Lin, Charles C. BA*†; Gao, Xing MD†; Chen, Xiang-Sheng MD, PhD†; Chen, Qiang MD†; Cohen, Myron S. MD‡
AT THE TIME OF THE FORMATION of the People’s Republic of China (1949), sexually transmitted diseases (STDs) were among the most common causes for medical care.1 Syphilis was detected in as many as 17% of the general population in some urban areas (i.e., Nanjing) and in more than 50% of prostitutes.1,2 Mao Zedong established a national STD control program in 1954, which used a combination of community mobilization, mass screening, and treatment.1 This STD prevention program proved among the most successful in the history of mankind. Data collected in 1964 demonstrated virtual eradication of STDs.2
However, with the end of China’s closed door policy, STDs reemerged with a vengeance. The first sporadic cases of syphilis were detected in 1979. To detect the magnitude of the problem, the National STD Center in Nanjing developed an STD enhanced recording and reporting surveillance system in 19873 that now includes 26 sentinel sites. This system has tracked a nearly 20-fold increase in syphilis incidence from 0.17 cases per 100,000 individuals in 1989 to 4.31 cases per 100,000 individuals in 1998.3 This increase can be attributed to a variety of reasons, including profound stigma against STDs, which contributes to poor public knowledge about these diseases, inadequate health care-seeking behavior, and promulgation of unsafe sexual practices, which have grave implications for the sexual transmission of HIV. In addition, in a country where couples are limited to having one child, prevention of congenital syphilis is of crucial importance.
However, questions remain about the accuracy of these data. The recent organizational change shifting STD prevention and control efforts under the supervision of the Chinese Center for Disease Control may have disrupted case reporting. In addition, local Chinese STD experts have estimated that the nation’s case reporting surveillance system may only catch 10% of total syphilis infections. Because a case reporting system is inherently subject to underreporting, other countries such as the United States use routine prevalence studies to supplement and evaluate case report data. Although not as accurate as population-based incident case reports in tracking new cases over a specific time period, sentinel prevalence studies, which are nominally a component of China’s nationwide surveillance system, would provide valuable information such as syphilis prevalence for different risk groups. Unfortunately, they are limited to date.
Given its importance for STD prevention efforts and as a facilitating cofactor in HIV transmission, a lucid understanding of syphilis in China is needed. The objective of this study is to shed light on this epidemic by using a systematic, descriptive, quantitative literature review to estimate current syphilis prevalence and trends among high-risk groups and the general population. This data will be used to develop STD prevention and control strategy. To our knowledge, this is the first literature review of syphilis prevalence in China.
Materials and Methods
A computerized search for published literature was performed on September 24, 2005, using PubMed and its Chinese equivalent, the Chinese Periodicals Database (CPD), one of the most comprehensive Chinese scientific literature databases that includes over 7400 journals and 15 million articles catalogued from 1979 to the present. Journal type was not used as a screening criterion for the CPD search because reliable syphilis prevalence studies are published in a wide range of Chinese periodicals, including national, provincial, and university-affiliated journals. Thus, recognized journals such as the Chinese Journal of Public Health and the Chinese Journal of AIDS/STD were included, as were lesser known, area-specific journals such as the Shanghai Journal of Preventive Medicine and the Southern China Journal of Dermatology and Venereology. An initial search through PubMed using the key words “syphilis” and “China,” and CPD, using the keyword “syphilis,” was limited to articles published after 2000 and resulted in 31 and 3736 hits, respectively. Given this large number of studies and the fact that most studies reporting syphilis prevalence would be retrieved in a search using the key word, “syphilis,” additional key words such as “STDs” were not used.
To focus the search, articles were chosen if they described serologic prevalence studies in mainland China that used both a screening nontreponemal test (rapid plasma reagin, Veneral Disease Research Laboratory, unheated serum reagin, or toluidine red unheated serum test) and a treponemal-based confirmatory test (fluorescent treponemal antibody absorption, Treponema pallidum particle agglutination assay, T. pallidum hemagglutination, or T. pallidum enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay) to corroborate clinical findings in identifying syphilis cases. To minimize outliers while retaining a sufficient number of studies, research sample population size had to be >500 people, except in the case of possible female sex workers (FSWs), incarcerated FSWs, men who have sex with men (MSM), and drug users, in which a dearth of studies required relaxing these criteria to >80 subjects. Studies were selected if they specifically researched one or more of the following population groups: antenatal women; premarital individuals; blood donors (both commercial and voluntary); internal migrant workers; employees at hotels, restaurants, and railroad stations (hereafter called “food and service employees”); employees at entertainment centers, beauty salons, and bathhouses where commercial sex is not the primary service offered and thus only engaged in by a subset of the employee population (hereafter called “possible FSWs”); FSWs who have been incarcerated or placed in reeducation centers (hereafter called “incarcerated FSWs”); MSM; and drug users. Although one study of nonincarcerated FSWs was located in PubMed, none were found in the CPD, presumably because the illegal nature of and stigma toward prostitution in China makes it particularly difficult to research identified FSWs outside of detention centers.
Studies were excluded if they specifically involved foreigners or if the sample population was not clearly defined. Based on the latter criteria, many studies were excluded because they researched a heterogeneous mix of employees at hotels, restaurants, saunas, bars, and massage parlors without providing distinct syphilis prevalence data for each group. Studies were also excluded if the year of data collection was not explicit or if average prevalence data spanning more than 3 years was presented without individual yearly statistics. The reference sections of these papers were examined and relevant papers were subsequently obtained and added to the list from the original search.
Syphilis prevalence data and study sample characteristics were extracted from these articles and entered into an Excel spreadsheet. Data accuracy was double-checked manually. Statistical analysis including linear regression was performed using functions within Excel. To minimize bias introduced by outliers, a median value for syphilis prevalence with a corresponding interquartile range was calculated for each population group. Substantial heterogeneity in study design of the selected studies prevented a more rigorous meta-analysis from being performed.
A total of 5 and 169 papers from PubMed and CPD, respectively, met the search criteria. By specific sample population, the 169 CPD papers included 19 premarital,4–22 19 antenatal,23–41 40 blood donor (33 volunteer,42–74 one commercial,75 6 combined,76–81), 19 food and service employee,82–100 11 possible FSW,101–111 21 incarcerated FSW or incarcerated FSW clients,112–132 4 MSM,133–136 28 drug users,137–164 and 8 multigroup studies,165–172 (Fig. 1). Data from all studies were collected in public or governmental health facilities and virtually all were performed in urban areas. None of the studies provided incidence data nor did they specify if data were collected anonymously. The 5 studies gathered from the PubMed search included one each of premarital individuals, nonincarcerated FSWs, and drug users and 2 of migrant workers.
Chinese Periodicals Database Studies
During the last 5 years, from 2000 to 2005, food and service employees had the lowest median syphilis prevalence, 0.30%, with an interquartile range (IQR) of 0.2% to 0.5%. As plotted in Figure 2, the prevalence increased approximately 0.04% per year. The majority of the studies enrolled participants undergoing routine employment physical examinations at local health centers.
Syphilis prevalence data reported in studies of premarital youth and antenatal women are plotted in Figure 3. Fitted trend lines show prevalence increasing at approximately 0.09% annually for both groups. From 2000 to 2005, median syphilis prevalence (IQR) was 0.66% (0.31–1.43%) for premarital individuals and 0.45% (0.29–0.6%) for antenatal women. There was one extreme outlier among premarital studies reported by Fujian’s Xiapu County (6.3%).
From 2000 to 2005, volunteer and commercial blood donors had a median syphilis prevalence (IQR) of 0.37% (0.20–0.65%) and 2.86% (1.71–9.90%), respectively. As shown in Figure 4, syphilis prevalence increased more rapidly for commercial (0.64% per year) versus volunteer donors (0.09% per year). In the 4 studies that directly compared both groups over the same time period, syphilis prevalence for commercial donors was higher than that of volunteers in the tourist destinations of Zhangjiajie (Hunan province) and Meishan (Sichuan province), but comparable to that in the other sites.
Among those involved with sex work, a scatterplot shows that syphilis burden is heaviest among incarcerated FSWs, followed by incarcerated FSW clients, and then possible FSWs (Fig. 5). During 2000 to 2005, median syphilis prevalence (IQR) for incarcerated FSWs, incarcerated FSW clients, and possible FSWs was 12.49% (4.95–17.8%), 3.04% (2.99–5.79%), and 0.83% (0.62–1.3%), respectively. Syphilis prevalence increased at a higher rate for incarcerated FSWs (1.41% per year) than for incarcerated FSW clients (0.75% per year) and possible FSWs (0.13% per year). All studies of FSWs were comprised of completely female samples.
The highest syphilis prevalence was observed among MSM and drug users (Fig. 6). All 4 MSM studies were conducted after 2000 and the median syphilis prevalence (IQR) was 14.56% (10.61–18.7%). Three of the studies were conducted in the south (Guangdong province) and the other in the northeast (Liaoning province). Self-identified MSM comprised the study sample in three of the studies. Despite a limited number of data points, a regression line plotted a 4.5% annual rise in syphilis (Fig. 6). Compared with other high-risk groups such as incarcerated FSWs, incarcerated FSW clients, and drug users, MSM have the highest median prevalence and experience the highest rate of syphilis rise. Among studies of drug users, most were conducted in compulsory drug abuse treatment centers, where intravenous drug users make up a large majority of the incarcerated. Median syphilis prevalence (IQR) was 6.81% (5.01–11.17%) from 2000 to 2005, increasing over time at an average of 0.96% per year. Female drug users had 2- to 10-fold higher syphilis prevalence than males. Very high prevalence (>10%) was reported in sites in Fujian, Gansu, Guangdong, Sichuan, and Xinjiang (Uygur population) provinces.
Median syphilis prevalence and interquartile ranges from 2000 to 2005 are summarized in Table 1. In general, higher syphilis burden is clustered in the economically developed northeastern, eastern, and southern coastal provinces.
Comparable syphilis prevalence was observed among studies retrieved in PubMed. Among premarital couples in rural and urban areas in 3 representative provinces, 0.33% to 0.71% of premarital individuals were infected.173 In van den Hoek et al, 13.87% of 966 FSWs in Guangdong were infected with syphilis.174 Also, in a study of injecting drug users in Sichuan, 15.3% were seropositive for syphilis.175
Two other studies retrieved from PubMed focused on the floating, or migrant, population in China. In one study of male rural migrants working as construction workers, market vendors, and factory workers in Shanghai, 1% of participants had syphilis.176 In a separate study of market vendors in eastern China, 1.8% of self-reported sexually active individuals were infected with syphilis.177
This study reveals an escalating syphilis epidemic at its most severe state since the infection was effectively eliminated on the mainland 4 decades ago. Among all risk groups, syphilis infection is increasing. The increase is most pronounced among high-risk individuals such as incarcerated FSWs and drug users, in whom syphilis prevalence has risen by roughly 1.4% and 4.5% per year, respectively. Although syphilis burden certainly differs by location, the fact that the majority of the collected data were reported by longitudinal studies makes it likely that results reflect temporal trends rather than geographic variability. Lending credence to these trends, which were derived from syphilis prevalence data reported in the Chinese literature, are similar findings from the 5 studies published in peer-reviewed English-language journals.
Syphilis prevalence was similar across low-risk groups approximating the general population: food and service employees, voluntary blood donors, antenatal women, and premarital youth. Unexpectedly, the median prevalence for possible FSWs, 0.83%, was only slightly higher. Because these studies provided limited information on the sexual behavioral risk characteristics of the individuals studied, it is difficult to conclude why the prevalence was so low. The most likely explanation is that the study samples included many employees at karaoke establishments, dance halls, massage parlors, saunas, and bars that did not engage, if at all, in commercial sex work. Another possibility is that possible FSWs and incarcerated FSWs represent 2 groups with distinct demographic and STD risk characteristics. Poorer, less-educated FSWs, typically at higher risk for STDs, may be disproportionately represented in the incarcerated FSW studies because they have fewer means to deflect increased police attention. In contrast, possible FSWs may be able to avoid incarceration because of social connections, financial recourses, or as a result of working in a protected establishment, which could influence safer sex practices and thus lead to lower syphilis prevalence. Both of these reasons probably contribute to the difference in syphilis prevalence between possible and incarcerated FSWs, a finding that underscores that FSWs and their associated STD risk profiles lie on a spectrum.178
With China’s total population estimated at 1.3 billion people, the sheer number of high-risk individuals suggests a worrisome epidemic. China is estimated to have 5 to 10 million FSWs,179,180 5 to 10 million MSM,181 6 to 8 million drug users,182 and 120 million migrant workers.183 Considering the overlap between these groups and unclear infection rates in rural areas, it is difficult to extrapolate to estimate total national disease burden. However, rough calculations suggest that millions are infected with syphilis among these groups alone.
The spread of syphilis is of important public health significance for several reasons. First, the dire consequences of congenital syphilis are magnified in a country where couples are limited to having one child. With universal antenatal screening, congenital syphilis could be curtailed. Second, STDs, particularly those that cause genital ulcers such as syphilis, contribute to the spread of HIV by increasing infectiousness and/or susceptibility.184 Increased HIV shedding has been reported in the semen of men with genital ulcers,185 and individuals with genital ulcer disease have adjusted risk ratios for HIV acquisition ranging from 2.2 to 11.3.186 Although the majority of studies gathered here did not specify syphilis and HIV coinfection rates, the 4 MSM studies reported HIV seroprevalence ranging from 1.0% to 3.4%, suggesting syphilis infection may be contributing to HIV transmission in this group.
Third, the spread of syphilis reflects unsafe sexual practices, which have an obvious potential to fuel the heterosexual transmission of other STDs, including HIV. In their large study of premarital couples, Hesketh et al173 found similar syphilis prevalence in rural and urban areas in 3 provinces: Yunnan (home of the largest number of injecting drug users in China), Zhejiang (the province with the highest STD incidence), and Shaanxi (a poor central province with low STD and HIV prevalence). Although this suggests widespread unsafe sexual practices, HIV does not yet appear to have spread significantly beyond localized epidemics through heterosexual transmission. Hesketh et al173 found no cases of HIV in Zhejiang or Shaanxi. In Yunnan, they did report HIV cases among known high-risk injecting drug users, but unexpectedly, also among low-risk, nondrug users.173 These results hint that in some places, HIV prevalence may have reached a threshold from which rapid heterosexual spread into the general population can occur. As Yang et al187 conclude in their systematic review of behavioral studies in China, risk factors that contributed to the explosive heterosexual HIV epidemics in Thailand and Cambodia, including high rates of sex worker patronage, low rates of condom use during commercial sex, and concurrent sex with both FSWs and casual sex partners, all exist in China currently.
Particularly concerning is the increasing prevalence of syphilis among high-risk potential bridge populations. Among drug users, females were infected at 2 to 10 times the rate as their male counterparts. This is probably because a significant percentage of female drug users (52–98%) exchange sex for drugs.187 The extent to which these individuals engage in commercial sex work to supplement their income determines their importance as a bridge population in spreading STDs and HIV to the general population. Another crucial group are Chinese MSM, up to 70% to 90% of whom marry wives to adhere to social mores and thus have heterosexual and homosexual partners.188 Although syphilis prevalence is high among MSM, there is growing evidence that HIV is spreading among these individuals as well. In 2004, the Chinese CDC reported >1% HIV infection among MSM and declared them to be the next highest risk group after injection drug users. As increasing social acceptance and more widespread internet use allow men to pursue sexual partners, an underlying practice of unsafe sex may facilitate STD and HIV transmission among MSM and their wives.
Although the results of this study have shed light on China’s syphilis epidemic, it has a few limitations. First, the collected data predominantly reflects urban populations; little research on sexual transmission of HIV has been done in rural areas. A large and growing floating population serving as a bridge between urbanites and farmers may facilitate transmission of STDs and HIV among rural inhabitants. Worse, poor healthcare access and delivery in rural areas render their inhabitants more vulnerable. Second, there may be selection bias in that all of the CPD data were collected from studies conducted in public or government facilities. With the strong stigma associated with STDs, many Chinese patients seek care at pharmacies or private clinics. Although there is no strong evidence that more patients with STDs are seeking treatment at public and government clinics, this phenomenon could contribute to the observed increase in syphilis prevalence. Information about this subset of patients is important both to monitor syphilis spread and to direct control efforts. Third, information about crucial population groups such as migrant workers and FSW clients is limited with only certain subsets of these groups studied. Further research should focus on addressing these unknowns. Fourth, although rising syphilis prevalence was observed for all analyzed population groups, this does not necessarily represent an increase in new cases, because some of these studies may have been conducted anonymously and thus unable to determine duplicate syphilis diagnoses. Nevertheless, these results do strongly suggest a proliferation of new syphilis cases because they lend credence to the rising incidence reported by the nationwide surveillance system.
Although a more robust surveillance system accurately tracking the spread of syphilis and other STDs is central to developing an effective response, results from this study indicate that prompt prevention and control measures are equally as important to avert further spread of syphilis and other STDs. Public health officials invested in STD work can take heart in knowing that syphilis has already been effectively eliminated once in China. However, the draconian measures used so successfully in the 1950s depended on a society closely monitored and controlled by the government.189 In China’s more open society today, effective control of the syphilis epidemic will rest on adaptations of more familiar public health tools, including population-based screening, education, and harm reduction techniques. In addition, existing standardized treatment guidelines must be widely disseminated and followed to treat syphilis cases. Together, these efforts should be directed at decreasing STD/HIV morbidity and reducing risky behavior among high-risk areas and populations.
1. Cohen MS, Henderson GE, Aiello P, et al. Successful eradication of sexually transmitted diseases in the People’s Republic of China: Implications for the 21st century. J Infect Dis 1996; 174:S223–229.
2. Hu CK, Ge Y, Chen ST. Control and Eradication of Syphilis in China. Paper presented at the Beijing Sci Conference, 1964.
3. Chen XS, Gong XD, Liang GJ, et al. Epidemiologic trends of sexually transmitted diseases in China. Sex Transm Dis 2000; 27:138–142.
4. He ZP, Zhuang H, Dong QM, et al. HBV, HCV, syphilis, and HIV infection among premarital individuals. Chinese Journal of Public Health 2003; 19:1417–1418.
5. Wu XH, Wu HM. 266 syphilis seropositive cases among premarital individuals. Modern Medicine Health 2003; 4:1505–1506.
6. Luo J, Yang X, Hu CM. Results of premarital health examinations of 8,462 individuals. Practical Preventive Medicine 2004; 11:343–344.
7. Liu MX. Epidemiology of syphilis among premarital individuals in Zengcheng from 2001–2002. South China Journal of Preventive Medicine 2003; 29:32–33.
8. Sun ZM, Zheng XL, Wu Z. Analysis of 111 syphilis cases among premarital individuals in Shanghai from 1991–2002. Maternal and Child Health Care of China 2005; 20:417–419.
9. Mao XE, Zhou HG. Syphilis screening among 13,272 premarital individuals. Maternal and Child Health Care of China 2003; 20:78–79.
10. Chen LJ. Syphilis screening among 43,017 premarital women. Zhejiang Preventive Medicine 2004; 16:21.
11. Zhang XL. Syphilis screening in 9,197 premarital youth. Fujian Medical Journal 2000; 22:361.
12. Wu HM. Syphilis screening among 5,300 premarital individuals in Nanping. Chinese Journal of Public Health 2000; 16:1022.
13. Lin S, Lin XD. Syphilis detection among premarital individuals. Chinese Journal of Reproductive Health 2002;13:33.
14. Zhu Y, Deng QY. 198 syphilis cases among premarital individuals. Guangzhou Medical Journal 2004; 35:42–43.
15. Jiang LZ, He LZ. Epidemiology survey of 67 syphilis infected premarital women in Fanyu, Guangzhou. International Medicine & Health Guidance News 2004; 10:238.
16. Wei QL. Syphilis infection among premarital youth in Yibin. Guangxi Journal of Preventive Medicine 2003; 9:47–48.
17. Guo PZ. Detection and management of syphilis in premarital individuals. Jiangsu Health Care 2000; 2:239.
18. Chu CR, Zeng J, Yang SM. Syphilis infection among premarital individuals in Wuhou District, Chengdu. Journal of Occupational Health and Damage 2000; 15:184.
19. Zhao SX. HBs-Ag, gonorrhea, and syphilis test results among 812 premarital couples in Wencheng County. Literature and Information On Preventive Medicine 2002; 8:101.
20. Chen H. Syphilis screening in 13,030 premarital women in Shaoxing. Chinese Journal of AIDS/STD 2004; 10:181.
21. Liu HN. Syphilis surveillance among 32,647 premarital individuals in Zhoushan. Disease Surveillance 2002; 17:258–259.
22. Dou MB, Mou ML, Han GC. Syphilis infection in premarital individuals in Rizhao during 2001–2004. Preventive Medicine Forum 2005; 11:481.
23. He C, Zeng JR, Li YF, et al. Syphilis and HIV among antenatal women in Shajing district. Practical Preventive Medicine 2003; 10:1003.
24. Zhang YM, Zhang M, Shi WZ, et al. HBV, HCV, syphilis, and HIV infection among antenatal women in Changzhou. Journal of Clinical Laboratory Science 2004; 22:469.
25. Yao HX, Qian SP, Gu WM. Syphilis trends among antenatal women. Shanghai Journal of Preventive Medicine 2002; 14:71.
26. Xu XH, Chen ZP, Lu Q, et al. Antenatal syphilis and HIV screening of 6,081 women from 2002–2004 in Baoan District, Shenzhen. Maternal and Child Health Care of China 2005; 20:888–890.
27. Xu XF, Chen LC. STDs among women undergoing abortions. Shanghai Journal of Preventive Medicine 2005; 17:270.
28. Wu P, GU ZL, Pan J. Syphilis infection among women undergoing abortions in Hongkou district, Shanghai. Shanghai Journal of Preventive Medicine 2002; 14:171.
29. Sheng RG, Nie Y, He F, et al. Reproductive tract infections in pregnant women in Beijing. Chinese Journal of Perinatal Medicine 2004; 17:359–361.
30. Li L. STD infection among 962 gynecologic patients. Maternal and Child Health Care of China 2005:691–692.
31. Huang ZM, Peng SQ, Zhang Y, et al. Syphilis infection among pregnant women in Shenzhen during 2003–2004. Southern China Journal of Dermatology and Venerology 2005; 12:168–169.
32. Huang WZ, Ning T. Syphilis screening among 7,685 pregnant women. Guangxi Journal of Preventive Medicine 2005; 11:86–87.
33. Guo YH, Lan JY. Examination results of 2,892 pregnant women with sexually transmitted diseases. Maternal and Child Health Care of China 2004; 19:39–40.
34. Chen XH, Li YL, Zhao JP. Surveillance results of four infectious diseases in 8,260 pregnant women. Chinese Journal of Misdiagnosis 2005; 5:1146–1147.
35. Chen X, Zeng H. Syphilis screening results in 3,456 antenatal women. Chinese Primary Health Care 2004; 18:56–57.
36. Chen JX, Huang YF, Zhou HL, et al. Analysis of HIV and syphilis results in 4,365 pregnant women. Youjiang Medical Journal 2005; 33:271–272.
37. Chen DL. Trends of HIV, HBV, HCV and syphilis infection in pregnant women in Yingtan. Practical Clinical Medicine 2005; 6:102.
38. Li L, Li P, Cao WL, et al. STDs among 1459 gynecological patients. Practical Preventive Medicine 2004; 11:1126–1127.
39. Hong FC, Zhou H, Luo D, et al. Syphilis epidemiology among antenatal women in Shenzhen. Modern Preventive Medicine 2004; 31:623–624.
40. Huang ZM, Zhou H, Hong FC, et al. Syphilis among antenatal women in Shenzhen’s Baoan District from 1999–2002. Southern China Journal of Dermatology and Venerology 2004; 11:71–73.
41. Zhou P, Xiao DK, Jiang WG. Syphilis among 2303 antenatal women in Sheyang County. Chinese Journal of Dermato-Venereology 2001; 15:132.
42. Qiu SH, Lu R. Syphilis infection among blood donors in Guiyang. Modern Medicine Health 2004; 20:1698.
43. Tan W, Xu SL, Ma GM, et al. Syphilis infection among blood donors in Nanjing. China Preventive Medicine 2004; 5:286–287.
44. Chen GL, Lin YY, Chen Y. Detection of syphilis among blood donors. Modern Preventive Medicine 2005; 32:164–165.
45. Miao ZH, Wang XS. Syphilis infection among voluntary blood donors in Heyuan. Chinese Journal of Frontier Health and Quarantine 2000; 23:134–135.
46. Li QH, Lu DR, Hu JZ. Serological surveillance of 5 infectious diseases among 159,721 voluntary blood donors in Jiangmen City. Practical Clinical Medicine 2005; 23:139–141.
47. Chen LJ. Disqualification of samples from 3,977 voluntary blood donors in Maoming. Journal of Guangdong Medical College 2005; 13:437–438.
48. Ye XL, Nie DM, Li H, et al. Screening of blood donors in Shenzhen. Modern Preventive Medicine 2004; 31:734–735.
49. Su MH, Wang DW, Li ZF. HIV and syphilis among blood donors in Kiamusze. Heilongjiang Medicine and Pharmacy 2000; 23:49.
50. Liang GH, Tian ZY. Syphilis infection among voluntary blood donors in Puyang, 1998–2003. Practical Preventive Medicine 2005; 12:344.
51. Gu YJ, Ju XQ. Serologic analysis of syphilis infection in voluntary blood donors in Jiangyin. Occupation and Health 2005; 21:258.
52. Wen CG, Liu XF. Syphilis infection among 11,072 voluntary blood donors. The Journal of Medical Theory and Practice 2004; 17:816–817.
53. Wang NH, Fu XM, Liao Y. Screening of four infectious diseases among voluntary blood donors. Modern Preventive Medicine 2005; 32:920–930.
54. Wang ZQ, Zhou G, Wu LB. Syphilis infection among voluntary blood donors in Dazhou in 2004. Journal of North Sichuan Medical College 2005; 20:93–94.
55. Qian LQ, Wang P. Syphilis infection among voluntary blood donors in Deyang. West China Medical Journal 2005; 20:360–361.
56. Zhou P. Syphilis infection among voluntary blood donors in Zhangjiang. Chinese Journal of Blood Transfusion 2004; 17:117.
57. Xu JC, Xu XW, Zhou MZ, et al. Syphilis infection among voluntary blood donors in Guiyang. Chinese Journal of Blood Transfusion 2004; 17:48–49.
58. Sun LP, Yu JP, Gu RZ, et al. Syphilis infection among blood donors in Wuhan. Chinese Journal of Blood Transfusion 2004; 17:194–195.
59. Lei WQ. Syphilis infection among voluntary blood donors in Maan Shan County. Chinese Journal of Disease Control and Prevention 2004; 8:261–262.
60. Wang LJ, Gan J, Jiang X, et al. Syphilis infection among blood donors in Beijing. Chinese Journal of Blood Transfusion 2002; 15:354.
61. Hu JZ, Yu MC. ALT, HBsAg, Anti-HCV, and syphilis results in voluntary blood donors in Jiangmen. Anthology of Medicine 2003; 22:208–209.
62. Liu YC, Zhang ZY, Zhou ZX, et al. Syphilis infection among voluntary blood donors in Nanjing. Chinese Journal of Blood Transfusion 2002; 15:421.
63. Cao W, Zhang H. Syphilis infection among voluntary blood donors in Suzhou. Shanghai Journal of Preventive Medicine 2002; 14:522.
64. Tang J. Syphilis infection among voluntary blood donors in Jinan. Chinese Journal of Misdiagnosis 2004; 4:472.
65. Qin YJ, Wang JC, Zhang YS, et al. Syphilis among voluntary blood donors in Rizhao. Occupation and Health 2004; 20:55–56.
66. Wang YT, Zhu AX. Syphilis infection among voluntary blood donors in Zaozhuang from 1999–2001. Literature and Information On Preventive Medicine 2003; 9:105.
67. Wu Y, Lei HX, Luo QF, et al. Syphilis infection among blood donors. Shenzhen Journal of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine 2003; 13:302–303.
68. Zhu YX, Guo F, Lei HX, et al. Syphilis prevalence among blood donors in certain areas of Shanghai. Chinese Journal of Blood Transfusion 2004; 17:268.
69. Su L, Wang ZM, Fu P, et al. Syphilis infection among voluntary blood donors in Chengdu. Chinese Journal of Blood Transfusion 2002; 15:209–210.
70. Sun G, Lan YX, Ma L. Analysis of discarded blood from voluntary blood donors in Shenzhen during 1999–2002. Journal of Clinical Transfusion and Laboratory Medicine 2004; 6:283.
71. Xiao JY, Zhang ZY, Zhu HQ, et al. Screening results of voluntary blood donors in Nanjing. Chinese Journal of Blood Transfusion 2005; 18:241–242.
72. Chen SQ, Wang FC, Ji CL. Syphilis infection among blood donors in Jinhua. Shanghai Journal of Medical Lab Science 2003; 18:127.
73. Li NL. Serologic analysis of HIV-Ab and syphilis among blood donors in Jinan. Chinese Journal of Blood Transfusion 2004; 17:193.
74. Qin N. Examination results of voluntary and commercial blood donors. China Preventive Medicine 2003; 4:257.
75. Song WF, Zhou SL. Syphilis infection among commercial blood donors in Qujin. Chinese Journal of Misdiagnosis 2003; 3:470.
76. Shen QR. Syphilis infection among voluntary and commercial blood donors in Zhuhai. Journal of Modern Clinical Medical Bioengineering 2003; 9:517.
77. Li HR, Wu YY, Yang XH, et al. Detection of blood-borne diseases in blood donors of Jiaozuo City, Henan Province. China Tropical Medicine 2004; 4:1050–1051.
78. Wang XH, Long ZY, Yu GB, et al. Syphilis infection among blood donors in Zhangjiajie. Practical Preventive Medicine 2004; 11:92–93.
79. Wang ZD, Lu C, He YG, et al. Syphilis infection among blood donors. Chinese Journal of Public Health Engineering 2002; 1:119–120.
80. Hu TM. Syphilis surveillance in blood donors in Zhoushan from 1994–1999. Zhejiang Preventive Medicine 2000; 12:22.
81. Deng YF. Syphilis among voluntary and commercial blood donors in Meishan City. Journal of Sichuan Health Management College 2004; 23:137.
82. Chen KL, Mao MJ, Zhu GL. Syphilis among restaurant and service employees in Ningbo. Shanghai Journal of Preventive Medicine 2000; 12:116–117.
83. Fu YF, Dan KR, Wu H, et al. Syphilis among railway employees in Guangzhou. Preventive Medicine Literature 2003; 9:456.
84. Gao Z, Zhang G, Shen Y. Latent syphilis infection among Taiyuan railway station workers. Modern Preventive Medicine 2002; 29:559–560.
85. Hu GH, Li RP, Yan Q, et al. Analysis of syphilis screening results in 49,661 employees. Chinese Journal of Public Health 2003; 19:1529.
86. Ji XS, Ding MJ, Fan LF, et al. Syphilis infection among employees at public facilities in Wuxi. Jiangsu Health Care 2001; 3:59.
87. Jiang WY, Wang SF. Latent syphilis among employees in Zhoushan during 1997–2002. Chinese Journal of Health Laboratory Technology 2002; 12:720–721.
88. Li XY, Zhao M, Zhou YY, et al. Syphilis surveillance results among hotel and department store employees in Chongqing in 2001. Journal of Preventive Medicine Information 2002; 18:163.
89. Li YL. Syphilis infection among employees at restaurants and public facilities. The Journal of Medical Theory and Practice 2002; 15:108–109.
90. Liu JW. Syphilis screening among 23,553 employees. Journal of Preventive Medicine Information 2003; 19:84–85.
91. Liu M, Li XY, Ding XB, et al. Epidemiologic analysis of syphilis infection among employees in Chongqing in 2003. China Journal of Leprosy and Skin Diseases 2005; 21:115–116.
92. Shao LP, Wu ZY, Shao Y. Syphilis infection among restaurant employees in Wuxi city’s Binghu area. Shanghai Journal of Preventive Medicine 2003; 15:548.
93. Tao L. Syphilis infection among restaurant and public facility employees in Fenxian district, Shanghai. Occupation and Health 2003; 19:99–100.
94. Xia LP, Xu WJ. Hepatitis B and syphilis infection among food and service employees in Nanjing. Disease Surveillance 2002; 17:20.
95. Ying YM, Ying YT. Syphilis and HIV infection among restaurant employees. Zhejiang Preventive Medicine 2004; 16:22.
96. You FX, Ji XS, Hu L, et al. Syphilis and HIV infection among service employees in Wuxi during 2000–2002. Occupation and Health 2004; 20:59–60.
97. Yuan GP. Syphilis infection among restaurant employees in Jintan. Jiangsu Preventive Medicine 2002; 13:45–46.
98. Yuan L, Wang SY, Gong M, et al. Syphilis infection among railway employees. Chinese Journal of Public Health 2004; 20:985.
99. Zhang YH, Zhu GL. Syphilis infection among employees in Ningbo during 2000–2002. Strait Journal of Preventive Medicine 2004; 10:57.
100. Zhu LY, Chen XL, Xu L, et al. Syphilis infection among employees at public facilities in Nanhui District, Shanghai. Shanghai Journal of Preventive Medicine 2005; 17:272–273.
101. Hu XB. STD. Infection among female attendants in beauty salons. Anhui Journal of Preventive Medicine 2004; 10:341–342.
102. Luo BY, Wen WD, Deng XH, et al. Syphilis infection among populations of special importance in Foshan. South China Journal of Preventive Medicine 2005; 31:27–29.
103. Nong NS, Chen ZH, Zhao XR. HIV/STD infection among employees at saunas and bathhouses in Jiangmen. Disease Surveillance 2003; 18:253–255.
104. Pan YQ, Wang QC, Weng JF, et al. A survey of syphilis epidemiology among employees at public facilities in Fuzhou from 1990–2002. Practical Preventive Medicine 2004; 11:513–514.
105. Sun J, Sun L, Zhou DS. STD infection among FSWs in an entertainment center in Kaifeng. Henan Journal of Preventive Medicine 2003; 14:89–90.
106. Wei XW, Wang H, Yang JZ, et al. Efficacy of interventions among prostitutes infected with STD/HIV. Chinese Journal of Dermatovenereology 2004; 18:732–734.
107. Wu WG, Xu LR. Syphilis infection among employees at public facilities in Yinxian from 1996–1999. Modern Practical Medicine 2001; 13:251.
108. Xu MF, Chen JC, Zheng DC. STDs among high risk individuals in Dehua. Port Health Control 2002; 7:41–42.
109. Zhang H, Cheng GC. Syphilis infection among employees at public facilities in Dongying during 1996–1999. Literature and Information On Preventive Medicine 2001; 7:479.
110. Zhang HW. HIV, HBV, HCV and syphilis infection among key populations at entertainment sites. Zhejiang Preventive Medicine 2000; 12:31.
111. Zhao Y, Lai R, Xia M, et al. Syphilis infection among employees at public facilities in Changchun. Journal of Environmental Health 2002; 19:382.
112. Gu YR. Syphilis surveillance among high risk groups in Wuxi. China Journal of Leprosy and Skin Diseases 2005; 21:71.
113. Hua YZ. STD infection among commercial sex workers in rural Wuxi. Chinese Journal of AIDS/STD 2005; 11:93–94.
114. Jiang AP, Lu WD, Chen B. Analysis of STD infection among high risk groups in Fuzhou. Chinese Journal of Dermatovenerology and Integrated Traditional and Western Medicine 2003; 2:236.
115. Lin YQ, Chen LH, Wang RQ, et al. STD infection among high risk individuals in Wenzhou. Zhejiang Preventive Medicine 2005; 17:20.
116. Lin YQ, Yu XH, Chen LH, et al. STDs among female sex workers in Wenzhou. China Tropical Medicine 2003; 3:261–262.
117. Luo B, Hong FC, Zhou H, et al. Analysis of syphilis surveillance among 5,696 sex-related criminals in Shenzhen. Southern China Journal of Dermatology and Venerology 2001; 8:207–210.
118. Luo J. A survey of STD/AIDS related-knowledge, attitude, behavior and infection among FSWs. Modern Preventive Medicine 2005; 32:644–645.
119. Qi HZ. Analysis of STDs among prostitutes. Disease Surveillance 2003; 18:45–47.
120. Wang BF, Chen QJ, Zhang YH, et al. Behavioral characteristics and HIV/syphilis infection among female sex workers. Disease Surveillance 2004; 19:296–297.
121. Wu Y, Liao HW, Zhou WK, et al. Sexually transmitted diseases among female sex workers. Disease Surveillance 2002; 18:365–367.
122. Xie HY. Behavioral characteristics and HIV and syphilis infection among commercial sex workers in Quanzhou. Strait Journal of Preventive Medicine 2004; 10:44–45.
123. Yan HJ, Xu XQ, Guan WH, et al. High risk behavior and sexually transmitted diseases among prostitutes in Jiangsu. Chinese Journal of AIDS/STD 2004; 10:36–38.
124. Yan SQ, Chen HX. Syphilis among female sex workers in a reeducation center in Zhoushan. Chinese Journal of Public Health Management 2004; 20:245–246.
125. Yang F, Chen QS, Hong FC, et al. Factors that influence syphilis prevalence in 2,192 male sex criminals in Shenzhen. Anthology of Medicine 2004; 23:8–10.
126. Yang Y, Zheng MH. Syphilis surveillance among 2,342 female sex workers in a reeducation center. Chinese Journal of AIDS/STD 2001; 7:44–45.
127. Yu WF, Feng XG, Yao XF, et al. STDs among 296 individuals. Journal of Dermatology and Venereology 2000; 22:50–52.
128. Zang JF. Clinical analysis of latent syphilis infection among 73 female sex workers. China Journal of Leprosy and Skin Diseases 2001; 17:63.
129. Zhang HP, Zhu W, Liu YC, et al. STD surveillance in 971 high risk women in Beijing. Chinese Journal of AIDS/STD 2001; 11:364.
130. Zhong N, Lu YZ, Wang FQ. Syphilis surveillance among 3,939 prostitutes. China Tropical Medicine 2002; 2:100–101.
131. Zhu Q. STDs among female sex workers in Nanping. China Journal of Leprosy and Skin Diseases 2005; 21:356.
132. Huang ZH, Wang YJ. A survey of syphilis infection among female sex workers in Danyang, 1998–2002. Chinese Journal of Disease Control and Prevention 2005; 9:76–77.
133. Yang ZF, Fang SN, Cai WD, et al. Syphilis/HIV infection and sexual behavior among MSM. Chinese Journal of Public Health 2003; 19:1292–1293.
134. Cai WD, Fen TJ, Tan JG, et al. Behavioral characteristics and STD/HIV infection of MSM in Shenzhen. Modern Preventive Medicine 2005; 32:328–330.
135. Gu Y, Qu P, Su R, et al. STD/HIV related Kabp analysis in Shenyang MSM. Chinese Journal of Public Health 2004; 10:350–351.
136. He Q, Wang YPL, et al. KAP study of HIV infection among MSM in Guangzhou. Chinese Journal of Disease Control and Prevention 2005; 9:106–108.
137. Chen AZ, Liao HL, Zhu SY, et al. HIV, HBV, HCV and syphilis infection among drug users in Foshan. South China Journal of Preventive Medicine 2004; 30:14–15.
138. Cheng H, Zhao AL. An epidemiological survey of HIV and syphilis infection among drug users in Lanzhou. Disease Surveillance 2004; 19:170–171.
139. Cui XL, Li Z. HBV, HCV, HIV and syphilis infection in 483 drug users in Baoji. Preventive Medicine Forum 2005; 11:169–170.
140. Du XZ. Syphilis infection among heroin addicts. Chinese Journal of Drug Abuse Prevention and Treatment 2001; 31:24–25.
141. Gu YC, WU BY, Zhou H, et al. HIV and syphilis infection and behavioral characteristics of drug users in Zhongshan from 1999–2003. South China Journal of Preventive Medicine 2004; 30:27–29.
142. He JM, Zhen J, Jiang Y, et al. HIV and syphilis infection among drug addicts at a detoxification unit. Practical Preventive Medicine 2004; 11:230–231.
143. He Z. Sexual behavioral among 294 drug users. Strait Journal of Preventive Medicine 2002; 8:45–46.
144. Huang JB, Ouyang QF, Liu YD, et al. Behavioral characteristics and prevalence of four STDs among drug users. Chinese Journal of Frontier Health and Quarantine 2005; 28:132–133.
145. Lan QP, Huang XX, Zhou XH, et al. Syphilis and HIV infection among 610 drug users. Southern China Journal of Dermatology and Venerology 2004; 11:189–199.
146. Li XM. Syphilis and HIV infection among drug users in Lanzhou from 1999–2000. Disease Surveillance 2002; 17:85–86.
147. Liu R, Wang H. Syphilis among drug users in Chengmai County. China Tropical Medicine 2004; 4:208–209.
148. Liu XP, Liu ML, Zhang YM, et al. HIV and syphilis infection among drug users in Huhehaote. Disease Surveillance 2003; 18:337–338.
149. Mo FE. Syphilis and HIV infection among 490 female drug users. Southern China Journal of Dermatology and Venereology 2004; 11:80–81.
150. Qin GM, He YX, Chen XH, et al. Community-based study of risk factors for syphilis infection among injecting drug users. Journal of Preventive Medicine Information 2004; 20:110–113.
151. Wang BF, Zhang YH, Li SR. Behavioral characteristics and HIV, syphilis, hepatitis B, and hepatitis C infection among drug users in Longyan city. Preventive Medicine Forum 2005; 11:410–412.
152. Wang FQ, Lan SZ, Fei DN. Behavioral characteristics and HIV and syphilis infection among 341 drug users. China Tropical Medicine 2002; 2:73–74.
153. Wang M, Du JW, Huang HZ, et al. Drug use methods and HIV, HCV, HBV and syphilis infection among drug addicts in Hainan Province. Chinese Journal of Public Health 2000; 16:854–855.
154. Wang M, Mei L. Epidemiologic analysis of drug users in Taiyuan. Journal of Practical Clinical Medicine 2005; 14:295–296.
155. Wang Z, Wang KY, Long QQ, et al. HIV sentinel surveillance results among drug users in Dazhou, Sichuan Province in 2003. Disease Surveillance 2004; 19:450–452.
156. Xie HY, Wang JC, Yang YH, et al. Syphilis and HIV infection among drug users in Quanzhou. Hubei Journal of Preventive Medicine 2004; 15:39–42.
157. Xu HF, Qiu CW, Lu YP. Sexual behavior and STDs among 167 female drug users. Southern China Journal of Dermatology and Venereology 2001; 8:182–183.
158. Yan J, Zeng CH, Li H, et al. Drug use and HIV/HCV/syphilis infection among drug users in Guangdong in 1998. Chinese Journal of AIDS/STD 2000; 6:338–339.
159. Yang HK, Liu AH, Li JQ, et al. HIV and syphilis infection among drug users in Dongguan city in 2004: A survey of 395 cases. Chinese Journal of Health Laboratory Technology 2005; 15:928–929.
160. Yang JL. HBV, HCV, HIV and syphilis infection among drug users in Danzhou. Disease Surveillance 2001; 16:138–139.
161. Zuo F, Ma JQ, Fu FX, et al. HIV and syphilis infection among drug addicts in Shunde, Foshan City. Occupation and Health 2005; 21:1035–1036.
162. Zhang XQ, Shi L, Yu H, et al. HIV Infection as detected by a national sentinel site in Gansu Province in 2002. Disease Surveillance 2003; 18:445–447.
163. Wang FX, Mao AL, Liang ZH, et al. Syphilis infection among drug users in Shanxi province. Chinese Journal of Health Laboratory Technology 2003; 13:331.
164. Zhang M, Rui BL, Chen YG. HIV, hepatitis B/C, and syphilis infection among drug users in Urumqi. Chinese Journal of AIDS/STD 2004; 10:350–351, 364.
165. Fei DN, Yang B, Lan SZ, et al. Syphilis infection and behavioral characteristics of female sex workers and drug users in Hainan. Chinese Journal of AIDS/STD 2002; 8:160–161.
166. Long QP, Yang SH, Yuan LH, et al. Sentinel surveillance of sexually transmitted diseases in Loudi City, Hunan Province from 1998–2002. Practical Preventive Medicine 2003; 10:342–343.
167. Wang ZF, Jiang WY, Gong YM, et al. Syphilis infection among blood donors, service employees and premarital youth in Zhoushan. Chinese Journal of General Practice 2003; 2:291–293.
168. Yang B, Zhong N, Fei DN. Syphilis prevalence among key population groups in Hainan. Chinese Journal of AIDS/STD 2001; 7:167–168.
169. Yu J, Liang GJ, Xia Q, et al. STD prevalence in low and high risk populations in 1999: Data from the National STD Surveillance System. Chinese Journal of AIDS/STD 2001; 7:135–136.
170. Zhao JX, Zhao LQ, Li XA, et al. 2003 syphilis surveillance results in Yuxi. Journal of Preventive Medicine Information 2004; 20:163.
171. Zhong N, Wang FQ, Zheng WA, et al. Syphilis infection in certain populations of Hainan Province. China Tropical Medicine 2004; 4:975–976.
172. Guan WH, Yang HT, Wei QL, et al. A serological survey of syphilis among special groups in Jiangsu. Journal of Clinical Dermatology 2002; 31:578–579.
173. Hesketh T, Tang F, Wang ZB, et al. HIV and syphilis in young Chinese adults: Implications for spread. Int J STD AIDS 2005; 16:262–266.
174. van den Hoek A, Yuliang F, Dukers NH, et al. High prevalence of syphilis and other sexually transmitted diseases among sex workers in China: Potential for fast spread of HIV. AIDS 2001; 15:753–759.
175. Ruan Y, Chen K, Hong K, et al. Community-based survey of HIV transmission modes among intravenous drug users in Sichuan, China. Sex Transm Dis 2004; 31:623–627.
176. He N, Detels R, Zhu J, et al. Characteristics and sexually transmitted diseases of male rural migrants in a metropolitan area of Eastern China. Sex Transm Dis 2005; 32:286–292.
177. Detels R, Wu Z, Rotheram MJ, et al. Sexually transmitted disease prevalence and characteristics of market vendors in eastern China. Sex Transm Dis 2003; 30:803–808.
178. Huang Y, Henderson GE, Pan S, et al. HIV/AIDS risk among brothel-based female sex workers in China: Assessing the terms, content, and knowledge of sex work. Sex Transm Dis 2004; 31:695–700.
179. HIV/AIDS: China’s Titanic Peril (2001 Update of the AIDS Situation and Needs Assessment Report). Beijing: The UN Theme Group on HIV/AIDS in China, 2001.
180. Prostitution an Economic Force in China. United Press International. Jan 4, 2003.
181. China’s MSM population size and HIV situation. Xinhua News, 2004.
182. Report on the Status of HIV and AIDS in China, 2001. World Health Organization.
183. Kaufman J, Jing J. China and AIDS—The time to act is now. Science 2002; 296:2339–2340.
184. Galvin SR, Cohen MS. The role of sexually transmitted diseases in HIV transmission. Nat Rev Microbiol 2004; 2:33–42.
185. Dyer JR, Eron JJ, Hoffman IF, et al. Association of CD4 cell depletion and elevated blood and seminal plasma human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) RNA concentrations with genital ulcer disease in HIV-1-infected men in Malawi. J Infect Dis 1998; 177:224–227.
186. Fleming DT, Wasserheit JN. From epidemiological synergy to public health policy and practice: the contribution of other sexually transmitted diseases to sexual transmission of HIV infection. Sex Transm Infect 1999; 75:3–17.
187. Yang H, Li X, Stanton B, et al. Heterosexual transmission of HIV in China: A systematic review of behavioral studies in the past two decades. Sex Transm Dis 2005; 32:270–280.
188. Zhang BC, Chu QS. MSM and HIV/AIDS in China. Cell Res 2005; 15:858–864.
189. Cohen MS, Ping G, Fox K, et al. Sexually transmitted diseases in the People’s Republic of China in Y2K: Back to the future. Sex Transm Dis 2000; 27:143–145.