Institutional members access full text with Ovid®

Share this article on:

Osteoarthritis Classification Scales: Interobserver Reliability and Arthroscopic Correlation

Wright, Rick W. MD; The MARS Group; Wright, Rick W. MD; Ross, James R. MD; Haas, Amanda K. MA; Huston, Laura J. MS; Garofoli, Elizabeth A.; Harris, David BE; Patel, Kushal BA; Pearson, David BA; Schutzman, Jake; Tarabichi, Majd; Ying, David SB; Albright, John P. MD; Allen, Christina R. MD; Amendola, Annunziato MD; Anderson, Allen F. MD; Andrish, Jack T. MD; Annunziata, Christopher C. MD; Arciero, Robert A. MD; Bach, Bernard R. Jr. MD; Baker, Champ L. III MD; Bartolozzi, Arthur R. MD; Baumgarten, Keith M. MD; Bechler, Jeffery R. MD; Berg, Jeffrey H. MD; Bernas, Geoffrey A. MD; Brockmeier, Stephen F. MD; Brophy, Robert H. MD; Bush-Joseph, Charles A. MD; Butler V, J. Brad MD; Campbell, John D. MD; Carpenter, James E. MD; Cole, Brian J. MD; Cooper, Daniel E. MD; Cooper, Jonathan M. DO; Cox, Charles L. MD; Creighton, R. Alexander MD; Dahm, Diane L. MD; David, Tal S. MD; DeBerardino, Thomas M. MD; Dunn, Warren R. MD, MPH; Flanigan, David C. MD; Frederick, Robert W. MD; Ganley, Theodore J. MD; Gatt, Charles J. Jr. MD; Gecha, Steven R. MD; Giffin, James Robert MD; Hame, Sharon L. MD; Hannafin, Jo A. MD, PhD; Harner, Christopher D. MD; Harris, Norman Lindsay Jr. MD; Hechtman, Keith S. MD; Hershman, Elliott B. MD; Hoellrich, Rudolf G. MD; Hosea, Timothy M. MD; Johnson, David C. MD; Johnson, Timothy S. MD; Jones, Morgan H. MD; Kaeding, Christopher C. MD; Kamath, Ganesh V. MD; Klootwyk, Thomas E. MD; Lantz, Brett A. MD; Levy, Bruce A. MD; Ma, C. Benjamin MD; Maiers, G. Peter II MD; Mann, Barton PhD; Marx, Robert G. MD; Matava, Matthew J. MD; Mathien, Gregory M. MD; McAllister, David R. MD; McCarty, Eric C. MD; McCormack, Robert G. MD; Miller, Bruce S. MD, MS; Nissen, Carl W. MD; O’Neill, Daniel F. MD, EdD; Owens, LTC Brett D. MD; Parker, Richard D. MD; Purnell, Mark L. MD; Ramappa, Arun J. MD; Rauh, Michael A. MD; Rettig, Arthur MD; Sekiya, Jon K. MD; Shea, Kevin G. MD; Sherman, Orrin H. MD; Slauterbeck, James R. MD; Smith, Matthew V. MD; Spang, Jeffrey T. MD; Spindler, Kurt P. MD; Stuart, Michael J. MD; Svoboda, LTC Steven J. MD; Taft, Timothy N. MD; Tenuta, COL Joachim J. MD; Tingstad, Edwin M. MD; Vidal, Armando F. MD; Viskontas, Darius G. MD; White, Richard A. MD; Williams, James S. Jr. MD; Wolcott, Michelle L. MD; Wolf, Brian R. MD; York, James J. MD; Carey, James L. MD, MPH

Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery - American Volume: 16 July 2014 - Volume 96 - Issue 14 - p 1145–1151
doi: 10.2106/JBJS.M.00929
Scientific Articles

Background: Osteoarthritis of the knee is commonly diagnosed and monitored with radiography. However, the reliability of radiographic classification systems for osteoarthritis and the correlation of these classifications with the actual degree of confirmed degeneration of the articular cartilage of the tibiofemoral joint have not been adequately studied.

Methods: As the Multicenter ACL (anterior cruciate ligament) Revision Study (MARS) Group, we conducted a multicenter, prospective longitudinal cohort study of patients undergoing revision surgery after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. We followed 632 patients who underwent radiographic evaluation of the knee (an anteroposterior weight-bearing radiograph, a posteroanterior weight-bearing radiograph made with the knee in 45° of flexion [Rosenberg radiograph], or both) and arthroscopic evaluation of the articular surfaces. Three blinded examiners independently graded radiographic findings according to six commonly used systems—the Kellgren-Lawrence, International Knee Documentation Committee, Fairbank, Brandt et al., Ahlbäck, and Jäger-Wirth classifications. Interobserver reliability was assessed with use of the intraclass correlation coefficient. The association between radiographic classification and arthroscopic findings of tibiofemoral chondral disease was assessed with use of the Spearman correlation coefficient.

Results: Overall, 45° posteroanterior flexion weight-bearing radiographs had higher interobserver reliability (intraclass correlation coefficient = 0.63; 95% confidence interval, 0.61 to 0.65) compared with anteroposterior radiographs (intraclass correlation coefficient = 0.55; 95% confidence interval, 0.53 to 0.56). Similarly, the 45° posteroanterior flexion weight-bearing radiographs had higher correlation with arthroscopic findings of chondral disease (Spearman rho = 0.36; 95% confidence interval, 0.32 to 0.39) compared with anteroposterior radiographs (Spearman rho = 0.29; 95% confidence interval, 0.26 to 0.32). With respect to standards for the magnitude of the reliability coefficient and correlation coefficient (Spearman rho), the International Knee Documentation Committee classification demonstrated the best combination of good interobserver reliability and medium correlation with arthroscopic findings.

Conclusions: The overall estimates with the six radiographic classification systems demonstrated moderate (anteroposterior radiographs) to good (45° posteroanterior flexion weight-bearing radiographs) interobserver reliability and medium correlation with arthroscopic findings. The International Knee Documentation Committee classification assessed with use of 45° posteroanterior flexion weight-bearing radiographs had the most favorable combination of reliability and correlation.

Level of Evidence: Diagnostic Level I. See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

MARS Group Principal Investigator, Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Washington University School of Medicine, 660 South Euclid Avenue, Campus Box 8233, St. Louis, MO 63110. E-mail address:

Copyright 2014 by The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery, Incorporated
You currently do not have access to this article

To access this article: