Optometry & Vision Science

Skip Navigation LinksHome > May 2006 - Volume 83 - Issue 5 > Measuring Contrast Sensitivity Under Different Lighting Cond...
Optometry & Vision Science:
doi: 10.1097/01.opx.0000216100.93302.2d
Original Article

Measuring Contrast Sensitivity Under Different Lighting Conditions: Comparison of Three Tests

BÜHREN, JENS MD; TERZI, EVDOXIA MD; BACH, MICHAEL PhD; WESEMANN, WOLFGANG PhD; KOHNEN, THOMAS MD

Collapse Box

Abstract

Purpose. The purpose of this study was to evaluate three psychophysical tests for the measurement of contrast sensitivity (CS) and disability glare (DG) at different luminance levels.

Methods. In 60 eyes of 60 individuals (group 1: 20 healthy eyes of young individuals; group 2: 20 healthy eyes of elderly subjects; group 3: 20 eyes with nuclear cataract), CS with best correction was measured twice with the Frankfurt-Freiburg Contrast and Acuity Test System (FF-CATS) and the Functional Acuity Contrast Test (FACT, 1.5 cycles per degree [cpd]) at 167 cd/m2 and 0.167 cd/m2, and with the Pelli-Robson Chart (PRC) at 100 cd/m2 with and without glare. Repeatability of test and retest, and discriminative ability between the different subgroups, were assessed for CS values.

Results. Maximum CS values varied across tests. In all groups, highest CS values were obtained with the photopic FF-CATS. For FACT scores at 1.5 cpd, there was a ceiling effect for young subjects. CS scores obtained with the PRC were the lowest. The PRC had the best test–retest repeatability of all tests. Under mesopic conditions with glare, reliability was generally lower; the FF-CATS had the highest repeatability of the mesopic tests. The FF-CATS discriminated best between the different groups for all conditions.

Conclusions. There are large discrepancies in the test results between CS testing methods, especially under different lighting conditions. Results from different CS tests are not interchangeable.

© 2006 American Academy of Optometry

Login

Article Tools

Share

Article Level Metrics

Search for Similar Articles
You may search for similar articles that contain these same keywords or you may modify the keyword list to augment your search.