Teaching and Learning Moments
Groggy medical students and a hematologist gathered around the table on a Monday morning for a tutorial session. We were there to discuss the case of Iman, a seven-year-old child who came to the clinic for a routine examination. He and his family had recently immigrated to Canada as refugees. As my colleagues and I began the discussion, we scrutinized lab results, which showed microcytic anemia. Our group discussed the differential diagnosis, then we collectively decided to order iron studies and a hemoglobin electrophoresis. The tests uncovered what we suspected, and a diagnosis of beta thalassemia minor was given to Iman. Ours were brief exchanges about different kinds of thalassemias, treatment options, and side effects. We asked questions and answered them. It seemed like a relatively simple exercise.
As our time was winding down, we considered what impact our diagnosis would have on Iman and his family. I paused for a moment and scanned the patient description. Iman’s refugee status grabbed my attention. “I don’t think Iman would even have been diagnosed,” I blurted out. Some of my colleagues gave me puzzled glances. I explained: “I don’t think he would have received care under current Canadian regulations because many refugees are not eligible for routine medical examinations. The government recently made significant cuts to refugee health care.”
Some of my colleagues understood what I was referring to and some looked surprised. The recent cuts prevented some refugees from receiving basic health services, like prenatal screening and routine medical examinations. Without health insurance coverage, many refugees were discouraged from seeking proper health care or were turned away at the clinic. My colleagues and I spent the last few minutes of the session talking about disparities in access to health care.
Reflecting on this session, I realized that my colleagues and I had spent almost an entire hour talking about history taking, physical examination, lab tests, and treatment options, when in reality, Iman and his family would probably not even have come into the clinic because they lacked health insurance coverage. Reaching a correct diagnosis and discussing comprehensive treatment options were irrelevant if Iman and many other refugees in similar situations could not access the health care that they needed. Perhaps we should have started the session with a discussion about Iman’s refugee status and how that affected his access to health care and treatment options.
From this experience, I gleaned that diagnosis and treatment of disease cannot be separated from the social context of our patients’ lives. In addition to the scientific evidence and clinical principles that we need to consider, we must not forget to look at the whole patient and consider how social context can impact health. Moreover, I realized that understanding the social determinants of health can provide valuable information to meet our patients’ unique health needs. Educating our selves about our patients’ health insurance coverage, access to health care, and policy changes are just as important as learning about the underlying causes and management of disease. Finally, being a good physician means not only learning about our patients’ social context but also advocating for changes—from the clinic to the community level—that will allow our patients to access quality health care, regardless of where they are from.
Matthew J. To, BMSc
Mr. To is a medical student, Faculty of Medicine, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada; e-mail: email@example.com.