What We Already Know about This Topic
* Although moderate hypothermia can be neuroprotective, profound hypothermia is associated with neurologic injury by poorly understood mechanisms
* Profound hypothermia and rewarming are associated with detrimental increases in intracellular calcium via N-methyl-D-aspartic acid (NMDA) type glutamate receptors
What This Article Tells Us That Is New
* In a rat hippocampal slice model, inhaled, but not intravenous, anesthetic agents provided early neuroprotection following profound hypothermia and rewarming
* The transient protective effect of isoflurane involved reduced calcium entry by NMDA receptor blockade, in contrast with ischemic protection that involves potentiation of type A γ-aminobutyric acid receptors
CONTROLLED mild hypothermia (core temperature 32–34°
C) improves neurologic outcomes after neonatal asphyxia1
and adult cardiac arrest.3
However, profound hypothermia (PH), defined here as temperatures less than 18°C, is associated with neurologic injury. Concerns about the deleterious effects of hypothermia date from the early days of cardiac surgery,4–6
with deeper levels of PH (less than 18°C) associated with frequent neurologic complications.7
The causes of neurologic injuries caused by hypothermia have been studied sparingly compared with hypoxic or ischemic injury.
Experimental studies examining the effects of PH on the central nervous system often have not separated injury caused by hypothermia with that caused by experimental ischemia or the cardiopulmonary bypass techniques. However, a number of laboratory studies suggest that PH/rewarming (RW) injures neurons separately from injury caused by cerebral blood flow insufficiency. For example, in dogs cooled to 12°C during normal blood flow cardiopulmonary bypass, DeLeon et al.
documented extensive neurologic damage in the cerebrocortex.9
Similarly, Watanabe et al.6
found widespread and persistent neural injury, including substantial loss of hippocampal neurons, in dogs after normal flow cardiopulmonary bypass in which the dogs were merely cooled to 20°C and not subjected to any ischemic stress. Alam et al.10
found that PH, independent of cerebral ischemia or other factors, causes central nervous system injury in swine. Damage and loss of hippocampal neurons are prominent findings after PH with or without circulatory arrest,6
similar to hippocampal damage caused by global ischemia.11
The mechanisms by which PH and/or RW injures neurons remain unclear and little studied. In a recent study12
we found that an increase in intracellular Ca2+
is a key pathologic event in hippocampal neurons during PH and/or RW. We found that the increase in Ca2+
was solely due to N
-methyl-D-aspartate receptors (NMDARs), with essentially no contribution from voltage gated Ca2+
channels, 2-amino-3-(5-methyl-3-oxo-1,2-oxazol-4-yl)propanoic acid-type glutamate receptors, or metabotropic glutamate receptors. This is distinct from excitotoxicity after hypoxia or ischemia, in which multiple Ca2+
entry processes are involved and can be targets for experimental neuroprotection.
Anesthetic agents are neuroprotective in focal or global brain ischemia.13
Numerous mechanisms of anesthetic protection have been examined in experimental models of ischemia, including attenuation of glutamate excitotoxicity by block of NMDARs or reduction of glutamate release,15
opening of KATP
augmentation of γ-aminobutyric acid (GABA) receptor currents,18
and activation of neuroprotective intracellular signaling pathways and prosurvival gene expression.19–21
Because anesthetic agents such as isoflurane blunt increases in intracellular Ca2+
mediated by glutamate excitotoxicity during and after ischemic insults and hypothermia involves excitotoxicity, we hypothesized that isoflurane and other anesthetic agents would also protect against injury caused by PH/RW. Although desflurane protects the brain during deep hypothermic cardiac arrest, the presumption is that desflurane targets the ischemic and not the hypothermic component of the injury.22
There has not been, to our knowledge, any study of how anesthetic agents affect the survival of neurons during and after PH/RW. The purpose of this study was therefore to determine whether anesthetics improve the cold tolerance of neurons, independent of ischemia-like conditions, and by what mechanisms.
Materials and Methods
The studies were approved by the University of California San Francisco Committee on Animal Research and conform to relevant National Institutes of Health guidelines for the use of animals in research.
Preparation of Hippocampal Slice Cultures
Organotypic hippocampal slice cultures (HSCs) were prepared by standard methods.23
Eight- or 9-day-old Sprague-Dawley rats (Charles River Laboratories, Hollister, CA) were anesthetized with 3% isoflurane until they did not move in response to a vigorous tail pinch, and then were decapitated. Seven-day-old animals were not anesthetized before decapitation, per University of California San Francisco animal care guidelines. After decapitation, the hippocampi were quickly removed and placed in 4°C Gey balanced salt solution with 20 mM glucose. Further preparation and culture were as described by Bickler et al.24
Approximately 16 slices are harvested from each rat pup, and a total of approximately 250 pups were used in the entire study.
Study Design: Cold Injury in HSCs and Treatment with Anesthetic Agents
Slice cultures were exposed to hypothermia by placing them in a Billups-Rothenberg modular incubator chamber (Del Mar, CA) filled with humidified 95% air/5% carbon dioxide and placed in a 4 ± 1°C cold room for varying amounts of time. In a mock study, a thermocouple probe was placed in the culture media to measure temperature changes and it was found that the media cools to 4°C in approximately 1 h and that RW is complete in a similar period of time. Survival measurements and histology studies were done 1 h after completion of RW to 37°C. In some studies, cell death was measured 24 h after RW. To determine whether the rate of RW is related to damage caused by hypothermia, we also measured cell death after 6 h of PH followed by a 2.5-h RW period. For this RW profile, slices were first rewarmed to 25°C over the course of 1 h and then warmed to 37°C over the next 1.5 h, achieving an approximately linear rate of warming over the 2.5-h period.
Exposures to anesthetic agents and study drugs were handled as follows. For the anesthetic agents isoflurane and sevoflurane, slice culture trays were placed open in Billups-Rothenberg chambers through which the anesthetic agent was flowed via a calibrated vaporizer with the carrier gas (air/5% CO2) for 5–8 min at 3 l/min flow to ensure that the desired anesthetic concentration was achieved within the chamber. Isoflurane was studied at 1% and 2% and sevoflurane at 3% and was measured with a calibrated clinical infrared anesthetic analyzer. Isoflurane concentration in slice culture media was also measured in several mock experiments by withdrawing media through a polyethylene tube into a glass syringe. Samples in the syringe were mixed with nitrogen to extract anesthetic vapor and the isoflurane concentration in the nitrogen bubble was measured with a gas chromatograph.
When xenon was studied, we mixed this gas with 5% CO2/air in 4 l precision spirometer calibration syringes and flushed through the chamber several times. Xenon concentration was not measured directly. Propofol (3 μM), pentobarbital (100 μM), or other study drugs (e.g., NMDAR antagonists and altered concentrations of K+) were present in the culture media 30 min before the start of the hypothermia.
Assessment of Cell Death in HSCs
Cell death was measured with propidium iodide (PI) or Sytox® fluorescence (Molecular Probes, Invitrogen, Eugene, OR), which provide essentially the same assessment of cell death. Each fluorescent dye penetrates damaged plasma membranes and binds to DNA. Confocal microscopy showed that PI and Sytox® both penetrate about 40 μm into the slice from both sides, labeling most dead neurons (slice cultures typically thin to approximately 100 μm). Sytox® (0.5 μM) was added to the wells of the culture trays 1 h after the slices were transferred to the 37°C incubator. After 15 min, the Sytox® was washed out and digital images of fluorescence were acquired. The Sytox® excitation light wavelength was 504 nm and the emission was 523 nM. PI (2.3 μM) was added to the wells of the culture trays 30 min after the slices were transferred to the 37°C incubator. After 30 min, the HSCs were rinsed in fresh media. The excitation light wavelength was 535 nm and emission was 620 nm for PI. For both Sytox® and PI, digital images were taken using a SPOT Jr. Digital Camera (Diagnostic Instruments, Sterling Heights, MI) and an inverted microscope. The fluorescence intensity of these dyes in slice cultures is a linear function of cell death25
and was analyzed in different regions of the cultures (CA1, CA3, and dentate) with Image J software‖
by a blinded observer.
Histologic Analysis: Cresyl Violet and Fluorojade
HSCs for histologic examinations were grown on membrane “confetti” as described by Lacour et al.27
Briefly, slices were cultured on discs of permeable membrane (Millipore, Billerica, MA; FHLC01300) on top of the usual slice culture inserts for 3 days before study. After experiments, the cultures et al.
were fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde in phosphate buffered saline for 1–2 h at 4°C. The cultures were then horizontally “resliced” as follows. Using a Z-axis controlled vibratome (Campden Instruments smz7000, Lafayette, IN), a flat surface was cut on a block of 3% agar. The confetti containing HSC was removed from the culture insert and glued to the flat agar bed with cyanoacrylate cement, providing an absolutely horizontal tissue for slicing. From the approximately 100-μm thick HSC, one 30-μm horizontal slice was obtained and mounted on a gelatin slide to dry. The dried and fixed slices were stained with cresyl violet to assess cell morphology or fluorojade to identify degenerating neurons. Confocal microscopy was used to image fluorojade-labeled neurons.
Measurement of Intracellular Ca2+
Intracellular Ca2+ in HSCs was measured with the fluorescent indicator calcium green 1-AM (Molecular Probes, Eugene, OR), because this dye loads into neurons in HSCs somewhat better than fura-2, which we have used previously. Cultures were loaded with 5–6 μM of the indicator during the 1-h RW period at 37°C. The cultures were rinsed and the fluorescence was quantified (excitation 488 nm, emission 520 nm) using an inverted microscope with the Spot Jr. camera. The background fluorescent signal from nonslice regions of the images was subtracted from the total fluorescent signal in the slice region. Fluorescence intensity was analyzed with Image J software.
The ENLITEN® Luciferase/Luciferin reagent (Promega, FF2021, San Diego, CA) and a luminometer was used to measure ATP in HSCs. Slices were removed from culture membranes in cold 5% trichloroacetic acid and frozen in liquid nitrogen to inactivate ATP-degrading enzymes and preserve ATP levels during storage. Before assay, the pH in the samples was neutralized using 100 mM Tris-acetate buffer. ENLITEN® reagent was added to samples and ATP reference standards and the resulting luminescence was measured with a MicroLumat Plus LB96V (EG&G Berthold Technologies, Bad Wildbad, Germany) luminometer. Because individual slice cultures are uniform in size and weight, [ATP] in experimentally treated slices was simply expressed relative to [ATP] in control slices.
Measurement of Glutamate Release from Cultures
Hippocampal slice cultures were grown for 7 days as described previously and randomly assigned to these experimental groups: (1) control; (2) 6 h PH/1 h RW; (3) 6 h PH/1 h RW with 2% isoflurane present during PH and RW; and (4) control plus 80 mM KCl to cause depolarization and full glutamate release. One ml of slice culture media was placed in each of the wells immediately before the experiment. The media was removed at each of the sampling points and snap frozen in an ethanol/dry ice bath before being analyzed for glutamate with a commercially available enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay kit (BA E-2300; Rocky Mountain Diagnostics, Colorado Springs, CO). Glutamate concentration in the culture media (very low; the media contained no added glutamate) was also measured and subtracted from that in the experiment groups.
Neuron survival/injury experiments were designed to produce a normally distributed pattern of cell death as assayed by PI or Sytox® fluorescence. Therefore, analysis of variance (ANOVA) was used to compare the means of these data, and corrections were made for multiple comparisons with the Tukey-Kramer multiple comparison correction procedure; all statistical comparisons involve a two-tailed hypothesis of either an increase or decrease in a measured variable as a result of treatment. Differences were considered significant for P < 0.05. Other statistical comparisons involving multigroup design were also made with ANOVA and the Tukey-Kramer procedure. The GraphPad Prism® software package was used (GraphPad, Inc., La Jolla, CA).
Effects of Anesthetic Agents on Hypothermia and RW Injury in Hippocampal Neurons
Hippocampal slice cultures exposed to PH (4 ± 1°C) followed by 1 h RW to 37°C developed cell injury almost exclusively in the neuron cell body regions (fig. 1
A). The duration of hypothermia was not significantly related to the amount of cell death (fig. 1
B), suggesting that the RW period is the critical period in injury. Isoflurane (2%, approximately 1.3 minimum alveolar concentration), when present in the gas phase during hypothermia and RW, protected hippocampal neurons from cell death (one-way ANOVA with Tukey multiple comparison test, P
< 0.001 for 4, 6, 8, and 10-h periods of hypothermia), with similar degrees of protection observed after the different durations of PH (fig. 1
B). We also examined the effects of 1% isoflurane on cell death after PH/RW and found similar protection as with 2% isoflurane (data not shown). Isoflurane reduced PH/RW injury even if it was present only during the RW phase of the injury (fig. 1
C, one-way ANOVA with Tukey test, P
< 0.001). The anesthetic agents sevoflurane (3%, approximnately 1.3 minimum alveolar concentration28
) and xenon (60% of an atmosphere, approximately 0.4 minimum alveolar concentration for rats29
) were also protective against PH/RW injury (fig. 1
< 0.001, one-way ANOVA with Tukey test). Nitrogen substituted for air, as a control in the xenon experiments, did not increase the PH/RW injury, even though it diluted the carbon dioxide in the chamber to 2%. Experiments examining the effects of reducing the carbon dioxide in the atmosphere in the chamber during hypothermia showed that varying carbon dioxide level between 2% and 10% had no effect on hypothermia and RW injury (data not shown). We also examined propofol and pentobarbital and found that these agents, at concentrations commonly used in in vitro
had no effect on cold and RW injury (fig. 1
E). Measurements of isoflurane concentration in the slice culture media revealed that steady-state concentrations were achieved at 1 h and that less than half of the isoflurane remained in the media 1 h after removal of isoflurane from the gas phase in the study chambers (fig. 1
Histologic examination of resliced hippocampal cultures with cresyl violet after 6 h of PH (4°C) and a 1 h period of RW to 37°C revealed clear effects on the histologic appearance of neurons in the cell body regions. Rupture and loss of neurons was observed in cultures fixed immediately after RW (compare fig. 2
A and B). Isoflurane prevented apparent cell loss in the cultures (fig. 2
C). Acute neurodegeneration caused by NMDA application (fig. 2
D) caused cell disruption and nuclear condensation similar in histologic appearance to cold and RW. In cultures fixed 24 h after RW, greater numbers of condensed nuclei were seen, although total cell death, based on histologic appearance, did not appear to be much greater at 24 h after RW compared with 1 h after RW (fig. 2
E, compare to fig. 2
B). Isoflurane also improved the histologic appearance of cultures examined 24 h after RW (fig. 2
F). These findings are consistent with the central role of NMDAR-mediated excitotoxicity in PH/RW injury and observations that NMDAR antagonists uniquely prevent PH/RW injury.12
Fluorojade, a neuron-specific dye method for assessing cell death, was also used in the PH/RW studies. We examined the clearest cell body region in each culture, which was typically the CA1 or CA3 region. As with PI, fluorojade staining revealed that both isoflurane and sevoflurane reduced neuron injury caused by hypothermia and RW (fig. 3
A). Regional analysis of cell death in the cultures demonstrated isoflurane protection in all the neuronal areas (fig. 3
B, one-way ANOVA with Tukey multiple comparison test).
In experimental models of neural injury after PH and cardiopulmonary bypass, the rate of RW may influence the degree of neurologic damage.30
Therefore, we compared our standard RW protocol (RW from 4°C to 37°C in approximately 1 h) with a slower RW protocol (4°C to 37°C over 2.5 h). We found that slower RW had no effect on neuronal death (fig. 4
Isoflurane and ATP during PH
ATP levels and cell death in HSCs after 6 h at 4°C followed by RW to 37°C are shown in figure 5
. ATP measured in cultures at the end of 8 h at 4°C (frozen for ATP analysis before RW) was reduced by more than 80% compared with control cultures. ATP measured immediately after RW rebounded moderately from this nadir (one-way ANOVA with Tukey test, P
< 0.01), but remained low. Isoflurane present during hypothermia reduced ATP loss significantly only during the period of hypothermia (P
< 0.05) and did not preserve ATP after RW compared to the non-anesthetic treated groups. The moderately higher levels of ATP during hypothermia were apparently critical to cell survival because cell death in “sister” cultures from the same experiments in which the ATP measurements were made demonstrated that isoflurane substantially reduced cell death. This protection was found in CA1, CA3, and dentate regions of the slices (fig. 5
B-D, one-way ANOVA, P
< 0.001 in all regions).
Is Isoflurane Protection Durable?
The durability of volatile anesthetic neuroprotection was a major concern in previous studies of neuroprotection after global or regional hypoxia or ischemia.13
Indeed, from figure 3
A, it appears that both isoflurane and sevoflurane improve survival measured within 1 h after RW, but not 24 h later. We thought that this might be due to continuing excitotoxicity during the 24 h after RW. To test this, we exposed cultures to 1% isoflurane during PH/RW and for 24 h after RW. Figure 6
confirms that isoflurane protection from PH/RW injury fades significantly when assessed at 24 h after RW (protection significantly less in CA3 and dentate at 24 h, ANOVA with Tukey test, P
< 0.001 and P
< 0.05, respectively), and in addition shows that the continuous presence of 1% isoflurane during the 24-h period after RW was of no benefit in protecting neurons (P
> 0.05 for all comparisons, one-way ANOVA with Tukey multiple comparison test). This pattern was seen in CA1, CA3, and to a lesser degree, in dentate neurons.
NMDA Receptors and Ca2+ Are Involved in Isoflurane Protection against Cold and RW Injury, but Not GABA Receptors
PH/RW injury is caused by glutamate excitotoxicity involving NMDA receptors.12
Because isoflurane attenuates NMDAR currents31
and NMDA-based excitotoxicity both in the context of hypoxia/ischemia and exogenously applied neurotoxic concentrations of glutamate or NMDA,32
we reasoned that isoflurane protection of neurons exposed to PH/RW would also involve this mechanism. We found that the selective NMDA receptor antagonist AP5 reduces PH/RW injury and prevents Ca2+
entry (fig. 7
A-C). Isoflurane follows this pattern as well, suggesting that isoflurane is acting to antagonize NMDAR-mediated neuronal death in PH/RW injury.
Isoflurane's protective effect in hypoxic-ischemic neuronal injury is partly mediated by GABAA
receptor activation or augmentation.11
receptors are probably not related to protection against PH/RW injury because isoflurane remained protective when the GABAA
antagonists bicuculline and picrotoxin were present in concentrations sufficient to block all GABAA
receptor activity (fig. 7
D, one-way ANOVA with Tukey test, P
< 0.05 compared with the PH/RW group).
To further define the role of isoflurane in modulating glutamate excitotoxicity in PH/RW injury, we used media with 30 mM K+
during hypothermia to block glutamate release during the subsequent period of RW. This approach was based on the work of Hogins et al.33
who showed that 30 mM K+
conferred a preconditioning effect against a stress of oxygen/glucose deprivation that was clearly related to presynaptic silencing of glutamate release. Thirty mM KCl was markedly protective against PH/RW injury, consistent with the importance of glutamate excitotoxicity in PH/RW injury (fig. 8
< 0.01 one-way ANOVA with Tukey multiple comparison test). Isoflurane combined with 30 mM KCl produced additional protection, as did the NMDAR antagonist AP5. Because 30 mM K+
depolarizes and clamps hippocampal neurons to approximately −13 mV,12
membrane potential per se
must not be the parameter that is responsible for isoflurane protection in PH/RW injury. We also investigated whether isoflurane decreases the release of glutamate during PH/RW injury. We found that isoflurane significantly reduced the release of glutamate into the culture media during the period of hypothermia (fig. 9
), from a mean of approximately 0.35 μg glutamate per slice to 0.16 μg per slice (P
< 0.05, one-way ANOVA with Tukey multiple comparison test).
KATP Channels Are Not Involved in Isoflurane Protection against Cold and RW Injury
ATP-sensitive K channels are proposed to mediate part of isoflurane's protection of hypoxic or ischemic myocardium and brain tissue.17
To determine whether this mechanism accounts for isoflurane protection after PH/RW, slice cultures were preincubated in the KATP
channel blocker glibenclamide for 30 min before cooling them to 4°C for 6 h. Glibenclamide did not prevent isoflurane from protecting neurons when they were rewarmed from this period of hypothermia (fig. 10
, ANOVA with Tukey multiple comparison test, P
Deep hypothermia is currently used to facilitate complex surgical procedures, including those that involve cardiac arrest.35
Such procedures are frequently complicated by adverse neurologic outcomes, but it is unclear whether ischemia, hypothermia, or both cause the injury. The results of this study, and another from our laboratory,12
show that hypothermia (4°C) and RW damages rat hippocampal neurons. The experimental conditions for both these studies are such that we can exclude ischemia-like damage from the injury to the neurons. Studies in dogs suggest that PF, independent of other factors, causes neuronal injury.6
The rate of RW from hypothermia may influence the severity of injury caused by hypothermia or ischemia during the period of hypothermia, which is an important issue that is debated in the clinical use of hypothermia for cardiopulmonary bypass.37
However, when we slowed the RW period after hypothermia from 1 h to 2.5 h, no difference in neuron death was seen (fig. 4
). Whether RW rate matters for less severe hypothermia and RW injury is currently under investigation in our laboratory.
We found that the volatile anesthetic agents isoflurane, sevoflurane, and xenon, but not the intravenous anesthetic agents propofol and pentobarbital, protect neurons from the injury caused by PF (4°C) and RW. The mechanism of isoflurane protection appears to involve limiting NMDA receptor-dependent Ca2+ overload that may be related to suppressing the release of glutamate caused by the stress of hypothermia and RW or by antagonizing NMDA receptors. Isoflurane also reduced the loss of ATP during hypothermia itself, but not during the entire hypothermia and RW period. We excluded several other targets that were thought to be involved in isoflurane protection; including ATP-sensitive K+ channels and GABA receptors. Because protection from cold injury was achieved when isoflurane was present only during RW, it appears that the predominant target for isoflurane is NMDA receptors during the RW phase when energy depletion is severe and the potential for excitotoxicity may be greatest.
A major finding was that isoflurane protection of neurons injured by PH/RW was not completely durable; that is, we observed protection after 1 h of RW, but 24 h later, the injury increased. This decrease in protection was also seen when the isoflurane was continued during the entire 24-h postrewarming period. There are several possibilities for these observations. The first is that PH/RW injury continues to evolve long after completion of RW, even though injury measured by PI or Sytox® does not suggest this.12
The second is that isoflurane is relatively weak in preventing PH/RW injury and that excitotoxicity still kills many neurons if excitotoxicity persists for a long enough period of time. This possibility could be tested in experiments in which NMDA receptor antagonists remain in the culture media after RW, although NMDA antagonist toxicity was a problem when this was attempted.
Blocking NMDA receptors was effective in preventing PH/RW injury in hippocampal neurons (figs. 6
), as was reducing extracellular [Ca2+
] with the chelating agent EGTA.12
Similar to Ca2+
-related neuron injury after hypoxia or ischemia, hypothermia-RW injury involves glutamatergic excitotoxicity, where uncontrolled Ca2+
influx through NMDA receptors is caused by release of glutamate from depolarizing neurons. In contrast with hypoxic-ischemic injury, T-type Ca2+
channels and L-type Ca2+
channels and the reverse mode Na+
exchanger are not involved in PH/RW injury.12
Volatile anesthetics are known to modulate excitotoxicity by several processes, including augmentation of glutamate reuptake transporters, inhibition of voltage-gated Ca2+
channels and activation of KATP
channels, and suppression of glutamate release. Although we only examined the mechanisms of protection in the case of isoflurane, it is reasonable to suggest that similar processes apply in the case of sevoflurane and xenon. Neither propofol nor pentobarbital have significant effects on NMDA receptors and this is probably why they were ineffective in preventing PH/RW injury.
We observed that increasing extracellular K+
to 30 mM protects neurons from cold injury (fig. 7
). This effect is observed in a variety of preparations, including brain slices and dissociated neurons38
and is most likely due to suppression of presynaptic glutamate release.33
These findings support our belief that glutamate neurotransmission is important to the excitotoxicity involved in PH/RW injury. As seen in figure 9
, PH/RW involves glutamate release from the cultures. At much higher K+
concentrations (80–120 mM), neurons are killed by Ca2+
accumulation from activation of voltage-dependent Ca2+
The data in figure 8
also make it unlikely that maintenance of a range of membrane potential is the key to surviving PH/RW; based on previous patch-clamp studies of isolated hippocampal neurons we showed that 30 mM K+
drives the membrane potential to approximately −13 mV. Thirty mM K+
was markedly neuroprotective, making it unlikely that maintenance of normal or hyperpolarized membrane potential is uniquely necessary for cold survival. Furthermore, because isoflurane added to the neuroprotection afforded by 30 mM K+
, it is unlikely that K channels (i.e.
, background or tandem-pore K channels) exclusively confer isoflurane's protection against PH/RW injury because the membrane potential of neurons is effectively clamped to depolarized potentials by the high extracellular K+
The observation that isoflurane was additive in protection to that conferred by 30 mM K+
) suggests that isoflurane's effects on glutamate excitotoxicity are mediated by inhibition postsynaptic NMDARs rather than only by suppression of glutamate release. This is because 30 mM K+
acts to mute synaptic release of glutamate33
; the fact that isoflurane produces additional protection in the presence of the high K+
means that it must have a separate protective effect. However, isoflurane did reduce the release of glutamate during hypothermia and RW. Taken together, we suggest that these data mean that isoflurane probably has both a presynaptic and postsynaptic effect on limiting glutamate excitotoxicity during PH/RW injury.
The inference that isoflurane's main target in protecting neurons from PH/RW injury is the NMDA receptor is limited by the fact that we did not directly measure inhibition of NMDARs in hypothermic or RW neurons. This was attempted, but was defeated by the difficulty of patch-clamping neurons in RW cultures (swelling makes the neurons rupture easily). The conclusion that isoflurane inhibits the NMDARs and that NMDARs are related to PH/RW injury and calcium overload is based on solid evidence, however. Isoflurane also decreases the release of glutamate, an effect that also would act to limit NMDAR-mediated Ca2+ overload during PH/RW injury.
With the exception of isoflurane, we studied only single concentrations of each anesthetic agent and although the concentrations were similar to those used clinically, we cannot exclude the possibility that the protective effects of these compounds are dose-dependent. Another issue relates to anesthetic potency at different temperatures. What is the relevance of minimum alveolar concentration or anesthetic concentration at temperatures less than 28°C where low temperature itself produces immobility? It is important to consider that, when volatile anesthetic agents are used in patients with hypothermia, no specific temperature correction is used to adjust the delivered concentration. Further, we believe that the protective effect of isoflurane or the other anesthetic agents is exerted during the RW period when excitotoxicity must peak. This does not explain why isoflurane reduces ATP loss during the period of hypothermia but not during rewarming. It is possible that isoflurane decreases ATPase activity in hypothermic but not rewarming neurons.
Innate differences in the hypothermia tolerances of different species of animals means that extrapolation of our results to other species of animals is difficult. Rats are probably more hypothermia tolerant than humans and 7-day-old rats are extremely tolerant of hypothermia compared with adult rats.40
It is therefore likely that the neuronal damage after exposure of HSCs to 4°C would occur at higher temperatures or with shorter durations of hypothermia in less hypothermia tolerant species, including humans.
We conclude that the most important neuroprotective target for volatile anesthetics in neurons undergoing PH/RW is NMDA receptor-mediated Ca2+ influx caused by glutamate excitotoxicity, which may be mediated both by reduced glutamate release and reduced NMDAR activity. Excitotoxicity is probably most significant during RW, when energy-depleted neurons experience dissipated ion gradients and peak risk of excitotoxic Ca2+ accumulation. Despite these protective actions, neuroprotection after PH and RW decreased with time, with protection fading by 24 h even when isoflurane was present during the entire postrewarming period.
The authors thank Ted Eger, M.D., Professor of Anesthesia, University of California, San Francisco, San Francisco, California, for help measuring isoflurane concentration in media samples.
1. Gluckman PD, Wyatt JS, Azzopardi D, Ballard R, Edwards AD, Ferriero DM, Polin RA, Robertson CM, Thoresen M, Whitelaw A, Gunn AJ: Selective head cooling with mild systemic hypothermia after neonatal encephalopathy: Multicentre randomised trial. Lancet 2005; 365:663–70
2. Shankaran S, Laptook AR, Ehrenkranz RA, Tyson JE, McDonald SA, Donovan EF, Fanaroff AA, Poole WK, Wright LL, Higgins RD, Finer NN, Carlo WA, Duara S, Oh W, Cotten CM, Stevenson DK, Stoll BJ, Lemons JA, Guillet R, Jobe AH, National Institute of Child Health and Human Development Neonatal Research Network: Whole-body hypothermia for neonates with hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy. N Engl J Med 2005; 353:1574–84
3. Hypothermia after Cardiac Arrest Study Group: Mild therapeutic hypothermia to improve the neurologic outcome after cardiac arrest. N Engl J Med 2002; 346: 549–56
4. Egerton N, Egerton WS, Kay JH: Neurologic changes following profound hypothermia. Ann Surg 1963; 157:366–74
5. Khaladj N, Shrestha M, Meck S, Peterss S, Kamiya H, Kallenbach K, Winterhalter M, Hoy L, Haverich A, Hagl C: Hypothermic circulatory arrest with selective antegrade cerebral perfusion in ascending aortic and aortic arch surgery: A risk factor analysis for adverse outcome in 501 patients. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 2008; 135:908–14
6. Watanabe Y, Kawaura Y, Iwa T: Brain damage after deep hypothermia in dogs. Jap J Surgery 1982; 12:61–70
7. Levin DA, Seay AR, Fullerton DA, Simoes EA, Sondheimer HM: Profound hypothermia with alpha-stat pH management during open-heart surgery is associated with choreoathetosis. Pediatr Cardiol 2005; 26:34–8
8. Visconti KJ, Rimmer D, Gauvreau K, del Nido P, Mayer JE Jr, Hagino I, Pigula FA: Regional low-flow perfusion versus circulatory arrest in neonates: One-year neurodevelopmental outcome. Ann Thorac Surg 2006; 82:2207–11; discussion 2211–3
9. DeLeon SY, Thomas C, Roughneen PT, King N, Lehne R, DeLeon AM, Walenga J, Pifarr R: Experimental evidence of cerebral injury from profound hypothermia during cardiopulmonary bypass. Pediatr Cardiol 1998; 19:398–403
10. Alam HB, Chen Z, Li Y, Velmahos G, DeMoya M, Keller CE, Toruno K, Mehrani T, Rhee P, Spaniolas K: Profound hypothermia is superior to ultraprofound hypothermia in improving survival in a swine model of lethal injuries. Surgery 2006; 140:307–14
11. Lipton P: Ischemic cell death in brain neurons. Physiol Rev 1999; 79:1431–568
12. Warren DE, Bickler PE, Clark JP, Gregersen M, Brosnan H, McKleroy W, Gabatto P: Hypothermia and rewarming injury in hippocampal neurons involves intracellular Ca2+ and glutamate excitotoxicity. Neuroscience 2012; 207:316–25
13. Sakai H, Sheng H, Yates RB, Ishida K, Pearlstein RD, Warner DS: Isoflurane provides long-term protection against focal cerebral ischemia in the rat. ANESTHESIOLOGY 2007; 106:92–9
14. Weigl M, Tenze G, Steinlechner B, Skhirtladze K, Reining G, Bernardo M, Pedicelli E, Dworschak M: A systematic review of currently available pharmacological neuroprotective agents as a sole intervention before anticipated or induced cardiac arrest. Resuscitation 2005; 65:21–39
15. Eilers H, Bickler PE: Hypothermia and isoflurane similarly inhibit glutamate release evoked by chemical anoxia in rat cortical brain slices. ANESTHESIOLOGY 1996; 85:600–7
16. Kudo M, Aono M, Lee Y, Massey G, Pearlstein RD, Warner DS: Effects of volatile anesthetics on N-methyl-D-aspartate excitotoxicity in primary rat neuronal-glial cultures. ANESTHESIOLOGY 2001; 95:756–65
17. Wang J, Cottrell JE, Kass IS: Effects of desflurane and propofol on electrophysiological parameters during and recovery after hypoxia in rat hippocampal slice CA1 pyramidal cells. Neuroscience 2009; 160:140–8
18. Bickler PE, Warner DS, Stratmann G, Schuyler JA: gamma-Aminobutyric acid-A receptors contribute to isoflurane neuroprotection in organotypic hippocampal cultures. Anesth Analg 2003; 97:564–71
19. Bickler PE, Fahlman CS: Enhanced hypoxic preconditioning by isoflurane: Signaling gene expression and requirement of intracellular Ca2+ and inositol triphosphate receptors. Brain Res 2010; 1340:86–95
20. Bickler PE, Zhan X, Fahlman CS: Isoflurane preconditions hippocampal neurons against oxygen-glucose deprivation: Role of intracellular Ca2+ and mitogen-activated protein kinase signaling. ANESTHESIOLOGY 2005; 103:532–9
21. Gray JJ, Bickler PE, Fahlman CS, Zhan X, Schuyler JA: Isoflurane neuroprotection in hypoxic hippocampal slice cultures involves increases in intracellular Ca2+ and mitogen-activated protein kinases. ANESTHESIOLOGY 2005; 102:606–15
22. Kurth CD, Priestley M, Watzman HM, McCann J, Golden J: Desflurane confers neurologic protection for deep hypothermic circulatory arrest in newborn pigs. ANESTHESIOLOGY 2001; 95:959–64
23. Stoppini L, Buchs PA, Muller D: A simple method for organotypic cultures of nervous tissue. J Neurosci Methods 1991; 37:173–82
24. Bickler PE, Fahlman CS, Gray JJ: Hypoxic preconditioning failure in aging hippocampal neurons: Impaired gene expression and rescue with intracellular calcium chelation. J Neurosci Res 2010; 88:3520–9
25. Laake JH, Haug FM, Weiloch T, Ottersen OP: A simple in vitro model of ischemia based on hippocampal slice cultures and propidium iodide fluorescence. Brain Res Brain Res Protoc 1999; 4:173–84
26. Newell DW, Barth A, Papermaster V, Malouf AT: Glutamate and non-glutamate receptor mediated toxicity caused by oxygen and glucose deprivation in organotypic hippocampal cultures. J Neuroscience 1995; 15:7702–11
27. Lacour P, Heimrich B, Prls F: Induction of cellular stress and chaperone activation in organotypic slice cultures of hippocampus. J Neurosci Methods 2007; 166:24–31
28. Orliaguet G, Vivien B, Langeron O, Bouhemad B, Coriat P, Riou B: Minimum alveolar concentration of volatile anesthetics in rats during postnatal maturation. ANESTHESIOLOGY 2001; 95:734–9
29. Koblin DD, Fang Z, Eger EI 2nd, Laster MJ, Gong D, Ionescu P, Halsey MJ, Trudell JR: Minimum alveolar concentrations of noble gases, nitrogen, and sulfur hexafluoride in rats: Helium and neon as nonimmobilizers (nonanesthetics). Anesth Analg 1998; 87:419–24
30. Gordan ML, Kellermann K, Blobner M, Nollert G, Kochs EF, Jungwirth B: Fast rewarming after deep hypothermic circulatory arrest in rats impairs histologic outcome and increases NFκB expression in the brain. Perfusion 2010; 25:349–54
31. Ogata J, Shiraishi M, Namba T, Smothers CT, Woodward JJ, Harris RA: Effects of anesthetics on mutant N-methyl-D-aspartate receptors expressed in Xenopus oocytes. J Pharmacol Exp Ther 2006; 318:434–43
32. Bickler PE, Buck LT, Hansen BM: Effects of isoflurane and hypothermia on glutamate receptor-mediated calcium influx in brain slices. ANESTHESIOLOGY 1994; 81:1461–9
33. Hogins J, Crawford DC, Jiang X, Mennerick S: Presynaptic silencing is an endogenous neuroprotectant during excitotoxic insults. Neurobiol Dis 2011; 43:516–25
34. Nakayama M, Fujita S, Kanaya N, Tsuchida H, Namiki A: Blockade of ATP-sensitive K+ channel abolishes the anti-ischemic effects of isoflurane in dog hearts. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand 1997; 41:531–5
35. Elmistekawy EM, Rubens FD: Deep hypothermic circulatory arrest: Alternative strategies for cerebral perfusion. A review article. Perfusion 2011; 26(Suppl 1):27–34
36. Sundt TM, Flemming MD, Oderich GS, Torres NE, Li Z, Lenoch J, Kalra M: Spinal cord protection during open repair of thoracic and thoracoabdominal aortic aneurysms using profound hypothermia and circulatory arrest. J Am Coll Surg 2011; 212:678–83; discussion 684–5
37. Grigore AM, Murray CF, Ramakrishna H, Djaiani G: A core review of temperature regimens and neuroprotection during cardiopulmonary bypass: Does rewarming rate matter? Anesth Analg 2009; 109:1741–51
38. Scott BS, Fisher KC: Potassium concentration and number of neurons in cultures of dissociated ganglia. Exp Neurol 1970; 27:16–22
39. Gallo V, Kingsbury A, Balzs R, Jrgensen OS: The role of depolarization in the survival and differentiation of cerebellar granule cells in culture. J Neurosci 1987; 7:2203–13
40. Adolph EF: Tolerance to cold and anoxia in infant rats. Am J Physiol 1948; 155:366–77
© 2012 American Society of Anesthesiologists, Inc.