Desmoplastic (Sclerotic) Nevus

An Underrecognized Entity That Resembles Dermatofibroma and Desmoplastic Melanoma

Abstract

Desmoplastic (sclerotic) nevus, a benign melanocytic neoplasm characterized by predominantly spindle-shaped nevus cells within a fibrotic stroma, can be confused with fibrous lesions and other melanocytic proliferations, including desmoplastic melanoma. We compared the histologic and immunohistochemical features of 16 desmoplastic nevi, nine desmoplastic melanomas, four hypopigmented blue nevi, and six dermatofibromas. The similarities between desmoplastic nevi and dermatofibromas included epidermal hyperplasia (12 of 16), presence of keloidal collagen (15 of 16), hypercellularity (16 of 16), and increased numbers of factor XIIIa–positive dendritic cells (12 of 12). The absence of adnexal induction (0 of 16), the rarity of lesions with multinucleated cells (3 of 16) or epidermal hyperpigmentation (2 of 16), and the presence of S-100 immunoreactivity (16 of 16) and melanocytic proliferation (9 of 16) helped differentiate desmoplastic nevi from dermatofibromas. The similarities between desmoplastic nevi and desmoplastic melanomas included the presence of atypical cells (16 of 16) and HMB-45 expression in the superficial portion of the lesions (11 of 16). The infrequent location on the head or neck (1 of 16), the absence of mitotic figures (0 of 16), a significantly lower number of Ki-67–reactive cells, and a decrease in HMB-45 expression in the deep area of the lesions (8 of 11) helped distinguish desmoplastic nevi from desmoplastic melanoma. Desmoplastic nevi had overlapping features with hypopigmented blue nevi, but features tending to favor the latter included a predominance of ovoid nuclei, higher numbers of atypical cells, and homogeneous staining with HMB-45. We conclude that a combination of histologic and immunohistochemical criteria facilitates the reliable diagnosis of desmoplastic nevus from its simulators.