The Effects of Ambient Air Pollution on School Absenteeism Due to Respiratory Illnesses
Gilliland, Frank D.1; Berhane, Kiros1; Rappaport, Edward B.1; Thomas, Duncan C.1; Avol, Edward1; Gauderman, W. James1; London, Stephanie J.2; Margolis, Helene G.3; McConnell, Rob1; Islam, K. Talat1; Peters, John M.1
From the 1 Department of Preventive Medicine, Keck School of Medicine, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, CA; 2National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences, Research Triangle Park, NC; and 3California Air Resources Board, Sacramento, CA.
Submitted March 31, 2000; final version accepted August 1, 2000.
Address correspondence to: Frank Gilliland, Department of Preventive Medicine, USC Keck School of Medicine, 1540 Alcazar Street, CHP 236, Los Angeles, CA 90033.
This study was supported by the California Air Resources Board (Contract A033-186); the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences (Grants 5ES09581-01 and 5 P30 ES07048-02); the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (Grant R826708-01-0); the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute (Grant 1 R01 HL61768); and the Hastings Foundation.
The statements and conclusions in this report are those of the investigators and not necessarily those of the California Air Resources Board, the Environmental Protection Agency, or the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences. The mention of commercial products, their source, or their use in connection with material reported herein is not to be construed as either an actual or implied endorsement of such products.
We investigated the relations between ozone (O3), nitrogen dioxide (NO2), and respirable particles less than 10 μm in diameter (PM10) and school absenteeism in a cohort of 4th-grade school children who resided in 12 southern California communities. An active surveillance system ascertained the numbers and types of absences during the first 6 months of 1996. Pollutants were measured hourly at central-site monitors in each of the 12 communities. To examine acute effects of air pollution on absence rates, we fitted a two-stage time-series model to the absence count data that included distributed lag effects of exposure adjusted for long-term pollutant levels. Short-term change in O3, but not NO2 or PM10, was associated with a substantial increase in school absences from both upper and lower respiratory illness. An increase of 20 ppb of O3 was associated with an increase of 62.9% [95% confidence interval (95% CI) = 18.4-124.1%] for illness-related absence rates, 82.9% (95% CI = 3.9-222.0%) for respiratory illnesses, 45.1% (95% CI = 21.3-73.7%) for upper respiratory illnesses, and 173.9% (95% CI = 91.3-292.3%) for lower respiratory illnesses with wet cough. The short-term effects of a 20-ppb change of O3 on illness-related absenteeism were larger in communities with lower long-term average PM10 [223.5% (95% CI = 90.4-449.7)] compared with communities with high average levels [38.1% (95% CI = 8.5-75.8)]. Increased school absenteeism from O3 exposure in children is an important adverse effect of ambient air pollution worthy of public policy consideration.
Ambient air pollutants including ozone (O3), nitrogen dioxide (NO2), and respirable particles less than 10 μm in diameter (PM10) contribute to the occurrence of respiratory symptoms and diseases including increased occurrence and severity of symptoms, transient changes in lung function, and increased respiratory infections, more visits to physicians and emergency rooms and increased hospital admissions, and changes in lung function and increased mortality. 1-5 Consideration of a broader group of outcomes, such as school absenteeism, provides a more comprehensive assessment of the adverse impact of ambient air pollution. 6,7
Illness-related school absenteeism is an important but insufficiently studied outcome in children, a group identified as especially sensitive to the adverse effects of ambient air pollution. 8 Illness-related absences are common events that represent a broad spectrum of morbidity from mild transient illnesses to the most severe and prolonged illnesses that require emergency room visits or hospital admissions. 9 Although most absences are associated with illnesses at the low end of the morbidity spectrum, an absence indicates an illness of sufficient severity to affect the child's daily functioning, as well as child and family coping strategies. 9-13
Population-based studies show that absence rates vary by school, age, grade, and gender, and are affected by family structure, function, and other social factors. 14,15 Although the non-health-related influences on absenteeism limit its usefulness as a measure of the adverse effects of air pollution, the majority of school absences are illness related and attributable to either respiratory infections or gastroenteritis, suggesting that illness is the dominant factor for school absenteeism. 10,14 Because the effects of air pollution on school absences are likely to be due to increases in respiratory illnesses, respiratory illness-related absenteeism can be an important and relatively specific integrative outcome for the assessment of the effects of air pollution on children.
Most research on the effects of air pollution on children's health has focused on self-reported symptoms, indices of respiratory infections derived from clinical visits, medical records reviews, and lung function as outcome measures. 6,16 Few studies have examined the effects of ambient air pollution on school absenteeism, and none has examined the effects on respiratory-related absences in school-aged children residing in communities with large variations in pollutant levels.
The Children's Health Study (CHS) offers an opportunity to investigate the effects of three ambient pollutants, O3, PM10, and NO2, on school absenteeism with a focus on respiratory illness-related absences. 17 We conducted a substudy within the CHS cohort, the Air Pollution and Absence Study, and examined data on type-specific absence incidence collected by an active surveillance system for a cohort of 4th-grade school children 9-10 years of age who attended schools in the 12 CHS study communities during January through June 1996.
Subjects and Methods
The CHS is a 10-year longitudinal study that includes school children who reside in 12 communities within a 200-mile radius of Los Angeles that were selected to represent the broadest range in concentration of the ambient pollutants of interest. Details on the design, site selection, subject recruitment, and assessment of health effects are reported elsewhere. 17 In this report, we focus on school absences among 2,081 children in the 4th grade during the first 6 months of 1996.
Sociodemographic information, indoor exposures, and medical histories were obtained from questionnaires completed by parents or guardians at study entry in the fall of 1995. Environmental tobacco smoke (ETS) exposure was classified as exposure to a current household smoker or not. The subset of participants with asthma was defined using parent-reported history of physician-diagnosed asthma. Children with wheezing were defined as having any lifetime history of wheezing. Information regarding the number of hours spent outdoors over a 1-week period was collected by self-administered questionnaire. Children were stratified into more outdoors or less outdoors groups on the basis of whether they were above or below the median number of hours spent outside (11.25 hours).
We collected school absence reports from the 27 elementary schools attended by the newly recruited 4th-grade children for the period January 1 through June 30, 1996. Of the 2,081 children in the 4th-grade group, 2,068 were eligible for the absence surveillance because they were enrolled in the CHS at the beginning of the surveillance period. Of these 2,068 children, we excluded 135 from the analysis for the following reasons: 32 withdrew from the study, 90 changed schools during the study period, and 13 did not have absence data because of administrative errors.
Daily absence information was collected using two methods depending on school confidentiality policies. In 12 schools, attendance reports for entire classrooms were collected, and study staff identified absences for participating students. In the remaining 15 schools, school staff members supplied subject-specific absence reports based on lists of subjects provided to them at the beginning of the surveillance period. Study staff requested that absence reports be completed every 2-4 weeks, with the interval depending on the availability of personnel and electronic data systems at individual schools. We defined an absence as a day or an adjacent series of school days in which a participant did not attend school when the school was in session. Over the period of study, we ascertained 8,971 absences.
We established an active surveillance system to collect information about the reasons for absences; we categorized absences as illness-related and non-illness-related (these included injuries) and classified illness-related absences into gastrointestinal (GI) and respiratory categories. School reports classified absences with nonstandard codes including indicators for non-illness-related absences. Non-illness-related absences were not investigated by telephone interviews. Using school reports, study staff assigned daily absence reports to one of two categories: (1) non-illness related and (2) potentially illness related. To ensure adequate parental recall of events associated with the absence of interest, interviews were conducted only for absences that were reported within 4 weeks of occurrence. Of the 3,294 absences reported within 4 weeks, 536 were classified as non-illness absences on the basis of school reports, and 2,758 absences required telephone follow-up.
Telephone interviews were conducted in English or Spanish by trained interviewers using a standardized protocol. Parents were contacted after each absence that was reported within 4 weeks to inquire whether the absence was illness related and if so, what the symptoms were; what the physician diagnoses were, if any; and what medications were used for the reported illness. The interviewers used a list of symptoms to categorize respiratory illnesses (runny nose and sneezing, fever, sore throat, cough, wet cough, dry cough, earache, wheezing, and asthma attack) in addition to stomach problems; head and muscle aches with fatigue; rash or skin problems; watery, itchy, or burning eyes; allergies; and other symptoms. Repeat interviews were conducted for approximately 5% of absences for quality-control purposes.
Each illness-related absence was classified as respiratory or nonrespiratory on the basis of the reported symptoms. We defined a respiratory illness as an illness that included one or more of the following symptoms: runny nose/sneezing, sore throat, cough (any, wet, or dry), earache, wheezing, or asthma attack. Respiratory absences were further classified into non-mutually exclusive categories of upper respiratory illness and/or as one of two types of lower respiratory illness (LRI): LRI with wet cough or LRI with wet cough/wheeze/asthma. We defined an upper respiratory illness as a respiratory illness with one or more of the following symptoms: runny nose/sneezing, sore throat, and earache. GI illnesses included illnesses with stomach problems such as vomiting and diarrhea as one of the reported symptoms.
Absence Incidence Rates
We categorized each absence day as an incident or prevalent absence day using absence reports and school calendars to identify the days each school was in session. We defined an incident absence as an absence that followed attendance on the preceding school day. We defined a prevalent absence day as an absence that occurred after an absence on the preceding school day. The date of an absence occurrence was assigned to the incident day of each series of absence days.
We used the daily number of incident absences in each community and the corresponding daily number of children at risk for an absence in each community to calculate daily community-specific incident absence rates. We defined the number of students attending a school as the number of participants enrolled in a school on a day that the school was in session less the number of prevalent absences. We calculated daily community-specific incidence rates of absence by pooling the data from the reporting schools in each community and dividing the community-specific number of incident absences by the number of students attending schools in that community on the day of interest. The average incidence rate for school absences was computed for each community by averaging daily rates and for the entire cohort by averaging across days and communities. Stratified rates (for example, by asthma status) were calculated by identifying the number of absences and number of students at risk within each stratum and calculating daily community-specific rates and average rates as described.
On the basis of data collected by the active surveillance system, absences were divided into three mutually exclusive outcomes: non-illness-related absences, illness-related absences, and absences of unknown type (due to failure to obtain necessary classification information). Because some absences were of unknown type, the type-specific absence incidence rates were adjusted for ascertainment failure. To adjust the type-specific incident absence rates, we calculated a daily community-specific information success ratio, which we defined as the daily proportion of timely absence reports in each community for which sufficient information was obtained to assign the absence as illness related or non-illness related. This success ratio was then smoothed over time using a very rough smoother (using 10 degrees of freedom). The smoothing was intended to reduce the random fluctuation due to the limited number of events on each day within a community but in such a way that it did not substantially alter the overall trend in the data or the observed values. A symptom-specific incidence rate corrected for ascertainment is of the form: (number of incident cases)/(number at risk × smoothed success ratio).
Assessment of Air Pollution Levels
Levels for O3, PM10, and NO2 were measured continuously with hourly averaging at central-site monitors in each of the 12 communities. 18 We calculated the daily 1-hour maximum O3, the 24-hour average of O3, and the 10 am-6 pm average of O3, as well as the 24-hour averages of PM10 and NO2. We focused on the 10 am-6 pm average of O3 because it is an index of exposure during the temporal peak of ozone and outdoor activity. The 24-hour averages of PM10 and NO2 were used because they lack the temporal peak exhibited by O3. The monitoring program also reported daily 24-hour average, 24-hour maximum, and 24-hour minimum temperatures at each of the 12 monitoring locations. To assess the effects of long-term average levels of O3, PM10, and NO2 on acute effects, we divided communities into high and low groups for each pollutant on the basis of its ranking on average levels for 1995. The high and low groups included the same communities for PM10 and NO2.
To examine acute effects of each air pollutant on the rate of absences, we fitted a two-stage time-series model to the absence count data. 19-23 Letting μc(t) denote the expectation of these absence counts and Rc(t) denote the number of children at risk in community c on day t, the first-stage Poisson log-linear model has the form
where bc denotes the average absence rate in community c, adjusted for the effects of time-dependent covariates Zc(t) (for example, temperature, day of the week), and dc is the within-community slope of the regression of change in daily absence rates with change in daily pollution Xc(t) centered at the 6-month average for the study period Xc. The centering assumes a log-linear relation between the pollutants and absences. Here, s (t) denotes a smooth function of time to account properly for autocorrelation and long- and short-term time trends in the multiple time series of counts. We use 5 degrees of freedom for the 6-month period to remove any temporal cycles of up to 2 weeks. 20 The first-stage model was also adjusted for day of the week (with Friday as the reference day) and temperature (24-hour average, daily minimum, and daily maximum). The offset term, Rc(t), in the Poisson model was adjusted by using a smoothed version of the success ratio as described above.
Because the effects of pollutant exposure on a given day are likely to occur over several days, we fit models that allowed acute effects to be distributed over time. To account for a lag structure of the pollution effect, we modified the first-stage model by including community-specific polynomial distributed lag terms 24-27 leading to a model of the form:
where j =1, ..., L, dcj = Σkgckjk, and k =0, ..., D, implying that the effects of each of the previous L days are distributed over subsequent days following a polynomial function of degree D. Appropriate values for L and D are optimally selected by comparing the Akaike Information Criterion 22,28 of the models based on a grid of L and D values assuming the same D and L values for all communities. This assumption is based on biological considerations indicating that the effects of pollutants should have the same lag structure in different communities in the Los Angeles region. The quantity dcj = Σkgckjk is then interpretable as the polynomially smoothed estimate of the effect of air pollution on lagged j days, and their sum dc = Σjdcj is the overall effect of pollution over the entire lag period. The estimates of dcj and their variance estimates are then recovered through the explicit relation between dcj and gck. 26
The first-stage regression is followed by an ecologic linear regression model given by:
The stage 2 regression takes the sum of the lagged community-specific effects, dc, and the appropriate variance estimates from stage 1. The parameter δ0, the mean of the within-community slopes dc, serves as an aggregated acute-effect estimate and is the quantity of primary interest for testing acute effects of air pollutants. Because long-term pollution levels may affect responses to acute changes in exposure level, the stage 2 model includes long-term average levels of any of the pollutants of interest and allows modification of the community-specific slopes for the acute effects by long-term average pollution levels. The parameter δ characterizes the modifying effect of the long-term average pollution levels on the relation between change in absences and change in daily within-community pollution levels. Note that we use the deviation of the daily exposure values, Xc(t), from Xc in the first-stage model to make the within- and between-community comparisons of pollution effects independent. The second-stage ecologic regression is weighted by the inverses of the variances of dc.
Using this framework, we fitted separate models for three pollutants; O3 (24-hour average, daily maximum, and 10 am-6 pm daily average), PM10 (24-hour average), and NO2 (24-hour average). To account for effects of long-term ambient pollutant levels, regression models were fitted and the overall summary of acute effect of a pollutant across communities was estimated, adjusted for the 1995 community-specific average levels of a pollutant. The estimate of δ0 provides an overall summary of the acute effects from January through June 1996, adjusted for 1995 average levels of pollution or any other community-specific ecologic factor.
To assess further whether long-term average pollutant levels modify the acute effects of a pollutant, stratified models were fit using categories of high- and low-pollution communities. For any given number of strata, S, the stage 2 model becomes dc = δ0s + ηc, where s =1, . . . S and summary estimates are obtained as above. Strata of communities were formed on the basis of rankings using 1995 average pollution levels. We divided communities into high and low based on long-term average levels of O3 and PM10 or NO2.
The distribution of sociodemographic characteristics, medical conditions, ETS exposure, and outdoor activity varied among the communities (Table 1). The average daily incidence rate for all types of absences combined was 3.07 per 100 student-days based on an average daily attendance of 1,502 students (Table 2). Average daily absence rates were highest in Lake Gregory and lowest in Upland. Although the method of absence reporting by schools varied by community (Table 1), the method of school attendance reporting did not appear to have a large influence on incidence rates.
The subset of absences that was reported in a timely enough manner to be eligible for the active surveillance system was an unbiased sample of absences occurring on all days (Table 2). The distribution of determinants of absences and the average daily rates for all types of absences on days that were reported within 4 weeks did not differ substantially from the distribution and average rates on days ascertained over the period of study. The crude average daily rates per 100 participants were 1.07 for non-illness-related absences, 1.34 for illness-related absences, and 0.61 for absences of unknown type (Table 3). The daily information success ratio averaged 0.81, and exceeded 0.72, for all subgroups.
The ascertainment-adjusted daily rate for illness-related absences was higher than for non-illness-related absences for all participants combined (Table 4). Lake Gregory had the highest adjusted daily rate for illness-related absences, and Long Beach had the lowest rate. Illness-related absences were primarily due to respiratory illnesses, most of which had upper respiratory symptoms (Table 4). Adjusted daily rates of absences for respiratory illness, upper respiratory illness, LRI with wet cough/wheeze/asthma, and LRI with wet cough varied among communities and among ethnic and education groups. Rates of absences for respiratory illness and upper respiratory illness were twice as high in Lake Gregory compared with rates in Long Beach. Children with asthma, wheezing, and ETS exposure had higher absence rates for all categories of respiratory illness than children without asthma, wheezing, or ETS exposure. Adjusted absence rates for GI illness did not vary as substantially as rates for respiratory illness by children's asthma status, wheezing status, or ETS exposure (Table 4). Absences due to GI illness showed a different pattern among ethnic groups and communities from that of respiratory illnesses, with Alpine having approximately 2.5-fold higher rates than Santa Maria and Long Beach.
The patterns of O3, NO2, and PM10 varied markedly within and among the communities (Figure 1). The average 10 am-6 pm ozone was highest in Riverside and lowest in Long Beach. The communities with the largest daily variations were Mira Loma, Riverside, and San Dimas, with daily levels ranging from lower than the levels observed in unpolluted regions to greater than 150 ppb.
The 24-hour average PM10 varied by approximately the same magnitude as O3; however, several of the towns with the higher O3 had lower PM10 (Figure 1). Mira Loma had the highest level and largest range in 24-hour average PM10, and several communities had median levels below 20 μg/m3. The 24-hour average NO2 levels varied among the communities, and some communities (Lake Gregory and Lompoc) had very low levels (Figure 1). Long Beach, which had low O3, had comparatively high NO2. Lompoc, Santa Maria, and Atascadero had lower levels of all three of the pollutants of interest. The communities showed a large range of long-term average pollutant levels on the basis of 1995 pollution levels (Table 5). The same six communities were in the high stratum for both NO2 and PM10.
We found that a 30-day lag period with a cubic polynomial-constrained distributed lag model best described the data for all absences, non-illness-related absences, and respiratory absences for all three pollutant metrics of interest. A 15-day lag period provided the best fit for upper and lower respiratory absences for all three of the pollutant metrics.
Average O3 for 10 am-6 pm was strongly associated with illness-related absences and especially respiratory absences. The summary estimates of the percentage increase in absence rates associated with O3 on each of the 30 lag days are shown scaled to a 20-ppb change in O3, a change that is less than the smallest range in any of the 12 communities during the 6-month period of study (Figure 2). The acute effects of O3 were increased at a 3-day lag, peaked at a 5-day lag, and subsequently showed a slow decrease. Overall estimates of the effect of acute change in O3 on absences are obtained by summing the area under the distributed lag curve over the 30-day lag period. Daily 1-hour peak O3 produced the same overall results as analyses using the 10 am-6 pm average O3.
A 20-ppb increase in O3 was associated with a 62.9% absence rate increase for illness, 82.9% increase for respiratory illnesses, 45.1% increase for upper respiratory illnesses, 173.9% increase for LRI with wet cough, and 68.4% increase for LRI with wet cough/wheeze/asthma (Table 6). To determine the sensitivity of our estimates to the amount of smoothing used to remove seasonal variation, we refitted the models using 3 degrees of freedom and found that the estimates were essentially unchanged. For example, the effect of ozone on respiratory absences changed from an 82.9% increase to an 81.3% increase. Ozone-related increases in all absences and illness-related absences were larger in communities with lower levels of NO2 or PM10 than in communities with higher levels of NO2 or PM10 (Table 7). The acute effects of O3 on respiratory illness-related absenteeism were also larger in communities with lower long-term average PM10 (454.9%) compared with communities with high average PM10 (42.9%).
PM10 and NO2
Daily 24-hour PM10 was associated with all absences (Table 6). However, increased daily PM10 was only associated with increases in non-illness-related absences. A change of 10 μg/m3 in PM10 was associated with a 22.8% increase in all types of school absences combined and with a 97.7% increase in non-illness-related absences, but a 5.7% increase in illness-related absences. Daily PM10 was not materially associated with any of the categories of respiratory illness-related absences. NO2 had only a weak association with school absenteeism (Table 6).
We found that day-to-day changes in O3 were associated with a substantial increase in school absences from both upper and lower respiratory illnesses. Absences were increased 2-3 days after exposure and reached a peak on day 5 after exposure. The short-term effects of O3 on respiratory illness-related absences are consistent with a large body of evidence on the acute adverse effects of O3 on children's respiratory health. 3 Exposure to O3 is known to be associated with increased hospital admissions for respiratory infections among children. Hospital admission ranks as a severe outcome in the range of adverse effects, and most respiratory illnesses do not lead to hospital admission for treatment. School absences due to respiratory illnesses may usefully represent the first tier of adverse effects that are far more common than severe adverse effects.
A limited number of studies have examined the relation between O3 exposure and school absenteeism. In a study in Mexico City of 111 preschool children, O3 was associated with higher rates of absenteeism due to respiratory illnesses. 29 Children exposed to more than 130 ppb of O3 on 2 consecutive days had a 20% increase in the occurrence of preschool-reported respiratory illnesses. Studies of school absenteeism in California failed to find an association with oxidants or other pollutants, but these studies did not assess the effects of daily changes in pollutant levels on respiratory absences. 30 The relations between other air pollutants, such as SO2, and school absences have also been investigated; however, the effects of O3 were not examined, because levels were considered too low to have adverse effects. 31 We lack data to investigate further the reasons for the smaller effect of acute changes in O3 on respiratory illness-related absences in communities with high long-term average PM10 levels. One possible explanation is seasonal attenuation of children's responses to air pollution. Seasonal attenuation of the acute lung function response to O3 exposure during high-pollution months has been reported, suggesting that long-term exposure to elevated levels of PM can affect acute response to O3. 32,33
The association of daily 24-hour average PM10 with all absences in this study was primarily due to a relation with non-illness-related absences. The small association with illness-related absences was unexpected, because studies have shown that particulate pollution is associated with reduction in lung function, increased rates of acute bronchitis in children, increased incidence of respiratory symptoms, increased emergency room visits and hospitalizations for respiratory disease, and increased mortality. 5,17,34,35 Our study is consistent with a report by Ransom and Pope, 36 who studied the relation between school absenteeism and PM10 in Utah Valley for 6 years between 1985 and 1990, using weekly absenteeism data from one school district and daily data from one elementary school. They observed that a 100 μg/m3 increase in the 28-day moving average of PM10 was associated with a 40% increase in overall absences and that the effect was larger in younger children. The study did not, however, distinguish between illness and non-illness-related absenteeism. We were unable to investigate directly non-illness absences, because we did not ask about reasons for non-illness absences during interviews. We considered a number of potential sources of bias, such as incomplete control of temporal trends and the effects of temperature and differences in the effects among the communities, by conducting sensitivity analyses. We found the relations were consistent between communities and robust regardless of adjustments for temporal trends and temperature.
Acute effects of NO2 on school absenteeism were not observed at the levels measured in communities during the period of study. Although NO2 exposure may be associated with respiratory symptoms, little evidence exists that symptoms from NO2 exposure result in school absences. 2,4,37 In a study of the relation between air pollution and absenteeism in Helsinki, Ponka 38 reported that mean weekly NO2 concentrations were associated with absenteeism among adults; however, low ambient temperature accounted for the associations with absences among children in day care centers and school children. 38 In the present study, the lack of association may also reflect the narrow range of NO2 exposure and possible exposure misclassification due to the use of a central site monitor to assign exposure levels. Misclassification of exposure is likely to be the same on different days within each community, suggesting that misclassification is likely to be nondifferential. 39
In preliminary analyses, we used a bidirectional case-crossover approach to assess the air pollution and absence relation; however, the time-series analysis provides an analytic framework that efficiently uses all available information and does not have some of the conceptual drawbacks of the case-crossover approach. 40-43 The distributed lag model constrained the acute effects of pollutants to follow a polynomial function of air pollution. Based on an objective criterion for choice of the number of lag days, minimizing the Akaike Information Criterion, a cubic polynomial that included either 15 or 30 lag days, best described the lagged effects. Other choices of the lag period length would produce consistent results for the O3 effect on respiratory illness-related absences. The 15- to 30-day lag periods for the O3 effects on respiratory illness-related absences are consistent with data from a number of studies showing that effects of air pollution on respiratory health outcomes may persist for up to 5 weeks. 36,44,45
Our study enrolled and actively followed more than 2,000 4th-grade school children. The active surveillance system and modeling strategy did, however, have some limitations. Although the restriction of absences to those reported within 1 month of occurrence may have introduced bias into our study, it was adopted to minimize any recall bias of absence events by parents. On the basis of the distributions of the study population in the full and restricted sample of absence days, we found little evidence of any selection bias from the restriction. To account for the effects of incomplete ascertainment, we adjusted the denominator of the rates and the offset in the Poisson time-series models for the proportion of absences with information on absence type. To investigate the robustness of our estimates to the assumptions implicit in this adjustment, we conducted sensitivity analyses by limiting the analyses to those days with greater than 70% ascertainment. Restriction to days with nearly complete information had little effect on the magnitude of the associations. To assess further the potential for bias from the variation in ascertainment, we also examined the relations between the daily pollution and callback rates as well as absence rates and callback rates. We found that the community-specific smooth success ratios showed, in general, a weak negative correlation with ozone. Because ozone was positively correlated with absence rates over the period of study, a negative bias toward the null would be expected and cannot explain our ozone results. The correlations for NO2 and PM10 were generally smaller, making the potential for bias less likely.
We also attempted to examine variation in the relations using models stratified by asthma, ETS exposure, or other sociodemographic factors, but were unsuccessful owing to the short length of time series and the low number of events within community-specific strata. Lastly, it was not feasible to examine simultaneously the acute effects of multiple pollutants using the two-stage distributed lag framework developed for this analysis. Future development of a binomial time-series model with a flexible distributed lag structure would provide the framework to include individual-level covariates and multipollutant effects in time-series analyses.
In conclusion, relatively small short-term changes in O3 were associated with increases in respiratory illness-related school absences in children 9-10 years of age. Because exposures at the levels observed in this study are common, the increase in school absenteeism from respiratory illnesses associated with relatively modest day-to-day changes in O3 concentration documents an important adverse impact of O3 on children's health and well-being.
We thank William McDonnell, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.
1. Lippmann M. Ozone. In: Lippman M, ed. Environmental Toxicants: Human Exposures and Their Health Effects. 2nd ed. New York: John Wiley and Sons, 2000: 655-724.
2. Schlesinger R. Nitrogen oxides. In: Lippman M, ed. Environmental Toxicants: Human Exposures and Their Health Effects. 2nd ed. New York: John Wiley and Sons, 2000; 595-638.
3. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Air Quality Criteria for Ozone and Related Photochemical Oxidants. vol. III. Washington, DC: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, 1996.
4. Committee of the Environmental and Occupational Health. Assembly of the American Thoracic Society. Health effects of outdoor air pollution. Part 2. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1996; 153: 477-98.
5. Committee of the Environmental and Occupational Health. Assembly of the American Thoracic Society. Health effects of outdoor air pollution. Part 1. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1996; 153: 3-50.
6. Samet J, Speizer F. Assessment of health effects in epidemiologic studies of air pollution. Environ Health Perspect 1993; 101 (suppl 4): 149-153.
7. Ostro B, Rothschild S. Air pollution and acute respiratory morbidity: an observational study of multiple pollutants. Environ Res 1993; 50: 238-247.
8. Bates D. Effects of air pollution on children. Environ Health Perspect 1995; 103 (suppl 6): 49-53.
9. Weitzman M. School absence rates as outcome measures in studies of children with chronic illness. J Chron Dis 1986; 39: 799-808.
10. Rogers K, Reese G. Health studies: presumably normal high school students. Am J Dis Child 1965; 109: 9.
11. Parcel G, Gilman SC, Nader P, Bunce H. A comparison of absentee rates of elementary school children with asthma and nonasthmatic schoolmates. Pediatrics 1979; 64: 878-881.
12. Celano M, Geller R. Learning, school performance, and children with asthma: how much at risk? J Learn Disabil 1993; 26: 23-32.
13. Rozelle R. Relationship between absenteeism and grades. Educ Psychol Meas 1968; 28: 1151.
14. Bloom B. Current Estimates from the National Health Interview Survey, United States, 1981. Washington, DC: National Center for Health Statistics, U.S. Public Health Service, 1981.
15. Schiffer C, Hunt E. Illness among Children: Data from the United States National Health Survey. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health Education and Welfare, 1963.
16. Raizenne M, Dales R, Burnett R. Air pollution exposures and children's health. Can J Public Health 1998; 89 (suppl 1): S43-48.
17. Peters JM, Avol E, Gauderman WJ, Linn WS, Navidi W, London SJ, Margolis H, Rappaport E, Vora H, Gong H Jr, Thomas DC. A study of twelve Southern California communities with differing levels and types of air pollution. II. Effects on pulmonary function. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1999; 159: 768-775.
18. Peters JM, Avol E, Navidi W, London SJ, Gauderman WJ, Lurmann F, Linn WS, Margolis H, Rappaport E, Gong H, Thomas DC. A study of twelve Southern California communities with differing levels and types of air pollution. I. Prevalence of respiratory morbidity. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1999; 159: 760-767.
19. Schwartz J. Air pollution and daily mortality in Birmingham, Alabama. Am J Epidemiol 1993; 137: 1136-1147.
20. Dominici F, Samet J, Zeger SL. Combining evidence on air pollution and daily mortality from the 20 largest US cities: a hierarchical modeling strategy. JRSSA 2000; 163: 263-302.
21. McCullagh P, Nelder J. Generalized Linear Models. 2nd ed. New York: Chapman and Hall, 1989.
22. Hastie T, Tibshiarni R. Generalized Additive Models. London: Chapman and Hall, 1990.
23. Samet J, Zeger S, Berhane K. Particulate Air Pollution and Daily Mortality: Replication and Validation of Selected Studies. Cambridge, MA: Health Effects Institute, 1995.
24. Pope CA III, Schwartz J. Time series for the analysis of pulmonary health data. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1996; 154 (6 Pt 2):S229-S233.
25. Gold DR, Damokosh AI, Pope CA III, Dockery DW, McDonnell WF, Serrano P, Retama A, Castillejos M. Particulate and ozone pollutant effects on the respiratory function of children in southwest Mexico City (see comments) (Published erratum appears in Epidemiology 1999;10: 470). Epidemiology 1999; 10: 8-16.
26. Almon S. The distributed lag between capital appropriations and expenditures. Econometrica 1965; 33: 178-196.
27. Schwartz J. The distributed lag between air pollution and daily deaths. Epidemiology 2000; 11: 320-326.
28. Akaike H. Statistical predictor identification. Ann Inst Stat Math 1970; 22: 203-217.
29. Romieu I, Lugo MC, Velasco SR, Sánchez S, Meneses F, Hernández M. Air pollution and school absenteeism among children in Mexico City. Am J Epidemiol 1992; 136: 1524-1531.
30. Wayne WS, Wehrle PF. Oxidant air pollution and school absenteeism. Arch Environ Health 1969; 19: 315-322.
31. Ferris BG. Effects of air pollution on school absences and differences in lung function in first and second graders in Berlin, New Hampshire, January 1966 to June 1967. Am Rev Respir Dis 1970; 102: 591-606.
32. Linn WS, Avol EL, Shamoo DA, Peng RC, Valencia LM, Little DE, Hackney JD. Repeated laboratory ozone exposures of volunteer Los Angeles residents: an apparent seasonal variation in response. Toxicol Ind Health 1988; 4: 505-520.
33. Linn WS, Shamoo DA, Anderson KR, Peng RC, Avol EL, Hackney JD, Gong H Jr. Short-term air pollution exposures and responses in Los Angeles area schoolchildren. J Expo Anal Environ Epidemiol 1996; 6: 449-472.
34. Gauderman J, McConnell R, Gilliland F, London S, Thomas D, Avol E, Vora H, Berhane K, Rappaport E, Lurman F, Margolis HG, Peters J. Association between air pollution and lung function growth in Southern California. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2000; 162: 1383-1390.
35. McConnell R, Berhane K, Gilliland F, London SJ, Vora H, Avol E, Gauderman WJ, Margolis HG, Lurmann F, Thomas DC, Peters JM. Air pollution and bronchitic symptoms in Southern California children with asthma. Environ Health Perspect 1999; 107: 757-760.
36. Ransom MR, Pope CA III. Elementary school absences and PM10 pollution in Utah Valley. Environ Res 1992; 58: 204-219.
37. Neas LM, Dockery DW, Ware JH, Spengler JD, Speizer FE, Ferris BG Jr. Association of indoor nitrogen dioxide with respiratory symptoms and pulmonary function in children. Am J Epidemiol 1991; 134: 204-219.
38. Ponka A. Absenteeism and respiratory disease among children and adults in Helsinki in relation to low-level air pollution and temperature. Environ Res 1990; 52: 34-46.
39. Zeger SL, Thomas D, Dominici F, Samet JM, Schwartz J, Dockery D, Cohen A. Exposure measurement error in time-series studies of air pollution: concepts and consequences. Environ Health Perspect 2000; 108: 419-426.
40. Avol E, Peters J, London SJ, Navidi W, Rappaport E, Rodríguez P, Nasi L, Lurman F. Respiratory-related school absences and air pollution in Southern California. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1997; 155: A747.
41. Navidi W, Thomas D, Langholz B, Stram D. Statistical methods for epidemiologic studies of the health effects of air pollution. Res Rep Health Eff Inst 1999; 86: 1-56.
42. Lumley T, Levy D. Bias in the case-crossover design: implications for studies of air pollution. Environmetrics (in press).
43. Bateson TF, Schwartz J. Control for seasonal variation and time trend in case-crossover studies of acute effects of environmental exposures. Epidemiology 1999; 10: 539-544.
44. Ostro BD. Air pollution and morbidity: a sensitivity analysis of alternative monitors, pollutants, and averaging times. Sci Total Environ 1984; 39: 111-124.
45. Ostro BD. Associations between morbidity and alternative measures of particulate matter. Risk Anal 1990; 10: 421-427.
This article has been cited 61 time(s).
Environmental Health PerspectivesAir Pollution and Childhood Respiratory Allergies in the United StatesEnvironmental Health Perspectives
Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine
Association of air pollution with school absenteeism due to illness
Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine, 156():
Public HealthThe use of primary/national school absenteeism as a proxy retrospective child health status measure in an environmental pollution investigationPublic Health
Environmental Health PerspectivesAssessing the health benefits of air pollution reduction for childrenEnvironmental Health Perspectives
Designer schools: The role of school space and architecture in obesity prevention
Immunology and Allergy Clinics of North AmericaTraffic, outdoor air pollution, and asthmaImmunology and Allergy Clinics of North America
Journal of Toxicology and Environmental Health-Part A-Current IssuesAssociations Between Air Pollution and Peak Expiratory Flow Among Patients with Persistent AsthmaJournal of Toxicology and Environmental Health-Part A-Current Issues
Environmental ResearchChildren's asthma hospitalizations and relative risk due to nitrogen dioxide (NO2): Effect modification by race, ethnicity, and insurance statusEnvironmental Research
Jama-Journal of the American Medical Association
Air pollution as an underappreciated cause of asthma symptoms
Jama-Journal of the American Medical Association, 290():
Canadian Journal of Chemical EngineeringAtmospheric aerosols over two sites in a southeastern region of TexasCanadian Journal of Chemical Engineering
International Journal of Hygiene and Environmental HealthVulnerability to air pollution health effectsInternational Journal of Hygiene and Environmental Health
Occupational and Environmental MedicineNO2 and children's respiratory symptoms in the PATY studyOccupational and Environmental Medicine
Annual Review of Public HealthTime-series studies of particulate matterAnnual Review of Public Health
Journal of Allergy and Clinical ImmunologyThe role of air pollution in asthma and other pediatric morbiditiesJournal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology
Journal of AsthmaAwareness of and compliance with air pollution advisories: A comparison of parents of asthmatics with other parentsJournal of Asthma
Epidemiologia & Prevenzione
Health impact of ozone in 13 Italian cities
Epidemiologia & Prevenzione, 31(6):
Journal of Public Health DentistryTime absent from school due to dental conditions and dental care in Thai schoolchildrenJournal of Public Health Dentistry
American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care MedicineEffects of glutathione S-transferase P1, M1, and T1 on acute respiratory illness in school childrenAmerican Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine
PediatricsAmbient air pollution: Health hazards to childrenPediatrics
Environment InternationalParadoxical ozone associations could be due to methyl nitrite from combustion of methyl ethers or esters in engine fuelsEnvironment International
Journal of Environmental Engineering and Landscape Management
Investigation of ozone emission and dispersion from photocopying machines
Journal of Environmental Engineering and Landscape Management, 15(2):
Atmospheric EnvironmentA source area model incorporating simplified atmospheric dispersion and advection at fine scale for population air pollutant exposure assessmentAtmospheric Environment
Archives of Environmental Health
Effects of ambient air pollutants on asthma medication use and wheezing among fourth-grade school children from 12 southern California communities enrolled in the children's health study
Archives of Environmental Health, 59():
Atmospheric EnvironmentAtmospheric aerosol over two urban-rural pairs in the southeastern United States: Chemical composition and possible sourcesAtmospheric Environment
Paediatrics & Child Health
Ambient air pollution and children's health: A systematic review of Canadian epidemiological studies
Paediatrics & Child Health, 12(3):
Puerto Rico Health Sciences Journal
Clinical Conditions Associated with Environmental Exposures: an Epidemiologic Study in Two Communities in Juana Diaz, Puerto Rico
Puerto Rico Health Sciences Journal, 28(2):
American Journal of Epidemiology
Environmental tobacco smoke and absenteeism related to respiratory illness in schoolchildren
American Journal of Epidemiology, 157():
Indoor Air 2005: Proceedings of the 10Th International Conference on Indoor Air Quality and Climate, Vols 1-5
Continuous measurements of air quality in Minnesota schools
Indoor Air 2005: Proceedings of the 10Th International Conference on Indoor Air Quality and Climate, Vols 1-5, ():
Environment InternationalAdverse health effects of outdoor air pollutantsEnvironment International
Mutation Research-Genetic Toxicology and Environmental MutagenesisInhalation of ozone induces DNA strand breaks and inflammation in miceMutation Research-Genetic Toxicology and Environmental Mutagenesis
Atmospheric EnvironmentEnhanced source identification of southeast aerosols using temperature-resolved carbon fractions and gas phase componentsAtmospheric Environment
Archives of Environmental & Occupational Health
Interaction of Ambient Air Pollution With Asthma Medication on Exhaled Nitric Oxide Among Asthmatics
Archives of Environmental & Occupational Health, 64(3):
International Journal of Environment and Pollution
Air pollution and restricted activity days among New Zealand school children and staff
International Journal of Environment and Pollution, 41():
A two-stage model for multiple time series data of counts
Environmental Health PerspectivesStrategies for setting a national research agenda that is responsive to community needsEnvironmental Health Perspectives
American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care MedicineTNF-308 modifies the effect of second-hand smoke on respiratory illness-related school absencesAmerican Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine
Review of Economics and Statistics
Does Pollution Increase School Absences?
Review of Economics and Statistics, 91(4):
Environmental Health Perspectives
Hazardous air pollutants and asthma
Environmental Health Perspectives, 110():
Environmental Health Perspectives
Health-related benefits of attaining the 8-hr ozone standard
Environmental Health Perspectives, 113(1):
Journal of the Air & Waste Management Association
The health benefits of reduced tropospheric ozone in California
Journal of the Air & Waste Management Association, 56(7):
American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine
Respiratory effects of relocating to areas of differing air pollution levels
American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine, 164():
American Journal of Public Health
Breathless in Los Angeles: The exhausting search for clean air
American Journal of Public Health, 93(9):
International Journal of Environment and Pollution
Effects of air pollution on emergency admissions for chronic obstructive pulmonary diseases in Oporto, Portugal
International Journal of Environment and Pollution, 23(1):
Annals of EpidemiologyMode of delivery is associated with asthma and allergy occurrences in childrenAnnals of Epidemiology
Environmental Modeling & AssessmentAtmospheric Aerosol over a Southeastern Region of Texas: Chemical Composition and Possible SourcesEnvironmental Modeling & Assessment
Statistics in MedicineA three-level model for binary time-series data: the effects of air pollution on school absences in the Southern California Children's Health StudyStatistics in Medicine
Statistical issues in studies of the long-term effects of air pollution: The Southern California Children's Health Study - Comment
Statistical Science, 19(3):
International Journal of Environmental Research and Public HealthEvaluation of the Waste Tire Resources Recovery Program and Environmental Health Policy in TaiwanInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health
Environmental Impact Assessment ReviewPollution prevention at ports: clearing the airEnvironmental Impact Assessment Review
Indoor AirDo indoor pollutants and thermal conditions in schools influence student performance? A critical review of the literatureIndoor Air
Indoor AirCurrent asthma and respiratory symptoms among pupils in Shanghai, China: influence of building ventilation, nitrogen dioxide, ozone, and formaldehyde in classroomsIndoor Air
PediatricsIn Utero Smoke Exposure, Glutathione S-Transferase P1 Haplotypes, and Respiratory Illness-Related Absence Among SchoolchildrenPediatrics
Journal of Epidemiology and Community HealthMore effective home heating reduces school absences for children with asthmaJournal of Epidemiology and Community Health
PediatricsOutdoor Air Pollution, Genetic Susceptibility, and Asthma Management: Opportunities for Intervention to Reduce the Burden of AsthmaPediatrics
Environmental Science & TechnologyPotential Impact of Climate Change on Air Pollution-Related Human Health EffectsEnvironmental Science & Technology
American Journal of EpidemiologyFunctional Variants in the Catalase and Myeloperoxidase Genes, Ambient Air Pollution, and Respiratory-related School Absences: An Example of Epistasis in Gene-Environment InteractionsAmerican Journal of Epidemiology
Southern Economic Journal
Parental behavior and the value of children's health: A health production approach
Southern Economic Journal, 71(4):
Journal of Allergy and Clinical ImmunologyFamily history, dust mite exposure in early childhood, and risk for pediatric atopy and asthmaJournal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology
Social Science & MedicineThe association between contextual socioeconomic factors and prevalent asthma in a cohort of Southern California school childrenSocial Science & Medicine
EpidemiologyAmbient Ozone and MortalityEpidemiology
Family & Community HealthKids Need Clean Air: Air Pollution and Children's HealthFamily & Community Health
air pollution,; ozone,; respiratory illnesses and children,; school absenteeism.
© 2001 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Inc.
Highlight selected keywords in the article text.