Low bone mineral density (BMD) and decreased bone mass have been reported in HIV-infected men and women as well as children and adolescents [1–3]. Multiple factors appear to be involved, including effects of HIV-1 viral proteins, inflammatory cytokines and antiretroviral therapy (ART) on bone cells and bone turnover, and the effect of HIV infection on traditional determinants of BMD such as body weight [4–8]. However, whether HIV infection and/or ART increase fracture incidence has not been clearly established. Two large database studies [9,10] suggest that the prevalence of International Statistical Classification of Diseases (ICD)-9 coded or self-reported fracture is higher among HIV-infected individuals than among the general population, particularly among older individuals. In several large cohort studies, incidence of fracture among HIV-infected individuals was compared with incidence in prospectively enrolled HIV-uninfected individuals [11,12], individuals within the same clinic system  or the general population [14,15]. Other cohorts have reported incidence and predictors of fracture limited to HIV-infected individuals [16–18]. Complicating the comparison of these studies and the interpretation of their results are their contrasting study samples and differing research methodologies. Nevertheless, as the HIV-infected population continues to age, a sophisticated understanding of the relative impact of HIV and/or ART on fracture risk is needed to better inform clinical practice and future research.
We conducted a systematic review to investigate whether incidence of fracture (both overall and fragility) differs in individuals with and without HIV. The primary objective of the study was to conduct a meta-analysis to estimate an incidence rate ratio (IRR) of incident fractures and incident fragility fractures in HIV-infected compared with controls. A secondary goal was to compare and contrast the reported incidence rates of fracture among HIV-infected individuals and to summarize predictors of fracture from available studies.
Materials and methods
We conducted a literature search of Medline, Scopus and the Cochrane Library for all studies ever published of fracture incidence in HIV-infected individuals up to 28 September 2012. Studies that were electronically published ahead of print publication during this time period were eligible for inclusion. In addition, published abstracts from the Conference on Retroviruses and Opportunistic Infections (CROI; 1997–2012), the scientific meeting of the American Society for Bone and Mineral Research (ASBMR; 2000–2011), the Conference on HIV Pathogenesis and Treatment of the International AIDS Society (IAS; 2001–2011) and the International AIDS Conference (AIDS; 2002–2012) were searched online. Specific search terms are provided in Table 1.
Study selection and data collection
A study was eligible for inclusion if it reported data from adult participants (≥16 years) and reported fracture incidence data for HIV-infected individuals. We included studies with, as well as those without a control group. Randomized clinical trials were eligible for inclusion. Studies were excluded if they were not in English, reported only prevalence data or failed to report incidence rates in person-years. Two investigators (E.C.B., S.S.) independently screened all studies by title or abstract followed by a full text evaluation and abstracted all data. Any discrepancy regarding a study's eligibility after initial screening or data abstraction was further adjudicated by review by two other investigators (M.T.Y., S.M.A.). The following was abstracted from each study: study name, authors, year of publication, study location, number of total participants, number of HIV-infected participants, number of controls (if applicable), fracture classification method (self-report, ICD codes, discharge summary), fracture type (all fractures or fragility fractures), number of fractures and person-years of observation. When available, sex, race/ethnicity, age, BMI and ART exposure status of study participants were also collected.
Outcome and data analysis
The primary outcomes in this review were the all-fracture and fragility fracture IRRs of the HIV-infected group compared with the control group. Secondary outcomes were the all-fracture and fragility fracture incidence rates in HIV-infected individuals. Fracture incidence rate was calculated by dividing the number of fractures by the period of risk for all included patients during the study period expressed as per 1000 person-years of follow-up. Exact confidence intervals (CIs) were calculated for studies that did not provide a CI but did provide the number of individuals (N) and person-years of follow-up. Requests for additional data were made to all authors of eligible studies that did not present results for both all fractures and fragility fractures. A pooled estimate of the IRR comparing HIV-infected with controls for both all fractures and fragility fractures was calculated. To account for heterogeneity between studies, a random effects model was used to calculate the combined effect sizes. Statistical heterogeneity was assessed using the I 2 coefficient. Funnel plots were not assessed for publication bias, as there were fewer than 10 studies . Analyses were conducted using SAS version 9.1.3 (SAS Institute, Cary, North Carolina, USA) and RevMan (Version 5.2; The Cochrane Collaboration, Oxford, UK).
Selection of studies
Figure 1 shows results from the literature search and study selection process. We identified 179 articles from the Medline database, 338 from Scopus, and two from the Cochrane library. We also identified a total of 128 abstracts, including 39 from CROI, 44 from ASBMR, 29 from AIDS and 16 from IAS. After exclusion of duplicate records and studies that did not meet our inclusion criteria, 36 articles remained and we further evaluated the full texts of these publications. Twenty-three studies were excluded because they did not contain fracture incidence data or because they did not report fracture incidence rates in person-years of observation. Authors of four studies were contacted for additional data, and all responded to data or clarification requests (i.e. providing either CIs or numbers for all fractures and/or fragility fractures and person-years) [12–14,17]. We used the provided estimated person-years for the two groups in Grund et al. (7500 person-years) . A total of 13 studies met all inclusion criteria. A manual search of references cited by these studies did not yield any additional eligible articles.
The study by Young et al.  reported subgroup data for each year in the study, and different sampling weights were used for each year to produce population estimates and standard errors in the National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey of outpatient departments (NHAMCS-OPD). Therefore, we only used data from the most recent year (2006) containing information for both the HIV-infected group and the control group . Both the CROI abstract by Volk et al.  and the manuscript by Lo Re et al.  were included in the analyses. As the abstract contained data for fracture at the spine and hip and the published manuscript contained data only for fractures at the hip, we utilized the spine data from the abstract and the hip data from the manuscript.
Table 2 summarizes the characteristics of the 13 studies, published between 2007 and 2012, included in this systematic review. The meta-analysis includes only the seven studies with a control group [11–15,21–23]. Among the 13 selected studies, eight were conducted in the United States [11–14,16,21–24] and one each in France , Denmark , Australia  and Switzerland . Grund et al.  conducted their study in multiple countries. The sample sizes of HIV-infected individuals varied widely across the studies, from 317 in the Cohort of HIV at-risk Aging Men's Prospective Study (CHAMPS)  to 95 827 in the study by Lo Re et al. [21,22] of the United States Medicaid population. Approximately half of the studies identified incident fractures using the ICD codes [13,15–17,20–22], whereas others relied on patient reports [11,12,18,23–25]. Young et al.  used discharge summaries or patient self-report to identify fractures for HIV-infected individuals, and ICD codes recorded in charts or discharge records for controls. Of the 10 studies that reported fragility fractures, four defined fragility fractures in terms of trauma (fall from standing height or less, low-energy trauma, atraumatic or low trauma, and inadequate trauma) [11,15,17,25], and six studies defined them by location (hip and vertebral, and either forearm or humerus) [12–14,16,21,22,24].
Among the seven studies with a control group, three studies utilized prospectively enrolled HIV-uninfected individuals [11,12,23]. Two studies selected controls from the same healthcare system as HIV-infected individuals: Womack et al.  used controls matched by age, race, sex and site from the Veterans Aging Cohort Study Virtual Cohort (VACS-VC) and Lo Re et al. [21,22] used hepatitis C virus (HCV)-uninfected/HIV-uninfected Medicaid recipients as controls. Two studies had general population controls: Hansen et al.  linked data from the Danish HIV Cohort study with the national Danish Civil Registration System and Danish National Hospital Registry to obtain matched population controls, and Young et al.  used data from NHAMCS-OPDs to obtain bone fracture rates for the general United States population. Of the seven studies that included a control group, four studies reported all incident fractures [11,14,15,23] and six reported incident fragility fractures [11–15,21,22]. However, as we were unable to obtain person-years of observation for fragility fractures from Young et al. , data from that study were not utilized for the fragility fracture analyses. Thus, four studies were used to perform meta-analysis for all fractures and five for fragility fractures (Fig. 2a,b).
Four of the 13 studies included only or mainly men [12,13,16,23] and one involved women only . Not every study reported sex-specific fracture incidence data. Young et al.  reported that HIV-infected women aged 25–54 years experienced more fractures at vertebra and femoral neck sites, whereas HIV-positive men aged 25–54 years had more fractures at the wrist and vertebra, than the controls. The age means or medians of the study populations were between 35 and 55 years. Nine studies had a majority identified as ‘white’ or ‘Caucasian’ [12,14–17,20,24,25]. In general, the mean and median BMIs of the study participants were similar across the studies. The percentage of HIV-infected individuals on ART varied widely across the studies, from 27 to 100. Although most studies classified those with any ART exposure as ART treated, Bedimo et al.  applied a minimum exposure time of 1 month.
Figure 2a presents estimates of all-fracture IRR in HIV-infected individuals compared with controls. The pooled estimate of the crude IRR for all fracture was 1.58 (95% CI 1.25–2.00). Figure 2b presents estimates of fragility fracture IRR in HIV-infected individuals compared with controls. The pooled estimate of the crude IRR for fragility fracture was 1.35 (95% CI 1.10–1.65). The assessment for heterogeneity was not significant for all fractures (Q = 6.97, P = 0.07, I 2 = 57%) but was significant for fragility fractures (Q = 44.58, P < 0.00001, I 2 = 91%). No significant changes in heterogeneity with respect to fragility fracture were noted when the analyses were repeated omitting either the study by Yin et al. , which included only women and prospectively enrolled HIV-uninfected controls, or the study by Walker-Harris et al. , which included prospectively enrolled HIV-uninfected controls or both studies (results not shown). Table 3 presents estimates of all-fracture and fragility fracture incidence rate (per 1000 person-years) for HIV-infected individuals. Of note, there was a greater variation in the crude incidence rates of all fractures, which ranged from 0.8 to 30.6 per 1000 person-years, than the crude incidence rates of fragility fractures, which ranged from 1.4 to 7.4 per 1000 person-years.
Predictors of fracture
A summary of significant predictors of all fractures and fragility fractures in multivariable or adjusted analyses for HIV-infected individuals is presented in Table 3. Although predictors varied, several traditional risk factors remained consistent across studies, including older age [11,13–16,25], white race [11,13,15,16,23], low weight or BMI [13,14,16], smoking [11,13,15,16,24], and alcohol or substance abuse [13,14,18], particularly for fragility fractures. Diabetes, liver disease and a comorbidity index were also reported as significant predictors of fracture [11,13–15]. Although not a traditional risk factor, HCV was found to be a significant predictor of fracture in many studies [14–16,18,21,22]. Use of corticosteroids was also found to be a significant predictor of fracture in three studies [13,17,24], although only one study found proton pump inhibitors to be associated with fractures . As for HIV-specific variables, several studies found an association between low CD4+ cell count and fracture risk [14,17,25]. Few studies reported an independent effect of ART types or exposure on fractures. Bedimo et al.  found that tenofovir and ritonavir-boosted protease inhibitors were associated with an increased risk of osteoporotic fractures, adjusted for traditional risk factors among those who entered the cohort in the HAART era (1996–2009).
We found that HIV-infected individuals have a modestly increased risk for all fractures and fragility fractures compared with uninfected individuals or the general population. The test for statistical heterogeneity was not significant for the pooled estimate of all fractures; therefore, the IRR for all fractures appears to be a valid estimate. The test for heterogeneity, however, was significant for the pooled risk estimate for fragility fracture, and therefore, this IRR should be interpreted with caution. It should be noted that the overall incidence rate of fracture among HIV-infected individuals varied widely across studies, possibly due to the differences in demographics of the study populations.
Of the four studies that reported IRRs of all fractures, those with mainly white individuals reported a risk increase, whereas the two that did not reach significance had a majority of black participants [11,14,15,23]. With respect to fragility fracture, Lo Re et al. [21,22] and Womack et al.  found an increased risk in primarily minority cohorts; the largest risk, however, was reported by Hansen et al.  in which 80% of the individuals were white. Non-black race is a well known risk factor for osteoporosis. Our analysis suggests that race modifies the relationship between HIV infection and fracture and may explain some of the heterogeneity found in our analysis.
Review of the adjusted analyses of each study revealed that a number of traditional risk factors are importantly associated with fractures among individuals with HIV, including smoking [11,13,15], use of corticosteroids  or proton pump inhibitors , alcohol or substance abuse [14,18], low weight or BMI , and comorbidities such as diabetes and liver disease [13–15]. BMI may be of particular importance, as a meta-analysis conducted by Bolland et al.  found that lower body weight mediated the effect of HIV status on low BMD; however, reporting of weight or BMI in available fracture studies was inconsistent and therefore, could not be evaluated in an adjusted analysis. Low body weight may not only increase risk of fracture by leading to decreased BMD but may also be associated with increased prevalence of the frailty phenotype at earlier ages and predisposition to falls. Although early frailty has been previously documented in HIV-infected men [28,29], current data on fall rates in HIV-infected individuals are limited and is an important area for future research.
The role of HIV-specific factors in bone loss and fracture also remains unclear. Lower CD4+ cell counts before ART initiation have been reported to be a predictor of both bone loss after ART initiation and increases in bone turnover . Low current CD4+ cell counts (<200 cells/μl) in studies by Yong et al.  and Hasse et al.  were associated with increased fragility fracture incidence in multivariate analyses. Similarly, nadir CD4+ cell count of less than 200 cells/μl in the study by Young et al.  was associated with increased all-fracture incidence in multivariate analysis. However, pretreatment CD4+ cell count was not associated with fracture incidence in the longitudinal follow-up of participants enrolled in randomized clinical trials of ART initiation , and nadir or current CD4+ cell count was not predictive of fractures in other studies [13,15].
Several studies analysed the association between ART exposure and fracture risk. Hansen et al.  found that ART-exposed patients had a higher risk of fragility fracture than the general population that remained significant after adjusting for the comorbidity index (IRR = 1.6; 95% CI 1.36–1.87), but ART exposure was not associated with an increased risk of nonfragility fracture. In a larger database of HIV-infected individuals, when analyses were restricted to those entering the cohort in the era of potent ART, Bedimo et al.  found that exposure to either tenofovir or protease inhibitors was associated with an increased incidence of osteoporotic fracture. Most other studies failed to find an association between ART and fracture incidence; however, this may be partly due to insufficient sample size and differences in the classification of antiretroviral regimens used across the studies.
Interestingly, HCV was consistently identified as an independent risk factor for both fragility and nonfragility incident fractures [14–16,18,21,22]. The increased risk of fracture is approximately 1.5–2 times greater in HIV/HCV coinfected than HIV monoinfected individuals [15,16,21,22]. One study  found that BMD was lower in HIV/HCV coinfected than HIV monoinfected women, but not in men. A recent study found that DXA-derived hip geometry measures (buckling ratio and centroid position) differed between HIV/HCV coinfected men and uninfected controls, suggesting that fracture risk in HIV/HCV coinfected individuals may be due to compromised bone strength as well as lower bone density . Although the mechanisms are not well understood, HIV/HCV coinfection appears to have a negative effect on bone strength and fracture risk. The relationship between HIV/HCV coinfection and fracture risk warrants further study.
Our study has a number of limitations. We cannot exclude the possibility of publication bias, though we attempted to minimize this by reviewing abstracts from major scientific meetings. We were also unable to evaluate funnel plots due to the small number of published studies that met our criteria for inclusion. As mentioned, there was a considerable diversity across the studies in terms of study populations and how fractures were determined, thus introducing heterogeneity into our pooled analyses. The accuracy and reliability of the methods used to distinguish fragility from nonfragility fractures is also unknown, allowing for potential misclassification bias. In addition, we were not able to perform analyses on adjusted estimates of incidence rate for important factors such as age, race, sex, weight, antiretroviral exposure and CD4+ cell count, as these data were not available in most studies and those that conducted adjusted analyses included different variables.
This systematic review and meta-analysis suggests that HIV infection and/or ART are associated with modest increases in fracture risk with a pooled IRR of 1.58 (95% CI 1.25–2.00) for all fracture. Our results show the importance of including fracture outcomes in prospective studies that provide individual patient level data in order to establish the attributable risk of HIV infection and/or ART on fracture, as well as the contribution of other risk factors, including age, sex, race, weight and smoking. Validation of fracture prediction algorithms, such as FRAX , for HIV-infected individuals remains an important area of research. Although at present the overall increase in risk of fracture is modest, this can be expected to increase in the future as the HIV-infected population continues to age, and studies of risk reduction interventions are warranted.
We would like to thank Ludovic Trinquart, Magdalena Cerdá and Jeanine Genkinger for their advice. This work was supported in part by grants R01 AI095089 (M.T.Y.), R01 HD073977 (S.M.A. and M.T.Y.) and UL1 TR000040 (M.T.Y.). The content is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of the NIH.
E.C.B. and S.S. undertook searches, extracted data and contacted authors for additional data. S.S. performed the statistical analysis. All authors played a role in writing, editing and approving the text as submitted to AIDS.
Conflicts of interest
M.T.Y. has served as a consultant for Gilead and Abbott.
1. Jacobson DL, Lindsey JC, Gordon CM, Moye J, Hardin DS, Mulligan K, et al. Total body and spinal bone mineral density across Tanner stage in perinatally HIV-infected and uninfected children and youth in PACTG 1045
2. Mulligan K, Harris DR, Emmanuel P, Fielding RA, Worrell C, Kapogiannis BG, et al. Low bone mass in behaviorally HIV-infected young men on antiretroviral therapy: Adolescent Trials Network Study 021B
. Clin Infect Dis
3. Brown TT, Qaqish RB. Antiretroviral therapy and the prevalence of osteopenia and osteoporosis: a meta-analytic review
4. Fakruddin JM, Laurence J. HIV-1 Vpr enhances production of receptor of activated NF-kappaB ligand (RANKL) via potentiation of glucocorticoid receptor activity
. Arch Virol
5. Malizia AP, Cotter E, Chew N, Powderly WG, Doran PP. HIV protease inhibitors selectively induce gene expression alterations associated with reduced calcium deposition in primary human osteoblasts
. AIDS Res Hum Retroviruses
6. Wang MW, Wei S, Faccio R, Takeshita S, Tebas P, Powderly WG, et al. The HIV protease inhibitor ritonavir blocks osteoclastogenesis and function by impairing RANKL-induced signaling
. J Clin Invest
7. Cotter EJ, Chew N, Powderly WG, Doran PP. HIV type 1 alters mesenchymal stem cell differentiation potential and cell phenotype ex vivo
. AIDS Res Hum Retroviruses
8. Bolland MJ, Grey AB, Gamble GD, Reid IR. Low body weight mediates the relationship between HIV infection and low bone mineral density: a meta-analysis [Clinical review]
. J Clin Endocrinol Metab
9. Guaraldi G, Orlando G, Zona S, Menozzi M, Carli F, Garlassi E, et al. Premature age-related comorbidities among HIV-infected persons compared with the general population
. Clin Infect Dis
10. Triant VA, Brown TT, Lee H, Grinspoon SK. Fracture prevalence among human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-infected versus non-HIV-infected patients in a large U.S. healthcare system
. J Clin Endocrinol Metab
11. Yin MT, Shi Q, Hoover DR, Anastos K, Sharma A, Young M, et al. Fracture incidence in HIV-infected women: results from the Women's Interagency HIV Study
12. Walker-Harris V, Althoff K, Reynolds S, Palella F, Kingsley L, Danielson M, et al. Incident bone fracture in men with, or at risk for, HIV-infection in the Multicenter AIDS Cohort Study (MACS), 1996–2011.
XIX International AIDS Conference, 22–27 July 2012; Washington, DC.
13. Womack JA, Goulet JL, Gibert C, Brandt C, Chang CC, Gulanski B, et al. Increased risk of fragility fractures among HIV infected compared to uninfected male veterans
. PLoS One
14. Young B, Dao CN, Buchacz K, Baker R, Brooks JT. and the HIV
Outpatient Study (HOPS) InvestigatorsIncreased rates of bone fracture among HIV-infected persons in the HIV Outpatient Study (HOPS) compared with the US general population, 2000–2006
. Clin Infect Dis
15. Hansen AB, Gerstoft J, Kronborg G, Larsen CS, Pedersen C, Pedersen G, et al. Incidence of low and high-energy fractures in persons with and without HIV infection: a Danish population-based cohort study
16. Bedimo R, Maalouf NM, Zhang S, Drechsler H, Tebas P. Osteoporotic fracture risk associated with cumulative exposure to tenofovir and other antiretroviral agents
17. Yong MK, Elliott JH, Woolley IJ, Hoy JF. Low CD4 count is associated with an increased risk of fragility fracture in HIV-infected patients
. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr
18. Collin F, Duval X, Le Moing V, Piroth L, Al Kaied F, Massip P, et al. Ten-year incidence and risk factors of bone fractures in a cohort of treated HIV1-infected adults
19. Higgins JPT, Green S. Cochrane Handbook for systematic reviews of interventions, Version 5.1.0 [updated March 2011]. The Cochrane Collaboration. www.cochrane-handbook.org
[Accessed 15 January 2013].
20. Grund B, Peng G, Gibert CL, Hoy JF, Isaksson RL, Shlay JC, et al. Continuous antiretroviral therapy decreases bone mineral density
21. Volk J, Localio R, Newcomb C, Yang Y-X, Hennessy S, Kostman J, et al. HIV/HCV co-infection increases fracture risk compared to HCV mono-infected, HIV mono-infected, and uninfected patients.
18th Conference on Retroviruses and Opportunistic Infections, 27 February–2 March 2011; Boston, MA.
22. Lo Re V 3rd, Volk J, Newcomb CW, Yang YX, Freeman CP, Hennessy S, et al. Risk of hip fracture associated with hepatitis c virus infection and hepatitis C/human immunodeficiency virus coinfection
23. Arnsten JH, Freeman R, Howard AA, Floris-Moore M, Lo Y, Klein RS. Decreased bone mineral density and increased fracture risk in aging men with or at risk for HIV infection
24. Yin MT, Kendall MA, Wu X, Tassiopoulos K, Hochberg M, Huang JS, et al. Fractures after antiretroviral initiation
25. Hasse B, Ledergerber B, Furrer H, Battegay M, Hirschel B, Cavassini M, et al. Morbidity and aging in HIV-infected persons: the Swiss HIV cohort study
. Clin Infect Dis
26. El-Sadr WM, Lundgren J, Neaton JD, Gordin F, Abrams D, Arduino RC, et al. Strategies for Management of Antiretroviral Therapy (SMART) Study GroupCD4+ count-guided interruption of antiretroviral treatment
. N Engl J Med
27. Schoeni-Affolter F, Ledergerber B, Rickenbach M, Rudin C, Gunthard HF, Telenti A, et al. Swiss HIVCSCohort profile: the Swiss HIV Cohort study
. Int J Epidemiol
28. Desquilbet L, Jacobson LP, Fried LP, Phair JP, Jamieson BD, Holloway M, et al. HIV-1 infection is associated with an earlier occurrence of a phenotype related to frailty
. J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci
29. Desquilbet L, Margolick JB, Fried LP, Phair JP, Jamieson BD, Holloway M, et al. Relationship between a frailty-related phenotype and progressive deterioration of the immune system in HIV-infected men
. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr
30. Brown TT, McComsey GA, King MS, Qaqish RB, Bernstein BM, da Silva BA. Loss of bone mineral density after antiretroviral therapy initiation, independent of antiretroviral regimen
. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr
31. Lo Re V 3rd, Guaraldi G, Leonard MB, Localio AR, Lin J, Orlando G, et al. Viral hepatitis is associated with reduced bone mineral density in HIV-infected women but not men
32. Walker Harris V, Sutcliffe CG, Araujo AB, Chiu GR, Travison TG, Mehta S, et al. Hip bone geometry in HIV/HCV-co-infected men and healthy controls
. Osteoporos Int
33. Kanis JA, McCloskey EV, Johansson H, Oden A, Strom O, Borgstrom F. Development and use of FRAX in osteoporosis
. Osteoporos Int
2010; 21 (Suppl 2):S407–S413.