The next big break we got was that the polio foundation decided to equip all their polio centers with our analyzer, and that was quite successful. In fact, their cure rate doubled after they started. What they had been doing with these Drinker-type, what the press called, “Iron Lungs” is adjusting them for normal tidal volumes for their weight. When they’re paralyzed, their metabolism is way down, so they were blowing all of these patients into alkalosis. When they got the analyzer, they could control the carbon dioxide and keep it to normal levels.s Their success rate with patients and time in the Iron Lungs dropped in half and the death rate dropped in half. So that was a very successful program.19
In 1955, the financial backers of the company, Albert Austin and Dick Becker agreed to sell Liston-Becker Company to Beckman Instruments. The Liston-Becker Model 16 was renamed the LB-1 (Fig. 9).
It is interesting to note that the LB-1 was originally intended for use in operating rooms where ether and cyclopropane were commonly used anesthetics. As a safety precaution, it also included a pressure actuated switch that disabled power to the pick-up unit if the pressure decreased precipitously. The LB-1 was also sold with a separate sample pump, which was intended to permit its use outside the operating room.t Its successor, the LB-2 (and LB-3u), included technological improvements that replaced the vacuum tubes with solid-state circuitry.
Liston and his friend Miles Lowell of Edwards, having recently sold his company to American Hospital Supply [in 1966], were interested in pursuing other ventures and formed Liston-Edwards Corporation with the purpose of providing an IR analyzer to the pollution monitoring field. In the mid 1970s, Liston-Edwards decided to make a medical gas analyzer, marketing OEM versions of a CO2 analyzer and anesthetic agent analyzer. In 1980, Liston-Edwards had one flagship customer, Electronics for Medicine,v and provided an early sidestream CO2 module for a cardiac monitor. Liston Scientific continued until recently with Max at the helm to make gas monitoring devices for environmental applications.w
The story of the development of the Hewlett-Packard’s (HP) mainstream CO2 gas sensor is part of the overall story of HP’s entrance into medical devices. It is also a story of adapting technology developed for automotive applications to medical applications. This story is presented as told by both of its project managers (Jacob Wong), who led its development at HP Laboratories (Palo Alto, CA) and brought it to the newly established medical division in Waltham, and (Rodney Solomon) who took the product from prototype to a manufacturable product.
Jacob Wong started working in about 1967 at HP Labs, which was established in 1966 as the company’s central research facility. At HP Labs’ inception, its primary areas of research included solid-state physics, physical electronics, electronics, and medical and chemical electronics instruments. In the early 1970s, there was a greater recognition of the problem of air pollution from automobiles and HP Labs received a large contract from General Motors to design an exhaust gas analyzer to measure carbon monoxide, CO2, methane, hydrocarbons, and nitric oxide. When the device was demonstrated, the sensor worked well but only if it was cooled with liquid nitrogen which turned out to be a big problem.
We were saved by one of the lawyers at HP-he looked through the contract and observed that the contract never said it had to operate at ambient temperature-somebody forgot to specify that—so if it operated at liquid nitrogen temperatures we would still be OK—so obviously General Motors was not very happy—nobody was very happy—but the fact of the matter is that we went away and spent their money and learned a lot. It was right after that we were asked by Mr. Hewlett since we spent all this money is there anything we can use from that technology (Jacob Wong, 2005).
From the remnants of an automotive program, the idea of a medical CO2 sensor was born. The group at HP Labs had the theoretical understanding of IR absorption of all the gases and Jacob Wong was asked to spearhead a program to develop a medical CO2 sensor. When the development of the medical CO2 sensor started, HP had already developed its well-known eight wavelength ear oximeter.35
HP had recently entered the medical field with the purchase in 1961 of Sanborn Company, Waltham, Massachusetts. Bill Hewlett’s vision for Sanborn was to be the foundation of the HP medical division. Sanborn had an electrocardiograph and HP was going to refine the technology. The medical division idea was solidified with Lew Plattx as the engineering manager and Dean Morton y as the divisional manager. It was the late 1960s and 70s and HP took risks thus paving the way for monitoring devices that are now considered commonplace.
The technology was transferred to HP Medical Products Division in 1972. HP reduced the size of the sensor significantly using interference filters and IR detectors which were not available when the first capnometers for clinical use were developed. Because the device was to be placed near the patient’s airway, HP had to devise a special adapter to interface with the airway. This airway adapter, which contains the sample chamber (Fig. 10), consisted of a hollow aluminum casting with sapphire windows. The sensor, which mated with the airway adapter, comprised an IR source (heated broadband black body radiator) and a detector assembly consisting of a rotating filter wheel which included hermetically sealed gas cells serving as bandpass filters and a lead-selenide detector. The IR source,36 the only portion of the device that was patented, is basically a thin film heater.37
The concentration of CO2 within the sample chamber is determined by measuring the intensity of the transmitted radiation reaching the IR detector when each of the filters on the wheel is in alignment with the source and detector. This measurement technique, known as optical chopping,z is a mechanical method of periodically interrupting a light beam which is effective for eliminating electronic ”drift“ in the detector and the system electronics. The filter wheel driven by a motor drive rotates at sufficiently high angular velocity permitting 40 measurements per second through each filter wheel element. The filter wheel includes three separate elements through which IR radiation passes of which one is an opening in the filter wheel and the other two are sealed gas cells, a reference gas sample containing a known concentration of CO2 and a cell with only nitrogen (Fig. 10).
The device was connected via a cable to one of the earliest microprocessor-based instruments. Motorola had just introduced the 6800 microprocessor (1975) and HP was given the opportunity to use this microprocessor. Jacob notes
We were all fighting for it-Waltham medical division fought for it and we won that right because of Lew Platt. We got the 2nd prototype system from Motorola and it was used to develop the capnometer (Jacob Wong, 2005).
They designed the 6800 microprocessor into the 47210A Capnometer. The first microprocessor system as a development system was quite clumsy at the time and used five separate boards: I/O board, RAM/ROM boards, central processing unit and power supply boards.
Jacob left HP in 1978 and returned to the West Coast to work at Hughes Aircraft’s Santa Barbara Research Center. Rod Solomon then served as project manager for the capnometer. Rod notes that they spent a few years tuning the basic concept, but that the foundation laid by HP labs during Jacob’s tenure was substantial. The primary focus of the last two years of the development cycle was to reduce sources of error and variability in the design so it could be more easily manufactured. The problems worked on included cell filling, which was required so they could get an exact filter for CO2 rather than using a narrow band optical filter. Most current NDIR CO2 sensor designs use bandpass, lowpass and/or high pass optical filters of the type known as interference filters.aa
Other problems included getting the wheel to rotate evenly in order to remove output signal jitter, temperature control and overall robustness of the sensor, particularly the filter wheel, in the clinical environment. The filter wheel being dropped was considered primarily a manufacturing cost issue. Figure 6 from the HP Journal paper37 showed two of the four rubber bumpers placed in corners of transducer housing to act as shock absorbers. It was noted that this alludes to what Dr. Smalhout39,40 stated ”gravity is twice as strong in the hospital than anywhere else and implored us to do the best we could to make it rugged.”
The HP Journal article37 on this device provides an extraordinary amount of disclosure on processes and design of a medical device. Rodney notes that “we were encouraged to write articles for the journal-it’s hard to believe in today’s environment this would never happen. This article is basically a treatise on how to build a competitive device.”
This device38 remains one of the most successful of its type with perhaps 50,000 of these transducers manufactured and sold. It served as the “gold standard” for medical CO2 sensors for more than a decade since its introduction in the early 1980s.
The story of the development of the Siemens-Elema AB mainstream CO2 sensor41–43 (Fig. 11) and its associated Model 930 CO2 analyzer, the first commercial volumetric capnograph, is presented as told by Rolf Castor, a scientist who was closely tied to the project (Castor Rolf, 2004/5). In the early 1970s, Rolf Castor started working in the medical industry, after receiving an MSc in applied Physics (Lund University) and a short stint at Ericsson, he joined the Elema-Schönander company, famous for the Mingograph electrocardiogram inkjet recorder and the implantable pacemaker. He worked in a group of four headed by Sven-Gunnar Olsson, the father of the Servoventilator.44 Olsson asked Rolf if he believed they could make a small, fast CO2 analyzer since, to Mr. Olsson, nothing was impossible. With no company library at his disposal, he consulted available IR textbooks of the day45–48 at the local university. At this early stage in the product development, Rolf notes there was an “old” guy, Gabriel Tchang, in the company sitting nearby him who was developing a colorimeter for blood hemoglobin.49 Although this product was considered outside of the Elema business area, he had a contract with the company and Rolf was asked if Gabriel could be of some help. So, Mr. Gabriel Tchang entered the scene with valuable knowledge in analyzing instruments and a long experience in analog electronics.
Rolf notes that no acceptable off-the-shelf motors were available at that time and, as small size was very important, they developed a kind of “tuning fork” chopperbb which resulted in an inconvenient long chopper design which determined the length of the housing (Fig. 11). The first transducer prototype and an electronic box with an analog meter was developed and powered from the Servoventilator. This hand built prototype was used clinically for some time and is now in the museum at Lund University.
The device, intended for use with the 900 Servoventilator (SV) series of ventilators, assumed that inhaled air had a low and stable CO2 level that could be used for reference and that timing and respiratory phase information was known from the “mother” SV900 device. The reference signal (i.e., considered a fixed voltage) and the continuous signal were used to create a linear signal and the output was available both as a “continuous signal as well as the peak and end expiratory values.”50 cc The result was that CO2 concentration could be displayed as a function of time as well as the instantaneous peak and end expiratory values. The device was marketed as the “CA 130”dd but was never a commercial success.
Sven-Gunnar, working with Prof. Bjorn Jonsson and Dr. Lars Nordstrom at the Lund University hospital, continued further system development which resulted in the Model 930 module. This module was integrated with the SV series of ventilators and reported CO2 minute elimination, the effective and ineffective tidal volumes, and effective ventilation and tidal elimination. Rolf notes that this project was an interesting task for the analog engineer given that “everything had to be solved with the now mature opamp technology,” because microprocessors were not yet available.
In about 1976, Siemens-Elema began shipping CA 930 units for sale. With the analog recorder outputs provided from the rear of the unit and the values on the panel display, Rolf notes it was considered an ideal tool for researchers. Together with the SV, the CA 930 created a methodological platform for research and an everyday tool for the clinician that was widely used in Europe. Although few reached the United States’ “everyday clinic,” researchers throughout the world found a versatile tool.
Cascadia Technology Corporation/ Respironics-Novametrix, LLC
The story of the development of the Respironics-Novametrix mainstream CO2 sensor is presented as told by Les Mace and Dan Knodle who (along with two others) co-founded Cascadia Technology Corporation which developed the original Capnostat mainstream CO2 sensor. This author (and many others) have continued the development at Novametrix, Inc (and now Respironics-Novametrix, LLC) since joining the company in 1994.
In the late 1970s Les was at Physio-Control (Redmond, WA) and was invited to join a startup in the Seattle area by Ralph Astengo formerly the founder of ATL. Les notes that
We stumbled across a technology for respiratory monitoring for sleep apnea based on acoustic style technology that did not work well but we were very interested in the market and began looking for the most direct method to measure breathing and what we came up with was an inexpensive way to measure exhaled CO2 (Les Mace, 2005).
That was the beginning of Trimed, which was organized in 1981 for the “development, manufacture, and marketing of monitoring instruments for the medical field.” At Trimed they developed a qualitative CO2 detector based on non-dispersive IR (NDIR) technology consisting of a simple incandescent light bulb as a source, a lead selinide (PbSe) detector, and CO2 bandpass filter. The sensor was non-ratiometric, not chopped and had a tendency to drift. Because the primary interest was in the measurement of respiration rate, quantitative measurements were not important and it was introduced in an infant respiration monitor.ee A quantitative sidestream analyzer with a rotating chopper wheel and the associated disposables were also developed and cleared for marketing. This included the Model 126 sample line,ff with extended life, using for the first time NAFION® in a braided shield so it could be easily manipulated.gg After 3 years of funding their new start up, Trimed’s parent company, Integrated Circuits Inc., a hybrid circuit manufacturer (including thermal print heads), pulled the plug and gave the division 4 months to find a buyer.51,52 Trimed’s assets were finally sold to a Midwest-based company, Biochem International (now known as BCI). The founders of TriMed found themselves unemployed, but they still believed in the technology and subsequently put together a team at a new company called Cascadia Technology Corporation in order to build a quantitative system that was a true ratiometric, chopped and stable NDIR system. Further research led to the development of the pulsed thermal broadband IR source still being used today in Respironics-Novametrix capnometers.
In 1985, Cascadia Technology Corp was founded by Larry Labuda as VP of Production, Dan Knodle as VP of Research, Bob Lamson as Chief Executive Officer and Les Mace as Chief Operations Officer. Les notes he was the first and only full-time employee for about a year. Once Cascadia Technology was started, the founders realized that they needed to build an IR source with sufficient IR energy and very low thermal mass that could also be pulsed on/off at rates of up to 100 Hz. This quickly led them to the use of low thermal mass, thick film technology similar to that found in thermal print heads.
The pulsed thermal IR source technology was a result of some early work the founders did using thick film technology while at ICI. Trimed engineers had originally attempted to develop a stable and robust IR emitter (to replace the incandescent light bulb), but quickly realized this was not an easy task. Les notes:
There was a lot of chemistry going on-we had to pulse this thing in a bipolar fashion so that we did not get migration of the ionic components of the chemistry-we worked heavily with the thick film manufacturer to optimize the ink chemistry for this particular application. It was not optimal for a normal thick film application where you wanted long term thermal stability. We were overstressing this thing-heating it up to 600°C−700°C-which was much beyond what most people said we could do (Les Mace, 2005).
A number of sources and ideas have appeared since this device was developed, all with their pros and cons, but the pulsed thermal source turned out to be one of the optimum devices. It could be made very inexpensively, is very robust and could be pulsed in a bi-or unipolar fashion at relatively low power levels with sufficient IR output.53 As did other manufacturers of mainstream devices, Cascadia’s founders spent the early days of Cascadia (and later as employees of Novametrix) refining the IR source to make it easier to manufacture, more shock insensitive and with higher optical output. Les notes:
We initially thought to develop a sidestream CO2 sensor and someone said if you could develop a low power source without any mechanical moving parts-why aren’t you doing mainstream-the more I looked at mainstream the more I found this was a niche that needed a better solution and which had considerable application advantages over sidestream (Les Mace, 2005).
Other mainstream CO2 sensor solutions at the time included Siemens-Elema (Solna, Sweden), which used a mechanical tuning fork chopper, and HP (Waltham, MA), which used a rotating wheel. Each of these devices had their own respective problems, including accuracy and durability. While at Trimed, the founders looked very closely at the HP Journal article (describing their mainstream sensor) and subsequently met Jacob Wong (see HP section); this led them to thinking there was an opportunity for improving the mainstream application. Les notes:
The HP sensor, although very good, did have an Achilles heel-it was subject to damage and breakage if you dropped it. Our goal was to develop a solid state sensor that was “bullet proof,” and we were eventually successful at accomplishing this task. This gave us a huge market advantage over other fragile sensors like HP (Les Mace, 2005).
When Les was at Trimed he met clinicians from St. Joseph’s Hospital in Bellingham WA, Phil Nuzzo and Ivan Bustamante. Phil, a licensed respiratory care practitioner, had previous experience as a user of Liston-Becker, Beckman and other devices and had previously written papers on capnography.54,55 Phil notes that his interest in capnography started in the early 1970s during his tenure at University of Southern California County hospital with the development of a neonatal sidestream capnometer. Working with Cavitron (Santa Ana, CA), a sidestream bench with an adjustable sampling rate between 0 cc/min to 300 cc/min was developed. Humidity proved to be a problem since the sampling system was prone to water accumulation, so a method of dehumidication was sought. They bought unsheathed tubes of a fragile water permeable membrane (NAFION) from Dupont which they wrapped in a three foot coil and this proved to be effective. Given the uniqueness and scarcity of the device, the capnograph was used primarily in a spot-checking manner and for applications such as ventilator management and asthma screening. Great care had to be taken with using the devices available. For example, due to the long warm-up time and vibration sensitivity of the Beckman LB-1 head, the head was placed on a piece of foam for increased stability, and on a large and portable cart, with calibration gases and large batteries to keep power always applied. Phil moved north to Washington state in 1979. A few years later after the founders started Cascadia, Phil, then a product manager at Novametrix, called Les to see what progress was being made on their CO2 sensor (Fig. 12). As Les recounts:
Mike Polson, Novametrix’s director of engineering at the time, paid us a visit and peaked under our skirts. Two weeks later Bill Lacourciere, president of Novametrix, came out and the rest is history. It only took 15 years . . . a lot of Edisonian experimentation, it still has a lot of promise . . . and remains very well suited for medical capnography (Les Mace, 2005).
In 1987, Cascadia licensed their technology to Novametrix Medical Systems and in 1989 they were purchased by Novametrix (now Respironics-Novametrix, LLC). A number of the staff remained on in Redmond, WA as a sensor development group for Novametrix until the facility was eventually closed in 2001.
Additional innovations to the sensor included increased performance and accuracy under conditions of optical window contamination by the use of a coaxial optical design56 (Fig. 13). The next generation Capnostat mainstream CO2 sensor continues today with the introduction of the Capnostat 5 mainstream CO2 sensor, a sensor that leverages on the latest developments in micro-electronics to create a full functional capnometer within the sensor housing.
The stories of two additional companies are of interest both from the technological perspective as well the inter-relationships between them and the companies previously highlighted.
Square One,hh a design firm founded in late 1987 by Jim Braig and Dan Goldberger, developed a mainstream device smaller than the HP device as they were not happy with the capabilities of existing solid state devices and also wanted to develop sources with longer IR wavelengths to be able identify and quantify anesthetics. Jim Braig, a veteran in the gas analysis business, also spent some time before this venture working with Max Liston57 and also for Nellcor. Jim went to work at Nellcor for the sole purpose of building their second generation technology, the N-1000 multi-gas monitor.58 Jim notes “It gave Nellcor the second technology to let it go public-they were told at the time that oximetry wasn’t enough-it got them public and their second technology.” Square One developed a mainstream solid state non-modulated technology for Critikon59 that was not manufactured.
Pryon’s development of a mainstream device was described by Dan Knodle. Pryonii had developed a mainstream device based upon the HP capnometer that used a chopper wheel on the detector with sealed cells. They reduced the size of the chopper wheel in an effort to make it less sensitive to shock. However, they were still using an incandescent lamp as a source. If the device was dropped, the filament would move and the device would be out of calibration. In the meantime, Dan was pursuing an electrochemical sensor with his firm Evergreen Sensor Technology Corporation. Unfortunately, this project ran out of funds so they started looking for consulting work. About the same time, a company that they had previously visited, Pryon, called and asked if Evergreen Sensor Technology Corporation would be interested in working with them. Pryon sought to develop a solid state source to replace the incandescent lamp. Dan notes that to make a thick film resistor work under the conditions they had was an extreme challenge given that the power supply had a “wide power distribution.” Dan Knodle and Tom Clary developed the source with sufficient IR light output at the lowest current input level, yet still able to plug into the highest power opportunity and still work. They also built the manufacturing facility that could make the source60 for Pryon (later sold to Pryon). In 1994, Pryon began manufacturing the SC-300 CO2 Monitor, a stand-alone instrument that incorporates both mainstream and sidestream CO2 monitoring modalities. Pryon designed and manufactured a stand-alone instrument, the N-6000 UltraCap, for Nellcor Puritan Bennett incorporating Nellcor Puritan Bennett’s oximetry and Pryon’s mainstream CO2 monitoring capability.61
The reader should also be aware of the contributions of other companies with a long history in gas measurement including Andros which introduced in 1994 the Model 4210 On-Airway Carbon Dioxide sensor,62 Draeger (Germany) with the on-airway Capnolog D sensor,63 Nihon Kohden (Japan) which has offered both qualitative and quantitative mainstream devices,64 Instrumentarium (Finland),65 and others which have not published widely or in the English language. Companies in the former Soviet Union manufactured a number of analyzers for continuous CO2 monitoring in humans including the GUF-2 photoelectric gas analyzer, GUKh-2 chemical gas analyzer and GUM series of IR analyzers.66 The GUM-2 and GUM-3 CO2 analyzers were manufactured by the Smolensk Measuring Instrument Plant and designed by “Medfizpribor” Special Technical Design Office (SKTB). In addition, the G-1 gasograph was provided so that CO2 and volume data could be combined.
Modern IR Devices
Both mainstream (nondiverting) and sidestream (diverting) gas measurement technologies have found clinical applications for monitoring both intubated and nonintubated subjects. The vast majority of instruments (both mainstream and sidestream) in clinical use rely on IR-based technologies. However, in the past, other sidestream technologies have been used and include mass spectrometry, photoacoustic and Raman spectroscopy. Of these, only mass spectrometers found relatively wide clinical use. The magnetic sector with fixed detectors and the quadrupole mass spectrometers have been the predominant types. These instruments have been used either as a dedicated instrument providing continuous monitoring of single patients or as a shared instrument (multiplexed) providing discontinuous monitoring of several patients in sequence. In particular, the most well-known manufacturer of such devices for clinical use was Perkin-Elmer.
Today, IR-based capnometers are finding their way into a wide range of platforms including multiparameter monitors used throughout the hospital, critical care and transport ventilators, anesthesia machines and defibrillators with monitoring capabilities. They may be found integrated into bedside units, and hand-held units often in conjunction with pulse oximetry as well as stand-alone units. A greater number of clinical organizations, including those in anesthesia, critical care, respiratory care and emergency medicine, are either mandating or strongly recommending the use of capnography. Volumetric capnography (the combination of capnography and volume) is also finding greater application both in ventilated and nonventilated patients.
Currently marketed mainstream capnometers are based upon either solid-state electronically pulsed sources and solid-state detectors (e.g., Respironics, Draeger, Nihon Kohden) or filter-wheels with solid-state detectors (Phase-In). Most sidestream devices use solid-state sources which are either electronic pulsed or mechanically chopped and solid-state detectors, with the exception of a hermetically sealed gas source excited by a high voltage radio frequency electromagnetic field (Oridion) and dispersive IR (multi-gas) spectrometer (LumaSense Technologies, formerly Andros). Many of the anesthesia machines use multi-gas benches (either of their own design or from an OEM).
The history of IR CO2 gas measurement technology has been presented from the viewpoint of a number of the original developers (Table 1). It has more than a century of development, but measuring CO2 in the respiratory gas can now be accomplished using cost-effective, reliable devices. This technology has become an integral part of patient care worldwide and is fundamental to patient safety. Future technological improvements in gas measurements promise greater sensor robustness, and the ability to monitor multiple gases and extract information from these measurements to support both diagnosis and therapy.
The contributions to this article of following people who have served in various key roles in the development of this technology are acknowledged: Jim Braig of Optiscan (formerly of Square One); Rolf Castor (retired) formerly of Siemens-Elema; Dan Knodle (formerly of Cascadia Technology Corporation and Evergreen Sensor Technology Corporation); Max Liston (retired) of Liston Scientific (formerly of Liston-Becker and Beckman Instruments); Les Mace (retired) formerly of Novametrix Medical Systems; Phil Nuzzo of Respironics, Inc., Rodney Solomon of Philips Medical; and Jacob Y. Wong, PhD, of Airware, Inc. (formerly of Hewlett-Packard).
This article is dedicated to the memory of Allen Norton, PhD, who passed away in the Fall of 2004. I have been proud to know Allen, a former colleague of mine at Beckman Instruments, Inc. and Sensormedics, Inc. for nearly the past 25 yr and to call him my friend.
1. Tyndall J. On radiation. The “Rede” lecture delivered in the Senate-House before the University of Cambridge on Tuesday, May 16, 1865. London: Longman, Green, Longman, Roberts & Green. 62 p
2. Tyndall J. Fragments of science for unscientific people - a series of detached essays, lectures and reviews. New York: D. Appleton and Company, 1874
3. Tyndall J. On the transmission of heat of different qualities through gases of different kinds. Proc R Inst G B 1859;3:155–8
4. Tyndall J. Heat-a mode of motion. 6th ed. New York: D. Appleton and Company, 1890
5. Burchfield JA. John Tyndall-a biographical sketch. In John Tyndall, essays on a natural philosopher. Dublin, Ireland: Royal Dublin Society, 1981
6. Eklund J. The incompleat chymist: being an essay on the eighteenth-century chemist in his laboratory, with a dictionary of obsolete chemical terms of the period. Smithsonian studies in history and technology, number 33. Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institute Press, 1975
7. Haldane JS. Methods of air analysis. London: Griffin, 1912
8. Haldane JS, Priestley JG. Respiration. 2nd ed. London: Oxford, 1935
9. Daynes HA. Gas analysis by measurement of thermal conductivity. Cambridge, UK: University Press, 1933
10. Pfund AH. Apparatus for detecting and measuring heteroatomic gases. US Patent 2,212,2111. August 20, 1940
11. Pfund AH, Gemmill CL. An infrared absorption method for the quantitative analysis of respiratory and other gases. Bull Johns Hopkins Hosp 1940;67:61–5
12. Bell AG. Upon the production of sound by radiant energy. Am J Sci 1880;20:305–24
13. Luft KF, Schaefer W, Wiegleb G. 50 Jahre NDIR-Gasanalyse (50 years NDIR gas analysis). Tm Technisches Messen 1993;60:363–71
14. Luft K. Über eine neue Methode der registrierenden Gasanalyse mit Hilfe der Absorption ultraroter Strahlen ohne spektrale Zerlegung. Ztschrf Techn Phys 1943;24:97–104
15. Lehrer E, Luft K. Verfahren zur Bestimmung von Bestandteilen in Stoffgemischen mittels Strahlungsabsorption. Patentschrift (Process for determining the components of mixtures through radiation absorption) Nr. 730,478. Ausgegeben am 14 January 1943
16. Veingerov ML. Eine Methode der Gasanalyse beruhend auf dem optisch-akustischen Tyndall-Röntgeneffekt. Dokl Akad Nauk SSSR 1938;19:687–8
17. Blackburn JP, Williams TR. Evaluation of the Datex CD-101 and Godart Capnograph Mark II infra-red carbon dioxide analysers. Br J Anaesth 1980;52:551–5
18. Cormack R, Powell JN. Improving the performance of the infra-red carbon dioxide meter. Br J Anaesth 1972;44:131–41
19. Max D. Liston, interviews by David C. Brock and Gerald E. Gallwas at Irvine, California and Fullerton, California, 19 February 2002 and 22 January 2003 Philadelphia: Chemical Heritage Foundation, Oral History Transcript #0252
20. Sands RP, Bacon DR. An inventive mind: the career of James O. Elam, M.D. (1918-1995). Anesthesiology 1998;88:1107–12
21. Elam JO. Channeling and over packing in carbon dioxide absorbers. Anesthesiology 1958;19:403–4
22. Stow RW. An infrared analyzer for carbon dioxide and its application to certain problems in respiratory physiology. Ph.D.Thesis. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota, 1952
23. Stow RW. A systematic error in infrared analysis for carbon dioxide in respiratory gas analysis. Fed Proc 1952;11:155
24. Elam JA, Brown EL, Ten Pas RH. Carbon dioxide homeostasis during anesthesia. I. Instrumentation. Anesthesiology 1955;16:876–85
25. Elam JA, Brown EL. Carbon dioxide homeostasis during anesthesia. II. Total sampling for determination of dead space, alveolar ventilation, and carbon dioxide output. Anesthesiology 1955;16:886–902
26. Elam JA, Brown EL. Carbon dioxide homeostasis during anesthesia. III. Ventilation and carbon dioxide elimination. Anesthesiology 1956;17:116–28
27. Elam JA, Brown EL. Carbon dioxide homeostasis during anesthesia. IV. An evaluation of the partial rebreathing system. Anesthesiology 1956;17:129–34
28. Stephen CR, Slater HM. Nonresisting, nonrebreathing valve. Anesthesiology 1948;9:550
29. Siebecker KL, Mendenhall JT, Emanuel DA. Carbon dioxide in anesthetic atmospheres as measured by the Liston-Becker (infra-red absorption) gas analyzer. J Thorac Surg 1954;27:468–76
30. Crane MG, Affeldt JE, Austin E, Bower AG. Alveolar carbon dioxide levels in acute poliomyelitis. J Appl Physiol 1956;9:11–8
31. Drinker F, Shaw LA. An apparatus for the prolonged administration of artificial ventilation. J Clin Invest 1929;7:229–47
32. Eckenhoff JE, Helrich M, Hege MJ. A method for studying respiratory functions in awake or anesthetized patients. Anesthesiology 1956;17:66–72
33. Affeldt JE, Collier CR, Crane MG, Farr AF. Ventilatory aspects of poliomyelitis. Curr Res Anesth Analg 1955;34:41–53
34. Collier CR, Affeldt, JE, Farr AF. Continuous rapid infrared CO2
analysis; fractional sampling and accuracy in determining alveolar CO2
. J Lab Clin Med 1955;45:526–39
35. Hayes TJ, Merrick EB. Continuous, non-invasive measurements of blood oxygen levels. Hewlett Packard J 1976;28:2–10
36. Bridgham JA. Infrared Radiation Source. US Patent 3,875,413. Issued April 1, 1975
37. Solomon RJ. A reliable, accurate CO2
analyzer for medical use. Hewlett Packard J 1981;32:3–21
38. Kinsella SM. Assessment of the Hewlett-Packard HP47210A capnometer. Br J Anaesth 1985;57:919–23
39. Smallhout B. Capnografie. Thesis, University of Utrecht, The Netherlands: A. Oosthoek Publ. Co., 1967
40. Smalhout B, Kalenda Z. An Atlas of Capnography. 2nd ed. The Netherlands: Kerckebosche Zeist, 1981:163p
Analyzer 930-operating manual. 2nd ed. Solna, Sweden: Siemens-Elema AB Ventilator Division, S-17195, 1981
42. Fletcher R, Werner O, Nordstrom L, Jonson B. Sources of error and their correction in the measurement of carbon dioxide elimination using the Siemens-Elema CO2
Analyzer. Br J Anaesth 1983;55:177–85
43. Olsson SG, Fletcher R, Jonson B, Nordstom L, Prakash O. Clinical studies of gas exchange during ventilatory support-a method using the Siemens-Elema CO2
analyzer. Br J Anaesth 1980;52:491–9
44. Ingelstedt S, Jonson B, Nordstrom L, Olsson SG. A servo-controlled ventilator measuring expired minute volume, airway flow and pressure. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand Suppl 1972;47:7–27
45. Herzberg G. Atomic Spectra and Atomic Structure. 2nd ed. New York: Dover Publications, 1944
46. Kruse PW. Elements of infrared technology. New York: John Wiley & Sons Inc, 1962
47. Wolfe William F. The Infrared Handbook. Michigan: Environmental Research Institute of Michigan for the Office of Naval Research Dept. of Navy, 1978
48. Burch DE, Gryvnak DA, Williams D. Total absorptance of carbon dioxide in the infrared. Appl Opt 1962;1:759–65
49. Tchang, Gabriel. Photometer for determining the oxygen content of blood. US Patent 3,802,776, Issued April 9, 1974
50. Olsson SG, Castor R, Tchang, G. Arrangement for drift compensation in a gas analyzer US Patent 4,067,320, Issued January 10, 1978
51. “Integrated Circuits to cease operations in medical products.” Wall Street J
, November 28, 1984
52. Jalenan W. Facing losses, ICI pulls the plug on struggling Tri-Med. Seattle Business J 1984
53. Knodle D, Graham PK, Labuda LL. Infrared source. US Patent 5,369,277. 1994
54. Nuzzo PF. Capnography in infants and children. Pediatr Nurs 1978;30–8
55. Nuzzo PF, Anton WR. Practical applications of capnography. Respir Ther 1986;12–17
56. Mace LE, Labuda LL, Apperson GR, Cooke WA, Sams JO. Infrared radiation detector units and methods of assembling transducers in which said units are incorporated. US Patent 5,793,044. 1998
57. Braig JR, Liston MD. Infrared gas analyzer using count quadrature sampling. US Patent 4,586,026. Issued April 29, 1986
58. Corenman JE, Braig JR, Goldberger DS, Rojas EP, Stone JH. Multichannel gas analyzer and method of use. US Patent 4,817,013. 1989
59. Yelderman M, Goldberger DS, Braig JR. Optically stabilized infrared energy detector. US Patent 5,081,998. 1992
60. Knodle DW, Clary TR. Nondispersive infrared radiation source. US Patent 5,602,398. 1997
61. Joint Proxy Statement of Protocol Systems Inc., and Pryon Corporation, 1996
62. Drucker S, Goder A, Khalili D, Williams K, Christensen K, Major E. Respiratory gas analyzer. US Patent 5,464,982. 1995
63. Zander R, Mertzlufft F. [Checking the precision of capnometers] Anasthesiol Intensivmed Notfallmed Schmerzther 1992;27:42–50
64. Yamamori S, Hosaka H, Ono K, Ito M, Inoue M, Sugiura M. Capnometer. US Patent 5,728,585. 1998
65. Tammisto T. Historic perspective of CO2
monitoring in Scandinavia. J Clin Monit 1990;7:91–2
66. Abdrakhmanov MI. Current state of medical gas analysis instruments and prospects for development. Biomed Eng 1970;4:1-5 (Translated from Meditsinskaya Tekhnika, No. 1, pp. 3-8, January-February, 1970)
67. Gravenstein JS, Jaffe MB, Paulus DA (eds). Capnography: clinical aspects. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 2004:441
aIn a number of devices, the intensity of light that is transmitted is compared at two wavelengths, one at which CO2 strongly absorbs and another at which CO2 does not absorb.
bThe most commonly used type of IR source acts as a blackbody radiator which when heated to moderate temperatures radiates IR energy.
cThe solid-state devices usually used to detect IR radation include lead salt photoconductors (e.g. lead selenide) and thermopiles.
dNote that the relationship between emission and absorption spectra was elucidated in the work of Kirchhoff and Bunsen (Kirchhoff G, Bunsen R. Chemical Analysis by Observation of Spectra Annalen der Physik und der Chemie (Poggendorff) (1860), 110:161-189.) it was not until later improvements in instrumentation allowed quantification and visualization of the absorption spectra of CO2.
eCarbonic acid-Carbon dioxide (CO2).; Carbonic oxide-Carbon monoxide (CO).; Olefiant Gas- Ethylene (C2H2).6
fEduard Pfluger (1829-1910) and colleagues helped establish this with a series of publications between 1866 and 1878 including “on the origin and rationale of the oxidative processes in the animal organism.” (Garrison, FH. An Introduction to the History of Medicine, W.B. Saunders Company, Philadelphia, 1914 (763 pages)).
gThe reduction of the gas volume was measured and indicated the quantity of the gas absorbed.
hIn 1943 Luft published his often-referenced paper on the device in Zeitschrift fûr Technische Physik14 and he and Lehrer were awarded a patent (filed in 1938) on the technology.15
iPreviously termed IR CO2 meters or analyzers from the 1950s and into the early 1970s, it appears that the term “capnograph” was derived from the Godart Capnograph.
jNegative filtering typically uses the difference in absorption between 100 percent of gas A in one chamber and the “unknown” sample gas mixture containing gas A in another chamber.
kLow melting point wax.
lAt a data sampling rate of 4 Hz it is difficult to resolve breath-to-breath changes.
mThis story from Dr. Elam’s perspective (1918-1995) has been told as well20 and discusses how these devices helped Dr. Elam and colleagues discover a problem with canisters of the day, identify three characteristics of CO2 absorption with respect to these canisters, report on the property of channeling21 in soda lime and how they modified the canisters to minimize this effect.
nJames Whittenberger chaired of the Department of Physiology at Harvard School of Public Health from 1948 to 1980.
oA single-crystal ingot produced by synthetic means.
pRichard W. Stow, Ph.D. Associate Professor of Physical Medicine, OH State University, Columbus, OH; 1916-1995.
qDifferent sampling methods pictured in Figure 7.
rJohn E. Affeldt, medical director 1957-1964, Rancho Los Amigos Respiratory Center for Poliomyelitis, Hondo, CA.
sAffeldt et al notes “Because of the relationship between alveolar ventilation and alveolar carbon dioxide . . ., the alveolar carbon concentration is the best means of determining the ventilatory status of the patient. It eliminates the need of estimating the required minute volume and thus allows accurate adjustment of the respiratory pressures and rates.33
tAllen Norton, 2003, personal communication.
uLB-3 510(k) #K782138, cleared 01/31/1979.
vMarquette later acquired Electronics for Medicine in 1995; Marquette itself was later acquired by General Electric.
wListon Scientific, Irvine, CA was acquired by CA Analytical Instruments (CAI), Orange, CA.
x1941-2005; Rose from an entry-level engineer in the company’s medical products group, succeeded HP co-founder David Packard in 1993 as chairman as well as chairman of the Boeing Company (HP website).
y1932-; Became Executive Vice President, Chief Operating Officer and a director of Hewlett-Packard Company until his retirement in October 1992 (Forbes.com).
zThree types of optical choppers are available including rotating disc choppers (e.g. filter wheel), tuning fork choppers, and optical shutters.
aaInterference filters consist of multiple thin layers of dielectric materials with different refractive indices.
bbThe tuning fork choppers are fixed frequency electromechanically driven light choppers. Vanes attached to moving tines of a fork modulate a light beam.
ccRolf notes for those that have closely studied the schematic may notice that there is possibility to disconnect the device and use it external power supply without ventilator for spontaneously breathing patients.
ddCO2 Monitor 130 510(k) K802459 cleared 10/23/1980.
eeModel 511, 510(k) # K833397, cleared 11/28/83.
ffOne of the first to build oral and nasal sampling cannulas with NAFION.
ggTri-Med Model 126 Sample Line w/extended life NAFION 510(k) # K850746 - later assembled by PermaPure.
hhSquare One which was sold to OSI Systems later became part of Dolphin Medical.
iiincorporated in April 1988, co-founded by Daniel F. Carsten and Robert H. Ricciardelli who was also a principal in the startup of Biochem International; On July 10, 1996, the Protocol completed the acquisition of Pryon Corporation.61
jjLeslie’s cube (named after Sir John Leslie who experimented with radiant heat in 1804) consists of a cubical vessel with different sides - one of highly polished metal, another painted black, and the other two consisting of a dull metal (copper). He showed that radiation was greatest from the black side and negligible from the polished side.© 2008 International Anesthesia Research Society