International Journal of Rehabilitation Research:
Sensitivity of qualitative and quantitative spasticity measures to clinical treatment with cryotherapy
ALLISON, Stephen C.1 *; ABRAHAM, Lawrence D.2
1Academy of Health Sciences, Fort Sam Houston, TX 78234, USA 2The University of Texas at Austin, TX 78712, USA
*Address for correspondence: Physical Therapy Branch, AMEDD Center and School, Fort Sam Houston, TX 78234, USA.
This study examined the extent to which a battery of tests could detect a reduction of plantarflexor spasticity resulting from cryotherapy. The tests included a traditional qualitative spasticity scale, three potential quantitative spasticity measures and a measure of voluntary ankle muscle function. Twenty-six adult traumatic-brain-injured subjects were examined; these included 22 males and 4 females. The mean age was 28.15 years (range: 18–57, SD 10.78). The five tests were performed in random sequence on both ankles of each subject, before and after a 20 minute cold pack application to the calf. Tests were: modified Ashworth scale (MAS) scoring; H-reflex testing with and without dorsiflexor contraction (Hdf/Hctrl ratio); H-reflex testing with and without Achilles tendon vibration (Hvib/Hctrl ratio); reflex threshold angle (RTA) and timed toe tapping (TTT). Cryotherapy resulted in lowered MAS scores consistent with a reduction in spasticity. Doubly multivariate repeated measures ANOVA revealed a significant difference (F = 24.16, P < 0.001) in test scores between the pre- and post-cryotherapy test batteries. Significant pre- and post-cryotherapy differences (P ≤ 0.03) for all dependent measures contributed to the main effect for cryotherapy. However, among the potential quantitative measures of spasticity only the RTA test demonstrated appropriate sensitivity to the reduction in spasticity. In spite of spasticity reduction, TTT performance was impaired following muscle cooling. Failure of the H-reflex ratios to show a reduction consistent with reduced spasticity was attributed to competing alpha and gamma motoneuron effects resulting from peripheral cooling.
Sensitivität von qualitativen und quantitativen Massen der Spastizität nach klinischer Behandlung mit Kältetherapie
In dieser Studie wurde untersucht, inwieweit eine Testbatterie die Reduktion der Plantarflexorspastizität infolge einer Kältetherapie erfassen kann. Diese Tests umfaßten eine traditionelle qualitative Spastizitätsskala, drei potentielle quantitative Spastizitätsmaße und ein Maß der willkürlichen Muskelfunktion im Knöchelbereich. Es wurden 26 Patienten mit traumatischen Hirnverletzungen untersucht, 22 Männer und 4 Frauen. Das mittlere Alter lag bei 28,15 Jahren (Bereich: 18–57, SD 10,78). Die fünf Tests wurden in willkürlicher Reihenfolge an beiden Knöcheln der Patienten vor und nach 20minütiger Anwendung eines kalten Umschlags an den Waden vorgenommen. Folgende Tests kamen zum Einsatz: modifizierte Ashworth-Skala (MAS); H-Reflex-Prüfung mit und ohne Dorsalflexorkontraktion (Hdf/Hctrl-Verhältnis); H-Reflex-Prüfung mit und ohne Achillessehnenvibration (Hvib/Hctrl-Verhältnis); Muskeldehnungsreflexwinkel (Reflex Threshold Angle - RTA) und Zehenklopftest (Timed Toe Tapping - TTT). Die Kältetherapie bewirkte eine Senkung der Scores auf der MAS-Skala, die mit der Reduktion der Spastizität im Einklang stand. Die doppelt mehrdimensionale Varianzanalyse mit wiederholten Messungen ergab einen signifikanten Unterschied (F =24,16;P <0,001) für die Test-Scores zwischen den Testbatterien vor und nach der Kältetherapie. Die signifikanten Unterschiede vor und nach der Kältetherapie (P ≤0,03) für alle abhängigen Maße machten die Hauptwirkung der Kältetherapie aus. Unter den potentiellen quantitativen Maßen der Spastizität zeigte nur der RTA-Test eine angemessene Sensitivität gegenüber der Reduktion der Spastizität. Trotz der Verminderung der Spastizität war die TTT-Leistung nach der Muskelkühlung gestört. Die Unfähigkeit der H-Reflex-Quotienten, eine Reduktion nachzuweisen, die der verminderten Spastizität entspricht, wurde den aus der peripheren Kühlung herrührenden kompetitiven Alpha- und Gamma-Motoneuronenwirkungen zugeschrieben.
Sensibilité des mesures qualitatives et quantitatives de spasticité pour l’évaluation du traitement par cryothérapie
Cette étude a examiné la sensibilité d'une batterie de tests pour l’évaluation de l'effet de la cryothérapie sur la spasticité de la flexion plantaire. Les tests comportaient une échelle classique d’évaluation qualitative de la spasticité, trois mesures quantitatives potentielles de la spasticité et une mesure de la fonction musculaire volontaire de la cheville. La population de l’étude était composée de 26 adultes ayant eu un traumatisme cérébral, dont 22 hommes et 4 femmes, âgés en moyenne de 28,15 ans (extrêmes : 18–57, ET : 10,78). On a effectué chez chaque sujet les cinq tests selon une séquence randomisée sur les deux chevilles, avant et après application d'une poche de glace pendant 20 minutes sur le mollet. Les tests étaient les suivants : échelle d'Ashworth modifiée (EAM), évaluation du réflexe H avec et sans contraction des fléchisseurs dorsaux (rapport Hfd/Hctrl), évaluation du réflexe avec et sans vibration du tendon d'Achille (rapport Hvib/Hctrl), angle limite de déclenchement du réflexe (ALD) et percussion synchronisée des orteils (PSO). La cryothérapie a provoqué une diminution des scores EAM corroborant une diminution de la spasticité. L'analyse ANOVA sur mesures répétées à variables multiples a révélé une différence significative (F = 24,16, P < 0,001) des scores des tests avant et après cryothérapie. Les différences significatives avant et après cryothérapie (P ≤ 0,03) observées pour toutes les mesures dépendantes ont contribué à l'effet principal de la cryothérapie. Toutefois, parmi les mesures quantitatives potentielles de la spasticité, seul le test ALD a montré une sensibilité suffisante pour mettre en évidence la diminution de la spasticité. En effet, le test PSO a été perturbé par le refroidissement musculaire résultant de la cryothérapie et les rapports de réflexe H n'ont pas été sensibles, ce qui a été attribué à des effets antagonistes des motoneurones alpha et gamma résultant du refroidissement périphérique.
Sensibilidad de las medidas cualitativas y cuantitativas de la espasticidad al tratamiento clı`nico con crioterapia
En este estudio se examinó hasta qué punto es posible detectar mediante una baterı`a de pruebas una reducción de la espasticidad del flexor plantar después de crioterapia. Se utilizaron como pruebas una escala tradicional cualitativa de espasticidad, tres medidas cuantitativas de la espasticidad y una medida de la función voluntaria muscular del tobillo. Se examinó a 26 sujetos adultos, 22 varones y 4 mujeres, con lesiones cerebrales traumáticas. La media de edad era de 28,15 años (rango 18–57, DE 10,78). Las cinco pruebas se aplicaron en una secuencia aleatoria en los dos tobillos de cada sujeto, antes y después de la colocación de una bolsa frı`a en la pantorrilla durante 20 minutos. Las pruebas fueron, concretamente, la escala de Ashworth modificada (MAS), la prueba del reflejo-H con contracción del flexor dorsal y sin ella (proporción Hcf/Hctrl), la prueba del reflejo-H con vibración del tendón de Aquiles y sin ella (proporción Hvib/Hctrl), la prueba del ángulo umbral del reflejo (RTA) y la prueba de golpeteo cronometrado del dedo (TTT). La crioterapia provocó una reducción de la puntuación de MAS coherente con una reducción de la espasticidad. Medidas repetidas multivaribles ANOVA realizadas por duplicado revelaron una diferencia significativa (F =24,16, P< 0,001) en las puntuaciones entre la baterı`a de pruebas anterior y posterior a la crioterapia. Hubo diferencias significativas entre la fase anterior y posterior a la crioterapia (P ≤0,03) en todas las medidas dependientes, que contribuyeron al efecto principal de la crioterapia. Sin embargo, de las medidas cuantitativas de la espasticidad, sólo la prueba del RTA demostró una sensibilidad apropiada a la reducción de la espasticidad. A pesar de la reducción de la espasticidad, el resultado del TTT se alteró con el enfriamiento del músculo. La no demostración, por parte de los cocientes del reflejo-H, de una reducción coherente con la reducción de la espasticidad se atribuyó a los efectos competitivos de las motoneuronas alfa y gamma causados por el enfriamiento periférico.
Numerous qualitative and quantitative measures have been proposed for the measurement of spasticity (Katz and Rymer, 1989; Pierrot-Deseilligny, 1990; Allison and Abraham, 1995). Clinicians and researchers have expressed dissatisfaction with existing ordinal spasticity scales, which lack precision, rely on clinical judgements, and may not have generalizable reliability. This dissatisfaction has fuelled the search for quantitative spasticity measures.
If qualitative and proposed quantitative spasticity measures are to be useful for patient management decisions, such measures must be able to detect differences in spasticity brought about by clinical treatments. One such clinical treatment for spasticity is cryotherapy. Muscle cooling was chosen as the treatment for this study because of its frequent mention in spasticity treatment literature, for its relatively negligible side effects, and for its ease of application. The purpose of this study was to test the sensitivity of qualitative and quantitative measures for spasticity by applying those measures before and after a reduction in spasticity brought about by cryotherapy.
Several authors have used qualitative ordinal scales to assess the severity of spasticity by applying a manual stretch to a muscle group and scoring the resistance encountered (Ashworth, 1964; Bohannon and Smith, 1987; Peacock and Staudt, 1991; Allison et al., 1996). Despite the limitations of these scales and a recognized need for newer, more quantitative spasticity measures, Katz and Rymer (1989) stated that these qualitative scales are the ‘present yardstick against which newer, more exact methods must be compared’.
Some potential quantitative spasticity measures have been investigated. Tendon vibration will reduce the amplitude of H-reflexes (Gillies et al., 1969; Lance et al., 1973) caused by presynaptic Ia inhibition (Iles and Roberts, 1986; Pierrot-Deseilligny, 1990), but this inhibition is impaired in patients with spasticity (Hagbarth, 1973; Milanov, 1992a). Some investigators (Nance et al., 1989; Milanov, 1992b) have used the ratio of the H-wave evoked during vibration to the H-wave at rest (Hvib/Hctrl) as a measure of spasticity. Others have studied the sensitivity of H-reflexes to reciprocal inhibition associated with voluntary antagonistic muscle contraction. Leonard et al. (1990) and Boorman et al. (1992) defined reciprocal inhibition as the ratio of the soleus H-reflex amplitude during dorsiflexion to the H-reflex at rest (Hdf/Hctrl), and found deficits in patients with spasticity.
A third quantitative measure that discriminates between spastic and non-spastic muscle groups has been called the reflex threshold angle (RTA), stretch reflex angle or stretch reflex threshold by investigators (Powers et al., 1988, 1989 Katz and Rymer, 1989; Katz et al., 1992; Levin and Hui-Chan, 1993; Wolf et al., 1996). The test consists of stretching spastic muscle groups and recording the angle at which a simultaneous rise in torque and/or EMG activity occurs during the imposed stretch. Allison and Abraham (1995) demonstrated significant correlations among the modified Ashworth scale (MAS) and the Hdf/Hctrl ratio, the Hvib/Hctrl, the RTA and a simple functional test called timed toe tapping (TTT). Although these quantitative measures show promise as potentially useful measures of spasticity, only the RTA has been used to assess the efficacy of spasticity treatment (Dewald et al., 1996; Brouwer et al., 1998).
Cold applications have been used for some time to reduce spasticity clinically. Bassett and Lake (1958) reported three case studies of patients with UMN lesions, noting reduced clonus and spasticity for both cold water immersion and crushed ice wrapped in wet towels. Inasmuch as no spasticity measurements were reported, the assessments of reduced spasticity were apparently based on clinical judgment.
Electromyographic measurements have shown clonus to be reduced or abolished with local ice applications over the spastic muscles (Knutsson, 1970; Miglietta, 1973). Overall resistance to stretch has also been shown to decrease with ice treatment (Knutsson, 1970). Price and Lehmann (1990) reported passive (non-reflexive) stiffness to increase with cold application, and they attributed the overall decrease in stiffness with cryotherapy to a reduced stretch reflex response. This result is in harmony with the findings of reduced Achilles tendon reflex (Petajan and Watts, 1962) and reduced H-reflexes (Knutsson and Mattson, 1969) with cooling. Functional improvements consistent with spasticity reduction have also been reported with cooling. Knutsson (1970) studied the kinematics of spastic gait before and after cooling and observed increased dorsiflexion in late swing phase, consistent with a reduction in spasticity in the antagonistic spastic plantarflexors.
Miglietta (1973) concluded that reduced clonus was dependent on reducing the sensitivity of the muscle spindles, noting over the duration of the cryotherapy application that clonus did not abate until intramuscular temperature dropped. Indeed, Mense (1978) observed a strong depression of cat Ia activity with cold application. In contrast, type II fibers were found to be more active and Ib fibers were largely unaffected by cold.
Not all authors, however, have reported consistent findings with cooling. Urbscheit et al. (1971) found spastic patients to respond in unpredictable ways when ankle jerks and H-reflexes were measured before and after cooling. Bell and Lehmann (1987) found no reduction in H-reflexes or tendon reflexes after cooling in normal subjects. Price et al. (1993) reported a significant reduction of spasticity during cryotherapy for 11 of 17 subjects with significant spasticity levels. However, they also found a significant increase in spasticity for two of these subjects. Chiara et al. (1998) found that a cold bath slightly increased spasticity in subjects with multiple sclerosis. These contrary findings underscore the possibility that the underlying neural and mechanical mechanisms are complex and variable between spastic patients.
Cooling time required to reduce spasticity is controversial. Miglietta (1964) reported a reduction in clonus frequency within one minute of ice water immersion. Lehmann and deLateur (1990) argued that cryotherapy must be applied long enough to allow for intramuscular cooling: typically 20–30 minutes but dependent on the thickness of subcutaneous fat. This suggestion was based on Miglietta's (1973) finding of no reduction in clonus before intramuscular cooling, plus the suspicion that reduced spindle sensitivity with cold is the mechanism underlying the reduced stretch reflex with cooling (Ottoson, 1965; Mense, 1978). Bell and Lehmann (1987) measured cooling of the medial gastrocnemius with an intramuscular temperature probe during cryotherapy with an ice/water pack. They found only a slight reduction in intramuscular temperature (to about 31 °C) after 20 minutes of cooling. However, using ice water immersion, Miglietta (1973) measured lateral gastrocnemius intramuscular temperature at 15 °C after only 10 minutes of cooling.
The weighted linear composite variable formed by the following five dependent variables is significantly different when pre- and post-cryotherapy measures are compared:
1. Modified Ashworth scale (MAS) scores
2. Timed toe tapping (TTT) scores
3. Ratio of maximum soleus H-wave amplitudes measured with and without vibration to the Achilles tendon (Hvib/Hctrl ratio)
4. Ratio of maximum soleus H-wave amplitudes measured with and without dorsiflexor muscle activation (Hdf/Hctrl ratio)
5. Reflex threshold angle (RTA): the ankle angle at which a reflexive burst in EMG activity begins during an imposed plantarflexor stretch.
Material and methods
Twenty-six adult traumatic brain injured (TBI) subjects were examined in this study. These included 22 males and 4 females. The mean age was 28.15 years (range: 18–57, SD 10.78). Following physician approval, subjects were selected from a pool of volunteers at the Healthcare Rehabilitation Center in Austin, TX. Inclusion criteria were:
1. Age 18 or older
2. History of TBI at least six months prior to testing
3. Stable medical condition
4. Adequate range of motion at the ankle (zero degrees dorsiflexion to 40 degrees plantar flexion) without excessive inversion or hypersensitive tactile plantar reflexes
5. Ability to understand and follow instructions to relax the ankle and sit in a wheelchair for about one hour
6. Rancho Los Amigos cognitive scale score of 7 or 8
7. Absence of Raynaud's syndrome, peripheral vascular disease and pregnancy
Patients were interviewed to determine etiology, characteristics and duration of deficits. All subjects provided informed consent according to the guidelines set forth by the Department of Health and Human Services concerning protection of human subjects.
This study employed a doubly multivariate repeated measures experimental design with the dependent measures taken before and after the experimental treatment. Each of the 26 subjects received a battery of tests applied to both ankles, resulting in 52 cases for the analyses. The within-subjects factors were cryotherapy (with two levels: pre and post) and ankle side (two levels: right and left); dependent measures were: MAS scores, TTT scores, Hvib/Hctrl and Hdf/Hctrl ratios and RTA measures.
data and instrumentation
A full description of the data collection apparatus and testing procedures has been provided in a previous report (Allison and Abraham, 1995); a brief description is presented here. The instrumentation included electrical stimulation equipment (Grass Instruments model S48D), electromyographic recording apparatus (Iomed, Inc.), a vibrator (Panasonic model EV242W), an oscilloscope (Tektronix model 5111A), a torque motor (Parker Compumotor Inc., model 1030B) and a Macintosh LC II computer with an analog-to-digital converter board (LabLC) and controlling software (LabView version 2.2, National Instruments). Subjects were seated in an adjustable chair with armrests and headrest, and the apparatus was adjusted such that the hip joint was flexed to 80o and the knee to 60o.
The sequence of tests was randomized for each subject to avoid order effects. The one exception was that Hctrl was measured before Hvib or Hdf because the targeted range of M-wave amplitudes for the latter two tests was determined during Hctrl testing.
Subjects removed shoes and socks and assumed a sitting position. The investigator assigned MAS scores after passively moving the ankle from a position of full plantarflexion to full dorsiflexion. The investigator performed five to eight repetitions of the ankle movement before assigning a score based on the descriptions in Table 1.
With the resting subjects seated and the vibration and electrical stimulation apparatus prepared, the torque motor was used to position the footplate such that the ankle was in a neutral (zero degrees dorsiflexion) position. Stimulating intensity was adjusted to evoke the largest H-wave amplitude available in the presence of a measurable M-wave. Ten second intervals separated the electrical stimuli used to evoke the H-reflexes, to allow for H-reflex baselines to return to normal (Hugon, 1973; Lance et al., 1973). A set of ten H-waves was averaged to provide the Hctrl value for analysis.
Vibration was applied to the Achilles tendon at a point 5 cm proximal to its insertion on the calcaneus. Following 20 seconds of vibration, an H-reflex (Hvib) was elicited with an electrical stimulus intensity adjusted to elicit an M-wave amplitude within the range of values for M-waves observed during the collection of the Hctrl measures. A set of ten H-waves was averaged to provide the Hvib value for analysis.
To obtain the Hdf measure, subjects first performed a maximal voluntary contraction (MVC) of the dorsiflexors with the foot neutrally positioned by the torque motor. Using the oscilloscope display of the torque signal as a guide, the subjects then provided dorsiflexion contractions of 75% MVC at the same ankle position. Again, electrical stimulus intensity was adjusted to elicit M-wave amplitudes within the range of M-waves amplitudes observed with Hctrl measures, and a set of ten H-waves was averaged to provide the Hdf value for analysis.
The torque motor provided a ramp stretch of the triceps surae by rotating the ankle from 40 degrees plantarflexion to zero degrees neutral at an average angular velocity of 235 degrees per second. This procedure was repeated ten times, with a 20 second rest between repetitions. The RTA was identified as the ankle angle at which a reflexive burst in EMG activity began during the imposed plantarflexor stretch (Figure 1). The ten measurements of RTA were averaged to provide one representative RTA score for each ankle.
Timed toe tapping scores
While sitting, subjects began tapping the toes on a wedge as rapidly as possible, alternating between dorsiflexion and plantarflexion ankle motions. The 15 second test period was timed with a stopwatch and the number of times the toes tapped on the wedge was recorded with an electronic counter. The highest TTT score from three trials was entered into the analyses.
After all the above measures had been completed, the triceps surae muscle group was cooled by a 20 minute application of a gel-filled cold pack (at 10 to 15 degrees Fahrenheit), placed against the skin of the posterior calf. The cold pack was molded to conform closely to the contours of the calf, and Velcro straps secured the cold pack in place. During cryotherapy, the subject remained in the chair used for data collection and kept the limbs relaxed.
Immediately after the 20 minute period of cryotherapy, the battery of tests was repeated. The post-treatment sequence of tests was also randomized to avoid order effects. Post-cryotherapy testing was completed within 25–30 minutes following removal of the cold pack. In order to test for post-cryotherapy warming effects, scores for each post-cryotherapy spasticity measure were compared for two groups: those tested earliest in the sequence and those tested last. Paired t-tests with alpha level set to 0.05 revealed no significant differences between earliest- and last-tested scores for any of the variables, indicating that the effects of cryotherapy did not significantly dissipate during the 25–30 minutes required for post-cryotherapy testing.
Descriptive statistics were calculated for subject and experimental variables. The RTA was identified as the joint angle at which a burst of soleus EMG activity indicated a reflex response to the stretch. Average Hvib/Hctrl and Hdf/Hctrl ratios were calculated after peak-to-peak H-wave measurements were obtained for the H-reflexes evoked under the three conditions (at rest, vibration and isometric dorsiflexion). M-wave stability under the three conditions was assessed by one-way analyses of variance (ANOVA) using the software package Microsoft Excel, version 4.0. SPSS for Windows, release 8.0 was used to perform a multivariate repeated measures ANOVA for the four ratio scale variables (Hvib/Hctrl, Hdf/Hctrl, RTA and TTT). Post-hoc analyses consisted of paired t-tests (pre-cryotherapy versus post-cryotherapy) for the ratio scale variables and a Wilcoxon signed-ranks test for the ordinal scale variable (MAS). The alpha level was set to 0.10 for the ANOVA and the post-hoc procedures.
MAS scores ranged from zero to three but the distribution was positively skewed. Lowered post-cryotherapy MAS scores demonstrated an effective reduction in spasticity for 28 of the 52 cases. The remaining 24 cases had no change in pre- to post-cryotherapy MAS scores. Post-cryotherapy MAS scores were lowered by one category in 27 cases and by two categories in one case. Mode and median for pre-cryotherapy MAS scores were both one; post-cryotherapy MAS score median and mode were both zero. Frequencies of cases for each MAS score before and after cooling are presented in Figure 2. Descriptive statistics for the other dependent measures are displayed in Table 2.
The multivariate repeated measures ANOVA revealed a significant difference in test scores between the pre- and post-cryotherapy test batteries. No significant effects were observed for ankle side or the interaction between sidedness and cryotherapy. The MANOVA source table is presented as Table 3. Significant pre- and post-cryotherapy differences for all dependent measures contributed to the main effect for cryotherapy, as shown in Table 4.
M-wave amplitudes were consistently stable across conditions, evidenced by F-ratios below the critical F-value of 3.35 in all 104 comparisons for the 26 subjects included in the analyses. One additional subject was measured but not included in the analyses because of unstable M-waves.
The significant main effect for cryotherapy was expected inasmuch as the treatment is used to reduce spasticity. The most pertinent question for this study, however, was not whether the main effect would be significant, but how each dependent measure would contribute to the effect. Analysis of individual contributions from the dependent measures showed test scores were affected by cold, but not necessarily in a direction associated with reduced spasticity.
Post-hoc analyses revealed that all five dependent measures contributed to the main effect for cryotherapy. However, only two of the five dependent measures (MAS and RTA) showed changes in the anticipated directions; that is, they demonstrated appropriate sensitivity to the reduction in spasticity resulting from cryotherapy. MAS scores were closer to zero (normal tone) after cooling, indicating a reduction in spasticity (Figure 2). RTA scores were similarly closer to the zero degrees (neutral) ankle position after cooling; thus, the EMG reflex response occurred later in the stretch, after greater angular excursion compared to RTA scores pre-cryotherapy (Figure 1).
The effect size for cryotherapy as measured by RTA was so small (mean difference = 1.5 degrees) that its clinical relevance may be questionable. However, our aim was not to demonstrate the effectiveness of cryotherapy for spasticity treatment. Rather, we wished to discover whether quantitative measures such as RTA might be sensitive enough to detect changes in spasticity brought about by a treatment assumed to be effective. The ability of the RTA measure to detect such a small treatment effect underscores a potential advantage of using a quantitative spasticity measure in other circumstances where qualitative ordinal scales may not be sensitive to small changes.
Elevations in the post-cryotherapy H-reflex ratios might be mistakenly interpreted to indicate an increase in spasticity, particularly given the demonstrated positive correlations between each of these ratios and MAS scores (Allison and Abraham, 1995). Rather, this result suggests that presynaptic and reciprocal inhibition, the underlying mechanisms tested by the H-reflex ratio tests, are not improved by cryotherapy although other measures show that spasticity is reduced. Indeed, the significant elevations of the H-reflex ratios suggest that these two inhibitory mechanisms are further impaired by cryotherapy. These contrary results underscore the complex nature of spasticity and the competing influence of central and peripheral mechanisms.
Elevation of the H-reflex ratios following cryotherapy may be explained by investigations into reflex modulation by cutaneous afferents responding to cold. Summarizing numerous studies of these effects, Michlovitz (1990) concluded that cold facilitates alpha-motoneurons and inhibits gamma-motoneurons. Consequently, for these effects to result in spasticity reduction, the net effect of gamma inhibition must exceed that of alpha facilitation. If these mechanisms operate simultaneously, spasticity tests which incorporate muscle spindle activation (MAS and RTA) would be sensitive to gamma inhibition and would reveal cold-induced spasticity reduction; H-reflex tests of the monosynaptic reflex arc that bypass the spindles would detect only the alpha facilitation, resulting in elevated H-reflexes.
The usual inhibitory effects of vibration and voluntary antagonist muscle activation might well be diminished if cutaneous afferents respond to cold by facilitating the alpha motoneurons and inhibiting the gamma motoneurons. Reduced gamma input to the muscle spindles would render them less sensitive to vibration, resulting in fewer action potentials transmitted via the Ia afferents and consequently less presynaptic inhibition. A facilitated antagonist alpha pool would be closer to firing threshold, requiring less descending facilitation for activation; reduced descending input to the dorsiflexors would also mean less reciprocal inhibition of the plantarflexors.
It may be counterintuitive to think of a simultaneous reduction in spasticity and a facilitation of the alpha motoneuron pool. However, since spasticity is defined as an increased sensitivity to stretch, the manifestation of spasticity depends on an intricate interplay between peripheral and central mechanisms. If there is strong central inhibition of the gamma motoneuron pool, the muscle spindles in the peripheral muscle may be so insensitive that even a vigorous stretch will fail to elicit much afferent activity in the Ia pathway. Consequently, the alpha pool responsible for reflex activation of a stretched muscle may fail to respond to stretch even if its neurons are depolarized near threshold by prior facilitation. Therefore, cryotherapy may reduce spasticity (as tested by mechanically stimulating desensitized peripheral receptors) even while further contributing to dysfunction in the central mechanisms potentially responsible for spasticity in the resting state. In light of these considerations, findings from this study are consistent with the idea of competing alpha and gamma effects when cutaneous afferents respond to cold.
Competing effects of cold may also have been responsible for the lowered post-cryotherapy TTT scores. Although it seemed reasonable to propose that a reduction in spasticity might enhance motor control and improve performance on a task requiring coordination, the speed required for the TTT test was probably impaired by muscle and nerve cooling. Cold is known to increase joint stiffness and retard joint motion (Hecox, 1994). If the speed impairment was greater than the improvement in coordination, the net effect would be poorer TTT performance. Furthermore, slower nerve conduction velocities resulting from cryotherapy (Denys, 1991) and the consequent retardation of muscle activations may have combined to overshadow any TTT advantage gained by spasticity reduction.
Of the battery of potential quantitative measures of spasticity only the RTA test demonstrated appropriate sensitivity to spasticity reduction resulting from cryotherapy. The RTA measure demonstrated sufficient sensitivity to detect even a small treatment effect. Future studies of other spasticity interventions, particularly those thought to enhance spinal cord inhibitory mechanisms, should show whether tests such as RTA, Hdf/Hctrl and Hvib/Hctrl might be useful in documenting effectiveness of spasticity treatments.
The authors wish to thank Mr Christopher Stanford for technical assistance with the data collection apparatus and with software development. Financial support for this study was provided by Healthcare Rehabilitation America, Inc. Portions of this work have been presented orally at professional meetings. The opinions or assertions contained herein are the private views of the authors and are not to be construed as official or as reflecting the views of the Department of the Army or the Department of Defense.
1. Allison, S.C. and Abraham, L.D. ( 1995). Correlation of quantitative measures with the modified Ashworth scale in the assessment of plantarflexor spasticity in patients with traumatic brain injury. Journal of Neurology 242:699–706.
2. Allison, S.C., Abraham, L.D. and Petersen, C.L. ( 1996). Reliability of the modified Ashworth scale in the assessment of plantarflexor muscle spasticity in patients with traumatic brain injury. International Journal of Rehabilitation Research 19:67–78.
3. Ashworth, B. ( 1964). Preliminary trial of carisoprodol in multiple sclerosis. Practitioner 192:540–542.
4. Bassett, S.W. and Lake, B.S. ( 1958). Use of cold applications in the management of spasticity: Report of three cases. Physical Therapy Reviews 38:333–334.
5. Bell, K.R. and Lehmann, J.F. ( 1987). Effect of cooling on H- and T-reflexes in normal subjects. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 68:490–493.
6. Bohannon, R.W. and Smith, M.B. ( 1987). Interrater reliability of a modified Ashworth scale of muscle spasticity. Physical Therapy 67:206–207.
7. Boorman, G.I., Becker, W.J. and Lee, R.G. ( 1992). Impaired ‘natural’ reciprocal inhibition in patients with spinal spasticity. Abstracts of the Society of Neuroscience 18:1408.
8. Brouwer, B., Wheeldon, R.K., Stradiotto-Parker, N. and Allum, J. ( 1998). Reflex excitability and isometric force production in cerebral palsy: the effect of serial casting. Developmental Medicine and Child Neurology 40 ( 3):168–175.
9. Chiara, T., Carlos Jr., J., Martin, D., Miller, R. and Nadeau, S. ( 1998). Cold effect on oxygen uptake, perceived exertion, and spasticity in patients with multiple sclerosis. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 79:523–528.
10. Denys, E.H. ( 1991). The influence of temperature in clinical neurophysiology. Muscle and Nerve 14:795–811.
11. Dewald, J.P., Given, J.D. and Rymer, W.Z. ( 1996). Long-lasting reductions of spasticity induced by skin electrical stimulation. IEEE Transactions on Rehabilitation Engineering 4 ( 4):231–242.
12. Gillies, J.D., Lance, J.W., Neilson, P.D. and Tassinari, C.A. ( 1969). Presynaptic inhibition of the monosynaptic reflex by vibration. Journal of Physiology 205:329–339.
13. Hagbarth, K.E. ( 1973). The effect of muscle vibration in normal man and in patients with motor disorders. in Desmedt, J.E. (Ed), New Developments in Electromyography and Clinical Neurophysiology: Vol. 3 Human Reflexes, Pathophysiology of Motor Systems, Methodology of Human Reflexes, Basel: S. Karger:428–443.
14. Hecox, B. ( 1994). Clinical effects of thermal modalities. in Hecox, B., Mehreteab, T.A. and Weisberg, J. (Eds), Physical Agents: A Comprehensive Text for Physical Therapists, Norwalk, CT: Appleton & Lange:115–124.
15. Hugon, M. ( 1973). Proprioceptive reflexes and the H-reflex: Methodology of the Hoffmann reflex in man. in Desmedt, J.E. (Ed), New Developments in Electromyography and Clinical Neurophysiology: Vol. 3 Human Reflexes, Pathophysiology of Motor Systems, Methodology of Human Reflexes, Basel: S. Karger:277–293.
16. Iles, J.F. and Roberts, R.C. ( 1986). Presynaptic inhibition of monosynaptic reflexes in the lower limbs of subjects with upper motoneuron disease. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgury, and Psychiatry 49:937–944.
17. Katz, R.T., Roval, G.P., Brait, C. and Rymer, W.Z. ( 1992). Objective quantification of spastic hypertonia: Correlation with clinical findings. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 73:339–347.
18. Katz, R.T. and Rymer, W.Z. ( 1989). Spastic hypertonia: Mechanisms and measurement. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 70:144–155.
19. Knutsson, E. ( 1970). Topical cryotherapy in spasticity. Scandinavian Journal of Rehabilitation Medicine 2:159–163.
20. Knutsson, E. and Mattson, E. ( 1969). Effects of local cooling on monosynaptic reflexes in man. Scandinavian Journal of Rehabilitation Medicine 1:126–132.
21. Lance, J.W., Burke, D. and Andrews, C.J. ( 1973). The reflex effects of muscle vibration. in Desmedt, J.E. (Ed), New Developments in Electromyography and Clinical Neurophysiology: Vol. 3 Human Reflexes, Pathophysiology of Motor Systems, Methodology of Human Reflexes, Basel: S. Karger:444–462.
22. Lehmann, J.F. and deLateur, B.J. ( 1990). Cryotherapy. in Lehmann, J.F. (Ed), Therapeutic Heat and Cold, 4th edn, Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins.
23. Leonard, C.T., Mortiani, T., Hirschfeld, H. and Forssberg, H. ( 1990). Deficits in reciprocal inhibition of children with cerebral palsy as revealed by H reflex testing. Developmental Medicine and Child Neurology 32:974–984.
24. Levin, M.F. and Hui-Chan, C. ( 1993). Are H and stretch reflexes in hemiparesis reproducible and correlated with spasticity?. Journal of Neurology 240:63–71.
25. Mense, S. ( 1978). Effects of temperature on discharges of muscle spindles and tendon organs. Pflugers Archiv 374:159–166.
26. Michlovitz, S.L. ( 1990). Cryotherapy: The use of cold as a therapeutic agent. in Michlovitz, S.L. (Ed), Thermal Agents in Rehabilitation, Philadelphia: F.A. Davis Company:63–87.
27. Miglietta, O. ( 1964). Electromyographic characteristics of clonus and influence of cold. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 45:508–512.
28. Miglietta, O. ( 1973). Action of cold on spasticity. American Journal of Physical Medicine 52:198–205.
29. Milanov, I. ( 1992). A comparative study of methods for estimation of presynaptic inhibition. Journal of Neurology 239:287–292.
30. Milanov, I.G. ( 1992). Mechanisms of baclofen action on spasticity. Acta Neurologica Scandinavica 85:305–310.
31. Nance, P.W., Shears, A.H. and Nance, D.M. ( 1989). Reflex changes induced by clonidine in spinal cord injured patients. Paraplegia 27:296–301.
32. Ottoson, D. ( 1965). The effects of temperature on the isolated muscle spindle. Journal of Physiology 180:636–648.
33. Peacock, W.J. and Staudt, L.A. ( 1991). Functional outcomes following posterior rhizotomy in children with cerebral palsy. Journal of Neurosurgery 74:380–385.
34. Petajan, J.H. and Watts, N. ( 1962). Effects of cooling on the triceps surae reflex. American Journal of Physical Medicine 41:240–251.
35. Pierrot-Deseilligny, E. ( 1990). Electrophysiological assessment of the spinal mechanisms underlying spasticity. in Rossini, P.M. and Mauguiere, F. (Eds), New Trends and Advanced Techniques in Clinical Neurophysiology, Amsterdam: Elsevier:264–273.
36. Powers, R.K., Marder-Meyer, J. and Rymer, W.Z. ( 1988). Quantitative relations between hypertonia and stretch reflex threshold in spastic hemiparesis. Annals of Neurology 23:115–124.
37. Powers, R.K., Campbell, D.L. and Rymer, W.Z. ( 1989). Stretch reflex dynamics in spastic elbow flexor muscles. Annals of Neurology 25:32–42.
38. Price, R., Lehmann, J.F., Boswell-Bessette, S. and deLateur, B.J. ( 1993). Influence of cryotherapy on spasticity at the human ankle. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 74:300–304.
39. Price, R. and Lehmann, J.F. ( 1990). Influence of muscle cooling on the viscoelastic response of the human ankle to sinusoidal displacements. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 71:745–748.
40. Urbscheit, N., Johnston, R. and Bishop, B. ( 1971). Effects of cooling on the ankle jerk and H-response in hemiplegic patients. Physical Therapy 51:983–988.
41. Wolf, S.L., Segal, R.L., Catlin, P.A., Tschorn, J., Raleigh, T., Kontos, H. and Pate, P. ( 1996). Determining consistency of elbow joint threshold angle in elbow flexor muscles with spastic hypertonia. Physical Therapy 76:586–600.
This article has been cited 10 time(s).
Perceptual and Motor Skills
Perceived standing position after reduction of foot-pressure sensation by cooling the sole
Perceptual and Motor Skills, 96(2):
A treatment for a chronic stroke patient with a plegic hand combining CI therapy with conventional rehabilitation procedures: Case report
Disability and RehabilitationNeurophysiological methods for the assessment of spasticity: The Hoffmann reflex, the tendon reflex, and the stretch reflexDisability and Rehabilitation
Current management of pain associated with multiple sclerosis
CNS Drugs, 22(4):
Childs Nervous SystemNonoperative management of spasticity in childrenChilds Nervous System
Restorative Neurology and NeuroscienceModulatory effects of locomotor training on extensor spasticity in individuals with motor-incomplete spinal cord injuryRestorative Neurology and Neuroscience
2012 Annual International Conference of the Ieee Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society (Embc)
A New Approach to Assess the Spasticity in Hamstrings Muscles using Mechanomyography Antagonist Muscular Group
2012 Annual International Conference of the Ieee Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society (Embc), ():
American Journal of Physical Medicine & RehabilitationPain Management in Trauma PatientsAmerican Journal of Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation
American Journal of Physical Medicine & RehabilitationMeasurement of Plantarflexor Spasticity in Traumatic Brain Injury: Correlational Study of Resistance Torque Compared with the Modified Ashworth ScaleAmerican Journal of Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation
The Journal of Head Trauma RehabilitationOutcome Assessment for Spasticity Management in the Patient With Traumatic Brain Injury: The State of the ArtThe Journal of Head Trauma Rehabilitation
ankle; Ashworth scale; cryotherapy; measurement; spasticity
© 2001 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Inc.
Highlight selected keywords in the article text.