Brain Tumors and Salivary Gland Cancers Among Cellular Telephone Users
Auvinen, Anssi1; Hietanen, Maila2; Luukkonen, Ritva3; Koskela, Riitta-Sisko3
From the 1Finnish Cancer Registry and STUK-Radiation and Nuclear Safety Authority, and
2Finnish Institute of Occupational Health, Department of Physics, and
3Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, Helsinki, Finland.
Address correspondence to: Maila Hietanen, Finnish Institute of Occupational Health, Topeliuksenkatu 41 a A, FIN-00250 Helsinki, Finland; maila.hietanen@ occuphealth.fi
This study was supported by the Finnish National Technology Agency (TEKES) research program, “Electromagnetic Fields from Mobile Phones as a Possible Health Risk.” Finnish mobile phone manufacturers and network providers contributed to the funding for the TEKES research program.
Submitted 28 June 2001; final version accepted 10 January 2002.
Background. Possible risk of cancer associated with use of cellular telephones has lately been a subject of public debate.
Methods. We conducted a register-based, case-control study on cellular phone use and cancer. The study subjects were all cases of brain tumor (N = 398) and salivary gland cancer (N = 34) diagnosed in Finland in 1996, with five controls per case.
Results. Cellular phone use was not associated with brain tumors or salivary gland cancers overall, but there was a weak association between gliomas and analog cellular phones.
Conclusions. A register-based approach has limited value in risk assessment of cellular phone use owing to lack of information on exposure.
The current number of mobile phone users worldwide is approximately 500 million. 1 Possible health hazards of radiofrequency (RF) electromagnetic fields emitted by cellular phones have been a subject of public debate. Possible carcinogenic effect of RF electromagnetic fields has been a special concern, but few epidemiologic studies on the subject have been published. 2–6 We conducted a population-based, case-control study on mobile phone use and brain tumors and salivary gland cancers with exposure assessment based on cellular network company records.
The ethical committee of the Finnish Institute of Occupational Health approved the study protocol, and the National Research and Development Centre for Welfare and Health granted permission for use of cancer register data.
We identified all 398 brain tumors (198 gliomas, 129 meningiomas, and 72 other or unspecified types, excluding lymphomas) and 34 salivary gland cancers diagnosed in patients between 20 and 69 years of age in Finland in 1996 from the population-based Finnish Cancer Registry. The glioma group comprised astrocytomas, glioblastomas, oligodendrogliomas, oligoastrocytomas, and ependymomas. Eighty-eight percent of brain tumors (all of the gliomas and meningiomas, and 45% of other tumors) and 97% of salivary gland cancers were microscopically confirmed.
We selected five age- and sex-matched controls for each tumor case from the Population Registry Centre of Finland. Four controls were excluded because of a previous diagnosis of brain tumor. The mean age of both brain tumor cases and controls was 50.5 years; 56% were women. For salivary gland cancer cases and controls, the mean age was 52.6 years and 38% were women.
We also compared the location and histologic subtype of gliomas among cases with and without cellular phone subscription. We reviewed cancer register notifications for all 32 cases with a cellular phone subscription before 1996 (22 with analog, six with digital, and four with both), and compared these with 32 age- and sex-matched cases without cellular phone subscription.
We identified all private subscribers (>500,000 subjects) to the cellular phone networks in Finland. Information on cellular phone subscriptions for the cases and controls was obtained from the two cellular network providers operating in Finland in 1996. We used a computerized record linkage, based on the personal identification number, to identify cases and controls with cellular network subscriptions. We obtained information on the type of subscription (analog [transmitting constant RF signal] or digital [transmitting pulsed RF signal] 900 MHz system), and the start and end date of subscription. Use of 450 MHz analog phones was excluded, because these usually had a separate transmission unit (“bag phone”) with little or no RF field exposure to the users. Subjects with multiple accounts were identified. For persons who had switched from analog phones to digital phones (N = 18), duration of use for each type of phone was considered in the analyses.
Potential Confounding Factors
Potential confounders were urban residence, socioeconomic status, and occupation either in farming or with exposure to electromagnetic fields. We obtained information on place of residence from the Population Registry Centre, and information on occupation and socioeconomic status from Statistics Finland based on the 1990, 1993, and 1995 censuses. No information on occupation was available for 20% of cases and 18% of controls. Occupations, socioeconomic status, and places of residence were similar for controls and subjects with brain tumors (Table 1). A smaller proportion of salivary gland cancer patients than controls were farmers. Prior radiotherapy to the head and neck was reported at the cancer register for only three brain tumor cases (two hemangiomas and one meningioma) and four controls.
Adjusted odds ratios (ORs) were calculated using conditional logistic regression. The 95% confidence intervals (CIs) presented are likelihood based.
The statistical power of the study was sufficient to detect an odds ratio of 1.4 or higher for brain tumors and 2.8 or higher for salivary gland cancers (with α = 0.05, two-sided and 1-β = 0.8).
Thirteen percent of brain tumor cases, 12% of salivary gland cancer cases, and 11% of the controls had ever had a personal subscription to a cellular phone network (Table 2). Average duration of subscription was 2–3 years for the analog system, but less than 1 year for the digital phones.
Odds ratios of 1.3 (95% CI = 0.9–1.8) for brain tumors and 1.3 (95% CI = 0.4–4.7) for salivary gland cancers were observed for ever having a cellular phone subscription (Table 3). Gliomas had a weak association with cellular phone use (OR = 1.5; 95% CI = 1.0–2.4), whereas meningiomas (OR = 1.1; 95% CI = 0.5–2.4) and other histologic types (OR = 0.9; 95% CI = 0.4–2.0) were not associated with cellular phone use. In analyses by phone type, gliomas were associated with use of analog phones (OR = 2.1; 95% CI = 1.3–3.4), but not digital phones (OR = 1.0; 95% CI = 0.5–2.0). We found a weak, increasing trend in ORs by duration of analog phone subscription for gliomas, when duration was used as a continuous variable (OR = 1.2 per year; 95% CI = 1.1–1.5), but not among ever users of mobile phones, when duration was classified into three groups (Table 3). No such trend was found for digital phones. No association with duration of analog phone subscription was found for meningiomas (OR = 1.0; 95% CI = 0.6–1.5), or salivary gland cancers (OR = 1.3; 95% CI = 0.7–2.5). The results concerning brain tumors remained similar after adjustment for place of residence, occupation, and socioeconomic status.
In a detailed analysis of histologic type and tumor location (lobe and laterality), no differences were observed between exposed and unexposed glioma cases (Table 4).
Few epidemiologic studies have been published on the effects of cellular phone use on cancer risk. Two previous cohort studies and three case-control studies have not found an association between brain tumors and use of cellular phones. 2–6
We designed a case-control study based on the entire Finnish population 20–69 years of age in 1996. To maximize the duration of exposure and latency, the latest year available at the cancer register was selected. We restricted the age range to 20–69 years because use of mobile phones is most common in this age group.
A register-based approach avoids recall bias, as well as selection bias related to nonresponse. However, we were not able to verify that the actual user of the cellular phone was the subscriber or someone else (such as a family member). In a study conducted in the United States, the cellular phone subscriber was the primary phone user in 69% of subscriptions and was the sole user in 48%. 7 We also had no information on the frequency or duration of calls, or on cellular phones provided by companies to their employees. Before 1996, there were more corporate than private subscriptions in Finland, and therefore more than half of all cellular phone users could have been classified as nonusers in this study. Low sensitivity and specificity of exposure tend to attenuate exposure effect. However, 50% sensitivity in exposure assessment would have attenuated the effect by only about 10%, assuming a reference exposure prevalence of 20% and a true OR of 1.1–2.0.
In conclusion, information obtained directly from subjects on mobile phone use seems preferable to a register-based approach, which has insufficient level of information. An ongoing international collaborative study with exposure assessment based on personal interview rather than registries may provide more accurate results within a few years. 8 Future studies of these cancers with larger numbers of study subjects, more detailed exposure assessment, and longer periods of exposure and follow-up are needed for valid risk assessment.
We thank the Finnish Cancer Registry for the cancer data, Statistics Finland for the data on occupation and socioeconomic status, the Population Registry Centre for identifying the controls and providing data on vital status, and Sonera and Radiolinja for the provision of information on cellular phone subscriptions. We also thank the former Research Director, Sven Hernberg, and Professor Jorma Rantanen, Finnish Institute of Occupational Health, for their comments on the manuscript, and we gratefully acknowledge the assistance of Anna-Maija Hämäläinen throughout the study.
1. Independent Expert Group on Mobile Phones. Mobile Phones and Health. Chilton: National Radiological Protection Board, 2000.
2. Hardell L, Näsman A, Pahlson A, Hallquist A, Hansson Mild K. Use of cellular telephones and the risk of brain tumors: a case-control study. Int J Oncol 1999; 15: 113–116.
3. Dreyer NA, Loughlin JE, Rothman KJ. Cause-specific mortality in cellular phone users. JAMA 1999; 282: 1814–1816.
4. Muscat JE, Malkin MG, Thompson S, et al
. Handheld cellular telephone use and risk of brain cancer. JAMA 2000; 284: 3001–3007.
5. Inskip PD, Tarone RE, Hatch EE, et al
. Cellular telephone use and brain tumors. N Engl J Med 2001; 344: 79–86.
6. Johansen C, Boice JD Jr, McLaughlin JK, Olsen JH. Cellular telephones and cancer—a nationwide cohort study in Denmark. J Natl Cancer Inst 2001; 93: 203–207.
7. Funch DP, Rothman KJ, Loughlin JE, Dreyer NA. Utility of telephone company records for epidemiologic studies of cellular telephones. Epidemiology 1996; 7: 299–302.
8. Cardis E, Kilkenny M. International case-control study of adult brain, head and neck tumours: results of the feasibility study. Radiat Prot Dosim 1999; 83: 179–183.
This article has been cited 94 time(s).
International Journal of CancerIncidence trends of adult primary intracerebral tumors in four Nordic countriesInternational Journal of Cancer
British Medical BulletinElectromagnetic radiationBritish Medical Bulletin
Environmental Health PerspectivesEpidemiology of health effects of radiofrequency exposureEnvironmental Health Perspectives
Archives of Environmental Health
Limitations of interview-based risk assessment of RF exposure from appliances
Archives of Environmental Health, 59(6):
International Journal of Oncology
Meta-analysis of long-term mobile phone use and the association with brain tumours
International Journal of Oncology, 32(5):
Bulletin Du Cancer
Cellular phones and cancer: current status
Bulletin Du Cancer, 92():
Occupational and Environmental MedicineLong-term use of cellular phones and brain tumours: increased risk associated with use for >= 10 yearsOccupational and Environmental Medicine
British Journal of CancerMobile phone use, exposure to radiofrequency electromagnetic field, and brain tumour: A case-control studyBritish Journal of Cancer
Environmental Health PerspectivesThe Controversy about a Possible Relationship between Mobile Phone Use and CancerEnvironmental Health Perspectives
Faseb JournalElectromagnetic fields affect transcript levels of apoptosis-related genes in embryonic stem cell-derived neural progenitor cellsFaseb Journal
BioelectromagneticsEstimation of relative exposure levels for cellular phone users using a neural networkBioelectromagnetics
Laryngo-Rhino-OtologieEffects of electromagnetic fields emitted by cellular phone on auditory and vestibular labyrinthLaryngo-Rhino-Otologie
Techniques in Neurosurgery
Overview of meningioma biology and science
Techniques in Neurosurgery, 9(2):
American Journal of EpidemiologyLong-term mobile phone use and brain tumor riskAmerican Journal of Epidemiology
British Medical JournalMobile phone use and risk of glioma in adults: case-control studyBritish Medical Journal
Journal of Exposure Science and Environmental EpidemiologyThe effects of recall errors and of selection bias in epidemiologic studies of mobile phone use and cancer riskJournal of Exposure Science and Environmental Epidemiology
Journal of Exposure Science and Environmental EpidemiologyCall-related factors influencing output power from mobile phonesJournal of Exposure Science and Environmental Epidemiology
Journal of Clinical OncologyComparison of Studies on Mobile Phone Use and Risk of TumorsJournal of Clinical Oncology
Occupational and Environmental MedicineNo association between the use of cellular or cordless telephones and salivary gland tumoursOccupational and Environmental Medicine
International Journal of CancerBrain cancer mortality and potential occupational exposure to lead: Findings from the National Longitudinal Mortality Study, 1979-1989International Journal of Cancer
Neuroscience LettersExposure to cell phone radiation up-regulates apoptosis genes in primary cultures of neurons and astrocytesNeuroscience Letters
Turkiye Klinikleri Tip Bilimleri Dergisi
The Effect of Cellular Phone on Cancer: Review
Turkiye Klinikleri Tip Bilimleri Dergisi, 28(6):
Journal of Paediatrics and Child HealthPredictors of mobile telephone use and exposure analysis in Australian adolescentsJournal of Paediatrics and Child Health
BioelectromagneticsCellular phone use does not acutely affect blood pressure or heart rate of humansBioelectromagnetics
Scandinavian Journal of Work Environment & Health
Electromagnetic fields and health effects - epidemiologic studies of cancer, diseases of the central nervous system and arrhythmia-related heart disease
Scandinavian Journal of Work Environment & Health, 30():
American Journal of EpidemiologyCellular phone use and risk of benign and malignant parotid gland tumors - A nationwide case-control studyAmerican Journal of Epidemiology
International Journal of CancerOccupational risk factors for low grade and high grade glioma: Results from an international case control study of adult brain tumoursInternational Journal of Cancer
Otolaryngology-Head and Neck SurgeryCan mobile phone emissions affect auditory functions of cochlea or brain stem?Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery
International Journal of EpidemiologyMeningioma and mobile phone use - a collaborative case-control study in five North European countriesInternational Journal of Epidemiology
European Archives of Oto-Rhino-LaryngologyStudying the effects of mobile phone use on the auditory system and the central nervous system: a review of the literature and future directionsEuropean Archives of Oto-Rhino-Laryngology
Radiation Protection DosimetryExposure assessment and other challenges in non-ionizing radiation studies of childhood leukaemiaRadiation Protection Dosimetry
Cellular telephones and risk for brain tumors - A population-based, incident case-control study
BioelectromagneticsEffect of extremely low frequency electromagnetic fields (ELF-EMF) on Kaposi's sarcoma-associated Herpes virus in BCBL-1 cellsBioelectromagnetics
Journal of Exposure Science and Environmental EpidemiologyComparison of measuring instruments for radiofrequency radiation from mobile telephones in epidemiological studies: Implications for exposure assessmentJournal of Exposure Science and Environmental Epidemiology
Behavioural Brain ResearchHead-only exposure to GSM 900-MHz electromagnetic fields does not alter rat's memory in spatial and non-spatial tasksBehavioural Brain Research
Toxicology and Industrial HealthChronic prenatal exposure to the 900 megahertz electromagnetic field induces pyramidal cell loss in the hippocampus of newborn ratsToxicology and Industrial Health
Occupational and Environmental MedicineDeterminants of mobile phone output power in a multinational study: implications for exposure assessmentOccupational and Environmental Medicine
Occupational and Environmental MedicineMobile phone use and cancerOccupational and Environmental Medicine
Annual Review of Public HealthEMF and healthAnnual Review of Public Health
Archives of Environmental Health
Cellular and cordless telephone use and the association with brain tumors in different age groups
Archives of Environmental Health, 59(3):
Journal of Neuro-OncologyCellular phone use and brain tumor: a meta-analysisJournal of Neuro-Oncology
Scandinavian Journal of Work Environment & Health
Meta-analysis of mobile phone use and intracranial tumors
Scandinavian Journal of Work Environment & Health, 32(3):
Clinical Physiology and Functional ImagingEffects of cellular phone use on ear canal temperature measured by NTC thermistorsClinical Physiology and Functional Imaging
Radiation Protection DosimetryRadio frequency exposure in mobile phone users: Implications for exposure assessment in epidemiological studiesRadiation Protection Dosimetry
Revue D Epidemiologie Et De Sante PubliqueCell phones and risk of brain and acoustic nerve tumours: the French INTERPHONE case-control studyRevue D Epidemiologie Et De Sante Publique
Mutation Research-Genetic Toxicology and Environmental MutagenesisIncreased frequency of micronucleated exfoliated cells among humans exposed in vivo to mobile telephone radiationsMutation Research-Genetic Toxicology and Environmental Mutagenesis
Brain Research900 MHz electromagnetic field exposure affects qualitative and quantitative features of hippocampal pyramidal cells in the adult female ratBrain Research
BioelectromagneticsEpidemiological studies of radio frequency exposures and human cancerBioelectromagnetics
The effects of pulsed 860 MHz radiofrequency radiation on the promotion of neurogenic tumors in rats
Radiation Research, 165(5):
International Journal of CancerCellular telephones and non-Hodgkin lymphomaInternational Journal of Cancer
BioelectromagneticsA comparison of self-reported cellular telephone use with subscriber data: Agreement between the two methods and implications for risk estimationBioelectromagnetics
Journal of Toxicology and Environmental Health-Part B-Critical ReviewsRecent advances in research on radiofrequency fields and health: 2001-2003Journal of Toxicology and Environmental Health-Part B-Critical Reviews
Environmental ResearchCase-control study of the association between the use of cellular and cordless telephones and malignant brain tumors diagnosed during 2000-2003Environmental Research
International Journal of Radiation BiologyMobile phones, mobile phone base stations and cancer: a reviewInternational Journal of Radiation Biology
NeuroepidemiologyCase-control study on cellular and cordless telephones and the risk for acoustic neuroma or meningioma in patients diagnosed 2000-2003Neuroepidemiology
Informacije Midem-Journal of Microelectronics Electronic Components and Materials
Biological and health relevant effects from exposure to high-frequency EMF
Informacije Midem-Journal of Microelectronics Electronic Components and Materials, 34(4):
American Journal of EpidemiologyCellular phones, cordless phones, and the risks of glioma and meningioma (Interphone Study Group, Germany)American Journal of Epidemiology
International Journal of Oncology
Further aspects on cellular and cordless telephones and brain tumours
International Journal of Oncology, 22(2):
Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series A-Statistics in Society
Communication of risk: health hazards from mobile phones
Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series A-Statistics in Society, 166():
EMC 2005: IEEE International Symposium on Electromagnetic Compatibility, Vols 1-3, Proceedings
Collagen as a target for electromagnetic fields. Effects of 910-MHz
EMC 2005: IEEE International Symposium on Electromagnetic Compatibility, Vols 1-3, Proceedings, ():
International Journal of CancerMobile phone use and risk of glioma in 5 North European countriesInternational Journal of Cancer
Annales Des Telecommunications-Annals of TelecommunicationsSAR characterization inside intracranial tumors for case-control epidemiological studies on cellular phones and RF exposureAnnales Des Telecommunications-Annals of Telecommunications
Australasian Physical & Engineering Sciences in Medicine
Mobile phones and brain tumours: a review of epidemiological research
Australasian Physical & Engineering Sciences in Medicine, 31(4):
BioelectromagneticsElectromagnetic Fields and Epidemiology: An Overview Inspired by the Fourth Course at the International School of BioelectromagneticsBioelectromagnetics
Annals of EpidemiologySelection bias due to differential participation in a case-control study of mobile phone use and brain tumorsAnnals of Epidemiology
ToxicologyStudying gene expression profile of rat neuron exposed to 1800 MHz radiofrequency electromagnetic fields with cDNA microassayToxicology
Oral DiseasesThe influence of handheld mobile phones on human parotid gland secretionOral Diseases
Cellular telephone use and risk of intratemporal facial nerve tumor
Journal of Toxicology and Environmental Health-Part B-Critical ReviewsMobile telephones and cancer - A review of epidemiological evidenceJournal of Toxicology and Environmental Health-Part B-Critical Reviews
European Journal of Epidemiology
Cellular telephone use among primary school children in Germany
European Journal of Epidemiology, 19():
Journal of Exposure Analysis and Environmental EpidemiologyValidation of self-reported cellular phone useJournal of Exposure Analysis and Environmental Epidemiology
International Archives of Occupational and Environmental HealthPooled analysis of two case-control studies on use of cellular and cordless telephones and the risk for malignant brain tumours diagnosed in 1997-2003International Archives of Occupational and Environmental Health
American Journal of EpidemiologyMobile phone use and risk of parotid gland tumorAmerican Journal of Epidemiology
Journal of AdolescenceUse of information and communication technology (ICT) and perceived health in adolescence: The role of sleeping habits and waking-time tirednessJournal of Adolescence
Journal of Research and Practice in Information Technology
Global sense of risk: Media reporting on scientific studies and potential risks of mobile phones
Journal of Research and Practice in Information Technology, 40(2):
Journal of Exposure Science and Environmental EpidemiologyRecall bias in the assessment of exposure to mobile phonesJournal of Exposure Science and Environmental Epidemiology
European Journal of EpidemiologyThe INTERPHONE study: design, epidemiological methods, and description of the study populationEuropean Journal of Epidemiology
Environnement Risques & SanteValidation of the questionnaire used in the INTERPHONE study: Measuring mobile telephone use in FranceEnvironnement Risques & Sante
Turkiye Klinikleri Tip Bilimleri Dergisi
Cellular phone technology and health: Review
Turkiye Klinikleri Tip Bilimleri Dergisi, 28(1):
International Journal of Radiation BiologyCase-control study on the use of cellular and cordless phones and the risk for malignant brain tumoursInternational Journal of Radiation Biology
International Journal of Radiation BiologyMelatonin metabolite excretion among cellular telephone usersInternational Journal of Radiation Biology
Radio and microwave frequency radiation and health - an analysis of the literature
Journal of the National Cancer InstituteCellular telephone use and cancer risk: Update of a nationwide Danish cohortJournal of the National Cancer Institute
Journal of Clinical OncologyMobile Phone Use and Risk of Tumors: A Meta-AnalysisJournal of Clinical Oncology
International Journal of EpidemiologyBrain tumour risk in relation to mobile telephone use: results of the INTERPHONE international case-control studyInternational Journal of Epidemiology
International Journal of Molecular Medicine
Mobile telephones and cancer: Is there really no evidence of an association? (Review)
International Journal of Molecular Medicine, 12(1):
Radiation Protection Dosimetry
Recall of past use of mobile phone handsets
Radiation Protection Dosimetry, 106(3):
Archives of Disease in ChildhoodHow dangerous are mobile phones, transmission masts, and electricity pylons?Archives of Disease in Childhood
EpidemiologyMobile Phone Use and Acoustic NeuromasEpidemiology
EpidemiologyEpidemiologic Evidence on Mobile Phones and Tumor Risk: A ReviewEpidemiology
European Journal of Cancer PreventionCellular telephone use and time trends in brain tumour mortality in Switzerland from 1969 to 2002European Journal of Cancer Prevention
European Journal of Cancer PreventionUse of mobile phones in Norway and risk of intracranial tumoursEuropean Journal of Cancer Prevention
European Journal of Cancer PreventionEpidemiological risk assessment of mobile phones and cancer: where can we improve?European Journal of Cancer Prevention
brain neoplasms; salivary gland neoplasms; cellular telephones; radiofrequency fields
© 2002 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Inc.
Highlight selected keywords in the article text.