Skip Navigation LinksHome > March 2011 - Volume 253 - Issue 3 > A Clinician's Guide to Patient Selection for Watchful Waitin...
Annals of Surgery:
doi: 10.1097/SLA.0b013e31820b04e9
Original Article

A Clinician's Guide to Patient Selection for Watchful Waiting Management of Inguinal Hernia

Sarosi, George A. Jr, MD*; Wei, Yongliang MS; Gibbs, James O. PhD; Reda, Domenic J. PhD; McCarthy, Martin Jr, PhD§; Fitzgibbons, Robert J. Jr, MD; Barkun, Jeffrey S. T. MD**

Collapse Box

Abstract

Objective: The goal of this study was to assist surgeons in managing patients with minimally symptomatic inguinal hernia by identifying characteristics that predict crossover to surgery or worsening of hernia symptoms.

Background: Randomized trials have suggested that watchful waiting mana-gement of minimally symptomatic inguinal hernia is an acceptable alternative to surgical repair. However, these trials found that roughly a quarter of patients would elect for repair in the first 2 years, suggesting that not all patients are good candidates for watchful waiting.

Methods: The 336 patients randomized to watchful waiting in the American College of Surgeons Watchful Waiting Hernia Trial constituted the study popu-lation. Preoperative patient characteristics were used to predict 2 outcomes, either crossover to surgery or the development of hernia pain limiting activities and/or crossover to surgery. Patients in our study were part of a previously registered randomized trial: NCT00263250.

Results: At 2 years, 72 patients crossed over to surgery, with pain with strenuous activities [odds ratio (OR), 1.3 per 10-mm visual analog scale pain scale], chronic constipation (OR, 4.9), prostatism (OR, 2.9), being married (OR, 2.3), and good health [OR, 3.0 American Society of Anesthesiologists Class (ASA) 1 vs 2], predicting crossover. An additional 28 patients developed pain, limiting their activities, with pain during strenuous activities (OR, 1.3 per 10-mm visual analog scale) and chronic constipation (OR, 4.5), predicting the combined outcome of pain limiting activities and/or crossover to surgery. Higher levels of activity reduced the risk (OR, 0.95) of this combined outcome.

Conclusions: Readily identifiable patient characteristics can predict those patients with minimally symptomatic inguinal hernia who are likely to “fail” watchful waiting hernia management. Consideration of these factors will allow surgeons to optimally tailor hernia management.

© 2011 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Inc.

Login