JAIDS Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes:
HIV in Transgender Communities: Syndemic Dynamics and a Need for Multicomponent Interventions
Operario, Don PhD*; Nemoto, Tooru PhD†
From the *Department of Community Health, Brown University, Providence, RI; and †Public Health Institute, Oakland, CA.
Presented at the Domestic Prevention Working Group, 2010 HIV Prevention Trials Network meeting, March 4-5, 2010, New York, NY.
Supported by National Institutes of Health/National Institute on Drug Abuse grant R01DA018621 (D.O.).
The authors have no funding or conflicts of interest to disclose.
Correspondence to: Don Operario, PhD, Department of Community Health, Brown University, 121 S Main Street, 5th Floor, Providence RI 02906 (e-mail: Don_Operario@brown.edu).
Transgender communities are among the groups at highest risk for HIV infection in the United States. Using syndemic theory, we examine how HIV risk in transgender communities is embedded in multiple co-occurring public health problems, including poor mental health, substance use, violence and victimization, discrimination, and economic hardship. Although safer sex counseling and testing programs are essential platforms for HIV intervention, these modalities alone may be insufficient in reducing new infections. Multicomponent interventions are necessary to respond to the complex interacting syndemic factors that cumulatively determine HIV vulnerability in transgender individuals.
Transgender is an umbrella term referring to the population of individuals whose gender identity differs from the gender assigned at birth. Researchers have described a state of emergency related to HIV in the transgender community.1-3 To date, there exist no efficacious HIV prevention interventions for transgender individuals. The lack of research reflects, in part, the challenges in studying this population. For example, no reliable estimates exist of the size of the transgender population, many transgender individuals wish to be hidden, and assessing transgender identity and gender history remains difficult.3 We argue that the lack of progress in HIV prevention for transgender people is also due to the complexity of the epidemic in this community, attributable to multiple co-occurring public health problems that determine their HIV risk.
A systematic review by Herbst et al4 identified 29 studies reporting biological or behavioral HIV data in transgender communities, of which 22 reported HIV prevalence data on transgender women (or male-to-female transgenders) and 5 reported data on transgender men (or female-to-male transgenders). Meta-analysis of biological data estimated 28% HIV seroprevalence in transgender women, with extremely high seroprevalence (56%) in African Americans. Meta-analysis of self-report data estimated 12% HIV and 21% prevalence of any other sexually transmitted infection (STI) in transgender women; STIs commonly assessed include gonorrhea, chlamydia, herpes, syphilis, trichomoniasis, and hepatitis B and C. Compared with biological findings, lower self-reported HIV prevalence might reflect unknown infection or unwillingness to disclose. Two studies reported HIV incidence in transgender women: 7.8 infections per 100 person-years in a San Francisco study and 3.4 infections per 100 person-years in a Los Angeles study.5,6 Meta-analysis of data from transgender men was not conducted; only 1 study in transgender men reported HIV seroprevalence (2%),7 and 4 studies in transgender men found low self-reported HIV infection (0%-3%).4 Another study of transgender women in New York city, released after the meta-analysis by Herbst et al, found a high HIV seroprevalence in African American and Hispanic (22% and 36%) transgender women (48% and 50%, respectively) compared with white transgender women (4%).8 High prevalence of syphilis and hepatitis B were also detected in African American (15% and 36%) and Hispanic (36% and 22%) (22% and 36%) transgender women.
Multiple HIV behavioral risk factors have been identified, based mostly on studies of transgender women. Risk behaviors for transgender women include multiple partners, unprotected receptive anal intercourse, commercial sex, sex under the influence of alcohol and drugs, and needle use for injecting drugs and gender-related hormones or silicone.7,9,10 In several studies, African American and Hispanic transgender women report greater risk behaviors compared with white and Asian and Pacific Islander transgender women.4 Few studies have examined behavioral risk factors in transgender men, but there is emerging evidence of unprotected penetrative sex between transgender men and biological men.11
HIV-Related Syndemics in Transgender Communities
Syndemic theory has been a useful framework for understanding the determinants of HIV disparities in high-risk populations.12,13 Syndemic refers to the concentration within a specific population of multiple co-occurring epidemics interacting and reinforcing one another and ultimately giving rise to other health problems.14 Singer et al have described how epidemics of substance abuse and violence facilitated a subsequent HIV epidemic in inner city Hartford,15 and Stall et al16 have examined the epidemics of substance use, mental health, and childhood abuse in men who have sex with men as interacting drivers of the domestic HIV epidemic in men who have sex with men. Similarly, data from studies of transgender populations in the United States reveal syndemic dynamics that facilitate sexual risk behaviors and HIV transmission.
Mental health problems are frequently reported in transgender communities. Studies have shown high rates of depression, emotional distress, loneliness, and social isolation in transgender populations.3,10 Results from meta-analysis revealed that 54% of transgender individuals surveyed had suicidal thoughts and 31% had attempted suicide.4 Mental health problems can undermine motivations to practice safer sex behavior and can increase motivations for engaging in unprotected sex as a means for cognitive escape, emotional release, and feelings of love and intimacy.17-19
High rates of alcohol and drug use in transgender communities, including injection drug use (IDU), are also reported. In a San Francisco study, 34% of transgender women reported lifetime IDU and 18% reported past 6-month IDU, and 18% of transgender men reported lifetime IDU and 4% reported past 6-month IDU.7 Other drugs commonly used include marijuana, cocaine, crack, and methamphetamine, although within-group differences are observed. For example, in San Francisco, cocaine and crack use were higher among African American transgender women than among transgender women in other ethnic groups, and methamphetamine use was higher in Asian and Pacific Islander transgender women.9 Substance use before or during sex compromises cognitive or behavioral abilities to use condoms and is an independent predictor of unprotected receptive anal sex in transgender women.9
Transgender women and men may be at an increased risk for violence and victimization, including physical and sexual abuse. A national review of data from survey research, police reports, and social service records highlights multiple forms of violence that transgender people experience throughout their lifetimes.20 Abuse may begin in adolescence or childhood when transgender individuals begin to express atypical gender characteristics.21,22 Violence and victimization directly and indirectly lead to HIV risk. Forced sex confers likelihood of exposure for HIV/STI transmission, and other forms of physical violence can contribute to mental health problems and substance use, which increase the likelihood for sexual risk behaviors.
Studies have reported high levels of poverty, unemployment, and homelessness in transgender women and men.3,4,10 These outcomes likely stem from general stigma and job and housing discrimination against individuals whose transgender identity is exposed. Indeed, a goal for many transgender women and men is the ability to “pass” and receive affirmation as their desired gender,10,19 which manifests in the capacity to blend into mainstream society unnoticed. Some individuals have a difficult time passing due to physical characteristics that call attention to their transgender status, and these individuals may be more prone to stigma and discrimination and to ensuing syndemics of mental health, substance use, and violence that facilitate HIV risk.
Social and Structural Conditions for Syndemics in Transgender Communities
As noted, the syndemic dynamics described here reflect social and structural conditions that govern the treatment of transgender individuals. Because sex and gender are basic organizational principals in most societies, including contemporary US society, deviation from prescribed sex and gender dichotomies is reprimanded at nearly every level of social life. Consequently, transgender individuals experience a developmental life course characterized by cumulative stigma, alienation, and internalized stress.23,24 Studies of transgender youth have documented unsupportive and frequently hostile family members and peers.21,22 This adversity extends and augments into adulthood, manifesting in explicit discrimination, denial of opportunities, exposure to violence, and frequently unresponsive legal systems. Structural inequalities for transgender individuals are particularly salient in the health care system. Multiple studies report, among transgender communities, limited access to health services, inappropriate or nonexistent care protocols and facilities for transgender clients, and untrained and often discriminatory health providers and staff.25,26
Not Just Testing and Condoms: Need for Multicomponent Interventions
Recognition of multiple co-occurring epidemics and challenging social and structural conditions call into question the feasibility of standard HIV prevention approaches for addressing the needs of transgender women and men. Dominant paradigms in HIV prevention include testing and counseling, informational and motivational training to improve condom use and encourage partner reduction, and other approaches that focus on safer sex as the primary or sole outcome. Syndemic analysis of the determinants of HIV risk in transgender communities-particularly in transgender women, who have been the focus of most previous studies reviewed here-reveals that more complex prevention approaches are warranted. Indeed, previous research has suggested that transgender women are highly aware of their HIV-related sexual risk behaviors but that HIV prevention is simply a low priority compared with other immediate concerns.19
Multicomponent interventions are necessary to mitigate the HIV syndemic dynamics in transgender communities. Several recent articles have called for the development of multicomponent HIV interventions that recognize and address interactions among, for example, substance use, mental health, poverty, and HIV risk.27 Ickovics28 has described the benefit of “bundling” HIV prevention services with other health/social services to achieve meaningful improvements in public health. In order for multiple services to form a meaningful bundle, they must be complementary, synergistic in their health benefit, cost-effective, and accepted by target audiences. HIV testing and behavioral-motivational risk reduction counseling offer platforms for bundling other intervention foci and modalities, which might include transgender support groups, brief substance use counseling and treatment referrals, brief mental health counseling and referrals, life skills coaching and training, and other programs that correspond to recognized transgender syndemic dynamics. Intervention components must also consider developmental trajectories in transgender identity, including the needs of adolescents and young adults, and prevention needs that might differ according to gender transformation procedures. Enhancing sensitive and appropriate channels of care and establishing linkages between care services are essential to this multicomponent approach.
The science of multicomponent HIV prevention intervention for transgender and other high-risk populations is still in its infancy. Condoms and testing alone cannot reduce the burden of HIV infection and AIDS in transgender individuals and other high-risk populations. Major efforts must be invested in developing and testing complex population-focused interventions.27 For transgender communities, the capacity to respond to HIV syndemic dynamics can be a matter of life and death.2
1. Lombardi E. Enhancing transgender health care. Am J Public Health. 2001;91:869-872. PMCID: PMC1446458.
2. Feinberg L. Trans health crisis: for us it's life or death. Am J Public Health. 2001;91:897-900. PMCID: PMC1446107.
3. De Santis JP. HIV infection risk factors among male-to-female transgender persons: a review of the literature. J Assoc Nurses AIDS Care. 2009;20:362-372. doi:10.1016/j.jana.2009.06.005.
4. Herbst JH, Jacobs ED, Finlayson TJ, et al; the HIV/AIDS Prevention Research Synthesis Team. Estimating HIV prevalence and risk behaviors of transgender persons in the United States: a systematic review. AIDS Behav. 2008;12:1-17. doi:10.1007/s10461-007-9299-3.
5. Kellogg TA, Clements-Nolle K, Dilley J, et al. Incidence of human immunodeficiency virus among male-to-female transgendered persons in San Francisco. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr. 2001;28:380-384.
6. Simon PA, Reback CJ, Bemis CC. HIV prevalence and incidence among male-to-female transsexuals receiving HIV prevention services in Los Angeles County [research letters]. AIDS. 2000;14:2953-2955.
7. Clements-Nolle K, Marx R, Guzman R, et al. HIV prevalence, risk behaviors, health care use, and mental health status of transgender persons: implications for public health intervention. Am J Public Health. 2001;91:915-921. PMCID: PMC1446468.
8. Nuttbrock L, Hwahng S, Bockting W, et al. Lifetime risk factors for HIV/sexually transmitted infections among male-to-female transgender persons. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr. 2009;52:417-421. doi:10.1097/QAI.0b013e3181ab6ed8.
9. Nemoto T, Operario D, Keatley J, et al. HIV risk behaviors among male-to-female transgender persons of color in San Francisco. Am J Public Health. 2004;94:1193-1199. PMCID: PMC1448420.
10. Kosenko KA. Contextual influences on sexual risk-taking in the transgender community. J Sex Res. 2010;24:1-12.
11. Sevelius J. “There's no pamphlet for the kind of sex I have”: HIV-related risk factors and protective behaviors among transgender men who have sex with nontransgender men. J Assoc Nurses AIDS Care. 2009;20:398-410. doi:10.1016/j.jana.2009.06.001.
12. Mustanski B, Garofalo R, Herrick A, et al. Psychosocial health problems increase risk for HIV among urban men who have sex with men: preliminary evidence of a syndemic in need of attention. Ann Behav Med. 2007;34:37-45. PMCID: PMC2219199.
13. Freudenberg N, Fahs M, Galea S, et al. The impact of New York City's 1975 fiscal crisis on the tuberculosis, HIV, and homicide syndemic. Am J Public Health. 2006;96:424-434. doi:10.2105/AJPH.2005.063511.
14. Singer M, Clair S. Syndemics and public health: reconceptualizing disease in bio-social context. Med Anthropol Q. 2003;17:423-441. doi:10.1525/maq.2003.17.4.423.
15. Singer MC, Erickson PI, Badiane L, et al. Syndemics, sex and the city: understanding sexually transmitted diseases in social and cultural context. Soc Sci Med. 2006;63:2010-2021. doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2006.05.012.
16. Stall R, Friedman MS, Catania JA. Interacting epidemics and gay men's health: a theory of syndemic production among urban gay men. In: Wolitski RJ, Stall R, Valdiserri RO, eds. Unequal Opportunity: Health Disparities Affecting Gay and Bisexual Men in the United States. New York, NY: Oxford University Press; 2007:251-274.
17. Bockting WO, Robinson BE, Rosser BR. Transgender HIV prevention: a qualitative needs assessment. AIDS Care. 1998;10:505-525. doi:10.1080/09540129850124028.
18. Melendez RM, Pinto R. “It's a really hard life”: love, gender and HIV risk among male-to-female transgender persons. Cult Health Sex. 2007;9:233-245. doi:10.1080/13691050601065909.
19. Nemoto T, Operario D, Keatley J, et al. Social context of HIV risk behaviours among male-to-female transgenders of color. AIDS Care. 2004;16:724-735. doi:10.1080/09540120413331269567.
20. Stotzer RL. Violence against transgender people: a review of United States data. Aggress Violent Behav. 2009;14:170-179. doi:10.1016/j.avb.2009.01.006.
21. Garofalo R, Deleon J, Osmer E, et al. Overlooked, misunderstood and at-risk: exploring the lives and HIV risk of ethnic minority male-to-female transgender youth. J Adolesc Health. 2006;38:230-236. doi:10.1016/j.jadohealth.2005.03.023.
22. Stieglitz KA. Development, risk, and resilience of transgender youth. J Assoc Nurses AIDS Care. 2010;21:192-206. doi:10.1016/j.jana.2009.08.004.
23. Morgan SW, Stevens PE. Transgender identity development as represented by a group of female-to-male transgendered adults. Issues Ment Health Nurs. 2008;29:585-599. doi:10.1080/01612840802048782.
24. Bith-Melander P, Sheoran B, Sheth L, et al. Understanding sociocultural and psychological factors affecting transgender people of color in San Francisco. J Assoc Nurses AIDS Care. 2010;21:207-220. doi:10.1016/j.jana.2010.01.008.
25. Bauer GR, Hammond R, Travers R, et al. “I don't think this is theoretical; this is our lives”: how erasure impacts health care for transgender people. J Assoc Nurses AIDS Care. 2009;20:348-361. doi:10.1016/j.jana.2009.07.004.
26. Sanchez NF, Sanchez JP, Danoff A.Health care utilization, barriers to care, and hormone usage among male-to-female transgender persons in New York city. Am J Public Health. 2009;99:713-719. doi:10.2105/AJPH.2007.13 2035.
27. Rotheram-Borus MJ, Swendeman D, Chovnick G. The past, present, and future of HIV prevention: integrating behavioral, biomedical, and structural intervention strategies for the next generation of HIV prevention. Annu Rev Clin Psychol. 2009;5:143-167. PMCID: PMC2864227.
28. Ickovics JR. “Bundling” HIV prevention: integrating services to promote synergistic gain. Prev Med. 2008;46;222-225. PMCID: PMC2276879.
transgender; HIV; syndemics
© 2010 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Inc.
Highlight selected keywords in the article text.