The increase was most notable for illicit drugs, which had a 225% increase in attributable deaths from 2000 to 2013 [7]. Urbanization and the factors associated with it play a role in the changing patterns of substance use and addictive behaviours [8,9]. This does not preclude rural areas from also experiencing increases in substance abuse. Rural and urban spaces do not necessarily reflect distinct dichotomies but often exist on a continuum from one space to another [1]. Additionally, rural areas also experience numerous drivers of ill health that is not within the aim or scope of this study. This paper will review recent studies that examined the relationship between substance use and urbanization in high, low and middle income countries. We also aim to highlight the areas for intervention.

Box 1

Box 1

Back to Top | Article Outline

URBANIZATION AND THE INCREASING SUPPLY OF LICIT AND ILLICIT SUBSTANCES

The modern-day increase in supply of alcohol and drugs is a significant contributor to the changing trends in consumption [10▪▪]. The increase in availability and consumption of substances is influenced by numerous factors. Some of these are growing economies, international trade, reduced prices of substances, and access to the internet [11,12]. All of these factors are inherently linked to urbanization and help with understanding the root drivers of harmful substance use in urban environments.

Back to Top | Article Outline

Economic development, international trade and pricing

A study exploring increasing alcohol-related harm in Africa identified economic development and international trade as factors that need to be addressed [12]. The main ways in which economic development influence alcohol consumption are through higher incomes and the ability of corporations to influence policy decisions that favour alcohol consumption. The alcohol industry's penetration in Africa has led to steep competition resulting in increased production, more competitive marketing and pricing schemes [13]. In a qualitative study done in an urbanizing region of the Cape Verde, the cheap price of alcohol (reported as even cheaper than food) and high availability of it were major concerns for community residents [14]. International investment generally makes alcohol more affordable and international trade agreements in Africa have often bypassed domestic laws and national juridical authorities [12]. These factors combined with weak policy infrastructure in some developing countries contribute to increasing patterns of harmful alcohol use.

Back to Top | Article Outline

Marketing, the e-market and ‘legal’ highs

For many, a better internet connection and access to free Wi-Fi is almost synonymous with urban living. Evidently smart cities are connected by the Internet of Things [15]. Although the internet has created many positive connections and conveniences; it has also allowed for connection to the ‘dark web’ and created alternate uncontrollable routes of drug distribution. Tor, the darknet or dark web, is an online network which encrypts communication and allows for online anonymity [16]. This corner of cyberspace motivates sellers and vendors to move away from traditional street-based drug transactions to a more convenient, globalized distribution system. The 2018 world drug report states that drug sales on the darknet may be between 170 and 300 million USD a year and that although trafficking may be limited there are signs of rapid growth [10▪▪]. A US study investigating the geographical patterns of drug sales on Tor confirmed previous United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime findings that New Psychoactive Substances (NPS) and prescription drugs are largely marketed and sold on the darknet [16].

NPS are synthetic substances created to mimic the effect of illicit drugs. As they fall outside international drug control conventions, they are often referred to as ‘legal highs’[17]. In a sample of 3011 Italian youth, 53.3% had some knowledge of NPS with a higher knowledge in urban areas [18]. NPS use was reported among 4.7% of the sample; however, there were no differences in use between rural and urban areas. In a sample of students in the nonmetropolitan county of Norfolk in the United Kingdom, 8.7% reported use of NPS showing higher prevalence rates than urban areas [19]. A national study of Saudi Arabian schools found that there was a strong association with the heavy use of internet and use of legal and illegal substances [20▪]. These studies suggest links between adolescent internet use, internet-based marketing and sales of potentially dangerous substances. Although not a ‘substance’ addiction, in the context of urbanization, modernization and the internet it is also important to highlight the increase in internet gaming disorders especially in younger population groups.

As a result of the explosive growth in technology and internet usage in the last few years, internet gaming disorder has become a public health concern [21]. The ICD-11 now includes a diagnosis of gaming disorder [22] and internet gaming disorder was included in the appendix of the updated version of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual for Mental Disorders [21]. The prevalence of gaming disorders ranges from 0.2 and 8.5% and is highest in Asian countries [23▪]. Gaming disorders are associated with severe negative impact on the physical, psychological, social and occupational functioning of the affected individual and often lead to severe consequences. Currently, there is no direct evidence linking urban living or urban migration with gaming disorder. However, the widespread use of the internet, smartphones and the pathway to substance and behavioural addictions in urbanized areas warrant monitoring. Additionally, prevention strategies and enhancement of protective factors should be explored.

Back to Top | Article Outline

Prescription drug use and the US opioid crisis

The current opioid crisis in the United States has been declared the worst drug overdose crisis in US history. Initially the rise in opioid deaths was matched by an increase in doctors opioid prescriptions which some suggest was higher in urban regions [24]. There have been numerous recent publications analyzing the geographic distributions of opioid abuse and deaths in relation to rural–urban population groups [25▪,26–31]. The results are conflicting. Some report more deaths and higher prescription opioid use in the large metropolitan areas [25▪,31] whereas others state that the rate of death in large metros has decreased with a shift to small and nonmetropolitan areas [26]. There is also evidence pointing to higher rates of harmful use of opioids in rural areas compared to urban [28–31]. This review cannot conclude that the US opioid crisis is driven by factors associated with urbanization. It is, however, worthy to note that high levels of opioid use in urban areas has been linked with increased prescribing because of insufficient knowledge of the harms associated with opioids. Marketing influences from the pharmaceutical industry were also cited as contributing factors [24,32]. A study analyzing data of over 47 000 US adults found that urban adults were more likely to engage in opioid use compared to rural adults because of their higher use of other substances, including alcohol, cannabis and other illicit and prescription drugs. Opioid use in urban residents was also associated with greater use of these substances as children [31].

Back to Top | Article Outline

URBANIZATION AND THE DEMAND FOR LICIT AND ILLICIT SUBSTANCES

Reviews on urbanization and mental health consistently report that urban migrants experience numerous financial, environmental and cultural stressors [3,5,8,9]. The use of substances as a coping mechanism during periods of stress [33] or as a form of self-medication for symptoms of depression and anxiety [34] are well-known psychosocial aetiologies of substance abuse. Thus, it is plausible that the rather merciless fast paced, stressful, lonely and polluted atmosphere of some expanding cities would drive increases in alcohol, tobacco and illicit drug use. However, despite theories postulating the relationship between stress and substance abuse there is limited primary data exploring or confirming causal pathways between specific urban stressors and harmful substance use or substance dependence.

Back to Top | Article Outline

Urban sociocultural stressors and substance use

A three-decade longitudinal study of a minority group in China found that there were significant increases in alcohol abuse, alcohol-related psychosis and alcohol-related liver disease in the last decade [35▪▪]. The major factor influencing this group was modernization and urbanization. With urbanization came changes in patterns of social drinking, increase in divorces and gambling activities. All these factors coupled with a poor recognition of the mental health needs of this minority group contributed to the rise in alcohol use [35▪▪]. In another large-scale study of predominantly urban Chinese nationals, substance use disorder was significantly higher in those living alone [36]. These studies suggest a pathway between urbanization and traditional family structure, cultural norms and risks for increased alcohol consumption. Urbanization has also brought about a breakdown of family structure via migration of parents without their children.

Mass internal urban migration in China and particular Chinese policies have caused many families to be separated. It is estimated that more than 60 million children in China are ‘left behind’ because of their parents seeking work in urban areas [37]. In five Latin American countries, it was found that between 5 and 21% of children had absent parents due transnational urban migration [38]. Lack of parental supervision is repeatedly reported as a significant risk factor for harmful adolescent substance use [39–41]. Thus, although data is currently limited the substance use rates in children left behind because of urban migration should be closely monitored, and prevention strategies should be implemented.

Back to Top | Article Outline

Urban environmental stressors and substance use

In low and middle-income countries, massive slum populations are largely a result of rural urban migration and the inadequacy of cities to cater for migrant groups [42]. Slum populations experience stressors of unemployment, overcrowding and poor sanitation facilities. A study assessing tobacco use in adolescent youth from slum populations in India found that the overall lifetime prevalence of tobacco use was 25%. The prevalence was relatively higher than those reported in nationwide surveys of adolescent tobacco use in India. Tobacco use was higher among those with lower socioeconomic status and adolescents who used tobacco were more likely to use alcohol than those who did not use tobacco. Tobacco use was also significantly associated with family stress, more severe psychological distress and a sense of hopelessness [43].

Homelessness is another stressor affecting urban migrants. A study in New York assessing homeless people entering an urban hospital emergency department found that patients who were currently homeless had higher rates of past year unhealthy alcohol use, any drug use, heroin use, prescription opioid use and lifetime opioid overdose [44]. It is possible that severe substance dependence contributed to homelessness; however, the studies’ robust finding led the authors to conclude that unstable housing and frank homelessness may be associated with opioid abuse and overdose. This points to infrastructure and economic challenges within urban environments and the complex pathway to substance abuse.

Poor city infrastructure; water, air and noise pollution; insufficient green spaces and traffic congestion are some of the urban environmental factors potentially linked with mental health disorders [3,4,42]. Data specifically linking these urban infrastructure deficits to harmful use of substances is limited. There is, however, evidence of links between environmental factors and general mental health of adolescents. A systematic review on the impact of green space exposure on children and adolescent mental health found that there was a beneficial association between green space exposure and children's emotional and behavioural difficulties [6]. The association was more evident with hyperactivity and inattention problems. It is therefore evident that city planning needs to take into account the mental health of its residents and the need for more green spaces.

Back to Top | Article Outline

RECOMMENDATIONS

Governments should play a more protective role in regulating the supply of harmful licit and illicit addictive substances. Urban planning and infrastructure development should be priority areas for countries experiencing mass urban migration. There should be widespread implementation of evidence-based programmes for adolescent substance use. Many urban centres need to upscale treatment services to meet the needs of rising number of people with harmful substance use and dependence. More longitudinal studies would assist in elucidating the factors that predict harmful substance use after relocation to urban areas and clarify the impact of increasing urban spaces on population's substance consumption trends.

Back to Top | Article Outline

CONCLUSION

Although limited, there is data reporting significant associations between urbanization processes and increasing supply and demand for licit and illicit substances. Urbanization is associated with many distal physical and social stressors [4]; however, the pathways to increasing substance use often begin at the level of international trade and policy [12]. Factors ranging from policy, urban infrastructure, internet usage, changes in social and cultural norms, slum environments and frank homelessness may all contribute to rising trends in alcohol, tobacco and drug use in some urban centres. Policymakers need to respond to the impact of rapid unplanned urbanization on mental health and ensure that prevention and treatment services are tailored to changing health needs.

Back to Top | Article Outline

Acknowledgements

We would like to thank Ms Sherylene Ganesh for her support.

Back to Top | Article Outline

Financial support and sponsorship

N.M.: Recipient of a Cassandra-Miller Butterworth Fellowship for a clinician scientist PhD.

Recipient of a South African National Research Foundation (NRF) Thuthuka Grant.

Funding from the fellowship and grant did not directly support this study.

S.M.: Recipient of a South African Medical Research Council (MRC) self-initiated research Fellowship.

Recipient of a Claude Leon award for early career researchers.

Funding from the fellowship and award did not directly support this study.

Back to Top | Article Outline

Conflicts of interest

There are no conflicts of interest.

Back to Top | Article Outline

REFERENCES AND RECOMMENDED READING

Papers of particular interest, published within the annual period of review, have been highlighted as:

  • ▪ of special interest
  • ▪▪ of outstanding interest
Back to Top | Article Outline

REFERENCES

1. McGranahan G, Satterthwaite D. Urbanisation: concepts and trends. London: International Institute for Environment and Development (IIED); 2014. http://pubs.iied.org/10709IIED/. [Accessed 22 November 2018]
2. Godfrey R, Julien M. Urbanisation and health. Clin Med 2005; 5:137–141.
3. Okkels N, Kristiansen CB, Munk-Jørgensen P, et al. Urban mental health: challenges and perspectives. Curr Opin Psychiatry 2018; 31:258–264.
4. Gruebner O, Rapp MA, Adli M, et al. Cities and mental health. Dtsch Arztebl Int 2017; 114:121.
5. Szabo CP. Urbanization and mental health: a developing world perspective. Curr Opin Psychiatry 2018; 31:256.
6. Vanaken GJ, Danckaerts M. Impact of green space exposure on children's and adolescents’ mental health: a systematic review. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2018; 15:2668.
7. Forouzanfar MH, Alexander L, Anderson HR, et al. GBD 2013 Risk Factors Collaborators. Global, regional, and national comparative risk assessment of 79 behavioural, environmental and occupational, and metabolic risks or clusters of risks in 188 countries, 1990–2013: a systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2013. Lancet 2015; 386:2287–2323.
8. Chandra PS, Shiva L, Nanjundaswamy MH. The impact of urbanization on mental health in India. Curr Opin Psychiatry 2018; 31:276–281.
9. Morozov PV. Mental health and urbanization: a Russian perspective. Curr Opin Psychiatry 2018; 31:272–275.
10▪▪. United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime. Executive summary conclusions and policy implications. 2018; https://www.unodc.org/wdr2018. [Accessed 23 November 2018]

This is an annual world drug report by the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime. The complete five booklet report provides global estimates of drug supply and consumption trends, provides demographic patterns of substance use globally and includes a review of specific risks and vulnerabilities for substance abuse.

11. Li C, Li J, Wu J. What drives urban growth in China? A multiscale comparative analysis. Appl Geogr 2018; 98:43–51.
12. Ferreira-Borges C, Dias S, Babor T, et al. Alcohol and public health in Africa: can we prevent alcohol-related harm from increasing? Addiction 2015; 110:1373–1379.
13. Jernigan DH, Babor TF. The concentration of the global alcohol industry and its penetration in the African region. Addiction 2015; 110:551–560.
14. Craveiro I, Alves D, Amado M, et al. Determinants, health problems, and food insecurity in urban areas of the largest city in Cape Verde. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2016; 13:1155.
15. Silva BN, Khan M, Han K. Towards sustainable smart cities: a review of trends, architectures, components, and open challenges in smart cities. Sustain Cities Soc 2018; 38:697–713.
16. Dolliver DS, Ericson SP, Love KL. A geographic analysis of drug trafficking patterns on the tor network. Geogr Rev 2018; 108:45–68.
17. United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime. The challenge of new psychoactive substances: a report from the Global SMART Programme. 2013; https://www.unodc.org/documents/scientific/NPS_Report.pdf. [Accessed 29 November 2018]
18. Martinotti G, Lupi M, Carlucci L, et al. Novel psychoactive substances: use and knowledge among adolescents and young adults in urban and rural areas. Hum Psychopharmacol 2015; 30:295–301.
19. Roderick E, Penney J, Murrells T, et al. Epidemiology of adolescent substance use in Norfolk schools. QJM 2018; 111:699–706.
20▪. AlSayyari A, AlBuhairan F. Relationship of media exposure to substance use among adolescents in Saudi Arabia: results from a national study. Drug Alcohol Depend 2018; 191:174–180.

This study surveyed a national sample of 12 121 Saudi Arabian youth from ages 10–19. It reported that the odds of using tobacco, legal and illegal substances were higher for students who were watching television, surfing the internet, or playing video games for more than 2 h compared with their peers who watched less than 2 h. It also found that there was a strong multivariate association between the heavy use of internet and use of licit and illicit substances. Unlike other similar studies, this analysis controlled for covariates such as depression, chronic illness, exercise and parental relationships.

21. Poli R. Internet addiction update: diagnostic criteria, assessment and prevalence. Neuropsychiatry 2017; 7:4–8.
22. Higuchi S, Nakayama H, Mihara S, et al. Inclusion of gaming disorder criteria in ICD-11: A clinical perspective in favor: Commentary on: Scholars’ open debate paper on the World Health Organization ICD-11 Gaming Disorder proposal (Aarseth et al.). J Behav Addict 2017; 6:293–295.
23▪. Naskar S, Victor R, Nath K, et al. ‘One level more:’ a narrative review on internet gaming disorder. Ind Psychiatry J 2016; 25:145.

This study provides a comprehensive review on internet gaming disorder. It summarizes the literature describing the various aetiological theories, diagnostic issues, assessment tools, comorbidities and evidence-based prevention and treatment.

24. Ayres I, Jalal A. The impact of prescription drug monitoring programs on US opioid prescriptions. 2018; https://ssrn.com/abstract=3165524 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3165524. [Accessed 29 November 2018]
25▪. Seth P, Scholl L, Rudd RA, et al. Overdose deaths involving opioids, cocaine, and psychostimulants: United States, 2015–2016. Am J Transplant 2018; 18:1556–1568.

This report on 63 632 drug overdose deaths from 2015–2016 in the United States provides an analysis of the different drugs classes involved in overdoses. Opioid-involved overdoses accounted for two-thirds of drug overdose deaths with increases across age and racial/ethnic groups and urbanization levels. Although the death rate from prescription opioids and heroin decreased, the death rate from synthetic opioids (such as fentanyl) doubled from 2015 to 2016.

26. Stewart K, Cao Y, Hsu MH, Artigiani E, et al. Geospatial analysis of drug poisoning deaths involving heroin in the USA, 2000–2014. J Urban Health 2017; 94:572–586.
27. Dwyer-Lindgren L, Bertozzi-Villa A, Stubbs RW, et al. Trends and patterns of geographic variation in mortality from substance use disorders and intentional injuries among US counties, 1980-2014. JAMA 2018; 319:1013–1023.
28. Keyes KM, Cerdá M, Brady JE, et al. Understanding the rural–urban differences in nonmedical prescription opioid use and abuse in the United States. Am J Public Health 2014; 104:52–59.
29. Tompkins P. Confronting the disparity in nonmedical prescription opioid use among rural and urban youth: a call for broader recognition in the era of clandestine fentanyl. UBC Medical Journal 2018; 9:36–37.
30. Luu H, Slavova S, Freeman PR, et al. Trends and patterns of opioid analgesic prescribing: regional and rural-urban variations in Kentucky from 2012 to 2015. J Rural Health 2019; 35:97–107.
31. Rigg KK, Monnat SM. Urban vs. rural differences in prescription opioid misuse among adults in the United States: informing region specific drug policies and interventions. Int J Drug Policy 2015; 26:484–491.
32. Pacula RL, Powell D. A supply-side perspective on the opioid crisis. J Policy Anal Manage 2018; 37:438–446.
33. Sinha R. How does stress increase risk of drug abuse and relapse? Psychopharmacology (Berl) 2001; 158:343–359.
34. Turner S, Mota N, Bolton J, et al. Self-medication with alcohol or drugs for mood and anxiety disorders: a narrative review of the epidemiological literature. Depress Anxiety 2018; 35:851–860.
35▪▪. Yang J, Kang C, Li J, et al. A three-decade repeated cross-sectional survey on mental health of the Chinese Jino minority. Aust N Z J Psychiatry 2017; 51:1134–1141.

This study assessed the mental health on a Chinese minority group at four time points, over three decades from 1979 to 2009. As the community became more modern and urbanized, there were significant increases in alcohol abuse, alcohol dependence and Korsakoff's psychosis. Furthermore, there was three-fold increase in suicide rates from 1989 to 2009 and significant increases in major depressive disorder.

36. Yin H, Xu G, Tian H, et al. The prevalence, age-of-onset and the correlates of DSM-IV psychiatric disorders in the Tianjin Mental Health Survey (TJMHS). Psychol Med 2018; 48:473–487.
37. Guan H, Wang H, Huang J, et al. Health seeking behavior among rural left-behind children: evidence from Shaanxi and Gansu Provinces in China. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2018; 15:1–19.
38. DeWaard J, Nobles J, Donato KM. Migration and parental absence: a comparative assessment of transnational families in Latin America. Popul Space Place 2018; 24:e2166.
39. Muchiri BW, dos Santos MM. Family management risk and protective factors for adolescent substance use in South Africa. Subst abuse Treat Prev Policy 2018; 13:24.
40. Rusby JC, Light JM, Crowley R, et al. Influence of parent–youth relationship, parental monitoring, and parent substance use on adolescent substance use onset. J Fam Psychol 2018; 32:310–320.
41. Jones JD, Ehrlich KB, Lejuez CW, et al. Parental knowledge of adolescent activities: links with parental attachment style and adolescent substance use. J Fam Psychol 2015; 29:191.
42. Turan MT, Besirli A. Impacts of urbanization process on mental health. Anatol J Psychiatry 2008; 9:238–243.
43. Nayak S, Mishra A. Prevalence and factors affecting tobacco use among urban adolescents in Bhilai city, central India. Int J Community Med Public Health 2018; 5:1492–1498.
44. Doran KM, Rahai N, McCormack RP, et al. Substance use and homelessness among emergency department patients. Drug Alcohol Depend 2018; 188:328–333.
Keywords:

harmful substance use; mental health; pathways; urbanization

Copyright © 2019 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved.