Reliability Analysis of the 3-min All-Out Exercise Test for Cycle Ergometry

JOHNSON, TYLER M.1; SEXTON, PATRICK J.1; PLACEK, ASHLEY M.1; MURRAY, STEVEN R.2; PETTITT, ROBERT W.1

Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise:
doi: 10.1249/MSS.0b013e318224cb0f
Applied Sciences
Abstract

The 3-min all-out exercise test (3 MT) is purported to estimate critical power (CP) and anaerobic work capacity (W′) and serve as an exercise mode for measuring maximum oxygen uptake (V˙O2max). Reliability analysis of the 3 MT has been confined to CP, not W′, and verification of “true” V˙O2max was exclusive to a graded exercise test (GXT).

Purpose: We conducted a reliability analysis of the 3 MT and compared V˙O2max values from the 3 MT with a GXT and an exhaustive square-wave verification bout.

Methods: Upon completion of a custom GXT and square-wave verification protocol, 11 subjects of various aerobic powers completed two 3 MTs (separate visits). CP, W′, average power during 150 s from the 3 MT, and V˙O2max values were assessed using typical error (TE), coefficient of variation (CV), and intraclass correlation (α).

Results: CP (W) (trial 1 = 206 ± 47, trial 2 = 206 ± 42) did not differ between 3 MT trials (P = 0.37) and was reliable (TE = 15 W, CV = 7%, α = 0.93). W′ was less reliable (TE = 2864 J, CV = 28%, α = 0.76) but did not alter power–duration estimates from the two 3 MTs (P > 0.05). Variability for V˙O2max (TE (mL·kg−1·min−1)) between the GXT and the verification bout (1.16) was more consistent than the first (2.03) or second (2.69) 3 MT.

Conclusions: The 3 MT yields reliable estimates of CP and consistent estimates of the power–duration relationship. Power for 150 s, in comparison with W′, is a more reliable metric of short-term power performance. The square-wave protocol is recommended over the 3 MT for verifying true V˙O2max.

Author Information

1Viola Holbrook Human Performance Laboratory, Minnesota State University, Mankato, Mankato, MN; and 2Department of Kinesiology, Colorado Mesa University, Grand Junction, CO

Address for correspondence: Robert W. Pettitt, Ph.D., ATC, CSCS, Department of Human Performance, Minnesota State University, Mankato, Mankato, MN 56001; E-mail: robert.pettitt@mnsu.edu.

Submitted for publication January 2011.

Accepted for publication May 2011.

©2011The American College of Sports Medicine