Institutional members access full text with Ovid®

Share this article on:

Prospective Comparison of Panoramic Tomography (Zonography) and Helical Computed Tomography in the Diagnosis and Operative Management of Mandibular Fractures

Wilson, Ian F. M.D., M.P.H.; Lokeh, Adam M.D.; Benjamin, Charles I. M.D.; Hilger, Peter A. M.D.; Hamlar, David D. M.D.; Ondrey, Frank G. M.D.; Tashjian, Joseph H. M.D.; Thomas, William Ph.D.; Schubert, Warren M.D.
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery: May 2001
Articles: PDF Only

This prospective study compared the sensitivity of panoramic tomography (zonography) and helical computed tomography (CT) in diagnosing 73 mandibular fractures in 42 consecutive patients and correlated the results with known surgical findings. The purpose of the study was to determine the optimal radiologic examination for the diagnosis and operative management of mandibular fractures. The attending surgeons' interpretations of panoramic tomograms and helical CT images in the axial plane were compared with the patients' known surgical findings. A series of questions assessed the relative contribution of these two radiologic examinations in formulating an optimal operative plan for each patient. In the 42 patients studied, the sensitivity of helical CT was 100 percent in diagnosing mandibular fractures; this compared with 86 percent (36 of 42) for panoramic tomography, in which significantly more fractures were missed (p = 0.0412). In the six patients with fractures not visualized, the operative management was altered because of the new fracture visualized on helical CT. Of the seven missed fractures, six were in the posterior portion of the mandible. Comparing fracture detection by region, seven fractures found on helical CT were not visualized on panoramic tomography. Helical CT improved the understanding of the nature of mandibular fractures by providing additional information regarding fracture displacement and comminution and by locating injuries missed using panoramic tomography. This study suggests that helical CT alone may be more diagnostic than panoramic tomography alone in evaluating mandibular fractures. Helical CT sufficiently demonstrated details of fractures in 41 of 42 patients; in one patient, the nature of a dental root fracture was better delineated by panoramic tomography. (Plast. Reconstr. Surg. 107: 1369, 2001.)

From the Department of Plastic and Hand Surgery, the Department of Otolaryngology, and the Department of Radiology, Regions Hospital, and the Division of Biostatistics, School of Public Health, University of Minnesota. Received for publication October 25, 1999; revised July 10, 2000.

Presented at the Plastic Surgery Research Council Meeting in Seattle, Washington, May 17 through 20, 2000. This project was accepted as partial fulfillment of the first author's (I.F.W.) Master of Public Health degree requirements, School of Public Health, University of Minnesota.

©2001American Society of Plastic Surgeons