Malignant hyperthermia (MH) is an inherited muscle disorder characterized by hypermetabolism and is usually triggered after susceptible individuals are given volatile anesthetics and/or depolarizing muscle relaxants.1
We recently demonstrated that muscular build and disseminated intravascular coagulation were associated with an increased risk of cardiac arrest and death during MH episodes.2 However, there has been no systematic evaluation of MH clinical characteristics, treatment, and other complications since the 1970 study by Britt and Kalow3 that analyzed 94 case reports before use of dantrolene, with a reported mortality rate of 61%.
We analyzed epidemiologic characteristics of episodes reported to the North American Registry* database over a 19-year period with a focus on presentation, treatment including dantrolene, and factors associated with significant complications attributed to MH.
With exempt status by the Penn State College of Medicine IRB (Hershey, PA), we examined AMRA reports received by the Registry from January 1, 1987 through December 31, 2006. The AMRA is a standardized report form concerning relevant medical and anesthetic history that clinicians complete and submit to the MH Registry after a patient's adverse metabolic and/or musculoskeletal reaction to anesthesia.† Inclusion criteria were as follows: event occurred on January 1, 1987 or later and the AMRA report was received at the Registry by December 31, 2006; episode occurred in the United States or Canada; at least one anesthetic drug was given; and episode ranked by the MH clinical grading scale (CGS) as “very likely” or “almost certain” MH event.4
The CGS estimates the qualitative likelihood of MH in a given patient without the use of specialized diagnostic testing and is based on points assigned for specific abnormal signs and laboratory findings (rigidity, muscle breakdown, respiratory and metabolic acidosis, temperature increase, and cardiac involvement) observed during an acute anesthetic reaction. Seventy percent of the points are assigned based on critical cutoff values (e.g., inappropriately increased temperature >38.8°C in the perioperative period adds 10 points to the total score). Points are assigned when they are judged by the anesthesiologist to be inappropriate for the patient's underlying medical condition, anesthetic technique, and surgical procedure (e.g., 0 points instead of 15 points when hypercarbia is judged secondary to an inadequate airway or when a rapid increase in temperature is judged to be secondary to sepsis).‡4
Exclusion criteria were a pathologic condition other than MH (e.g., Duchenne muscular dystrophy, hypothalamic injury, and sepsis), and the surgical procedure being the likely cause as independently judged by the authors with MH expertise (MGL, GAG, GCA, and BWB).
For the complication analysis only, cases were excluded if complication status was unknown or was judged by the authors to be secondary to minor complications of dantrolene (e.g., thrombophlebitis). Cardiac arrest or death cases were included if additional complications were reported as part of their event.
We analyzed each episode for the order of appearance of each clinical sign (numbered by the clinician from 1 through 9). Clinicians were instructed to assign the same number to signs that occurred simultaneously (e.g., if masseter spasm and tachycardia were observed simultaneously as the first sign, then masseter spasm and tachycardia both received the number 1). The order of the clinical sign appearance did not influence CGS rank (e.g., no additional points were added if a sign was observed first).
The patterns of clinical presentation were defined as follows: a muscular presentation was defined as masseter spasm, generalized muscular rigidity, cola-colored urine, peak creatine kinase >10,000 U/L, or peak potassium >6.0 mEq/L. A respiratory acidosis presentation was defined as inappropriate hypercarbia, inappropriate tachypnea, maximum end-tidal carbon dioxide >55 mm Hg, or arterial Pco2 >60 mm Hg. A metabolic acidosis presentation was defined as an arterial base excess more negative than −8 mEq/L. Numeric thresholds matched those of the CGS.4
Complications were defined as a change in consciousness level and/or coma; disseminated intravascular coagulation; pulmonary edema; cardiac, renal, or hepatic dysfunction; or “other” complication as specified by the reporting clinician. Independent variables for complication analysis included demographics, body build, procedure type and urgency, type of temperature monitor, nature of anesthetic (volatile anesthetic, succinylcholine, tracheal intubation, maximum end-tidal Pco2, and maximum temperature), initial and total dantrolene dose, adjunctive treatment (active cooling, anesthesia circuit change, bicarbonate administration, hyperventilation, and IV fluid loading), time interval between first clinical sign and first dantrolene dose, and time intervals between induction to: first clinical sign, maximum end-tidal Pco2, maximum temperature, and first dantrolene dose.
Descriptive statistics (median, first and third quartiles, and range) of the population experiencing MH are presented. For continuous variables such as time or dosage in which 2 groups of variables were compared, a Wilcoxon rank sum test compared their medians with first and third quartiles as surrogates for confidence intervals (CIs). For continuous variables in which >2 groups of variables were compared, a Kruskal-Wallis test compared their medians with first and third quartiles as surrogates for CIs. For categorical variables such as gender and absence of a temperature probe, a Pearson exact χ2 tested the difference in proportion between categories. Exact odds ratios with exact 95% CIs quantified magnitude and direction of the difference between proportions. A Bonferroni correction adjusted for multiple comparisons within groups of clinically related variables to maintain an overall error rate of 0.05.
Univariate analysis was used to identify independent variables associated with complications, adjusting for multiple comparisons by the Hochberg method.5 A multivariable model was built with stepwise selection of significant variables with fit judged by the Hosmer-Lemeshow statistic.6A P value ≥0.05 for this statistic demonstrates adequate fit. Statistical analysis was performed using SAS version 9.1.3 Service Pack 4 (SAS Institute, Cary, NC).
Two hundred eighty-six cases (47.9% of all submitted AMRA reports) met entry criteria, but not all data were reported for all of the cases. Thus, some categories include <286 values. One hundred twelve cases (39.2%) were graded by the CGS as “very likely” MH, and 174 cases (60.8%) were “almost certain” MH.
Clinical Characteristics Before MH Triggering
A total of 1.8% were from Canada, 74.8% were males, 69.4% were Caucasian, and 29% of all patients had a muscular body build. Of the 269 with age data, the median age was 22.0 years (10.0, 41.0 years), range 116 days to 78.0 years, and 45% were 19 years and younger. Gender distribution did not change with age.
Sixteen of 248 patients (6.5%) had an MH family history (although in many cases it was not known preoperatively§); one patient had received a non-MH triggering anesthetic. There was a family history of heat stroke in 3.6% of cases (n = 9), and 6 of these patients received one or more unremarkable general anesthetic before MH.
In 7.0% of patients, there was a personal history of increased muscle tone. Muscle weakness (2.1%), muscle cramps (3.9%), exercise intolerance (0.7%), cola-colored urine (1.1%), heatstroke (1.1%), and heat intolerance (0.4%) were also reported. Nine patients (3.3%) reported an unusual metabolic response during previous anesthetics, whereas 77 patients (50.7%) had ≥2 prior unremarkable general anesthetics. The number of unremarkable general anesthetics before 152 MH events was 2 (1, 2, range 0–30). Whether these included MH triggers is unknown, but the median year of the last uneventful anesthetic was 1991 (1984, 1996, range 1940–2006), when volatile anesthetics were frequently administered during general anesthesia.
The procedure was an emergency in 24.1% of 282 cases. Succinylcholine was given 3.8 times more often in emergency cases (95% CI, 2.0–7.0; P < 0.0001). Volatile anesthetics were used as frequently in emergency as in nonemergency cases. MH occurred most frequently during orthopedic (25.5%); ear, nose, and throat (ENT) (15.7%); and general surgical (14.0%) procedures. Succinylcholine was given 1.9 times more often during these 3 procedure types when analyzed together compared with all other procedure types (95% CI, 1.2–3.0; P = 0.009).
Pulse oximetry was used in 99.3%, capnography in 96.2%, and temperature monitoring in 90.9% (n = 259) of cases. A skin liquid crystal temperature indicator was used as the sole temperature probe in 39 cases (13.8%). In 10 patients, skin liquid crystal temperature probes did not accurately trend with core temperature probes. (Appendix A, cases 1 and 2 contain events that did not trend during simultaneous esophageal and skin liquid crystal temperature monitoring.) Although the simultaneous liquid crystal temperature readings are unknown, the maximum temperature was 40.0°C (range, 36.5°C–41.2°C) at tympanic, esophageal, and nasopharyngeal sites. When patients with (n = 259) and without (n = 26) temperature probe monitoring were compared, no significant difference was observed in the interval between anesthetic induction and first MH sign. However, in 5 of 26 patients with no temperature monitoring when the first MH sign was recognized, there was a rapidly increasing temperature or increased temperature with a median maximum temperature of 39.1°C (range, 37.5°C–42.4°C).
The median year for the anesthetic was 1996 (1993, 2000, range 1987–2006). A total of 218 patients (76.2%) received tracheal intubation. Laryngeal mask airway use is unknown. Table 1 depicts the frequency with which volatile anesthetics and/or succinylcholine were administered. Patients aged 19 years and younger were 11.6 times more likely to receive a volatile anesthetic without IV induction drug (95% CI, 5.8–23.2; P < 0.0001) and had a shorter time from induction to volatile anesthetic discontinuation (45 minutes [19.0–90.0 minutes] vs 112 minutes [60.0–180 minutes]; P < 0.0001) than those older than 19 years. There was no difference in exposure to succinylcholine with age or gender.
Abnormal Signs and Presentation Pattern
For 255 cases in which the order of clinical sign appearance (Table 2) was known, a median of 4 signs was noted (3, 5, range 1–9). The first or only MH clinical sign noted was hypercarbia (38.0%), sinus tachycardia (31.0%), or masseter spasm (20.8%). Induction of anesthesia to first sign interval was shorter in patients aged 19 years and younger (30 minutes [9.5, 70 minutes] vs 94 minutes [32.5, 168 minutes]; P < 0.0001) and for females (34 minutes [8.0, 105.0 minutes] vs 70 minutes [21.5, 143.5 minutes]; P = 0.0026).
The time between induction and first sign was <30 minutes for 89 of 268 events for which data were available including 0 minutes for 6 cases (i.e., immediately on induction). For 5 of these zero interval cases, masseter spasm followed succinylcholine administration. In one, generalized muscular rigidity with sinus tachycardia followed sevoflurane induction.
For the 255 patients in which the order of appearance of the signs was known, inappropriately elevated (>38.8°C) or rapidly increasing temperature was one of the first signs in 8.2% and the only initial sign in 3.9% of patients. Temperature abnormalities were the first to third signs in 63.5% of patients with a median temperature maximum of 39.1°C (38.4°C, 40.0°C). Although the median time interval from induction to maximum temperature was 105 minutes (50.0, 197.5 minutes), the range was large (0–880.0 minutes).∥ Because of the wording of the AMRA report, we do not know the interval from induction to rapidly increasing temperature unless it was the first sign noted. However, there was no significant difference in the interval from induction to first sign between the group that had rapidly increasing temperature as the first sign and the group that did not.
The dataset includes 196 cases in which relevant clinical signs (hypercarbia, tachypnea, generalized muscular rigidity, and cola-colored urine) were observed, and/or maximum expired CO2, creatine kinase, potassium, and arterial blood gas measurements were made. Ninety-nine percent developed respiratory acidosis, but only 26% developed a metabolic acidosis with all but one of those cases also having respiratory acidosis. A total of 79.6% had a muscular presentation.
Table 3 lists the frequency with which combinations of each presentation type occurred. The most frequent presentation was a combined respiratory acidosis and muscular presentation (58.2%). Twenty percent of patients had signs or abnormal laboratory findings that were representative of all possible (respiratory acidosis, metabolic acidosis, and muscular) presentation types. Presentation type was not significantly associated with varying combinations of volatile anesthetic and succinylcholine exposure.
Evaluation and Treatment
Although 232 of 286 patients (81.1%) had maximum expired CO2, creatine kinase, potassium, and arterial blood gas measurements, only 91 patients (31.8%) also had maximum temperature, platelet count, and prothrombin or partial thromboplastin time determinations. Seven percent of patients had no documented arterial blood gas analysis.
The time between the first sign and the first dantrolene dose used to treat MH events was 30 minutes (15, 60 minutes). Table 4 lists the dantrolene doses used to treat MH events. There was no significant difference in total dantrolene dose administered to those experiencing a “very likely” versus an “almost certain” MH event. There was also no significant difference in total dantrolene dose according to presentation pattern.
Twenty-two patients received no dantrolene and survived their event without cardiac arrest. Eleven of these cases had information regarding MH complications. There were 2: hepatic dysfunction and bilateral lower extremity soreness in association with a peak creatine kinase of 365,970 U/L (Appendix A, cases 3 and 4). Those treated with dantrolene were 2.97 times more likely to have an “almost certain” episode than those not treated with dantrolene (95% CI, 1.19–7.14; P = 0.019).4 There was inadequate power to detect differences between the group receiving dantrolene and the one not receiving dantrolene regarding age, sex, muscular body build, MH triggers, time between induction and first MH sign, time between induction and maximum end-tidal Pco2, time between induction and finish time, length of volatile anesthetic exposure, and MH complications.
Trigger Anesthetic Discontinuation
The time between the first sign and volatile discontinuation was 10 minutes (2, 30 minutes). However, 2 young ENT patients had volatile anesthetics continued and they survived (Appendix A, cases 5 and 6). A 30-year-old cesarean delivery patient given a second dose of succinylcholine after masseter spasm also survived (Appendix A, case 7).
Table 5 lists the adjunctive treatments reported for 284 MH events. Treatment frequency correlated with the severity of abnormal findings (Appendix B).
Complication data covered 181 patients. Of these, 34.8% (n = 63) reported 1 or more complications other than recrudescence, cardiac arrest, or death. The median complication number observed in 63 cases was 1 (1, 2, range 1–5). Table 6 lists the frequency of neurologic, cardiac, pulmonary, renal, hematologic, hepatic, and/or “other” complications.
There was no significant difference between the group experiencing complications and the group not experiencing complications regarding rapidly increasing temperature or temperature exceeding the CGS threshold value of >38.8°C. For the 13 patients experiencing disseminated intravascular coagulation, the median maximum temperature of 40.3°C was higher than the median (39.0°C) in the 162 patients without this complication (P = 0.0067). Twenty-one patients experienced hematologic and/or neurologic complications with maximum temperatures <41.6°C. Six of these experienced neurologic complications without cardiovascular instability during a nonneurologic and noncardiac procedure. For those with maximum temperatures <41.6°C, there was no significant difference in the frequency of bicarbonate administration between those experiencing and those not experiencing hematologic and/or neurologic complications.
Univariate analysis identified maximum temperature as a significant independent variable for the experience of an MH complication (P = 0.024). One hundred twenty-one subjects had data for all variables analyzed in the multivariable model; 38 subjects experienced a complication, 6 of whom also had a cardiac arrest. According to the multivariable model, the likelihood of a complication increased 1.61 times (95% CI, 1.16–2.25) for every 30-minute increase in time between the first sign and the first dantrolene dose and 2.85 times (95% CI, 1.60–5.08) for every 2°C increase in maximum temperature. The Hosmer-Lemeshow goodness of fit test for this model is P = 0.140. When the 6 patients experiencing cardiac arrest were eliminated from the multivariable dataset, the multivariable model still identified these 2 variables as increasing the likelihood of an MH complication with a Hosmer-Lemeshow goodness of fit test (P = 0.135).
We used the AMRA report database with well-documented clinical experiences and the MH clinical grading scale to determine clinical MH likelihood and selected only patients at the highest MH likelihoods. The CGS has served as a clinical case definition for the MH syndrome for multiple research studies including those validating the North American caffeine halothane contracture test7 and the in vitro contracture test (European MH Group).8,9,10,2,11 In addition, the 4 authors with MH expertise excluded cases involving a pathologic condition other than MH or a likely causative surgical procedure. Although the North American MH Registry database also has biopsy reports from caffeine halothane contracture tests on probands and their relatives and, in some cases, molecular genetic analyses, proband clinical experiences are variably documented and less well suited to a study of MH clinical presentation.
Our study may be limited by incomplete patient data, underreporting, or biased reporting, but a disorder as rare as MH precludes a multicenter prospective study.12 Similarly, we could not perform a case-control study of MH complications because the AMRA report portion of the Registry database lacks appropriate control cases. In addition, our study of factors associated with MH complications may be biased because the CGS independent classification of MH and our dependent variable temperature may be correlated because of the importance of temperature as 1 of 6 possible categories contributing to the CGS score. However, complication analysis bias seems to be minimal because there were no significant differences between the group with and without complications regarding the frequency with which temperature exceeded the critical cutoff value of 38.8°C or the frequency with which inappropriately rapid increase in temperature was noted.
Although MH susceptibility is inherited as an autosomal dominant, we confirmed in our study that its expression is primarily in males.3,13 Males with MH also had a longer period of anesthesia before first sign recognition.
Our results confirm those of others who reported that predominantly younger patients develop MH.14,15,13 We also demonstrated that MH occurred sooner in patients aged 19 years and younger who solely received volatile anesthetics for induction. The minimum alveolar concentration (MAC) that prevents incisional movement in 50% of patients exposed to a surgical incision decreases with age16–18; therefore, compared with older patients, younger patients were more likely to receive an increased dose of the inhaled anesthetics. It may be reasonable to extrapolate that the young experienced a higher initial dose of volatile anesthetics, although the total dose of volatile anesthetic may have been equivalent to that given to those who were older, because of their shorter exposure time.
A total of 6.5% of our patients had a family history of MH that was frequently not known at the time of the perioperative evaluation, illustrating the difficulty anesthesiologists may have in obtaining an accurate family history.¶
Our data regarding prior unremarkable general anesthetics (2, range 0–30) confirm the observation made by Halsall et al.19 in 20 patients that lack of MH during prior anesthetic triggers does not indicate insusceptibility to MH. However, our dataset also included 9 patients who had experienced an unusual metabolic response during a prior anesthetic. We do not know when the anesthesiologist learned this. We recommend that MH trigger-free anesthetics be administered to anyone with this history unless a thorough review of past anesthetic and hospital records reveals a cause other than MH.
Skin liquid crystal temperature indicators were inaccurate in 10 MH cases, human findings that confirm prior porcine observations.20 We recommend that skin liquid crystal temperature monitors not be used for detection of MH.
It is likely that more frequent administration of succinylcholine underlies the prevalence of emergency and orthopedic, ENT, and general surgical procedures in this dataset. Because 45% of MH cases involved the administration of volatile anesthetics without concomitant succinylcholine, we believe that MH cases will continue to occur even without succinylcholine use.
The most frequent initial MH sign was hypercarbia, sinus tachycardia, or masseter spasm with temperature abnormalities as a further relatively early sign. This finding was unbiased by our use of the CGS for case selection because the order of appearance of MH signs does not influence the CGS score. Although no single pattern of clinical signs consistently occurs during the onset of MH, the majority of patients had both muscular and respiratory acidotic presentations although some presented with acidosis without evidence of rigidity or muscle destruction. Early clinical investigations documented metabolic acidosis during MH events.3,13 Our low incidence of metabolic acidosis may have been attributable to dantrolene treatment (given to none of the patients in the study by Britt et al.14 and only to 15% of the patients in the study by Mauritz et al.13) or failure to obtain arterial blood gases during the most acute phase of the MH reaction.
Before dantrolene's introduction, Britt and Kalow3 documented a 36% survival rate with symptomatic treatment only. Our study documents 9 patients (3.3%) who did not receive dantrolene and survived MH without cardiac arrest or significant complication. There was inadequate power to determine whether a shorter exposure to volatile anesthetics explains this outcome. We also document survival albeit with significant rhabdomyolysis of 3 patients who received additional MH triggers after the diagnosis of MH. Nevertheless, we do not recommend withholding dantrolene or continuing MH triggers when MH is suspected.
Our study of 229 MH episodes with documented dantrolene doses found a wide range with an initial median dantrolene dose of 2.4 mg/kg and a total median dantrolene dose of 5.9 mg/kg. These doses approximate those recommended by the Malignant Hyperthermia Association of the United States (MHAUS). Our findings for initial dantrolene dose are similar to those of Kolb et al.21 in their first multicenter study of dantrolene use in humans from 1977 to 1979, in which 11 MH patients received a dose of 2.5 ± 0.5 mg/kg. The median total vials of dantrolene required were 17 (first quartile 7, third quartile 36). Our data support current MHAUS recommendations for initial dantrolene treatment doses. MHAUS recommendations for the availability of at least 36 dantrolene vials in anesthetizing locations# were predicated on an average patient body weight of 70 kg. However, because 25% of our cases required >36 vials of dantrolene and considering the current obesity epidemic, local demographics may suggest that >36 vials be stocked where feasible and reasonable.
Unfortunately, the AMRA report form did not request data on the techniques used to achieve active cooling or the expired or arterial carbon dioxide levels achieved after initiation of hyperventilation. Although MHAUS does not currently recommend the use of mannitol for MH events, 34% of our patients were treated with mannitol. We suggest that mannitol be stocked on MH carts and that its possible administration be added to the current MHAUS treatment protocol.** We were also able to show a correlation between the severity of abnormal findings and the use of other adjunctive treatments. This lends support to the remainder of the MHAUS treatment protocol, although we were unable to demonstrate that any of these adjunctive treatments decreased the MH complication rate.
Twenty-one patients with MH experienced disseminated intravascular coagulation or neurologic dysfunction at a temperature <41.6°C. Our data suggest that MH may decrease this potentially lethal human critical thermal maximum.22,23
Our earlier study found that disseminated intravascular coagulation was associated with a 50-fold increased likelihood of cardiac arrest (n = 8) and an 89-fold likelihood of death (n = 4).2 We now report higher maximum temperatures in 13 patients experiencing disseminated intravascular coagulation. Furthermore, we identify higher maximum temperatures as significantly increasing the likelihood of all complications. Because core temperature perturbations during the first 30 minutes are difficult to interpret, Sessler24 recommends temperature monitoring during general anesthetics that exceed 30 minutes in duration. We agree and suggest revision of current American Society of Anesthesiologists Standards†† and Canadian Anesthesiologists' Society Guidelines.‡‡ Although the actual dantrolene dose administered was not significant, a longer interval from first sign of MH to first dantrolene dose also increased the likelihood of MH complications. Accurate temperature monitoring can facilitate an early diagnosis of MH, and with prompt dantrolene administration may prevent complications and death.
The authors are grateful to Julien F. Biebuyck, MD, DPhil (Chairman, Department of Anesthesia [retired] and Senior Associate Dean for Academic Affairs [retired], Penn State College of Medicine, Hershey, Pennsylvania) for his extraordinary support of the establishment of the North American Malignant Hyperthermia Registry. They thank Michael C. Young, database manager of the North American Malignant Hyperthermia Registry of the Malignant Hyperthermia Association of the United States for his response to their data queries. They also thank the many anesthesiologists, intensive care physicians, surgeons, and nurse anesthetists who submitted AMRA reports to the Registry.
1.Gronert GA, Pessah IN, Muldoon SM, Tautz TJ. Malignant hyperthermia. In: Miller RD, ed. Miller's anesthesia. 6th ed. Philadelphia: Elsevier Churchill Livingstone, 2005:1169–90
2.Larach MG, Brandom BW, Allen GC, Gronert GA, Lehman EB. Cardiac arrests and deaths associated with malignant hyperthermia in North America from 1987 to 2006: a report from the North American Malignant Hyperthermia Registry of the Malignant Hyperthermia Association of the United States. Anesthesiology 2008;108:603–11
3.Britt BA, Kalow W. Malignant hyperthermia: a statistical review. Can Anaesth Soc J 1970;17:293–315
4.Larach MG, Localio AR, Allen GC, Denborough MA, Ellis FR, Gronert GA, Kaplan RF, Muldoon SM, Nelson TE, Ørding H, Rosenberg H, Waud BE, Wedel DJ. A clinical grading scale to predict malignant hyperthermia susceptibility. Anesthesiology 1994;80:771–9
5.Hochberg Y. A sharper Bonferroni procedure for multiple tests of significance. Biometrika 1988;75:800–2
6.Hosmer W, Lemeshow S. Applied logistic regression. 2nd ed. New York, NY: Wiley, 2000:147–56
7.Allen GC, Larach MG, Kunselman AR, The North American Malignant Hyperthermia Registry of MHAUS. The sensitivity and specificity of the caffeine-halothane contracture test: a report from the North American Malignant Hyperthermia Registry. Anesthesiology 1998:88;579–88
8.Ørding H, Brancadoro V, Cozzolino S, Ellis FR, Glauber V, Gonano EF, Halsall PJ, Hartung E, Heffron JJA, Heytens L, Kozak-Ribbens G, Kress H, Krivosic-Horber R, Lehmann-Horn F, Mortier W, Nivoche Y, Ranklev-Twetman E, Sigurdsson S, Snoeck M, Stieglitz P, Tegazzin V, Urwyler A, Wappler F. In vitro contracture test for diagnosis of malignant hyperthermia following the protocol of the European MH group: results of testing patients surviving fulminant MH and unrelated low-risk subjects. The European Malignant Hyperthermia Group. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand 1997;41:955–66
9.Bachand M, Vachon N, Boisvert M, Mayer FM, Chartrand D. Clinical reassessment of malignant hyperthermia in Abitibi-Témiscamingue. Can J Anaesth 1997;44:696–701
10.Burkman JM, Posner KL, Domino KB. Analysis of the clinical variables associated with recrudescence after malignant hyperthermia reactions. Anesthesiology 2007;106:901–6
11.Litman RS, Flood CD, Kaplan RF, Kim YL, Tobin JP. Postoperative malignant hyperthermia: an analysis of cases from the North American Malignant Hyperthermia Registry. Anesthesiology 2008;109:825–9
12.Forrest WH Jr. A collaborative clinical trial on trial. Anesthesiology 1982;56:249–50
13.Mauritz W, Sporn P, Steinbereithner K. Malignant hyperthermia in Austria. I. Epidemiology and clinical aspects. Anaesthesist 1986;35:639–50
14.Britt BA, Kwong FHF, Endrenyi L. The clinical and laboratory features of malignant hyperthermia management: a review. In: Henschel EO, ed. Malignant hyperthermia: current concepts. New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts, 1977:9–45
15.Ørding H. Incidence of malignant hyperthermia in Denmark. Anesth Analg 1985;64:700–4
16.Gregory GA, Eger EI, Munson ES. The relationship between age and halothane requirement in man. Anesthesiology 1969;30: 488–91
17.Mapelson WW. Effect of age on MAC in humans: a meta-analysis. Br J Anaesth 1996;76:179–85
18.Nickalls RWD, Mapelson WW. Age-related iso-MAC charts for isoflurane, sevoflurane and desflurane in man. Br J Anaesth 2003;91:170–4
19.Halsall PJ, Cain PA, Ellis FR. Retrospective analysis of anaesthetics received by patients before susceptibility to malignant hyperpyrexia was recognized. Br J Anaesth 1979;51: 949–54
20.Iaizzo PA, Kehler CH, Zink RS, Belani KG, Sessler DI. Thermal response in acute porcine malignant hyperthermia. Anesth Analg 1996;82:782–9
21.Kolb ME, Horne ML, Martz R. Dantrolene in human malignant hyperthermia—a multicenter study. Anesthesiology 1982;56: 254–62
22.Bynum GD, Pandolf KB, Schuette WH, Goldman RF, Lees DE, Whang-Peng J, Atkinson ER, Bull JM. Induced hyperthermia in sedated humans and the concept of critical thermal maximum. Am J Physiol 1978;235:R228–36
23.Bouchama A, Knochel JP. Heat stroke. N Engl J Med 2002; 346:1978–88
24.Sessler DI. Temperature monitoring and perioperative thermoregulation. Anesthesiology 2008;109:318–38
APPENDIX A: CASE HISTORIES FOR SELECTED MH EVENTS
Case 1: Liquid Crystal Temperature Trend Failure
This 25-year-old man with a muscular body build was anesthetized with isoflurane but no succinylcholine for an emergent plastic surgical/dental repair after a gun shot wound. He had a familial history positive for MH. He had never previously been anesthetized. Before his adverse reaction, he was monitored with both skin liquid crystal and esophageal temperature probes. While intubated and on controlled ventilation, he developed sinus tachycardia, tachypnea, hypercarbia (maximum expired CO2, 80.9 mm Hg), and inappropriately increased temperature. The anesthesia providers reported that the skin liquid crystal temperature probe did not accurately trend with the core temperature probe. A maximum temperature of 40.0°C was reported 105 minutes after induction. The order of appearance of the adverse signs was not reported, but the first sign occurred 20 minutes after induction. Results of an arterial blood gas drawn 100 minutes after induction while the patient was being hyperventilated with a fraction of inspired oxygen of 1.0 were a pH of 7.14, a Pco2 of 69 mm Hg, a Po2 of 256 mm Hg, a base excess of −8.1 mEq/L, and a bicarbonate level of 21.7 mEq/L. Peak potassium was 6.7 mEq/L, and peak creatine kinase was 16,570 U/L. He was treated with volatile anesthetic discontinuation 100 minutes after induction, dantrolene (0.9 mg/kg initial dose 130 minutes after induction and total dose of 8.9 mg/kg), active cooling, fluid loading, and bicarbonate. He experienced no MH-related complications.
Case 2: Liquid Crystal Temperature Trend Failure
This 34-year-old man with a muscular body build was anesthetized for an elective ENT procedure. He had never previously been anesthetized. He had a positive family history of MH of which he was unaware at the time of his anesthetic. His anesthetic included sevoflurane and succinylcholine. Before his adverse reaction, he was monitored with both a skin liquid crystal and an esophageal temperature probe. One hundred fifty-five minutes after anesthetic induction, when surgery had already been completed but the patient was still in the operating room, he developed generalized muscular rigidity and tachypnea, sinus tachycardia, sweating, hypercarbia (maximum expired CO2, 76 mm Hg), and rapidly increasing temperature. His maximum temperature was 39.1°C at 160 minutes after anesthetic induction. The anesthesiologists reported that the liquid crystal temperature probe did not accurately trend with his esophageal temperature probe. Results of an arterial blood gas drawn 171 minutes after induction while the patient was being hyperventilated with a fraction of inspired oxygen of 1.0 were a pH of 7.06, a Pco2 of 95.9 mm Hg, a Po2 of 269 mm Hg, a base excess of −6.7 mEq/L, and a bicarbonate level of 27.1 mEq/L. Peak potassium was 5.5 mEq/L, and peak creatine kinase was 52,700 U/L. He was treated with volatile anesthetic discontinuation, dantrolene (2.5 mg/kg initial dose 170 minutes after induction and total dose of 10.1 mg/kg), active cooling, fluid loading, furosemide, mannitol, glucose and insulin, and bicarbonate. He experienced no MH-related complications.
Case 3: No Dantrolene, Complication Reported
This 13-year-old boy was anesthetized with desflurane and succinylcholine for an elective ENT operation. He developed masseter spasm, dark-colored urine, generalized muscular rigidity, inappropriate sinus tachycardia, inappropriately increased temperature, tachypnea, and sweating. His peak creatine kinase was recorded as 37,911 U/L. He was not treated with dantrolene. Although hepatic dysfunction was reported as an MH complication, no further details on its severity or nature were noted.
Case 4: No Dantrolene, Complication Reported
This 35-year-old woman was anesthetized with propofol, sevoflurane, and succinylcholine for an elective plastic surgical procedure. She developed masseter spasm, sinus tachycardia, rapidly increasing temperature, and hypercarbia. Her peak creatine kinase was 365,970 U/L. Her sevoflurane was discontinued within 1 minute of its initiation, but she received no dantrolene. Her MH complication was reported as other: bilateral lower extremity muscle soreness. No renal dysfunction was reported.
Case 5: Continued Volatile Anesthetic, Survivor with Rhabdomyolosis
This MH survivor was a 6-year-old boy undergoing an elective ENT procedure who had a 65-minute anesthetic that included halothane and succinylcholine. He developed masseter spasm, inappropriate hypercarbia (maximum expired CO2, 51 mm Hg), and inappropriate sinus tachycardia. Volatile anesthetics were continued. Five hours and 10 minutes after the anesthetic was finished, inappropriate rapidly increasing temperature with a peak temperature of 40°C developed and dantrolene was administered. His peak creatine kinase was 33,000 U/L. He was noted to have significant muscle weakness after his event.
Case 6: Continued Volatile Anesthetic, No Dantrolene, Survivor with Rhabdomyolysis
This MH survivor was a 9-year-old boy undergoing an elective ENT procedure who had a 50-minute anesthetic that began with halothane and succinylcholine. Five minutes after anesthetic induction, he developed masseter spasm. The halothane was discontinued, and isoflurane was begun. It is not clear when he developed inappropriate tachypnea, dark-colored urine, and a peak creatine kinase of 45,300 U/L. The isoflurane was continued, and he was not treated with dantrolene. No information exists as to whether this child had any MH-related complications such as acute renal failure.
Case 7: Second Dose of Succinylcholine, Survivor with Severe Myalgia
A 30-year-old woman for an emergency Caesarean delivery was given a second dose of succinylcholine after developing masseter muscle rigidity. She then developed inappropriate tachypnea, inappropriate hypercarbia, generalized muscular rigidity, and dark-colored urine with a peak creatine kinase of 3,860 U/L. She was given 2 mg/kg dantrolene and survived, but she complained of severe myalgia. Fetal outcome was not reported.
APPENDIX B: CORRELATION BETWEEN TREATMENT FREQUENCY AND SEVERITY OF ABNORMAL FINDINGS DURING MH EVENTS
Hyperventilation was used when end-tidal Pco2 was higher (median 68.5, first quartile 59.0, third quartile 80.0 mm Hg with hyperventilation vs median 54.5, first quartile 45.0, third quartile 66.0 mm Hg without hyperventilation) (P < 0.0001).
Active cooling was associated with a higher maximum temperature of 39.2°C (first quartile 38.5°C, third quartile 40.2°C) vs 37.7°C without cooling (first quartile 36.7°C, third quartile 38.9°C) (P < 0.0001).
Furosemide, mannitol, and/or glucose and insulin adminstration were associated with higher maximum potassium (median 5.4, first quartile 4.6, third quartile 6.2 mEq/L with drug vs median 4.7, first quartile 4.3, third quartile 5.2 mEq/L without drug treatment) (P < 0.0001).
Bicarbonate use was associated with lower arterial pH (median 7.19, first quartile 7.07, third quartile 7.25 with bicarbonate vs 7.25, first quartile 7.20, third quartile 7.33 without bicarbonate therapy) (P < 0.0001) and a more negative base excess (median −6.9, first quartile −2.5, third quartile −9.0 with bicarbonate vs −3.5, first quartile −1.4, third quartile −6.0 without bicarbonate) (P < 0.0001). Four patients received bicarbonate and no dantrolene. The median year for bicarbonate administration was 1997 (first quartile 1994 and third quartile 2000 with a range of 1988–2006) and was later than the median year of 1996 for those not receiving bicarbonate (first quartile 1992 and third quartile 2000 with a range of 1987–2006) (P = 0.020).
*Internet access to the Registry Web site may be found at www.mhreg.org.
†Samples of one of the earliest (1.2) and one of the latest (9.0) versions used to report adverse anesthetic events for this study may be found in the supplementary material posted on the Anesthesia & Analgesia Web site (see Supplementary Digital Content 1, http://links.lww.com/AA/A43, Supplementary Digital Content 2, http://links.lww.com/AA/A44. To report a new case, clinicians may obtain a current AMRA report form (version 9.3) from The North American Malignant Hyperthermia Registry Web site at www.mhreg.org (downloads).
‡The MH clinical grading scale may be found in the supplementary material posted on the Anesthesia & Analgesia Web site (Supplementary Digital Content 3, http://links.lww.com/AA/A45).
§Comments include: “family didn't think it was relevant to bring it up (second cousin's death from MH thought to be inherited through the nonrelated side of the family),” “reported after surgery (first cousin's similar anesthetic event in Japan),” “discovered only after the event,” “not known preop” (MH history in a daughter, MH history in a nephew). In one case, the family MH history was “questionable, thought unlikely at time of preop.”
∥In 3 lean, nonorthopedic pediatric or adolescent patients without infection, a maximum temperature >38.8°C (39.2°C, 39.7°C, and 41.1°C) was observed 12, 10, and 25 minutes, respectively, after anesthetic induction. In 2 nonobese patients, inappropriately elevated or rapidly increasing temperature was the first sign <30 minutes after induction.
¶MHAUS has sample letters that may be used by individuals to notify their family members of their possible MH susceptibility. See www.mhaus.org. When consent has been given, a summary of a registered patient's anesthetic history may be obtained by contacting the MH Registry by phone at 888-274-7899 or by e-mail to Dr. Brandom (BrandomBW@anes.upmc.edu).
#Available at: www.mhaus.org (medical professionals; general FAQs). Accessed December 12, 2008.
**Available at: www.mhaus.org (medical professionals; MH crisis management; MH Protocol Poster). Accessed April 21, 2009.
††Available at: www.asahq.org/publicationsAndServices/standards/02.pdf. Accessed December 12, 2008.
‡‡Available at: www.cas.ca/members/sign_in/guidelines/practice_of_anesthesia/default.asp?load=patient_monitoring. Accessed December 12, 2008.