JAIDS Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes:
Clinical Science: Brief Report
Rapid Emergence of Enfuvirtide Resistance in HIV-1-Infected Patients: Results of a Clonal Analysis
Lu, Jing MD*; Deeks, Steven G. MD†; Hoh, Rebecca RD†; Beatty, George MD†; Kuritzkes, Benjamin A. MPH*; Martin, Jeffrey N. MPH‡; Kuritzkes, Daniel R. MD*
From the *Section of Retroviral Therapeutics, Brigham and Women's Hospital; and Division of AIDS, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA; †Department of Medicine, University of California-San Francisco; and San Francisco General Hospital, San Francisco, CA; and ‡Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, University of California-San Francisco, San Francisco, CA.
Received for publication March 2, 2006; accepted June 15, 2006.
This work was supported in part by Public Health Service Grants (R01 AI055357, AI052745, AI055273, and K24 RR16482), the Harvard Medical School Center for AIDS Research (CFAR) Virology Core (P30 AI60354), the UCSF/Gladstone Institute of Virology and Immunology CFAR (P30 AI27763), the General Clinical Research Center at San Francisco General Hospital (M01 RR00083), the University of California University-wide AIDS Research Program (CC99-SF-001), and the Center for AIDS Prevention Studies (P30 MH62246).
Presented in part at the 12th Conference on Retroviruses and Opportunistic Infections, 2005, Boston, MA (abstract 680).
Reprints: Daniel R. Kuritzkes, MD, Section of Retroviral Therapeutics, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Room 449, 65 Landsdowne St, Cambridge, MA 02139 (e-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org).
Objectives: To study the dynamics of enfuvirtide (T-20) resistance development in HIV-1-infected subjects.
Patients and Methods: Clonal analysis of gp41 sequences was performed on serial samples obtained from HIV-1-infected subjects with early virologic failure of T-20-based regimens.
Results: Enfuvirtide resistance mutations at codons 36 to 45 in the first heptad repeat of gp41 emerged within 2 weeks in most subjects and were associated with the return of plasma HIV-1 RNA level toward baseline by weeks 4 to 8. Mutations at codons 36 (G36E, G36D, or G36S) and 38 (V38A, V38G, or V38M) were the most commonly detected resistance mutations at week 2. Mutations at codons 40 (Q40H) and 43 (N43D) were more prevalent at week 4 than at week 2 and seemed to emerge more slowly than mutations at codons 36 and 38.
Conclusions: The rapid emergence of mutations associated with T-20 resistance in the absence of a fully suppressive antiretroviral regimen demonstrates a low genetic barrier to resistance and underscores the importance of combining T-20 with other active drugs when constructing regimens for highly treatment-experienced patients.
Enfuvirtide (T-20) is a synthetic 36-amino acid oligopeptide that inhibits fusion of HIV-1 to CD4+ target cells. Entry of HIV-1 requires the antiparallel association of 2 heptad repeats (HR-1 and HR-2) of the gp41 ectodomain to form a 6-helix bundle.1 Enfuvirtide binds to the trimeric HR-1 complex, thereby inhibiting fusion and blocking virus entry.2 The drug is highly effective in suppressing HIV-1 replication in treatment-experienced patients when combined with other active antiretroviral drugs.3-5
Resistance to T-20 is mediated by amino acid substitutions within HR-1 at amino acids 36 to 45 of gp41.6,7 The substitutions most frequently associated with T-20 resistance include G36D, G36S, G36V, or G36E, V38A, V38E, or V38M, Q40H, N42T, and N43D.8-10 These mutations confer significantly reduced binding of T-20 to HR-1 and a substantial decrease in antiviral activity in vitro.9 In addition, the N126K and S138A mutations in HR-2 may contribute to reduced T-20 susceptibility.8 Viruses carrying T-20 resistance mutations show reduced viral fitness in vitro in the absence of T-20.11
Previous reports of T-20 resistance generally have been based on the results of population sequencing of viral samples obtained from subjects receiving various doses of T-20 as monotherapy or added to a failing regimen, or after long-term T-20 therapy. To our knowledge, no study has focused on the early dynamics of T-20 resistance. Because the knowledge regarding the rate at which resistance emerges provides important insights into the genetic barrier to resistance, we performed a clonal analysis of HR-1 sequences from serial plasma samples obtained within the first month of treatment.
Plasma samples were obtained from subjects enrolled in an ongoing prospective cohort study (Study of the Consequences of the Protease inhibitor Era [SCOPE]).12 All subjects provided written informed consent, and all aspects of this study were conducted according to institutional guidelines for experiments with human subjects. The subjects received T-20 (dosage, 90 mg 2 times a day) plus a background antiretroviral regimen selected on the basis of genotypic and phenotypic drug resistance testing (Monogram BioSciences, Inc, South San Francisco, CA). Thirty subjects enrolled in this study were followed up every 2 weeks for 4 weeks, and then every 4 weeks. From this cohort, we identified 11 subjects with evidence of early virologic failure, defined as lack of response or virologic rebound within the first 8 weeks of T-20 therapy. Samples from baseline and weeks 2 and 4 (or 8) were selected for detailed virologic analysis.
Cloning and Sequencing of HIV-1 gp41
Viral RNA was extracted from plasma using the QIAamp viral RNA Kit (Qiagen, Valencia, CA). A 650-base pair fragment of gp41 that included the HR-1 and HR-2 coding region (corresponding to nucleotides 7660-8310 of the Hxb2 sequence; information available at: http://hiv-web.lanl.gov) was amplified by nested reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) using QIAgen OneStep RT-PCR kit with forward primer gp41OS 5′ GAG GGA CAA TTG GAG AAG TGA ATT 3′ and reverse primer gp41OA 5′ GTG AGT ATC CCT GCC TAA CTC TAT 3′ in the RT-PCR, and forward primer gp41IS 5′ GGA GAA GTG AAT TAT ATA AAT ATA AAG 3′ and reverse primer GP41A1 5′ TTA AAC CTA CCA AGC CTC C 3′ in the second-round PCR. After a reverse transcription reaction at 50°C for 30 minutes, reverse transcriptase was inactivated at 95°C for 15 minutes. The first-round PCR was performed using the following cycling conditions: 94°C for 30 seconds, 58°C for 30 seconds, and 72°C for 45 seconds for 35 cycles, followed by incubation at 72°C for 7 minutes. To minimize sampling bias, first-round RT-PCR products were performed in quadruplicate except for samples with plasma HIV-1 RNA level of less than 1000 copies/mL. (Performing quadruplicate RT-PCRs on the samples with low virus loads would have required additional plasma, which was not available to us. Although this approach might have introduced sampling bias, all but one of these samples from which we obtained sequence data showed presence of a mixture of wild-type and mutant sequences, suggesting that at least some of the heterogeneity present in the original sample had been preserved; Fig. 1). Five microliters of each quadruplicate first-round PCR product were pooled, and 3 μL of the mixture was then carried over to quadruplicate second-round PCR. The cycling conditions for the second-round PCR were 94°C for 30 seconds, 56°C for 30 seconds, and 72°C for 45 seconds for 35 cycles, followed by incubation at 72°C for 7 minutes.
To obtain individual clones of the HR-1 and HR-2 coding region for sequence analysis, 1 μL of pooled second-round PCR product was cloned into plasmid vector pCR-2.1 (Stratagene, La Jolla, CA) using the TOPO TA cloning system (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA). A minimum of 8 clones were picked and subjected to bidirectional automated DNA sequencing using Taq DyeDeoxy Terminator cycle sequencing (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA). The DNA sequences were edited and translated using BioEdit. The phylogenetic trees constructed using PHYLIP13 and TreeView14 showed distinct clusters of viral sequences for each subject.
Cloning and sequencing of gp41 was successful in week 2 samples from 10 of 11 subjects with early failure of T-20-based therapy (the plasma HIV-1 RNA level in the week 2 sample from which gp41 could not be cloned was 146 copies/mL). The median CD4 count at the time of T-20 initiation was 8 cells/μL (interquartile range [IQR], 5-47 cells/μL), and the median plasma HIV-1 RNA level was 5.08 log10 copies/mL (IQR, 4.92-5.28 log10 copies/mL). The continuous phenotypic susceptibility score15,16 of the background optimized regimen was 1.0 (IQR, 0.5-1.5). Figure 1 shows the virologic response to therapy in these subjects. The median change in plasma HIV-1 RNA levels at weeks 2 and 4 was −1.73 (IQR, −2.19 to −0.98) and −0.58 (IQR, −1.64 to −0.31) log10 copies/mL, respectively. The median change in CD4 T-cell counts at weeks 2 and 4 were +29 (IQR, 10-41) and +26 (IQR, 14-46) cells/μL, respectively. In most cases, a 1-log10 or greater reduction in plasma HIV-1 RNA level at week 2 was followed promptly by rebound in plasma viremia.
Mutations at HR-1 positions associated with T-20 resistance were detected at week 2 in samples from 8 of 10 subjects (Fig. 2). Mutations at codon 38 (V38A, V38G, or V38M) were detected most often in these early samples (4 subjects each had at least one of these mutations). Three subjects had virus with mutations at codon 36 (G36E, G36D, or G36S). Mutations at codons 40 and 43 were detected in samples from only 1 and 2 subjects, respectively. In addition, a single clone with an I37V mutation was detected in 1 patient (patient 3514). In 1 subject (patient 3506), a mixture of mutations at codons 36 (G36D in 1 clone) and 38 (V38G in 5 clones) was found; these viruses were replaced at week 4 by a virus carrying the Q40H mutation. In a second subject (patient 3507), a mixture of V38A (3 clones) and N43D (1 clone) was present at week 2, but the V38A mutant predominated at week 4 (9/9 clones). A third subject (patient 3508) showed a mixture of Q40H (3 clones) and N43D (4 clones) mutants at week 2, which persisted at week 4 (6 and 3 clones, respectively).
No T-20-associated resistance mutations were detected in week 2 samples from 2 subjects with early treatment failure. In the case of subject 3151, all clones were wild type at codons 36 to 45 at week 2, but the N43D mutation was present in all 7 clones at week 4. In subject 3501, wild-type virus was replaced at week 2 by virus carrying the N42S polymorphism, which is not associated with T-20 resistance.7 Of note, the appearance of this polymorphism was accompanied by R46K and Q56R. At week 4, the Q40H resistance mutation was detected in 10 of 15 clones, along with persistence of N42S, R46K, and Q56R. Mutations in HR-1 outside the region of codons 36 to 45 that emerged on T-20 treatment included S35T, Q56R, and V72L. The emergence of Q56R seemed linked to S35T in clones from subject 3504, but the S35T mutation was present at baseline in clones from another subject (subject 3514), as was the V72L mutation (subject 3508).
Our results show that early treatment failure of a T-20-based salvage therapy regimen is associated with rapid emergence of T-20 resistance mutations in HR-1 of gp41. Variants carrying T-20 resistance mutations were detected at week 2, when the viral load was well below baseline levels, in samples from most subjects and became the predominant members of the viral quasispecies by week 4 in all 11 subjects. These results are consistent with previous studies of other groups10,17 but provide greater detail through clonal sequence analysis on the emergence of T-20 resistance mutations at time points soon after initiation of T-20-containing regimens. The earlier emergence of mutants with gp41 substitutions at amino acids 36 and 38 suggests that these mutants may have an initial fitness advantage over mutants with substitutions at codons 40 and 43, which tended to emerge later. It will be interesting to compare the relative fitness of these mutants by conducting growth competition experiments in the presence and absence of T-20.11
The prompt emergence of HR-1 mutations and their association with the rapid rebound of plasma HIV-1 RNA levels reflect the low genetic barrier to T-20 resistance and are consistent with the observations made with lamivudine and the nonnucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitors (NNRTI).18,19 These results also suggest that resistance to T-20, as with lamivudine and the NNRTIs, can emerge rapidly in the setting of incomplete adherence or in patients interrupting therapy.
The results of clinical trials with novel protease inhibitors, such as tipranavir and darunavir, which retain activity against many highly drug-resistant HIV-1 isolates, demonstrate the important contribution of T-20 to achieving durable virologic suppression.20,21 The antiviral activity of these T-20-protease inhibitor combinations was greatest among subjects receiving T-20 for the first time, suggesting that the previous use of T-20 in a suboptimal regimen resulted in resistance that compromised its use in a subsequent regimen. Taken together, these results reinforce the importance of administering T-20 together with other active drugs to maximize the likelihood of suppressing plasma HIV-1 RNA levels to a level below the limits of detection (ie, <50 copies/mL).
1. Chan DC, Fass D, Berger JM, et al. Core structure of gp41 from the HIV envelope glycoprotein. Cell. 1997;89:263-273.
2. Wild CT, Shugars DC, Greenwell TK, et al. Peptides corresponding to a predictive alpha-helical domain of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 gp41 are potent inhibitors of virus infection. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 1994;91:9770-9774.
3. Kilby JM, Hopkins S, Venetta T, et al. Potent suppression of HIV-1 replication in humans by T-20, a peptide inhibitor of gp41-mediated virus entry. Nat Med. 1998;4:1302-1307.
4. Lazzarin A, Clotet B, Cooper D, et al. Efficacy of enfuvirtide in patients infected with drug-resistant HIV-1 in Europe and Australia. N Engl J Med. 2003;348:2186-2195.
5. Lalezari JP, Henry K, O'Hearn M, et al. Enfuvirtide, an HIV-1 fusion inhibitor, for drug-resistant HIV infection in North and South America. N Engl J Med. 2003;348:2175-2185.
6. Rimsky LT, Shugars DC, Matthews TJ. Determinants of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 resistance to gp41-derived inhibitory peptides. J Virol. 1998;72:986-993.
7. Sista PR, Melby T, Davison D, et al. Characterization of determinants of genotypic and phenotypic resistance to enfuvirtide in baseline and on-treatment HIV-1 isolates. AIDS. 2004;18:1787-1794.
8. Xu L, Pozniak A, Wildfire A, et al. Emergence and evolution of enfuvirtide resistance following long-term therapy involves heptad repeat 2 mutations within gp41. Antimicrob Agents Chemother. 2005;49:1113-1119.
9. Mink M, Mosier SM, Janumpalli S, et al. Impact of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 gp41 amino acid substitutions selected during enfuvirtide treatment on gp41 binding and antiviral potency of enfuvirtide in vitro. J Virol. 2005;79:12447-12454.
10. Marcelin AG, Reynes J, Yerly S, et al. Characterization of genotypic determinants in HR-1 and HR-2 gp41 domains in individuals with persistent HIV viraemia under T-20. AIDS. 2004; 18:1340-1342.
11. Lu J, Sista P, Giguel F, et al. Relative replicative fitness of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 mutants resistant to enfuvirtide (T-20). J Virol. 2004;78:4628-4637.
12. Hunt PW, Martin JN, Sinclair E, et al. T cell activation is associated with lower CD4+ T cell gains in human immunodeficiency virus-infected patients with sustained viral suppression during antiretroviral therapy. J Infect Dis. 2003;187:1534-1543.
13. Felsenstein J. PHYLIP: Phylogeny Inference Package, Version 3.5c. Seattle, WA: University of Washington; 1993.
14. Page RDM. Treeview: an application to display phylogenetic trees on personal computers. Comput Appl Biosci. 1996;12:357-358.
15. Swanstrom R, Bosch RJ, Katzenstein D, et al. Weighted phenotypic susceptibility scores are predictive of the HIV-1 RNA response in protease inhibitor-experienced HIV-1-infected subjects. J Infect Dis. 2004;190:886-893.
16. Beatty G, Hunt P, Smith A, et al. A randomized pilot study comparing combination therapy plus enfuvirtide versus a treatment interruption followed by combination therapy plus enfuvirtide. Antivir Ther. 2006;11:315-319.
17. Poveda E, Rodes B, Lebel-Binay S, et al. Dynamics of enfuvirtide resistance in HIV-infected patients during and after long-term enfuvirtide salvage therapy. J Clin Virol. 2005;34:295-301.
18. Schuurman R, Nijhuis M, van Leeuwen R, et al. Rapid changes in human immunodeficiency virus type 1 RNA load and appearance of drug-resistant virus populations in persons treated with lamivudine (3TC). J Infect Dis. 1995;171:1411-1419.
19. Richman DD, Havlir D, Corbeil J, et al. Nevirapine resistance mutations of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 selected during therapy. J Virol. 1994;68:1660-1666.
20. Valdez H, McCallister S, Kohlbrenner V, et al. Tipranavir/ritonavir (TPV/r) 500 mg/200 mg bid drives week 24 viral load (VL) below 400 copies/mL when combined with a second active drug (T-20) in protease inhibitor experienced HIV+ patients. In: Program and abstracts of the 3rd IAS Conference on HIV Pathogenesis and Treatment, July 24-27, 2005; Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. Abstract We.Oa.0205.
21. Wilkin T, Haubrich R, Steinhart CR, et al. TMC114/r superior to standard of care in 3-class-experienced patients: 24-wks primary analysis of the power 2 study (C202). In: Proceedings of the 45th Interscience Conference on Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy, December 16-19, 2005; Washington, DC. Abstract H-413.
This article has been cited 37 time(s).
Antimicrobial Agents and ChemotherapyHIV-1 Resistance Mechanism to an Electrostatically Constrained Peptide Fusion Inhibitor That Is Active against T-20-Resistant StrainsAntimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy
Viruses-BaselEscape from Human Immunodeficiency Virus Type 1 (HIV-1) Entry InhibitorsViruses-Basel
Current Pharmaceutical Design
Inhibitors of HIV-1 Entry
Current Pharmaceutical Design, 19():
Current Pharmaceutical Design
Synthesized Peptide Inhibitors of HIV-1 gp41-dependent Membrane Fusion
Current Pharmaceutical Design, 19():
Current Pharmaceutical Design
Development of Small Molecule HIV-1 Fusion Inhibitors: Linking Biology to Chemistry
Current Pharmaceutical Design, 19():
Current Opinion in VirologyIs there a future for antiviral fusion inhibitors?Current Opinion in Virology
Current Opinion in VirologyHIV-1 entry inhibitors: recent development and clinical useCurrent Opinion in Virology
The current state of HIV therapy
RetrovirologyPeptide P5 (residues 628-683), comprising the entire membrane proximal region of HIV-1 gp41 and its calcium-binding site, is a potent inhibitor of HIV-1 infectionRetrovirology
Successful long-course after failure of short-course desensitization in a patient with severe hypersensitivity reaction to enfuvirtide
HIV-1 drug resistance mutations: an updated framework for the second decade of HAART
AIDS Reviews, 10(2):
Journal of Theoretical BiologyMechanism-based model of the pharmacokinetics of enfuvirtide, an HIV fusion inhibitorJournal of Theoretical Biology
Infectious Disease Clinics of North AmericaApproach to the treatment-experienced patientInfectious Disease Clinics of North America
In vivo selection by enfuvirtide of HIV type-1 env quasispecies with optimal potential for phenotypic expression of HR1 mutations
Antiviral Therapy, 14(4):
Expert Review of Anti-Infective TherapyMicrobicides and other topical agents in the prevention of HIV and sexually transmitted infectionsExpert Review of Anti-Infective Therapy
Expert Opinion on PharmacotherapyReassessment of enfuvirtide's role in the management of HIV-1 infectionExpert Opinion on Pharmacotherapy
International Journal of Antimicrobial AgentsHIV resistance and the developing worldInternational Journal of Antimicrobial Agents
Enfuvirtide cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) pharmacokinetics and potential use in defining CSFHIV-1 origin
Antiviral Therapy, 13(3):
AIDS Research and Human RetrovirusesHuman Immunodeficiency Virus Type 1 gp 41 Mutations in Proviral DNA among Antiretroviral Treatment-Naive Individuals from IndiaAIDS Research and Human Retroviruses
Clinical Infectious DiseasesAntiretroviral drug resistance testing in adult HIV-1 infection: 2008 recommendations of an International AIDS Society-USA panelClinical Infectious Diseases
Journal of VirologyCombinations of the First and Next Generations of Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) Fusion Inhibitors Exhibit a Highly Potent Synergistic Effect against Enfuvirtide-Sensitive and -Resistant HIV Type 1 StrainsJournal of Virology
AIDS Research and Human RetrovirusesShort Communication: High Polymorphism Rates in the HR1 and HR2 gp41 and Presence of Primary Resistance-Related Mutations in HIV Type 1 Circulating in Brazil: Possible Impact on Enfuvirtide EfficacyAIDS Research and Human Retroviruses
Nature Reviews Drug DiscoveryThe design of drugs for HIV and HCVNature Reviews Drug Discovery
Current Opinion in Investigational Drugs
Novel treatment options for pediatric HIV infection
Current Opinion in Investigational Drugs, 9(2):
Journal of VirologyHR-2 Mutations in Human Immunodeficiency Virus Type 1 gp41 Restore Fusion Kinetics Delayed by HR-1 Mutations That Cause Clinical Resistance to EnfuvirtideJournal of Virology
Antimicrobial Agents and ChemotherapyLong-Lasting Enfuvirtide Carrier Pentasaccharide Conjugates with Potent Anti-Human Immunodeficiency Virus Type 1 ActivityAntimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy
Current Pharmaceutical Design
Peptide-Based Inhibitors of the HIV Envelope Protein and Other Class I Viral Fusion Proteins
Current Pharmaceutical Design, 16(9):
Computational Statistics & Data AnalysisTwo-way Bayesian hierarchical phylogenetic models: An application to the co-evolution of gp120 and gp41 during and after enfuvirtide treatmentComputational Statistics & Data Analysis
Journal of VirologyClinical resistance to enfuvirtide does not affect susceptibility of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 to other classes of entry inhibitorsJournal of Virology
Molecular TherapyFoamy virus vectors expressing anti-HIV transgenes efficiently block HIV-1 replicationMolecular Therapy
Journal of VirologyHuman immunodeficiency virus type 1 variants resistant to first- and second-version fusion inhibitors and cytopathic in ex vivo human lymphoid tissueJournal of Virology
Antiviral ResearchSynonymous mutations in stem-loop III of Rev responsive elements enhance HIV-1 replication impaired by primary mutations for resistance to enfuvirtideAntiviral Research
AIDS Research and Human RetrovirusesAnalysis of HIV type 1 gp41 sequences in diverse HIV type 1 strainsAIDS Research and Human Retroviruses
AIDS Research and Human Retroviruses
Continued evolution in gp41 after interruption of enfuvirtide in subjects with advanced HIV type 1 disease
AIDS Research and Human Retroviruses, 22():
Viruses-BaselApproaches for Identification of HIV-1 Entry Inhibitors Targeting gp41 PocketViruses-Basel
JAIDS Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency SyndromesViral Dynamics and In Vivo Fitness of HIV-1 in the Presence and Absence of EnfuvirtideJAIDS Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes
enfuvirtide; drug resistance; HIV-1; fusion inhibitors
© 2006 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Inc.
Highlight selected keywords in the article text.