You could be reading the full-text of this article now if you...

If you have access to this article through your institution,
you can view this article in

Does Offering More Support Calls to Smokers Influence Quit Success?

Carlin-Menter, Shannon PhD; Cummings, K. Michael MPH, PhD; Celestino, Paula BS; Hyland, Andrew PhD; Mahoney, Martin C. PhD, MD; Willett, Jeffrey PhD; Juster, Harlan R. PhD

Journal of Public Health Management & Practice:
doi: 10.1097/PHH.0b013e318208e730
Original Article
Abstract

Background: Previous studies have found that offering additional callback counseling support to smokers calling a telephone quit line increases quit rates. However, what is less certain is the most cost-efficient protocol for offering such a service.

Objective: This study compares the efficacy of offering 2 versus 4 counseling callbacks after an initial call from Medicaid/uninsured adult smokers contacting the New York State Smokers' Quit Line (NYSSQL). Outcomes compared are the 7- and 30-day nonsmoker prevalence rates measured at 3-month follow-up and the cost per quit.

Design: A 2-group randomized trial was conducted.

Setting and Participants: The study population included 1923 adult (18+ years) Medicaid/uninsured current smokers (10+ cigarettes per day) who called the NYSSQL between February and March 2009 seeking help to stop smoking. At the time of the study, the NYSSQL provided Medicaid/uninsured callers with up to 6 weeks of free nicotine medications and up to 4 counseling callbacks. Half the subjects were randomized to standard care with up to 4 counseling callbacks with the remaining subjects offered only 2 counseling callbacks. All participants were sent a minimum of a 2-week supply of nicotine replacement therapy, with some receiving up to 6 weeks. Participants were recontacted 3 months after enrollment in the study to assess smoking status.

Main Outcome Measures: Quit rates, total counseling callbacks completed, reductions in cigarette consumption, and cost per quit measures.

Results: There was not a significant difference between study groups in the number of callbacks completed. There was also no difference in 7- or 30-day nonsmoker prevalence rates measured after 3 months' follow-up or reported use of the free nicotine replacement therapy between those assigned to either the 2- or 4-callback protocols. The cost per quit was essentially the same in both groups (2 callbacks—$442 per quit vs 4 callbacks—$445 per quit).

Conclusion: There was no advantage in terms of quit success or cost to offering up to 4 callbacks instead of 2 callbacks.

In Brief

This study compares the efficacy of offering 2 vs 4 counseling callbacks after an initial call from Medicaid/uninsured adult smokers contacting the New York State Smokers' Quit Line.

Author Information

New York State Smokers' Quitline, Roswell Park Cancer Institute (Drs Carlin-Menter and Mahoney and Ms Celestino) and Department of Health Behavior, Roswell Park Cancer Institute (Drs Cummings and Hyland), Buffalo; and New York State Tobacco Control Program (Dr Willett) and New York State Department of Health, Tobacco Surveillance, Evaluation, & Research (Dr Juster), Albany.

Correspondence: K. Michael Cummings, MPH, PhD, Department of Health Behavior, Division of Cancer Prevention and Population Sciences, Roswell Park Cancer Institute, Elm and Carlton St, Buffalo, NY 14263 (Michael.cummings@roswellpark.org).

Funding for this study was provided by the New York State Department of Health.

Authors Contributions: Conception and design—K.M.C., A.H., S.C.M., P.C., M.H., H.J.; acquisition of data—A.H., S.C.M., P.C., J.W.; data analysis and interpretation—K.M.C., A.H., S.C.M., M.C.M.; and drafting the article and/or revising it critically for important intellectual content—K.M.C., A.H., S.C.M., M.C.M., P.C., J.W., H.J.

© 2011 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Inc.