OBJECTIVE: The primary objective of this study was to compare Aquacel (ConvaTec, Skillman, New Jersey), Allevyn (Smith & Nephew, St Petersburg, Florida), and Mediskin I (Mölnlycke, Health Care AB, Gothenburg, Sweden) in the treatment of split-thickness skin graft donor sites.
DESIGN: This study was performed as a prospective randomized, 3-arm, clinical study.
SETTING: A clinical study performed at a hand and plastic surgery department with burn unit.
PARTICIPANTS: The study included 67 adults with a total of 73 donor sites, which were on the thigh, not reharvested, and ranged between 30- and 400-cm2 area.
INTERVENTIONS: Subjects were randomly assigned to treatment with Aquacel, Allevyn, or Mediskin I.
MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The donor site was assessed on postoperative days 3, 14, and 21 for healing, infection, pain, impact on everyday life, ease of use, and cost.
MAIN RESULTS: The obtained results demonstrate significantly faster re-epithelialization for patients treated with Aquacel or Mediskin I compared with Allevyn. Regarding infections, there were no significant differences between the groups. Patients wearing Aquacel experienced significantly less pain changing the dressing and less impact on everyday life than the patients wearing Allevyn. Aquacel was shown to be significantly easier for the caregiver to use than Allevyn and Mediskin I. There is a significant difference in cost of treatment between the dressings, whereas Mediskin I is the most expensive.
CONCLUSION: The authors’ results support the use of Aquacel in the treatment of split-thickness skin graft donor sites. Aquacel has a low cost per unit, is user friendly, gives short healing time, and minimizes patient discomfort.
The authors compare the effectiveness of dressing products used in the treatment of split-thickness skin graft donor sites.
Matilda Karlsson, RN, is a Nurse, Department of Hand and Plastic Surgery and Burn Intensive Care, University Hospital of Linköping, Sweden. Margareta Lindgren, PhD, RN, is, a Senior Lecturer, Division of Nursing Science, Department of Medical and Health Sciences, Linköping University, Linköping, Sweden. Ingmarie Jarnhed-Andersson, RN, is a Nurse, Department of Hand and Plastic Surgery and Burn Intensive Care, University Hospital of Linköping, Sweden. Erkki Tarpila, MD, PhD, is a Senior Plastic Surgeon, Department of Hand and Plastic Surgery, University Hospital of Linköping, Sweden.
The authors have disclosed that they have no financial relationships related to this article.
Submitted September 18, 2012; accepted in revised form March 8, 2013.