Ciriaco, Paola†; Negri, Giampiero†; Bandiera, Alessandro†; Casiraghi, Monica†; Ferla, Luca†; Torracca, Lucia†*; Zannini, Piero†
From the Division of Thoracic Surgery† and Cardiac Surgery*, University Vita-Salute and Scientific Institute, H San Raffaele, Milan, Italy.
Presented at the annual meeting of the International Society for Minimally Invasive Cardiothoracic Surgery, San Francisco, CA, June 2006.
Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr. Paola Ciriaco, Division of Thoracic Surgery, H San Raffaele, Via Olgettina 60, 20132 Milan, Italy. E-mail: email@example.com.
Objective: Videothoracoscopy is becoming the preferred approach for the removal of neurogenic mediastinal tumors. Tumors extending into the spinal canal (dumbbell type) require a combined neurosurgical approach. The aim of the study was to evaluate the feasibility of videothoracoscopic resection of benign neurogenic tumors (BNT) of the posterior mediastinum, including dumbbell-type tumors, through a retrospective review of our experience.
Methods: Between January 1993 and November 2005, 30 patients underwent resection of a BNT of the posterior mediastinum at our institution. Twenty-five tumors developed in the costovertebral sulcus, and five were dumbbell type. Preoperative assessment included chest CT scan, nuclear magnetic resonance for dumbbell-type tumors, and spinal angiography when the tumor was located in the vicinity of the Adamkiewicz artery.
Results: Mean tumor size was 5.6 ± 1.4 cm (range, 4 to 11). Videothoracoscopic resection was possible in 26 patients, 5 of whom had dumbbell-type tumors requiring a combined neurosurgical approach. Reasons for conversion to thoracotomy were pleural adhesions in one case and bleeding in three. Mean operative time was 215 ± 42 minutes (range, 180 to 280) for the patients with dumbbell-type tumors and 140 ± 55 minutes (range, 95 to 230) for those without. There were no operative and/or postoperative complications. Histology showed 25 schwannomas, 4 ganglioneuromas, and 1 neurofibroma. Mean postoperative stay was longer for the patients with dumbbell-type tumors (6.5 ± 1 versus 4 ± 1 day).
Conclusions: BNT of the posterior mediastinum, including dumbbell-type tumors, can be safely resected thoracoscopically. The feasibility of a videothoracoscopic approach should be assessed on the basis of the preoperative evaluation. Pleural adhesions and bleeding may determine conversion to thoracotomy.
Neurogenic tumors are the most frequent posterior mediastinal tumors, representing 19% to 39% of all mediastinal tumors and 75% of all posterior mediastinal tumors.1 These tumors are benign in 70% to 80% of cases, are mostly asymptomatic, and are detected incidentally during radiologic investigations.1,2 Ten percent of posterior mediastinal neurogenic tumors may also present with spinal canal extension, the so-called dumbbell-type tumors.3 Surgical resection is always advised because these tumors, left untreated, continue to grow and become symptomatic. Traditionally, they are resected by means of a standard posterolateral thoracotomy with a combined spinal approach for the dumbbell type.1,3–6 In the last decade, videothoracoscopic surgery has rapidly become accepted as an effective method of resecting these neurogenic tumors.3,7–9 The aim of this study was to evaluate the feasibility of videothoracoscopic resection of benign neurogenic tumors of the posterior mediastinum, including dumbbell-type tumors, through a retrospective review of our experience.
Between January 1993 and November 2005, 30 patients underwent resection of a benign neurogenic tumor of the posterior mediastinum at our institution. The patient group included 21 men and 9 women, with a mean age of 45 ± 7 years. Preoperative assessment included chest CT scan for all cases and nuclear magnetic resonance for suspected dumbbell-type tumors (Fig. 1). When the tumor was located in the vicinity of the Adamkewicz artery, a spinal angiography was performed to avoid the artery during surgery (Fig. 2).
Surgery is performed with the patient under general anesthesia, with double-lumen endotracheal intubation. The patient is positioned on the operative table as for standard posterolateral thoracotomy and is prepared for a videothoracoscopic approach through three 10-mm access ports. A 25° to 30° endoscope is introduced into the midaxillary line, usually between the VIII–IX intercostal space, and two working 10-mm ports are used for insertion of the dissecting instruments, which are directed toward the location of the tumor.
Once the tumor has been identified, the pleura is incised circumferentially around the surface of the lesion with either an electrocautery hook or endoscopic bipolar forceps. The lesion is then mobilized and lifted up with a blunt-tipped instrument to expose the vessels. Intercostal and vertebral vessels are clipped with a clip applier. In cases of tumors of nerve sheath origin, the peripheral section of the involved intercostal nerve is sectioned after clipping. The tumor is extracted with the aid of an endoscopic bag through one of the port sites, which can be enlarged, depending on the dimension of the tumor. A 32F chest tube is left in place, and, after reinflation of the lung under direct visualization, the trocars are removed and the incisions are closed.
Dumbbell-type tumors are removed through the combined neurosurgical approach, as described by Vallières et al.5 Dissection of the intraspinal part is performed first through a posterior approach, with the patient in the thoracotomy position. This is followed by a unilateral laminectomy and a wide foraminectomy. Part of the adjacent intervertebral facet and of the transverse process is then removed. The use of the neurosurgical operating microscope facilitates the procedure. After dural opening, the intraspinal component is removed. The dural tube is sutured in a watertight manner. The patient is then ready for the thoracoscopic stage.
Preoperative symptoms were observed in seven cases (23%), including back pain in three, chest pain in two, dyspnea in one, and radicular symptoms in one. Twenty-five tumors developed in the costovertebral sulcus, and five were dumbbell-type. Nineteen tumors (63%) were located on the right side and 11 (37%) on the left side. Mean tumor size was 5.6 ± 1.4 cm (range, 4 to 11). Videothoracoscopic resection was possible in 26 patients, of whom 5 were dumbbell-type, requiring a combined neurosurgical approach. Reasons for conversion to thoracotomy were pleural adhesions in one case and bleeding in three. The operative procedure was radical tumor extirpation in all cases. Mean operative time was 140 ± 55 minutes (range, 95 to 230) for non–dumbbell-type tumors and 215 ± 42 minutes (range, 180 to 280) for dumbbell-type tumors. No operative and/or postoperative complications occurred. The chest tube remained in place for an average of 1.5 days. Final histology showed 25 schwannomas, 4 ganglioneuromas, and 1 neurofibroma. Mean postoperative stay was 6.5 ± 1 day for patients with dumbbell-type tumors and 4 ± 1 day for those without.
Neurogenic tumors of the posterior mediastinum arise from a spinal nerve root but may involve any thoracic nerve. They are benign in 70% to 80% of the cases, and almost half of the patients are asymptomatic.1,7,10 Only 23% of our patients were symptomatic, most of them having pain, but other series report respiratory symptoms in up to 45% to 50% of their patients and neurologic symptoms ranging from 6% to 13%.1,11,12 Tumor finding is often incidental, but surgery is the treatment of choice because both benign and malignant neurogenic tumors may look alike, and they tend to grow slowly.10
Accurate preoperative diagnosis is essential to define the appropriate surgical strategy. Suzuki et al13 and Naidich et al14 reported a 60% to 79% sensitivity of CT scan in detecting chest wall invasion. Most series report a 72% to 90% diagnostic yield of percutaneous needle biopsy.15 In our series, however, a biopsy was needed in only a minority of patients because the CT scan was able to exclude local invasion in 73% of cases and provided detailed information on the feasibility of a radical excision of the lesion.
Nuclear magnetic resonance appears to be highly effective in accurately diagnosing neurogenic tumors of the mediastinum.16 In our series, it proved to be particularly useful in confirming the presence of suspected dumbbell-type tumors because it was able to identify spinal cord involvement of the tumor in all five cases.6
Spinal angiography is indicated if the tumor is located near the site of the Adamkiewicz artery, which, when present, usually originates from the aorta or from an intercostal artery on the left side between T9 and L2. Injury to this artery should be avoided during surgery because it leads to serious spinal cord ischemia.
Benign neurogenic tumors of the posterior mediastinum can be removed by means of thoracotomy or videothoracoscopy.1,2,7,10 Videothoracoscopy minimizes the trauma of incision, reduces hospital stay, and provides an appropriate view of the posterior mediastinum.6,10 On the other hand, removal of tumors lodged within the superior sulcus, large tumors, and dumbbell-type tumors might be challenging.1 Moreover, the presence of dense pleural adhesions or bleeding often requires conversion to thoracotomy. These factors prompted conversion to thoracotomy in four patients in our series. When the tumor was close to the stellate ganglion, we avoided the use of monopolar electrocautery and carried out dissection with bipolar forceps. Large tumors over 7 to 8 cm in size may also be removed thoracoscopically and extracted by enlarging the thoracoscopic access. The use of an endoscopic bag facilitates the passage through the incision. The largest tumor (11 cm in diameter) in our series was removed through a small thoracotomy mainly because of the onset of bleeding.
Different surgical approaches have been described to remove dumbbell-type tumors.3–5 The favorable results achieved with videothoracoscopic resection of non–dumbbell-type tumors prompted Vallèries et al5 to extend the use of this technique to the thoracic phase of treatment of the dumbbell type. Our experience with this combined neurosurgical and thoracic approach6 has shown that an accurate neurosurgical dissection associated with a wide foraminotomy makes the subsequent thoracoscopic approach brief and easy.6 Controversies regarding the thoracoscopic phase concern the possible damage that might occur to the spinal cord as the result of traction on the tumor during dissection.17 In our experience, this can be obviated by leaving a patch of lyophilized dura mater in situ on the dural sac during the neurosurgical phase. The patch can be easily identified in the thoracoscopic phase and provides a guide for the depth limit of the thoracoscopic dissection. Another useful maneuver is to leave a portion of parietal pleura around the border of the tumor to allow the mass to be grasped and dissected with greater precision. In cases of dumbbell-type tumors with a very small paravertebral portion, the posterior approach may suffice.17
In conclusion, our experience confirms that videothoracoscopy represents a safe and effective alternative to thoracotomy in managing benign neurogenic tumors of the posterior mediastinum. Videothoracoscopy can also be useful in resecting dumbbell-type tumors through a combined thoracoscopic-neurosurgical approach.5 Preoperative evaluation is crucial to determine the appropriate surgical strategy. Conversion to thoracotomy may be necessary because of pleural adhesions, bleeding, and large tumor size.
1.Rahman A, Sedera MA, Mourad IA, et al. Posterior mediastinal tumors: outcome of surgery. J Egypt Nat Cancer Inst. 2005;17:1–8.
2.Kumar A, Kumar S, Aggarwal S, et al. Thoracoscopy: the preferred approach for the resection of selected posterior mediastinal tumors. L Laparoendosc Adv Surg Tech A. 2002;12:345–353.
3.Akwari OE, Payne WS, Onofrio BM, et al. Dumbbell neurogenic tumors of the mediastinum: diagnosis and management. Mayo Clin Proc. 1978;53:353–358.
4.Grillo HC, Ojemann RG, Scannel JG, et al. Combined approach to ‘dumbbell’ intrathoracic and intraspinal tumors. Ann Thorac Surg. 1983;36:402–407.
5.Vallèries E, Findlay JM, Fraser RE. Combined microneurosurgical and thoracoscopic removal of neurogenic dumbbell tumors. Ann Thorac Surg. 1995;59:469–472.
6.Negri G, Puglisi A, Gerevini S, et al. Thoracoscopic techniques in the management of benign mediastinal dumbbell tumors. Surg Endosc (Epub May 7). 2001;15:897.
7.Arapis C, Gossot D, Debrosse D, et al. Thoracoscopic removal of neurogenic mediastinal tumors. Surg Endosc. 2004;18:1380–1383.
8.Sakumoto N, Inafuku S, Shimoji H, et al. Videothoracoscopic surgery for thoracic neurogenic tumors: a 7-year-experience. Surg Today. 2000;30:974–977.
9.Hazelrigg SR, Boley TM, Krasna MJ, et al. Thoracoscopic resection of posterior neurogenic tumors. Am Surg. 1999;65:1129–1133.
10.Yamaguchi M, Yoshino I, Fukuyama S, et al. Surgical treatment of neurogenic tumors of the chest. Ann Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2004;10:148–151.
11.Saenz NC, Schnitzer JJ, Angelo E, et al. Posterior mediastinal masses in children. J Pediatr Surg. 1993;28:172–176.
12.Ribet ME, Cardot GR. Neurogenic tumors of the thorax. Ann Thorac Surg. 1994;58:1091–1099.
13.Suzuki N, Saitoh T, Kitamura S. Tumor invasion of the chest wall in lung cancer: diagnosis with ultrasound and CT. Radiology. 1993;187:39–48.
14.Naidich DP, Webb R, Mueller NL (eds). The mediastinum. In: Computed Tomography and Magnetic Resonance of the Thorax. 3rd ed. New York: Lippincott Williams and Wilkins; 2000:134–159.
15.Gregson RS. The mediastinum. In: Textbook of Radiology and Imaging. 7th ed. David Sutton. London: Churchill Livingstone; 2003:57–85.
16.Sakai F, Sone S, Kiyono K, et al. Magnetic resonance imaging of neurogenic tumors of the thoracic inlet: determination of the parent nerve. J Thorac Imaging. 1996;11:272–278.
17.Konno SI, Yabuki S, Kinoshita T, et al. Combined laminectomy and thoracoscopic resection of dumbbell-type thoracic cord tumor. Spine. 2001;26:130–134.
© 2006 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Inc.