CAMBODIA HAS EXPERIENCED a burgeoning HIV epidemic since the first case of HIV infection was detected in 1991. The effects of poverty and civil war, in combination with an explosive spread of sexually transmitted infections (STIS) among sex workers in the mid-1990s, and widespread patronage of sex work has facilitated the expansion of the HIV epidemic from high-risk populations to the general population.1–9 One decade later, Cambodia has the highest prevalence of HIV infection in Asia.10 From 1991 to 2002, the cumulative number of HIV cases was approximately 82,000 among men and 75,000 among women, representing 3% of the adult population ages 15 to 49 years.
Since 1995, the National Center for HIV, AIDS, Dermatology and STDs (NCHADS) of the Ministry of Health of Cambodia has conducted annual, national HIV sentinel surveillance (HSS) surveys among well-defined risk populations to monitor trends in HIV infection. In 2002, the HSS estimated an HIV prevalence of 28.8% (95% confidence interval [CI], 26.6–31.2%) among 3109 brothel-based sex workers (referred to as “direct sex workers” [DSWs]); 14.8% (95% CI, 12.7–17.1%) among 1231 indirect sex workers (nonbrothel-based such as beer promoters, karaoke lounge singers, bar girls, and massage parlor women); 8.4% (95% CI, 7.3–9.7%) among 2356 tuberculosis patients; 3.1% (95% CI, 2.6–3.7%) among 4375 police; and 2.8% (95% CI, 2.5–3.2%) among 9166 women attending antenatal clinics.11 Trend data from HSS suggest that the prevalence of HIV among DSWs has steadily declined from 43% in 1998 to 29% in 2002. This trend was not observed among indirect sex workers (IDSWs), in whom the prevalence of HIV remained stable at approximately 15% during the same period.11
Beer promotion girls (hereafter referred to as “beer girls”) are the predominant group of IDSWs in Cambodia. Beer girls are employed by local beer distributors to promote and sell beer to customers in restaurants and bars. Beer girls typically receive a monthly salary of 280,000 Riels ($70 US)12,13 and also receive monetary bonuses based on the number of beer can tabs collected each night. Beer girls are required to wear a uniform and are encouraged to socialize with their customers to increase the purchase and consumption of alcohol. To supplement their salary, beer girls may also exchange sex for money with their customers.12,13
According to national behavioral surveillance surveys, risky sexual behavior is highly prevalent among IDSWs. Reported condom use is lower among beer girls compared with DSWs.12–15 Furthermore, more beer girls are reporting a history of exchanging sex for money or gifts in the past year, up from 13% reported in 1997 to 31% in 2001.13 Of note, although the majority of beer girls may not report engaging in “sex work,” many report receiving compensation from sexual relationships such as from a boyfriend after each sex act and/or having “another” source of income from clients.
Current programs to prevent HIV infection in Cambodia include a national condom use campaign, screening for and treatment of STI, voluntary HIV counseling and testing, and health outreach and education.5 The most successful program to date has been a 100% condom use program implemented in 1999 and tailored after Thailand's national program.16–19 Cambodia's program exclusively targets DSWs and their clients by promoting consistent condom use through education and collaboration among sex workers, brothel owners, local law enforcement authorities, and the government sector. The combined efforts of the condom campaign, improved STI management, and outreach efforts have coincided with concomitant increases in consistent condom use among DSWs with their clients, from 37.4% in 1997 to 89.7% in 2001.13 In contrast, similar interventions designed specifically to reach IDSWs have not been widely implemented.19 At present, IDSWs remain one of the populations at highest risk for HIV in Cambodia.
In this article, we report baseline findings on the prevalence of and risk factors for HIV and STI infection in beer girls who enrolled in an HIV risk reduction intervention study conducted in Battambang, Cambodia, from August 2001 to February 2002.
The city of Battambang is located in the northwest region of Cambodia, approximately 300 km from Phnom Penh and 100 km from the Thai border. With a population of approximately 500,000, Battambang is the second largest province in Cambodia. Because of its location along a major road connecting Phnom Penh with Thailand, Battambang has a significant amount of commercial and agricultural activity, providing employment opportunities for a number of mobile populations, including truckers, traders, businessmen, uniformed officials, and sex workers.20 In 2003, it was estimated that approximately 250 DSWs and 500 IDSWs resided in Battambang.
Recruitment and Enrollment
At the time of the survey, there were 5 beer distribution companies operating in Battambang, each of which employed approximately 10 to 30 women to promote their product. All beer girls in Battambang were recruited to participate in this study through special recruitment sessions conducted in a private room at each beer company site. Women who were interested in participating in the study were asked to come to the municipal STI clinic, where they could obtain more information, enroll in the study, and complete study screening and enrollment procedures.
After providing written informed consent, participants completed a 20-minute, interviewer-administered questionnaire that identified participant demographic characteristics, HIV and STI-related risk behaviors, HIV/AIDS knowledge, and reproductive health-related behaviors. After the interview, blood specimens were collected to test for HIV-1 and syphilis (Treponema pallidum) infections. All participants were instructed on collection procedures for self-administered vaginal swabs, and subsequently asked to collect 3 specimens under the supervision of a nurse to test for gonorrhea (Neisseria gonorrhoeae), chlamydia (Chlamydia trachomatis), trichomonas, and bacterial vaginosis (BV) infections.21 Women were given a unique code at enrollment to receive their STI and HIV test results.
Because of the delay in obtaining results of gonorrhea and chlamydia testing, all participants were treated for gonorrhea (400 mg cefixime mg orally) and chlamydia infection (1 g azithromycin orally) at enrollment, regardless of symptoms. Participants were requested to return to the clinic after 2 weeks to obtain their STI results and to receive treatment for BV and trichomonas infections if needed (2 mg metronidazole orally). Additional medications for partner treatment were available to women who were diagnosed with any STI and reported having a private sexual partner. Posttest counseling and HIV results were available to participants at the municipal voluntary counseling and testing site.
Blood specimens were tested for HIV-1 antibody using 2 rapid enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay kits (Genscreen HIV1/2 version 2, Sanifi Diagnositics, Pasteur, France; Serodia HIV, Fujirebio Inc., Tokyo, Japan). Specimens reactive on both tests were considered HIV-1 antibody-positive. Sera were tested for syphilis using the rapid plasma reagin test and confirmed using the microhemagglutination test for T. pallidum. A polymerase chain reaction test (PCR; Abbott Laboratories, Abbott Park, IL) was used to detect gonococcal DNA, chlamydia DNA, or both in self-collected vaginal swab specimens. “Trich In Pouch” (Biomed Diagnostics, Santa Clara, CA) was used to test for trichomonas; BV was detected using the “BV Blue” testing kit (Gryphus Laboratories, Birmingham, AL).22
Laboratory tests for the detection of HIV, syphilis, BV, and trichomonas were conducted at the Battambang Municipal Referral Hospital laboratory. Cervical specimens were placed in PCR transport media, stored and frozen at −20°C, and transported to Bangkok, Thailand, where they were processed to detect gonorrheal and chlamydial infections at the laboratory of the STI Cluster, Bureau of AIDS, TB and STI of the Department of Disease Control, Thailand Ministry of Public Health.
Key measures included data on demographic characteristics, employment history, sexual and drug use risk behaviors, STI symptoms, health-seeking behaviors, and HIV and laboratory-confirmed test results for STI. Demographic data included age, education, marital status, place of residence, and migratory patterns. Employment data included employment history, duration of work as a beer girl, income, and sources of income. Risk behavior data included condom use at last sex, condom use in the past 3 months, type(s) of partners, number of partners, history of exchanging sex for money or gifts, and history of drug use. Histories of abnormal vaginal discharge, genital ulcer, burning while urinating, lower abdominal pain, abnormal vaginal bleeding, genital rash, and genital warts in the past 3 months and in the past year were also collected.
A history of sex work was defined as answering “yes” to one or more of the following questions and/or statements: 1) Have you ever received money or gifts for having sex with a man? 2) Do you have another source of income from “sexual clients”? 3) My sweetheart/boyfriend gives me money every time we have sex.
Data were entered into a database using a unique study identification number. Frequencies were generated for categorical data and means, medians, ranges, and interquartile ranges (IQRs) for continuous variables. Ninety-five percent confidence intervals for the prevalence of HIV infections and STI were based on a binomial exact distribution. Bivariate analyses of associations between selected risk exposures and HIV and STI outcomes were assessed. Multiple logistic regression analysis was used to identify independent correlates of prevalent HIV infection. Variables found to be associated with HIV infection at the 0.2 significance level in the univariate analysis were tested in the model. Variables that remained significantly associated with HIV infection at a P <0.05 significance level or were important confounders were included in the final model. All analyses were performed using STATA 7.0 (STATA, College Station, TX).
The protocol for the study was approved by the Institutional Review Board of the Committee on Human Research at the University of California, San Francisco and the Ethical Review Board of NCHADS in Cambodia.
A total of 114 beer girls were employed in Battambang at the time of the survey. Of these, 92 women came to the STI clinic (80.7%) and were enrolled in the study. Two women (2.2%) refused to provide vaginal specimens; all women provided a blood specimen. Two weeks after enrollment, 80 of the 92 (87.0%) study participants returned for their STI results. Of the 46 women (51.1%) with a positive STI test result, 7 (15.2%) did not return for results and treatment.
The median age of the 92 participants was 24 years (range, 18–36 years). The median number of years of education was 4 years (range, 0–12 years). Over one fourth (26.1%) of participants were married (Table 1). The majority of women (72.8%) reported a monthly income of 200,000 to 300,000 Riels ($50 to $75 US) as a beer girl, and nearly all (96.7%) reported that they had another source of income. Among the various sources reported, 30.3% stated that they received money from their boyfriends and 61.8% reported receiving money from clients. Participants reported living in Battambang for a median of 7 years (IQR 1–20) and working as a beer girl for a median of 7 months (IQR 2–24) (data not shown).
Eighty-two participants (89.1%) reported ever having sex. Among those, the median number of lifetime sexual partners was 3 (IQR 1–5) (Table 2). A history of sex work was reported by 81.7% of sexually active women. Among women who reported having a husband or boyfriend, 24.6% reported always using a condom in the past month with that partner. Furthermore, 38.7% of those reporting a sexual client also reported always using a condom with their client in the past month.
HIV infection was detected in 26.1% (95% CI, 17.5–36.3) of participants. The overall prevalence of any STI and/or BV was 50.0% (95% CI, 39.6–60.4), including gonorrhea (3.3%; 95% CI, 6.9–9.4), chlamydia (14.4%; 95% CI, 7.9–23.4), trichomonas (12.2%; 95% CI, 6.3–20.8), and BV (43.3%; 95% CI, 33.7–55.3) (Table 3). The prevalence of any STI without BV was 26%. No syphilis infections were detected.
Participants reported the following symptoms in the past year: abnormal vaginal discharge (62.0%), genital rash (48.9%), lower abdominal pain (41.8%), burning while urinating (26.1%), genital ulcer (7.6%), abnormal vaginal bleeding (6.5%), and genital warts (1.1%) (Table 3). Among the 70 women who reported symptoms in the past 3 months, 36.4% reported using medicine purchased at a pharmacy (self-medication), 16.7% reported never seeking treatment, and 6.1% reported seeking treatment at an STI clinic.
The prevalence of HIV infection among women employed as a beer girl for less than 6 months was 27.3% (Fig. 1). The prevalence of HIV infection was 21.4% among women employed between 7 and 12 months, 16.7% among women employed between 13 and 24 months, and 37.5% among women employed greater than 24 months. Women who had worked as a beer girl for less than 6 months were significantly more likely to be younger (median age: 22 years vs 26 years, P <0.01), report previous employment as a karaoke lounge singer (31% vs 3%, P <0.01), and were significantly less likely to report having used condoms at last sex (31% vs 58%, P = 0.01) compared with women who had worked for longer periods of time.
Fewer years of education (AOR, 2.0 for every category decrease in education; 95% CI, 1.1–3.3), greater number of lifetime sexual partners (AOR, 2.0 for every category increase in sexual partners; 95% CI, 1.0–4.0), and self-reported symptoms of STI in the past 3 months, including “abnormal vaginal discharge” (AOR, 3.0; 95% CI, 1.0–9.0) and “genital rash” (AOR, 3.5; 95% CI, 1.1–9.7) were significantly associated with prevalent HIV infection after adjusting for age (Tables 2 and 3).
In this sample of beer girls, one in 4 women was infected with HIV. These results are higher than national figures in which 15% of IDSWs in Cambodia were infected with HIV in 2002.11 In addition, the prevalence of STI and BV infection was elevated, with one in 2 women infected with an STI and/or BV. The high prevalence of STI, especially chlamydia and trichomonas, markedly contrasts with the low prevalence of STI (<3%) found in women attending antenatal clinics in 2000.23 Together, these results highlight the acute and serious nature of the HIV epidemic and the ongoing susceptibility to HIV infection that exists among Cambodian IDSWs and their clients.
Beer girls who had been employed for greater than 24 months had the highest prevalence of HIV. As reflected in the “U-shaped” distribution of HIV prevalence by duration of employment, women working less than 6 months also had elevated levels of HIV infection. The high front end of this curve is suggestive of the following hypotheses and highlight areas of future prevention research. First, before becoming a beer girl, these women may already be engaging in high-risk behaviors that place them at increased risk for HIV infection. Second, newly employed beer girls may be perceived as more desirable to potential clients and thus, quickly enter into a high-risk lifestyle of sex, drinking, and social competition. In particular, these women may feel pressured to have sex with “core transmitters” in their surroundings, which may include beer company owners, restaurant owners, and uniformed officials. Finally, the younger age of these women also may increase their vulnerability to HIV transmission as a result of more immature genital tracts, which are susceptible to small vaginal tears during frequent sexual intercourse.24–26
Intertwined in the desirability of beer girls are the economics of alcohol consumption in Cambodia. Because customers who can afford to buy alcohol at entertainment venues are typically “well to do,” beer girls are perceived as high-class women in comparison with other women who engage in sex work in Cambodia. Consequently, beer girls typically charge up to 25 times more for sexual exchanges than do other sex workers.27 Beer girls can therefore choose to have fewer clients, with whom they can maintain long-term sexual relationships. However, despite a low number of sexual partners, beer girls remain at very high risk for HIV infection. Notably, 23% of women in our sample who reported only one lifetime partner were HIV-infected. Beer girls, therefore, may feel a greater level of intimacy and attachment to their partners and engage in high-risk behaviors within these partnerships.28 In this context, a beer girl's risk for HIV infection may be magnified through inconsistent condom use and/or difficulties in negotiating condom use with an intimate partner who may be concurrently engaging in other high-risk partnerships. Even in the era of a successful condom use campaign in the country, it is evident that beer girls are not receiving important prevention messages. Given this, future interventions specifically designed for IDSWs should incorporate condom negotiation skills in HIV prevention messages.
Self-reported STI symptoms were widespread in our study sample and significantly associated with HIV infection. However, few beer girls reported seeking proper medical care for their symptoms. Rather, self-medication and not seeking treatment were more common. These data suggest that current STI programs in Cambodia have had limited effectiveness among IDSWs. This presents a timely opportunity for various stakeholders in the community, including pharmacists, employers, community-based organizations, and the Ministry of Health, to work in parallel to educate women on the benefits of regular sexual health checkups and prompt management of STI symptoms.
Although the rate of participation in this study was high, the sample size was small. Therefore, the estimates gained from this study are vulnerable to imprecision. Furthermore, the results may not be generalizable to other populations of beer girls in different geographic locations as well as other groups of IDSWs in the country. We note, however, that the prevalence of HIV in our sample was comparable with provincial estimates of HIV prevalence found among beer girls in Battambang in 2002.11 It is likely there was underreporting of high-risk behaviors such as number of sexual partners or history of sex work as a result of social desirability bias, which may underestimate the true population estimates of risk and disease.29 Finally, inferences from prevalence data are limited in that correlates of incident infections may differ substantially from correlates of prevalent infections. Data on recent HIV infections are therefore needed to develop effective HIV intervention strategies that target the period of highest vulnerability to HIV infection among sex workers.30,31
In summary, the results of this study provide a framework for planning future HIV and STI interventions among IDSWs in Cambodia. Most worrisome are the high HIV prevalence, elevated STI prevalence, and high frequency of self-reported risky sexual behaviors among this population. Given the high mobility and rapid turnover among beer girls and other IDSWs in Cambodia, current STI programs and HIV prevention interventions that are intermittently implemented are unlikely to have a major impact in this population. Rather, targeted and frequently repeated interventions specifically designed for beer girls and other IDSWs are urgently needed to prevent new HIV and STI infections and subsequent HIV transmission.
1. Soeprapto W, Ertono S, Hudoyo H, et al. HIV and peacekeeping operations in Cambodia. Lancet 1995; 346:1304–1305.
2. Muller O, Kamnuan U, Leng HB, Chung A, Tadiar F. HIV and AIDS in Southeast Asia. Lancet 1997; 350:288.
3. Ryan C, Ouk V, Gorbach P, et al. Explosive spread of HIV-1 and sexually transmitted disease in Cambodia. Lancet 1998; 351:1175.
4. Richner B, Laurent D, Sunnarat Y, Bee D, Nadal D. Spread of HIV-1 to children in Cambodia. Lancet 1997; 349:1451–1452.
5. Saphonn V, Sopheab H, Sun LP, et al. Current HIV/AIDS/STI Epidemic Intervention Programs in Cambodia, 1993–2003. AIDS Educ Prev 2004; 16:64–77.
6. World Health Organization and Ministry of Health National Center for HIV/AIDS Dermatology and STDs. Consensus Report on STI, HIV, and AIDS Epidemiology, Cambodia, 2001. Phnom Penh: Ministry of Health, 2001.
7. Gorbach P, Sopheab H, Phalla T, et al. Sexual bridging by Cambodian men: Potential importance for general population spread of STD and HIV epidemics. Sex Transm Dis 2000; 27:320–326.
8. Po S, Page-Shafer K, Kim A, et al. HIV prevalence and risk factors among Fishermen in Sihanouk Ville, Cambodia. Int J STD AIDS 2004; 15:479–483.
9. Sopheab H, Gorbach P, Gloyd S, et al. Rural sex work in Cambodia; work characteristics, risk behaviours, HIV, and syphilis. Sex Transm Infect 2003; 79:e2.
10. Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS), World Health Organization. AIDS Epidemic Update, December 2002. Geneva: UNAIDS/WHO, 2002.
11. National Center for HIV/AIDS, Dermatology, and STI. Preliminary report on HIV Sentinel Surveillance 2002. Phnom Penh: Ministry of Health, 2002. Available at: http://www.nchads.org
. Accessed September 1, 2004.
12. Leng HB, Wantha SS, Sopheab H, Phalkun M, Gorbach P. Cambodia's Behavioral Surveillance Survey, 1999 (BSS I–III). Final report. Phnom Penh: National Center for HIV/AIDS, Dermatology and STDs, Ministry of Health, 2000 [online]. Available at: http://www.nchads.org
. Accessed September 1, 2004.
13. Gorbach P, Sopheab H, Leng HB, Vonthanak S. BSS V: Sexual Behavior Among Urban Sentinel Groups: Cambodia 2001. Phnom Penh: National Center for HIV/AIDS, Dermatology and STDs, Ministry of Health, 2002.
14. Ohshiege K, Morio S, Mizushima S, et al. Behavioural and serological human immunodeficiency virus risk factors among female commercial sex workers in Cambodia. Int J Epidemiol 2000; 29:244–254.
15. Morio S, Soda K, Tajima K, et al. Sexual behavior of commercial sex workers and their clients in Cambodia. J Epidemiol 1999; 9:175–182.
16. Rojanapithayakorn W, Hanenberg R. The 100% condom program in Thailand. AIDS 1996; 10:1–7.
17. Mastro TD, Limpakarnjanarat K. Condom use in Thailand: How much is it slowing the HIV/AIDS epidemic? AIDS 1995; 9:523–525.
18. Kilmarx PH, Palanuvej T, Limpakarnjanarat K, Chitvarakorn A, St. Louis ME, Mastro TD. Seroprevalence of HIV among female sex workers in Bangkok: Evidence of ongoing infection risk after the ‘100% Condom Program'’ was implemented. J Acquir Immun Defic Syndr 1999; 21:313–316.
19. David Lowe Consulting–Asia: Documenting the Experiences of Sex Workers. Draft Report to the Policy Project, December 2002 [online]. Available at: http://www.nswp.org/safety/CUP-REPORT.DOC
. Accessed October 1, 2003.
21. Tanksale V, Sahasrabhojanee M, Patel V, Nevrekar P, Menezes S, Mabev D. The reliability of a structured examination protocol and self administered vaginal swabs: A pilot study of gynaecological outpatients in Goa, India. Sex Transm Dis 2003; 79:251–253.
22. BV Blue [package insert]. Birmingham, AL: Gryphus Diagnostics, 2000.
23. National Centre for HIV/AIDS, Dermatology, and STI. 2001 Cambodia STI Prevalence Survey. Phnom Penh: Ministry of Health, 2002 [online]. Available at: http://www.nchads.org
. Accessed September 1, 2004.
24. Quinn TC, Wawer MJ, Sewankambo N, et al. Viral load and heterosexual transmission of human immunodeficiency virus type 1. Rakai Project Study Group. N Engl J Med 2000; 342:921–929.
25. United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA). Addressing Gender Perspectives in HIV Prevention, HIV Prevention Now, Programme Briefs no 4. Geneva: UNFPA, 2002.
26. World Health Organization (WHO). Women and HIV/AIDS, Fact Sheet no 242. Geneva: WHO, 2000.
27. Center for Advanced Study: Survey on Health Seeking Behaviour Among Women Working in the Entertainment Sector in Phnom Penh, August 2002 [online]. Available at: http://www.cascambodia.org/karaoke.htm
. Accessed October 15, 2003.
29. Morisky DE, Ang A, Sneed CD. Validating the effects of social desirability on self-reported condom use behavior among commercial sex workers. AIDS Educ Prev 2002; 14:351–360.
30. Kilmarx PH, Limpakarnjanarat K, Mastro TD, et al. HIV-1 seroconversion in a prospective study of female sex workers in northern Thailand: Continued high incidence among brothel-based women. AIDS 1998; 12:1889–1898.
31. Pisani E, Garnett G, Brown T, et al. Back to basics in HIV prevention: Focus on exposure. BMJ 2003; 326:1384–1387.