Epidemiology and Social: Concise Communication
Safety of multiple daily applications of COL-1492, a nonoxynol-9 vaginal gel, among female sex workers
Van Damme, Luta; Chandeying, Verapolb; Ramjee, Gitac; Rees, Helend; Sirivongrangson, Pacharae; Laga, Mariea; Perriëns, Josf; on behalf of COL-1492 Phase II Study Group
From the aInstitute of Tropical Medicine, Antwerp, Belgium, the bPrince of Songkla University, Hat Yai, Thailand, the cCentre for Epidemiological Research (CERSA), Durban, the dReproductive Health Research Unit, Johannesburg, Republic of South Africa, eMinistry of Public Health, VD Division, Bangkok, Thailand and fUNAIDS, Geneva, Switzerland. *See Appendix.
Correspondence to Lut Van Damme, STD/HIV Research and Intervention Unit, Institute of Tropical Medicine, Nationalestraat 155, 2000 Antwerp, Belgium.
Received: 8 October 1999; revised: 23 September 1999; accepted: 27 October 1999.
Rationale: COL-1492 is a nonoxynol-9 (N-9)-containing vaginal gel and may be a potential microbicide. As part of an effectiveness trial, an initial toxicity study was conducted.
Objectives: The main objective of the reported study was the assessment of the toxicity of a 52.5 mg N-9 gel, COL-1492, when used a number of times each day by female sex workers.
Methods: This was a randomized, placebo-controlled triple-blinded trial among female sex workers. The participants were asked to use the product for each vaginal sexual act. At each monthly visit a gynaecological examination with sexually transmitted disease sampling and colposcopy was performed. Venous blood was drawn for syphilis and HIV serology. All women received intensive counselling on condom use. Male condoms and sexually transmitted disease treatment were given free of charge.
Results: Only blinded results on the colposcopic examinations are reported. The incidence of lesions with or without an epithelial disruption was low: 0.06 and 0.29, respectively, per 100 woman–days in group A; 0.09 and 0.26 respectively per 100 woman–days in group B. There was no significant difference between the two arms.
Conclusion: The multiple daily use of COL-1492 by female sex workers did not show an increase of local toxicity over that of a placebo. Colposcopy was discontinued in the autumn of 1997 in accordance with a Data Safety Monitoring Board decision. In the currently ongoing effectiveness trial the assessment of the product's toxicity continues to be monitored by simple visual examination.
For several years nonoxynol-9 (N-9) has received a lot of attention as a potential microbicide. It acts by disrupting the membranes of cells, viruses and bacteria. N-9 has an in vitro activity against HIV and other sexually transmitted disease (STD) pathogens [1–6] Although most in vivo data show a protective effect against Neisseria gonorrhoeae and Chlamydia trachomatis[7–11] the data on in vivo anti-HIV effectiveness are not conclusive. Two cohort studies showed a protective effect of N-9 among consistent users [12,13] One randomized controlled trial among female sex workers in Kenya showed an increased HIV incidence among women using a 1000 mg N-9 sponge compared with placebo users  However this study has been criticized for methodological reasons  A randomized controlled trial with a vaginal film containing 70 mg N-9 among Cameroonian female sex workers showed no effect, either harmful or beneficial, on HIV, N. gonorrhoeae or C. trachomatis Despite these results, an effectiveness trial with COL-1492, using a 52.5 mg N-9-containing vaginal gel, is continuing with the justification that a different formulation may give a better availability of N-9 in the vagina and that a lower N-9 concentration may be associatied with less toxicity. The trial started with an intensive toxicity monitoring phase using colposcopy. The results of these colposopic evaluations are reported here.
The reported study is part of a larger randomized, placebo-controlled, triple-blind trial among female sex workers to assess the product's effect in the prevention of heterosexual vaginal HIV infection and other STDs. Participants were recruited through the Venereal Disease Unit of the Ministry of Public Health, Bangkok, Thailand; the Prince of Songkla University, Hat Yai, Thailand; the Centre for Epidemiological Research (CERSA), Durban, South Africa and the Reproductive Health Research Unit, Johannesburg, South Africa. The technical coordination was carried out by the Institute of Tropical Medicine, Antwerp, Belgium. The main trial sponsor was UNAIDS, Geneva, Switzerland. The study was approved by all local and national ethical review boards.
HIV-seronegative female sex workers who volunteered could be enrolled if they had at least five partners per week; were participating in a 100% condom-use programme; were above the local legal adult age and were willing and able to comply with the study protocol. They were excluded if they had a genital ulcer, abrasion or clinical STD; required any long-term treatment; used intravenous drugs, crack or cocaine; were pregnant or wished to become pregnant; were allergic to latex or nonoxynol-9 or were using a vaginal spermicide. A separate randomization was carried out for each centre.
COL-1492 gel (marketed in the United States as the spermicidal gel Advantage S®, Columbia Laboratories, New York, New York, USA) contains 3.5% (52.5 mg) nonoxynol-9; other constituents include polycarbophil, a polymer with bio-adhesive properties. The placebo gel contained the same ingredients with the exception of nonoxynol-9. Both were packed in single-dose, disposable plastic applicators designed to deliver 1.5 g gel. COL-1492 and the placebo were provided by Columbia Laboratories (Paris, France).
At each visit a gynaecological examination with STD sampling and a colposcopic evaluation were carried out. Blood was drawn for HIV and syphilis serology. Participants were counselled on HIV testing and safe sex. At screening concise information on the study was given. Oral informed consent for the screening procedures was obtained. Eligible women were enrolled within 28 days after their screening. At the enrolment visit comprehensive information was given and written informed consent obtained. Whenever an STD was diagnosed, treatment was given free of charge. Women received the required quantity of study product and male condoms. They were asked to use the male condom for every sexual act and to apply the gel for every vaginal act if they had cleaned their vagina after the last intercourse.
The main outcomes of the reported sub-study were lesions revealed by colposcopy performed according to the modified WHO manual on colposcopy (i.e. no acetic acid, iodine or green filter were used) 
To have an 80% chance of detecting a difference of 15% in incidence of colposcopic findings between the two groups, a sample size of 150 subjects was needed (α = 0.05, one-sided), or 75 subjects in each treatment group. An intention-to-treat analysis was performed on data of women with at least one colposcopic examination. The analysis was focused on the first five visits. For each of these visits the sample size was sufficient. A preliminary investigation to study the relationship between presence of a lesion and study drug was done by construction of 2 × 2 tables for each of these five visits. In order to control for confounding, logistic regression was performed comparing the treatment groups with respect to the presence of colposcopic lesions at these visits. Finally, a Cox's proportional hazards model was used to compare the incidence of lesions in each treatment group. A P-value of 0.05 was regarded as statistically significant.
Only the blinded results on colposcopy will be presented, because the other outcomes (gynaecological signs, visual pelvic examination, STDs and acceptability) are part of the phase III endpoints.
A total of 320 women had at least one colposcopic evaluation: 158 in group A, 162 in group B. At baseline all characteristics were similar in both arms as summarized in Table 1. Women in Hat Yai had on average fewer clients (mean of 1.6) than women in the other centres. There was a major difference between the centres with regard to condom use. In Bangkok all women reported more than 75% condom use, in Durban 63% used condoms for less than 25% of their sexual acts and 91% for less than 50%, whereas in Hat Yai and Johannesburg almost all women (98 and 91% respectively) used condoms for more than half of their sexual acts.
The mean daily gel use was 1.2 (range, 0–9.9) and 1.3 applicators (range, 0–5.9) in groups A and B respectively.
At baseline around 10% of participants in both groups had an abnormality on colposcopy. These women were excluded from the survival analysis.
During product use few lesions as described in the WHO manual were observed. In group A five ulcers occurred in the vagina and on the external genitalia. In group B seven ulcers were diagnosed. All ulcerations had disappeared at the next visit. Abrasions were diagnosed on the cervix and the external genitalia. These had also healed at the next visit. In lesions without epithelial disruption, erythema occurred most frequently and was mostly observed on the cervix. In logistic regression, controlling for centre, there was no difference at any visit (up to week 12) between the treatment groups for the probability of having a lesion.
The incidence of colposcopic lesions was low with no difference between group A and B (Table 2), and this for lesions with or without epithelial disruption. In both groups, the chance of having a lesion increased with an increase in the mean daily use of the product (P < 0.001). No other factors could be associated with the observation of lesions.
The reported data show that the multiple daily use of COL-1492, a 52.5 mg N-9 gel, by female sex workers is non-toxic. The incidence of lesions with epithelial disruption was low, 0.06 and 0.09/100 woman–days in groups A and B, respectively. Lesions without an epithelial disruption occurred at similar rates in both groups.
At the present time there is some hesitation and doubt about the role of colposcopy in microbicide trials. Researchers were concerned about the potential toxicity of spermicides, and as a consequence a possible increased risk of HIV infection [14,18] A consensus was reached that before effectiveness trials could start, the safety of a product should be established. One tool for monitoring vaginal toxicity is colposcopy. It is a good light source, gives an enlarged view, the vascular pattern can be assessed and photographs can be taken. An international team developed the WHO manual with a primary objective of defining the standardization of colposcopy in the evaluation of vaginal products  However, researchers are now aware of some limitations to colposcopy. Firstly, it is not clear how one should interpret lesions without an epithelial disruption. Do they enhance HIV infectivity and/or infectiousness? Therefore the relevance of recording them has been questioned. Secondly, lesions with an epithelial disruption, which are likely to enhance HIV transmission in analogy with ulcerative STDs [19,20] can be seen with the naked eye. Thirdly, implementing and standardizing colposcopy in the field is difficult. Fourthly, no association between colposcopic and histologic findings has been established so far  In January 1999 the Contraceptive Research and Development Program (CONRAD) organized a meeting on colposcopy in microbicide trials. Among other subjects, a revision of the WHO manual was discussed. The main changes proposed were dropping the use of acetic acid, a green filter and a high magnification. Colposcopy was defined as `a magnified visualization of the cervix and vagina' for which the use of a colposcope is not necessary as long as there is an ability to magnify between 4× and 10×, a self-contained light source and a bi- or monocular visual tool.
In the trial presented here, colposcopy was discontinued in the autumn of 1997. Together with the effect on HIV infection and other STDs, the toxicity of the product continues to be assessed through simple visual examination.
The authors would like to thank all the study participants, the staff and the monitors in each centre, Tessa James for correcting the manuscript and Yvette Jacob for the administrative support. The analysis on colposcopic findings was performed by Veerle Vandersmissen, Institute of Tropical Medicine, Antwerp, Belgium.
1. Malkovsky M Newell A Dalgleish AG Inactivation of HIV by nonoxynol-9. Lancet 1988 1 (8586)645.645.
2. Bourinbaiar AS Fruhstorfer EC The efficacy of nonoxynol-9 from an in vitro point of view. AIDS 1996 10558.558.
3. Patton DL Wang S Kuo C In vitro activity of Nonoxynol-9 on HeLa 229 Cells and primary monkey cervical epithelial cells infected withChlamydia trachomatis. Antimicrob Agents Chemother 1992 361478–1482.
4. Hicks DR Martin LS Getchell JP et al Inactivation of HTLV-III/LAV-infected cultures of normal human lymphocytes by nonoxynol-9 in vitro. Lancet 1985 21422–1423.
5. Benes S McCormack WM Inhibition of growth ofChlamydia trachomatisby Nonoxynol-9in vitro. Antimicrob Agents Chemother 1985 27724–726.
6. Harrison C Chantler E The effect of nonoxynol-9 and chlorhexidine on HIV and spermin vitro. Int J STD AIDS 1998 992–97.
7. Weir SS Feldblum PJ Zekeng L Roddy RE The use of nonoxynol-9 for protection against cervical gonorrhea. Am J Public Health 1994 84910–914.
8. Niruthisard S Roddy RE Chutivongse S Use of nonoxynol-9 and reduction in rate of gonococcal and chlamydial cervical infections. Lancet 1992 3391371–1375.
9. Rosenberg MJ Rojanapithayakorn W Feldblum PJ Higgins JE Effect of the contraceptive sponge on chlamydial infection, gonorrhea, and candidiasis. JAMA 1997 2572308–2312.
10. Louv WC Austin H Alexander WJ Stagno S Cheeks J A clinical trial of nonoxynol-9 for preventing gonococcal and chlamydial infections. J Infect Dis 1988 158518–523.
11. Cook RL Rosenberg MJ Do spermicides containing nonoxynol-9 prevent sexually transmitted infections? Sex Transm Dis 1998 25144–150.
12. Hira SK Feldblum PJ Kamanga J Mukelabai G Weir SS Thomas JC Condom and nonoxynol-9 use and the incidence of HIV infection in serodiscordant couples in Zambia. Int J STD & AIDS 1997 8243–250.
13. Zekeng L Feldblum PJ Oliver RM Kaptue L Barrier contraceptive use and HIV infection among high-risk women in Cameroon. AIDS 1993 7725–731.
14. Kreiss J Ngugi E Holmes KK et al Efficacy of nonoxynol-9 contraceptive sponge use in preventing heterosexual acquisition of HIV in Nairobi prostitutes. JAMA 1992 268477–482.
15. Stone KM Peterson HB Spermicides, HIV, and the vaginal sponge. JAMA 1992 268521–523.
16. Roddy RE Zekeng L Ryan KA Tamoufe U Weir SS Wong EL A controlled trial of nonoxynol-9 film to reduce male-to-female transmission of sexually transmitted diseases. New Engl J Med 1998 339504–510.
17. WHO Global Programme on AIDS, Geneva, Switzerland. Manual for the standardization of colposcopy for the evaluation of vaginally administered products. WHO/GPA/RID/CRD/95. 10.
18. Goeman J Ndoye I Sakho LM et al Frequent use of menfegol spermicidal vaginal foaming tablets associated with a high incidence of genital lesions. J Infect Dis 1995 1711611–1614.
19. Wasserheit JN Epidemiological synergy: interrelationships between Human Immunodeficiency Virus infection and other sexually transmitted diseases. Sex Transm Dis 1992 1961–77.
20. Laga M Nzilambi N Goeman J The interrelationship of sexually transmitted diseases and HIV infection : implications for the control of both epidemics in Africa. AIDS 1991 5(suppl 1)S55–S63.
21. Stafford MK Cain D Rosenstein I et al A placebo-controlled, bouble-blind prospective study in healthy female volunteers of dextrin sulphate gel. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr Hum Retrovir 1997 14213–218.
The COL-1492 phase II study group
Institute of Tropical Medicine, Antwerp, Belgium: Lut Van Damme, Eddy Van Dyck, Marie Laga; Prince of Songkla University, Hat Yai, Thailand: Verapol Chandeying; the Centre for Epidemiological Research (CERSA), Durban, RSA: Salim S. Abdool Karim, Gita Ramjee, Neetha Morar; Reproductive Health Research Unit, Johannesburg, RSA: Helen Rees, Kim Dickson, Audrey Pettifor, Patience Ndaba, Carol Richards; Ministry of Public health, VD Division, Bangkok, Thailand: Pachara Sirivongrangson, Somchai Niruthisard; UNAIDS, Geneva, Switzerland: Jos PerriMns. Cited Here...
This article has been cited 45 time(s).
Biology of ReproductionSeminal Plasma Induces Prostaglandin-Endoperoxide Synthase (PTGS) 2 Expression in Immortalized Human Vaginal Cells: Involvement of Semen Prostaglandin E2 in PTGS2 UpregulationBiology of Reproduction
Plos MedicineSouth Africa's experience of the closure of the cellulose sulphate microbicide trialPlos Medicine
International Journal of Biochemistry & Cell BiologySafety concerns for the potential use of cyanovirin-N as a microbicidal anti-HIV agentInternational Journal of Biochemistry & Cell Biology
South African Journal of Science
Reducing women's risk of HIV infection: South Africa's contribution to microbicide research and development
South African Journal of Science, 96(6):
Reproductive Health Matters
What's up with nonoxynol-9?
Reproductive Health Matters, 8():
Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy3-Hydroxyphthalic Anhydride-Modified Chicken Ovalbumin Exhibits Potent and Broad Anti-HIV-1 Activity: a Potential Microbicide for Preventing Sexual Transmission of HIV-1Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy
Nature Reviews Drug DiscoveryMicrobicides: A new approach to preventing HIV and other sexually transmitted infectionsNature Reviews Drug Discovery
Effectiveness of COL-1492, a nonoxynol-9 vaginal gel, on HIV-1 transmission in female sex workers: a randomised controlled trial
Indian Journal of Medical Research
Phase I safety & preliminary acceptability of nonoxynol-9 vaginal pessary as a vaginal microbicide in low risk women in Pune, India
Indian Journal of Medical Research, 117():
Journal of VirologyGenetic and neutralization properties of subtype C human immunodeficiency virus type 1 molecular env clones from acute and early heterosexually acquired infections in southern AfricaJournal of Virology
Antiviral TherapySusceptibility to genital herpes as a biomarker predictive of increased HIV risk: expansion of a murine model of microbicide safetyAntiviral Therapy
Plos OneIn Vitro and Ex Vivo Testing of Tenofovir Shows It Is Effective As an HIV-1 MicrobicidePlos One
Antimicrobial Agents and ChemotherapySophorolipids, microbial glycolipids with anti-human immunodeficiency virus and sperm-immobilizing activitiesAntimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy
Microbicides: a long and bumpy road to success?
AIDS Reviews, 9(1):
European Journal of Contraception and Reproductive Health CareUpdate on nonoxynol-9 as vaginal spermicideEuropean Journal of Contraception and Reproductive Health Care
Vaginal microbicides: moving ahead after an unexpected setback
Journal of Infectious DiseasesDisruption of Tight Junctions by Cellulose Sulfate Facilitates HIV Infection: Model of Microbicide SafetyJournal of Infectious Diseases
Up-date on microbicide clinical trials for the Microbicide 2000 Conference
Journal of Infectious Diseases
The molecular basis of nonoxynol-9-induced vaginal inflammation and its possible relevance to human immunodeficiency virus type 1 transmission
Journal of Infectious Diseases, 184(4):
Nonoxynol-9 100 mg gel: multi-site safety study from sub-Saharan Africa
Expert Opinion on Investigational Drugs
Considerations and development of topical microbicides to inhibit the sexual transmission of HIV
Expert Opinion on Investigational Drugs, 11(8):
Journal of VirologyRegional clustering of shared neutralization determinants on primary isolates of clade C human immunodeficiency virus type 1 from South AfricaJournal of Virology
Antimicrobial Agents and ChemotherapyMouse model of cervicovaginal toxicity and inflammation for preclinical evaluation of topical vaginal microbicidesAntimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy
Drugs of Today
An integrated approach to the study of Chlamydia trachomatis infection of the female genital tract
Drugs of Today, 42():
American Journal of Obstetrics and GynecologyCervicovaginal colposcopic lesions associated with 5 nonoxynol-9 vaginal spermicide formulationsAmerican Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology
Diaphragm and lubricant gel for prevention of HIV acquisition in southern African women: a randomised controlled trial
5Th European Congress on Tropical Medicine and International Health
Microbicides delivery system
5Th European Congress on Tropical Medicine and International Health, ():
Antimicrobial Agents and ChemotherapyCandidate topical microbicides bind herpes simplex virus glycoprotein B and prevent viral entry and cell-to-cell spreadAntimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy
Febs LettersSAMMA, a mandelic acid condensation polymer, inhibits dendritic cell-mediated HIV transmissionFebs Letters
Vaginal transmission of HIV-1 in hu-SCID mice: a new model for the evaluation of vaginal microbicides
Tropical Medicine & International Health
Clinical microbicide research: an overview
Tropical Medicine & International Health, 9():
Indian Journal of Pharmaceutical Education and Research
Formulation and Modulation of Drug Release from an Intra Vaginal Ring
Indian Journal of Pharmaceutical Education and Research, 43(2):
Journal of Biomedical OpticsAutomated segmentation algorithm for detection of changes in vaginal epithelial morphology using optical coherence tomographyJournal of Biomedical Optics
Plos OneIs Wetter Better? An Evaluation of Over-the-Counter Personal Lubricants for Safety and Anti-HIV-1 ActivityPlos One
Current Opinion in Infectious DiseasesVaginal microbicidesCurrent Opinion in Infectious Diseases
Obstetrics & GynecologyEffects of Long-Term Use of Nonoxynol-9 on VaginalFloraObstetrics & Gynecology
JAIDS Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency SyndromesWillingness to Use Microbicides Is Affected by the Importance of Product Characteristics, Use Parameters, and Protective PropertiesJAIDS Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes
microbicides; effectiveness; colposcopy; clinical trial; female sex workers; safety; HIV prevention; female controlled methods
© 2000 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Inc.
Highlight selected keywords in the article text.