The HIV care continuum: no partial credit given
McNairy, Margaret L.a,b,c; El-Sadr, Wafaa M.a,b
bDepartment of Epidemiology, Mailman School of Public Health, Columbia University
cDepartment of Medicine, Weill Cornell Medical College, New York, New York, USA.
Correspondence to Margaret McNairy, ICAP, Columbia University, 722W, 168th Street, 712, New York, NY 10032, USA. Tel: +1 212 304 5483; fax: +1 212 342 1824; e-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org
Received 29 March, 2012
Revised 7 May, 2012
Accepted 11 May, 2012
Despite significant scale-up of HIV care and treatment across the world, overall effectiveness of HIV programs is severely undermined by attrition of patients across the HIV care continuum, both in resource-rich and resource-limited settings. The care continuum has four essential steps: linkage from testing to enrollment in care, determination of antiretroviral therapy (ART) eligibility, ART initiation, and adherence to medications to achieve viral suppression. In order to substantially improve health outcomes for the individual and potentially for prevention of transmission to others, each of the steps of the entire care continuum must be achieved. This will require the adoption of interventions that address the multiplicity of barriers and social contexts faced by individuals and populations across each step, a reconceptualization of services to maximize engagement in care, and ambitious evaluation of program performance using all-or-none measurement.
Scale up of HIV testing, care, and treatment across the world, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa (SSA), where the majority of people living with HIV (PLWH) reside, has been extraordinary with millions of individuals tested for HIV, over 11 million enrolled in HIV care, and more than 6 million initiated on antiretroviral therapy (ART) [1,2]. The impact of this effort is evident in the decrease in HIV-related deaths and rates of mother-to-child-transmission in high prevalence countries as well as in the notable decrease in HIV incidence in several countries in SSA [2,3]. However, the overall effectiveness of HIV programs is severely undermined by attrition of patients across the HIV care continuum, both in resource-rich and resource-limited settings. In studies from the United States, only 19–28% of PLWH are estimated to achieve viral load suppression [4,5]. In SSA, insufficient data are available on overall viral load suppression given it is not routinely available, but less than one-third of individuals who test HIV positive are estimated to be retained from time of testing through ART initiation [6,7].
Completion of the entire care continuum is essential for optimal health outcomes for PLWH. This continuum begins with HIV testing and continues through multiple steps on the path to viral suppression for those initiated on ART (Fig. 1). The first step of the continuum begins with HIV testing and requires linkage from the site of HIV testing to enrolment in a HIV clinic to begin care. The second step of the continuum involves counseling, clinical and laboratory monitoring for disease progression on an ongoing basis to determine ART eligibility. The subsequent step is prompt ART initiation based on prevailing guidelines. Upon initiation of ART, similar monitoring and counseling is needed to achieve and maintain viral suppression, a critical outcome necessary for attaining individual benefits from treatment . Viral suppression in PLWH has also been associated with a decrease in risk of HIV transmission to sexual partners, an additional benefit from effective completion of the continuum .
No single step in the care continuum appears to be the sole bottleneck in the achievement of the entire continuum. Linkage from testing to care has not been routinely reported by programs, but limited data suggest that it is poor across diverse settings. In the United States, only 48% of PLWH in South Carolina and 77% in New York City linked to care within 3 months of receiving an HIV-positive test result [10,11], as compared to the target of 85% recommended by the US National AIDS Strategy . In SSA, median linkage is 59% across an analysis of 28 studies . Determination of ART eligibility and initiation of ART for eligible patients is also suboptimal. In the United States only half of PLWH, once enrolled, remained in care and 89% of those eligible were prescribed ART . Results are similar in SSA where less than half of PLWH receive a CD4+ cell count test results or clinical staging, two critical assessments required to determine ART eligibility . Approximately, two-thirds of PLWH who are eligible for ART remain in care to the time of ART initiation [6,7], and approximately 70% of patients on ART are retained in care at 24 months .
Improvements in each step of the continuum must be achieved simultaneously to improve outcomes such as achievement of viral load suppression, decreased mother-to-child transmission, and reduced HIV-related mortality. To improve viral suppression in PLWH in the United States, it has been noted that only when each step in the continuum is completed with 90% fidelity would the proportion of viral suppression increase from the current 19% to 66% . In the context of the programs for prevention of mother-to-child transmission (PMTCT), programs need to perform with 90–95% effectiveness across the various steps in the continuum in order to achieve the ultimate desired mother-to-child-transmission rate of less than 5% .
There are multiple reasons for the failure to achieve optimal linkages and retention including structural, biomedical, and behavioral barriers. In a meta-analysis of 17 studies evaluating loss to follow-up in ART patients, the most common reasons reported were lack of money, improving or deteriorating health, and transfer to another HIV care site . In a study from Uganda, reported reasons for loss to follow-up included lack of transport (50%), lack of money (35%), work (27%) or childcare (22%), and deteriorating health (6%) . Stigma also continues to be a barrier, particularly in marginalized populations such as men who have sex with men (MSM), and has been associated with nondisclosure of HIV status and poor retention [17,18]. To address these challenges, interventions such as use of point-of-care CD4+ cell count testing at time of receipt of positive HIV test result [19,20], case managers , counseling, mobile technology [22,23], and financial incentives  offer encouraging results for enhancing various steps in the continuum. However, no single intervention to date has been able to substantially impact all steps in the continuum. Combination approaches, which evaluate the feasibility of multiple interventions, are being explored with a focus on overall adherence with all steps in the continuum . Furthermore, interventions must be tailored to the social context and characteristics of the specific patient populations they serve. For example, MSM in resource-rich settings are likely to face different barriers as compared to pregnant women in resource-limited settings.
In addition to the interventions listed above, a reconceptualization of how HIV services are organized may also be needed to achieve desired health outcomes. For example, HIV testing and HIV care and treatment services have historically been organized and operated separately in disparate physical locations, operated by different staff members sometimes working in parallel and isolation of each other. New models of integrated HIV services should be developed to create networks of testing and care with agile referral systems. Another example is the current organization of HIV services for pregnant HIV-infected women. These services are traditionally based on having PMTCT interventions during pregnancy and delivery provided separately from HIV care and treatment services required by the pregnant HIV-infected women and their infants beyond delivery. Recent studies have shown alarmingly high rates of loss to follow-up for these women, particularly in the transition after delivery, between PMTCT and lifelong HIV care services [26–28]. Integrated HIV care, including provision of ART and antenatal services, whether within antenatal clinics or preferably in primary care clinics that provide continuity care for HIV-infected women and their children may need to be considered.
In addition to the organization of services, another issue that needs particular attention is the manner in which HIV program performance is evaluated. To date, performance indicators largely measure activities within each service, or step, rather than throughout the continuum. For example, HIV testing sites report the numbers of tests conducted or individuals tested rather than the ultimate disposition of those found to be HIV positive. Similarly, HIV care and treatment programs are largely evaluated by the number of individuals enrolled in care or who initiated ART rather than the number of individuals who were retained across the entire HIV care continuum. Likewise, PMTCT programs have focused on achieving HIV testing in a high percentage of pregnant women attending antenatal care clinics and the number of women and infants who received antiretroviral regimens for PMTCT, rather than the number of HIV-infected pregnant women who were retained in care beyond delivery and whether their infants were appropriately followed in care until their HIV status is confirmed.
The time is right for HIV programs to be evaluated ambitiously based on the proportion of PLWH who receive a full package, or bundle, of HIV services across the continuum, that is in an all-or-none manner with ‘no partial credit given’ for achievement in one step of the continuum . Success would be determined by the proportion of patients who received all the steps, or all of the care components, for which he or she is eligible. In a 2006 article, Nolan and Berwick  articulated the advantages of an ‘all-or-none’ measurement as a patient-centered approach, a tool to ensure quality, and a means of promoting a systems perspective. All-or-none measurement is particularly appropriate for chronic disease management, as in the case of HIV disease, given the importance of retention over time and the need for receipt of multiple interventions. In order to operationalize this concept, country and program leadership as well as funders must embrace this approach, whereas at the same time appropriate data elements must be collected and data management capacity strengthened.
The historic global response to the HIV epidemic has demonstrated the feasibility of establishing large-scale HIV programs in some of the poorest countries in the world. To realize the potential of this extraordinary investment and to enable meeting the remaining challenges will require attention to every step of the HIV care continuum. The loss of program effectiveness is particularly tragic at a time of tremendous potential, immense needs and constrained resources. Attention to the full care continuum coupled with the implementation of creative integrated models of care and ambitious performance measures can go a long way to achievement of an AIDS-free generation.
M.M. and W.E.S. coauthored all drafts of this manuscript.
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
Disclaimers and Disclosures: none.
Sources of support for this work: none.
4. Cohen SM, Van Handel MM, Branson BM, Blair JM, Hall HI, Hu X, et al
. Vital signs: HIV prevention through care and treatment – United States.MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep
5. Gardner EM, McLees MP, Steiner JF, Del Rio C, Burman WJ. The spectrum of engagement in HIV care and its relevance to test-and-treat strategies for prevention of HIV infection
. Clin Infect Dis
6. Rosen S, Fox MP. Retention in HIV care between testing and treatment in sub-Saharan Africa: a systematic review
. PLoS Med
7. Mugglin CEJ, Wandeler G, Bender N, Gsponer T, Egger M, Keiser O. Linkage, retention, and retention in care [abstract 1143].
In: 19th Conference on Retroviruses and Opportunisitc Infections
; 5–8 March 2012. Seattle, Washington.
8. Paterson DL, Swindells S, Mohr J, Brester M, Vergis EN, Squier C, et al. Adherence to protease inhibitor therapy and outcomes in patients with HIV infection
. Ann Intern Med
9. Cohen MS, Chen YQ, McCauley M, Gamble T, Hosseinipour MC, Kumarasamy N, et al. Prevention of HIV-1 infection with early antiretroviral therapy
. N Engl J Med
10. Tripathi A, Gardner LI, Ogbuanu I, Youmans E, Stephens T, Gibson JJ, et al. Predictors of time to enter medical care after a new HIV diagnosis: a statewide population-based study
. AIDS Care
11. Jenness SM, Myers JE, Neaigus A, Lulek J, Navejas M, Raj-Singh S. Delayed entry into HIV medical care after HIV diagnosis: Risk factors and research methods.AIDS Care
2012. [Epub ahead of print].
12. Holtgrave DR. On the epidemiologic and economic importance of the National AIDS strategy for the United States
. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr
13. Fox MP, Rosen S. Patient retention in antiretroviral therapy programs up to three years on treatment in sub Saharan Africa, 2007–2009: systematic review
. Trop Med Int Health
14. Barker PM, Mphatswe W, Rollins N. Antiretroviral drugs in the cupboard are not enough: the impact of health systems’ performance on mother-to-child transmission of HIV
. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr
15. Brinkhof MW, Pujades-Rodriguez M, Egger M. Mortality of patients lost to follow-up in antiretroviral treatment programmes in resource-limited settings: systematic review and meta-analysis
. PLoS One
16. Geng EH, Bangsberg DR, Musinguzi N, Emenyonu N, Bwana MB, Yiannoutsos CT, et al. Understanding reasons for and outcomes of patients lost to follow-up in antiretroviral therapy programs in Africa through a sampling-based approach
. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr
17. Nachega JB, Morroni C, Zuniga JM, Sherer R, Beyrer C, Solomon S, et al.HIV-related stigma, isolation, discrimination, and serostatus disclosure: a global survey of 2035 HIV-infected adults.J Int Assoc Physicians AIDS Care (Chic)
18. Wohl AR, Galvan FH, Myers HF, Garland W, George S, Witt M, et al. Do social support, stress, disclosure and stigma influence retention in HIV care for Latino and African American men who have sex with men and women?
. AIDS Behav
19. Jani IV, Sitoe NE, Alfai ER, Chongo PL, Quevedo JI, Rocha BM, et al. Effect of point-of-care CD4 cell count tests on retention of patients and rates of antiretroviral therapy initiation in primary health clinics: an observational cohort study
20. Faal M, Naidoo N, Glencross DK, Venter WD, Osih R. Providing immediate CD4 count results at HIV testing improves ART initiation
. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr
21. Gardner LI, Metsch LR, Anderson-Mahoney P, Loughlin AM, del Rio C, Strathdee S, et al. Efficacy of a brief case management intervention to link recently diagnosed HIV-infected persons to care
22. Lester RT, Ritvo P, Mills EJ, Kariri A, Karanja S, Chung MH, et al.Effects of a mobile phone short message service on antiretroviral treatment adherence in Kenya (WelTel Kenya1): a randomised trial.Lancet
23. Mukund BKC, Murray P. Cell phone short messaging service (SMS) for HIV/AIDS in South Africa: a literature review
. Stud Health Technol Inform
24. Emenyonu N, Thirumurthy H, Muyindike W, Mwebesa B, Ragland K, Geng E, et al.Cash transfers to cover clinic transportation costs improve retention in care in a HIV treatment program in rural Uganda [abstract 831].
In: Conference on Retroviruses and Opportunistic Infections
; 16–19 February 2010; San Francisco, California.
25. The HIV Prevention Trials Network
26. Rawizza HMS, Oyebode T, Sagay S, Adewole I, Okonkwo P, Kanki P, . Evaluation of loss to follow-up within the PMTCT care cascade in a large ART program: Nigeria [abstract 1017].
In: 19th Conference on Retroviruses and Opportunisitic Infections
; 5–8 March 2012. Seattle, Washington.
27. Myer LCM, Fox M, Garone D, Wood R, Prozesky H, Ndirangu J, et al.Loss to follow-up and mortality among pregnant and nonpregnant women initiating ART: South Africa [abstract 27].
In: 19th Conference on Retroviruses and Opportunistic Infections
; 5–8 March 2011. Seattle, Washington.
28. Wang B, Losina E, Stark R, Munro A, Walensky RP, Wilke M, et al. Loss to follow-up in a community clinic in South Africa: roles of gender, pregnancy and CD4 count
. S Afr Med J
29. Nolan T, Berwick DM. All-or-none measurement raises the bar on performance
This article has been cited 4 time(s).
AIDS and BehaviorConditional Economic Incentives to Improve HIV Treatment Adherence: Literature Review and Theoretical ConsiderationsAIDS and Behavior
Journal of the International AIDS SocietyBarriers and facilitators to linkage to ART in primary care: a qualitative study of patients and providers in Blantyre, MalawiJournal of the International AIDS Society
Jama Internal MedicineDifferences in Human Immunodeficiency Virus Care and Treatment Among Subpopulations in the United StatesJama Internal Medicine
Journal of Loss & TraumaGrief and HIV Medication Adherence: The Work of Transcending LossJournal of Loss & Trauma
adherence; HIV; retention
© 2012 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Inc.
Highlight selected keywords in the article text.