Secondary Logo

Journal Logo

Invited Commentary

Prevention of Noncontact ACL Injuries in Women

Use of the Core of Evidence to Clip the Wings of a "Black Swan"

Hewett, Timothy E.

Author Information
Current Sports Medicine Reports: September 2009 - Volume 8 - Issue 5 - p 219-221
doi: 10.1249/JSR.0b013e3181b7d3ab
  • Free


A high school forward rebounds the basketball, as she has thousands of times before. She lands with a flat foot, extended knee, and torso leaning awkwardly sideways, as her knee buckles inward. An audible pop is heard and felt as the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) in her knee tears and ends her season, compromising her hopes of a college scholarship and perhaps even her expectation of a long, active, and healthy life.

My M.D./Ph.D. student Carmen, who began working in my laboratory after both she and her identical twin sister suffered devastating noncontact ACL injuries while playing high school sports, recently gave me the gift of an irreverent treatise titled The Black Swan: The Impact of the Highly Improbable. Written by self-assured and self-described "empirical skeptic" Nassim Nicolas Taleb, the running theme of the book is a zealous critique of our ability to predict unexpected events, which he refers to as "black swans." Taleb's definition of a black swan is an event that is rare, has a major impact, and to which we teleologically ascribe the obvious reasons for its happening, but only after it has already occurred. My student gave me the book because "it reminded her of me"! As an empirical skeptic of sorts myself, I was only a page or two into the prologue when I realized that a noncontact ACL injury is, by Taleb's definition, a black swan.


The underlying mechanisms of noncontact ACL injuries have yet to be defined precisely; however, we now have a relatively good understanding of the mechanisms and interventions to prevent these injuries. Although I agree with Taleb that chaotic events are difficult, if not impossible, to predict, most of the available evidence indicates that prophylactic interventions that target underlying mechanisms of ACL injuries can decrease risk. Theories for the underlying mechanisms of these injuries may be divided into intrinsic and extrinsic mechanisms. Extrinsic factors include variables such as playing surface, shoe type, and number of risk exposures. Intrinsic mechanisms include anatomical, hormonal, and most importantly, neuromuscular factors. Neuromuscular mechanisms should be emphasized because they are the intrinsic factors that appear to have the greatest effect and the only ones we can readily alter. Anatomic variables include increased quadriceps (Q)-angles or decreased notch width, which may strain or impinge the ACL. Hormonal theories propose that estrogen increases ligamentous laxity of the ACL, predisposing it to injury. Systematic review of the literature shows that there is a slight increase in ACL laxity during the postovulatory phase of the menstrual cycle, but the injury events show significant clumping during the preovulatory phase of the cycle. Hence, these "predictive" factors are as chaotic (and contradictory) as the injury occurrences themselves! It is too much to expect of naïve scientists to discover the contributions of such complex hormonal feedback and feed-forward systems on such an acute injury event. Finally, a multitude of studies show neuromuscular control differences between women and men. However, a major caveat to these studies is that if a measurable variable is observed to be different between the sexes, we cannot conclude that this difference must underlie the injury risk disparity between the sexes. We need to remember that men experience many ACL injuries, too.

Despite intensive study of ACL injuries during the past three decades, previous reports on actual ACL injuries were based on interviews with the athletes or descriptive analyses of videotapes. These sources are not ideal for analysis because athlete interviews are highly subjective and prone to inaccuracies secondary to trying to recall the details of an extremely rapid (<100 msec), painful, chaotic event that occurred some time in the past. Our laboratory has used what we think is a paradigm shift in the field of sports medicine, what we term prospective, longitudinal, coupled biomechanical-epidemiologic studies that are geographically based (entire county school systems) to address this important problem and to answer very specific study hypotheses. To our knowledge, these state-of-the-art, labor-intensive tools of investigation have not been used previously to investigate such questions. In addition, we currently use computer modeling to complement these biomechanical studies and to simulate what occurs during the injury event and identify the high-risk athlete. We hope to be able to tailor neuromuscular intervention strategies to the athlete's specific neuromuscular control deficits.


I grew up the sole boy among six active, older sisters. I always had a good idea of the potential power of women's sports. My sister Patti was the best athlete in our neighborhood and went on to play multiple collegiate sports. However, because she grew up in the 1960s, she missed out on the immense influence and power Title IX has had on the young women of later generations. Many of the young women these days not only are great athletes, but also are tied up socially in their sport. Consequently, loss of participation can be a devastating effect of the injury. My sister Jenny tore her ACL playing basketball and now suffers from a debilitating, unstable, and osteoarthritic knee. We know from the long-term data coming out of Scandinavia that 50% to 100% of women with ACL tears, whether they have the ligament reconstructed or not, will go on to experience osteoarthritis within one to two decades of the original injury.

Serendipity may be defined as "a fortunate accident." I have experienced it a few times in my scientific life, and it has become one of the few concepts that this empirical skeptic greatly values (especially if it comes in the form of valid scientific discovery). One such serendipitous scientific discovery for me came while we performed a high school outreach study in the early 1990s. Designed to test the effects of plyometric neuromuscular training on performance in female high school athletes, we made the important discovery that these athletes demonstrate specific neuromuscular imbalances, that not only differentiate them from male athletes, but that also correlate with observed ACL injury mechanisms. For the past two decades, we have used our prospective coupled biomechanical-epidemiologic approaches to determine that these neuromuscular imbalances indeed likely underlie the increased risk of noncontact ACL injury.


More recently, another promising line of inquiry looking at the influence of the trunk on ACL injuries was the result of a serendipitous conversation I had with a group of spine biomechanists at Yale. On examination of their data from a series of studies originally designed to examine risk factors for future onset of low back pain, we reanalyzed the data relative to subsequent knee injury events and discovered that collegiate women athletes who do not sense or control their trunk (or "core") position well in three-dimensional space had significantly higher risk of future knee and ACL injury. Of interest, men showed no such association between core control and knee or ACL injury risk. I value these findings highly since there was no inherent bias to the study design or the hypotheses. The spine biomechanists who set up the study to examine low back pain had no a priori intention to examine the parameters of core control relative to knee injury risk.


Our current theory is that pubertal growth in the absence of a neuromuscular spurt results in neuromuscular imbalances that directly underlie the ACL injury mechanism. These observed neuromuscular imbalances give important clues for guiding prevention program strategies. The dynamic neuromuscular imbalances commonly observed in women can be divided into several broad categories. The first imbalance is the tendency for women to be ligament-dominant. Ligament dominance refers to the absence of muscle control of medial-lateral knee motion that results in high valgus knee torques and high ground reaction forces. A second common imbalance is referred to as quadriceps dominance. Athletes with quadriceps dominance preferentially activate their knee extensors over their knee flexors and gluteal muscle groups to stabilize their knee during movement. This imbalance accentuates and perpetuates strength and recruitment imbalances between these muscles. Yet another imbalance is leg dominance. This imbalance is characterized by one leg with weaker and less coordinated hamstring musculature than the other. A final observed imbalance can be termed trunk dominance, in which the momentum of the trunk is not controlled sufficiently, which leads to uncontrolled motion of the center of mass during deceleration and movement of the ground reaction force vector to the lateral side of the joint.


Neuromuscular imbalances can be used as screening tools to identify athletes at increased risk and funnel them into efficacious neuromuscular training programs that target each athlete's specific neuromuscular imbalances. A potential black swan ACL injury event may transform into a gray swan once we identify an athlete at risk. This athlete is now on our radar screen, since we now know that he or she is at risk and we have targeted him or her for intervention. Taleb claims that we should abandon attempts at predicting black swans, but gray swans are potentially predictable and even preventable.

The correction of neuromuscular imbalances is an important concept for the development of any neuromuscular training program. Neuromuscular balance is important in every plane of motion (i.e., imbalance of neuromuscular parameters usually occurs in all three muscular contraction planes). ACL injury is a multiplanar injury, and the sports movements that cause them likely occur in all three planes of motion. Ligament dominance can be addressed with awareness training and biomechanical technique and biofeedback training. Quadriceps dominance imbalance can be addressed with plyometric power training in flexion positions. Leg dominance imbalance can be addressed with single leg balance and symmetry training. Trunk dominance can be addressed with core stability training. Multiple randomized controlled trials have demonstrated that neuromuscular training programs focused on neuromuscular reeducation of these imbalances are highly effective in increasing control of dynamic movement and decreasing ACL injury both in the laboratory and on the playing field. A black swan like an ACL injury is a random and chaotic event that occurs in all three planes of motion. Therefore, it is likely that we cannot predict a single occurrence of a noncontact ACL injury. However, it does appear that we likely can predict a profile of increased risk. In addition, we may be able to predict risk for and develop neuromuscular interventions to prevent second injuries, which occur at an extremely high rate (12% to 28%) in the young, active, female population.


So what are our next steps in the decipherment of this hidden, chaotic, and destructive process? First, the new interventions to be tested must target all planes of motion. Our future study designs must be rigorous; we must use randomized, controlled trials (RCT), with placebo treatments in place. We must have sham treatments in place to control for bias, confounding, unnecessary error, and incorrect interpretation of results. Moreover, result interpretation may be the most common and greatest offender; as Taleb warns us, bias is inherent to the human mind and must be avoided in our intervention efforts at all cost.


This commentary is dedicated to Carmen and her sister Katie and to all the author's past and present students and research assistants over the past decades. This work is supported in part by NIH/NIAMS R01 AR049735, R01 AR05563, and R01 AR056259 (TEH).


1. Hewett TE, Lindenfeld TN, Riccobene JV, Noyes FR. The effect of neuromuscular training on the incidence of knee injury in female athletes. A prospective study. Am. J. Sports Med. 1999; 27:699-706.
    2. Hewett TE, Myer GD, Ford KR. Anterior cruciate ligament injuries in female athletes: part 1, mechanisms and risk factors. Am. J. Sports Med. 2006; 34:299-311.
      3. Hewett TE, Myer GD, Ford KR, et al. Biomechanical measures of neuromuscular control and valgus loading of the knee predict anterior cruciate ligament injury risk in female athletes: a prospective study. Am. J. Sports Med. 2005; 33:492-501.
        4. Krosshaug T, Nakamae A, Boden BP, et al. Mechanisms of anterior cruciate ligament injury in basketball: video analysis of 39 cases. Am. J. Sports Med. 2007; 35:359-67.
          5. Zazulak BT, Ponce PL, Straub SJ, et al. Gender comparison of hip muscle activity during single-leg landing. J. Orthop. Sports Phys. Ther. 2005; 35:292-9.
            6. Zazulak BT, Hewett TE, Reeves NP, et al. The effects of core proprioception on knee injury: a prospective biomechanical-epidemiological study. Am. J. Sports Med. 2007; 35:368-73.
              © 2009 American College of Sports Medicine