Special Theme: Complementary, Alternative, and Integrative Medicine: RESEARCH REPORTS
Depressed Medical Students' Use of Mental Health Services and Barriers to Use
Givens, Jane L. MD; Tjia, Jennifer MD
Dr. Givens is staff physician, Student Health Services, and Dr. Tjia is physician—scientist fellow, Division of General Internal Medicine, University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine, Philadelphia.
Correspondence and requests for reprints should be addressed to Dr. Tjia, Division of General Internal Medicine, University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine, Blockley Hall 1208, Philadelphia, PA 19104; e-mail: 〈firstname.lastname@example.org〉.
This article was presented in part at the annual meeting of the Society of General Internal Medicine, April 30, 1999, in San Francisco, California.
For a research report on a related topic, see page 911.
Purpose: Depression is an underrecognized yet common and treatable disorder among medical students. Little is known about the rate of mental health service use by depressed medical students. This study sought to determine the level of mental health service use by depressed medical students and their reported barriers to use.
Method: In the spring of 1994, a one-time survey of 194 first- and second-year medical students was conducted in the School of Medicine at the University of California, San Francisco. Outcome measures were self-reported use of counseling services, barriers to use, suicidal ideation, and depressive symptoms as measured by the 13-item Beck Depression Inventory (BDI).
Results: Twenty-four percent (n = 46) of the medical students were depressed by BDI criteria. Of the depressed students, only 22% (n = 10) were using mental health counseling services. The most frequently cited barriers to using these services were lack of time (48%), lack of confidentiality (37%), stigma associated with using mental health services (30%), cost (28%), fear of documentation on academic record (24%), and fear of unwanted intervention (26%).
Conclusion: These data demonstrate that depression among medical students may be undertreated. Medical schools can assist depressed students by addressing issues such as the stigma of using mental health services, confidentiality, and documentation. Early treatment of impaired future caregivers may have far-reaching implications for the individual students, their colleagues, and their future patients.
Medical students have rates of depression and suicide that are higher than those of the general population.1,2,3,4,5,6 Previous work shows that students enter medical school with their lowest rates of depression and peak in depressive symptoms at the end of their second year of school.2 Although counseling is known to be an effective treatment for depression, depressed medical students have low rates of using mental health counseling services and may not have access to such services at all.7 One study found that only 40% of depressed medical students used available mental health services.3 Undertreatment of depression can have significant immediate and delayed consequences because depression is a recurrent disease for many who suffer from it.
Reasons for undertreating depression identified in the literature are derived largely from data about the general population. These reasons include underdiagnosis, limited access to treatment, stigmatizing mental health, and lack of health insurance.8 Previous studies of medical students report confidentiality as a major concern regarding use of mental health services.7,9 There are, however, few data about treating depression among medical students, and the modifiable factors that may hinder use of treatment options.
The goal of this study was to measure depressed medical students' use of mental health services and to assess barriers to use. Apart from demonstrating areas for improvements by student services in medical schools, these data may inform the discussion about access to mental health services and future directions for research.
In spring of 1994, we conducted a cross-sectional, population-based survey of first- and second-year medical students in the School of Medicine at the University of California, San Francisco (UCSF), a state-sponsored medical school. Our target population was the 280 students of the first- and second-year classes of the medical school. We distributed in class a one-time, anonymously self-reported questionnaire. A total of 209 students (98% of the first-year class and 51% of the second-year class) were in attendance and received the questionnaire. To protect confidentiality, non-attendees were not specifically identified and, therefore, could not be sampled at a later date. Repeated anonymous sampling was avoided to prevent duplicate sampling of individual participants.
We constructed our questionnaire to identify the medical students' severity of depression, use of mental health services, perceived barriers to use, and demographic data. Specifically, we used a standardized measure of depression symptoms, the 13-item Beck Depression Inventory (BDI).10 This self-reported instrument correlates well with clinicians' ratings of depression, depression diagnosed by criteria of the third edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-III), and other tests of depression, including the Center for Epidemiological Studies-Depression (CES-D) scale, Depression Adjective Check Lists (DACL), and the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI).11,12
Additional items on the questionnaire elicited current use of both university-based and non-university mental health services. We also asked participants to identify barriers to their use of mental health services from a checklist constructed from a separate survey of a convenience sample of similar students. Respondents could choose as many barriers as applied and could also provide other responses not on the list. The entire questionnaire was pretested on a convenience sample of 36 preclinical medical students drawn from a population separate from the target students.
For the purpose of dichotomous analysis, we defined depression as a BDI score of 8 or higher, a score designated by the BDI to correlate with moderate or severe depressive symptoms (0–4 is none to minimal depression, 5–7 is mild depression, 8–15 is moderate depression, and 16 or higher is severe depression).10 We calculated descriptive statistics for the point-prevalence of depression, suicidal ideation, and use of mental health services, and used descriptive methods to analyze the barriers to using mental health services.
This study was reviewed and approved by the Human Subjects Committee at the University of California, Berkeley.
Of the 280 students in the target population, 209 were in attendance when we distributed the questionnaire. A total of 194 of the 209 students (93%) returned the questionnaires. The second-year class, however, was undersampled; only 51% of 140 second-year students were in attendance on the day we distributed of the questionnaire. Nevertheless, the demographics of the respondents were representative of the overall class of second-year medical students. The demographics of all respondents (first- and second-year students) were: 57% women, 75% under age 25, 52% Caucasian, 22% Asian American, and 21% underrepresented minorities.
Of the 194 students who responded, 46 (24%) had BDI scores of 8 or higher, indicating the presence of moderate to severe depressive symptoms. Only ten (22%) of the 46 depressed students had used mental health services. Of these, half had used university-based services, while the other half had used services not affiliated with the university.
Table 1 shows the frequencies of the 46 medical students' reported barriers to using mental health services. The most commonly cited barrier was lack of time, reported by almost half of the depressed students who were not using mental health services. More than one third of the depressed students cited lack of confidentiality as a reason for not seeking treatment. In addition, close to a third of the depressed students also cited the stigma of mental illness and cost as reasons for not seeking treatment.
In the free-response section of the questionnaire, the students noted several other barriers, including lack of faith in mental health services, a feeling that stress is normal in medical school, a concern with the limited number (ten) of sessions offered by the counseling services at UCSF, and the belief that the counseling service staff tended to recommend pharmacotherapy without sufficient psychotherapy.
Since non-depressed students may become depressed at some time in the future, we were also interested to see whether non-depressed students perceived similar barriers to using mental health services. To see whether depressed and non-depressed students cited different barriers, we compared the frequencies of barriers reported by the two groups. Although most of the barriers cited by the non-depressed students were the same in level of importance, the depressed students were much more concerned about “lack of confidentiality” than were the non-depressed students.
We also examined suicidal students' rate of using counseling services, since these students are most in need of mental health treatment. Of the 46 depressed students, 12 (26%) had contemplated suicide during their medical school training; only five of the 12 (42%) were receiving treatment for their depression. Suicidal students were 2.8 times more likely than were the other depressed students to report a “fear of unwanted intervention” as a major barrier for seeking treatment.
Twenty-four percent of the first- and second-year students in our survey were depressed by BDI measurement. Only 22% of the depressed students reported using mental health services. This percentage, though similar to treatment rates in the general community,8 is much lower than that found in another study of depressed medical students, which reported a 40% rate of use.3 This difference is difficult to explain, but may represent differences in local cultural attitudes toward mental health services or institutional differences.
To our knowledge, ours is the first study to examine depressed medical students' reported barriers to the use of mental health services, and we document numerous obstacles to treatment. Obstacles reported by more than one third of the students included lack of time, lack of confidentiality, concern that “no one will understand my problems,” the stigma of mental health care, and feeling that “my problems are not important” (see Table 1). Previous work in this area shows that academic jeopardy is an important consideration for medical students seeking care for depressive symptoms.9 Students may be correct in their perception that using mental health services is stigmatizing; it has been reported that students who receive psychological counseling are less likely to secure residency positions.15
When categorized according to the National Depressive and Manic Depressive Association's three main domains for obstacles to treatment8 (patient-based barriers, system-based barriers, and provider-based barriers), system-based barriers were cited most often (see Table 2). An earlier study of student representatives from medical schools across the United States reported a need for greater confidentiality regarding mental health records and also documented that students desired more information regarding mental health services, as well as more preventive services.16
Of the 24% of medical students in our study who were depressed according to BDI measurement, 26% reported suicidal ideation. This percentage is higher than the published prevalence of 15% suicidal ideation for severely depressed patients13 and supports previously published data that indicate medical students have higher rates of depression and suicide than the general population. Although physicians are known to have higher rates of suicide than the general population, our study is the only one we are aware of that reports undertreatment of suicidal medical students—only five of the 12 suicidal students (42%) were receiving treatment. The only other comparable data are from a study of university students that reported about 50% of their suicidally depressed students were using counseling.14
One limitation of our study is that we did not investigate the prevalence of pharmacotherapy, and this may account for a possible overestimation of under-treatment. Use of counseling services, however, may be a fair marker of treatment, since counseling usually accompanies drug therapy. Another limitation of our study is its limited scope; we surveyed students from one school at one point in time. Previously published longitudinal studies reported fluctuating levels of depression, depending on level of training and time of year. One study found a peak prevalence of depression among medical students at the end of the second year of medical school. The level of depression found in our study, however, is comparable to other reported levels and may, in fact, underestimate the level of depression, since we undersampled the second-year students.
The instrument we used in this study, the BDI, measures depressive symptoms and tends to overestimate true depression. Nevertheless, the BDI is a well-validated instrument and has been used in most of the previously published studies of medical students' depression. In addition, for our estimates we relied on the medical students to self-report their use of mental health services. Because of doctor—patient confidentiality, we could not obtain objective measures for use of counseling services for verification.
Depressive symptoms are prevalent among medical students, but few depressed students are using mental health services. Significant barriers to seeking treatment include lack of confidentiality, the stigma of mental health care, and fear of documentation.
We believe that medical schools can address some of these concerns by ensuring that counseling services are confidential, available to all students, easily accessible, and well advertised. Our data also suggest that the point of contact should be separate from the academic affairs and dean's offices and that long-term counseling should be available if necessary.
Adequate treatment of medical students' depression will have important effects on the students themselves, their lives as physicians, and their future patients. Early detection and treatment of depression may help prevent the unnecessary deaths of medical students and prevent the impairment of future physicians.
1. Epstein L, Thomas C, Shaffer J, Perlin S. Clinical prediction of physician suicide based on medical student data. J Nerv Ment Dis. 1973;156:19–29.
2. Clark D, Zeldow P. Vicissitudes of depressed mood during four years of medical school. JAMA. 1988;260:2521–8.
3. Zoccolillo M, Murphy G, Wetzel R. Depression among medical students. J Affective Disorders. 1989;11:91–6.
4. Milagros RC, Ockene IS, Ockene JK, Barrett SV, Ma Y, Herbert JR. A longitudinal study of students' depression at one medical school. Acad Med. 1997;72:542–6.
5. Vitaliano P, Maiuo R, Russo J, Mitchell E, Carr J, Van Citters R. A biopsychosocial model of medical student distress. J Behav Med. 1988;11:311–31.
6. Mosley TH, Perrin SG, Neral SM, Dubbert PM, Grothues CA, Pinto BM. Stress, coping and well-being among third-year medical students. Acad Med. 1994;69:765–7.
7. Seigle RD, Schuckit MA, Plumb D. Availability of personal counseling in medical schools. J Med Educ. 1983;58:542–6.
8. Hirshfeld RMA, Keller MB, Panico S, et al. The National Depressive and Manic-depressive Association consensus statement on the undertreatment of depression. JAMA. 1997;277:333–40.
9. Roberts LW, Hardee JT, Franchini G, Stidley C, Siegler M. Medical students as patients: a pilot study of their health care needs, practices and concerns. Acad Med. 1996;71:1225–32.
10. Beck A, Beck R. Screening depressed patients in family practice, a rapid technique. Postgrad Med. 1972;52:81–5.
11. Stehouwer RS. Beck Depression Inventory. In: Keyser SJ. Test Critiques. Kansas City, MO: Westport Publishers, 1985:83–7.
12. Zich JM, Attkisson CC, Greenfield TK. Screening for depression in primary care clinics, The CED-D and the BDI. Int J Psychiatr Med. 1990;20:259–77.
13. American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. 4th ed. Washington, DC: APA, 1994.
14. Schweitzer R, Klayich M, McLean J. Suicidal ideation and behaviours among university students in Australia. Aust NZ J Psychiatr. 1995;29:473–9.
15. Oppenheimer K, Miller M, Forney P. Effect of history of psychological counseling on selection of applicants for residencies. J Med Educ. 1987;62:504–8.
16. Plaut MS, Maxwell SA, Seng L, O'Brien JJ, Fairclough GF. Mental health services for medical students: perceptions of students, student affairs deans, and mental health providers. Acad Med. 1993;68:360–5.
This article has been cited 47 time(s).
Explore-the Journal of Science and HealingIntegrative Medicine and Patient-Centered CareExplore-the Journal of Science and Healing
Advances in Health Sciences EducationEnhancing the health of medical students: outcomes of an integrated mindfulness and lifestyle programAdvances in Health Sciences Education
Journal of Adolescent HealthMental Health Problems and Help-Seeking Behavior Among College StudentsJournal of Adolescent Health
Archives of Suicide ResearchApplication of an Interpersonal-Psychological Model of Suicidal Behavior to Physicians and Medical TraineesArchives of Suicide Research
Comprehensive PsychiatryMedical student illness and impairment: a vignette-based survey study involving 955 students at 9 medical schoolsComprehensive Psychiatry
Physician impairment: Is it relevant to academic psychiatry?
Academic Psychiatry, 32(1):
Gaceta Medica De Mexico
Academic performance among first year medical students at the School of Medicine, UNAM
Gaceta Medica De Mexico, 143(1):
Jama-Journal of the American Medical Association
Confronting depression and suicide in physicians - A consensus statement
Jama-Journal of the American Medical Association, 289():
Confidentiality in the age of HIPAA: A challenge for psychosomatic medicine
Academic Emergency MedicineCommentary: Physician well-being: The seventh competency?Academic Emergency Medicine
European PsychiatryMental health treatment needs for medical students: a national longitudinal studyEuropean Psychiatry
Medical EducationFactors influencing treatment for depression among medical students: a nationwide sample in South KoreaMedical Education
Advances on Medical Sciences
A Comparative Cross-Sectional Study: "Is the Medical Degree Course Bad for Your Health?"
Advances on Medical Sciences, ():
GesundheitswesenPsychosocial behaviour and subjective experience specific to the course of study of medical students in their first and fifth years of studyGesundheitswesen
Social Science & MedicineVeterans seeking disability benefits for post-traumatic stress disorder: who applies and the self-reported meaning of disability compensationSocial Science & Medicine
Psychological ReportsBarriers to use of mental health services by Japanese university studentsPsychological Reports
The role of academic psychiatry faculty in the treatment and subsequent evaluation and promotion of medical students: An ethical conundrum
Academic Psychiatry, 32(1):
International Journal of Social PsychiatrySymptoms of Anxiety and Depression in Medical Students and in Humanities Students: Relationship With Big-Five Personality Dimensions and Vulnerability to StressInternational Journal of Social Psychiatry
New England Journal of Medicine
White coat, mood indigo - Depression in medical school
New England Journal of Medicine, 353():
Psychotherapie Psychosomatik Medizinische PsychologieMental health and performance of medical students with high and low test anxietyPsychotherapie Psychosomatik Medizinische Psychologie
A conceptual model of medical student well-being: Promoting resilience and preventing burnout
Academic Psychiatry, 32(1):
Chronobiology InternationalDepression in medical school: The influence of morningness-eveningnessChronobiology International
Journal of American College Health
Factors associated with undertreatment of medical student depression
Journal of American College Health, 53(5):
Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric EpidemiologyDoes stigma concerning mental disorders differ through medical education? A survey among medical students in IstanbulSocial Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology
Medical Journal of Australia
Painting the picture: Australasian medical student views on wellbeing teaching and support services
Medical Journal of Australia, 192(4):
Medical EducationHealth-related quality of life of medical studentsMedical Education
Our fallen peers: A mandate for change
Academic Psychiatry, 32(1):
British Journal of Guidance & Counselling'People look at you differently': students' experience of mental health support within Higher EducationBritish Journal of Guidance & Counselling
Journal of Health CommunicationSocial support and social undermining as correlates for alcohol, drug, and mental disorders in American Indian women presenting for primary care at an Indian health service hospitalJournal of Health Communication
Journal of Substance Abuse TreatmentRelationship of depressive symptoms and mental health functioning to repeat detoxificationJournal of Substance Abuse Treatment
Turk Psikiyatri Dergisi
The prevalence of depression and its associated factors among resident doctors working in a training hospital in Istanbul
Turk Psikiyatri Dergisi, 18(1):
Mayo Clinic Proceedings
Medical student distress: Causes, consequences, and proposed solutions
Mayo Clinic Proceedings, 80():
Jama-Journal of the American Medical Association
Experts address risk of physician suicide
Jama-Journal of the American Medical Association, 294():
Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric EpidemiologyHelp-seeking for mental health problems among young physicians: is it the most ill that seeks help?Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology
Journal of College Student Development
Graduate student mental health: Needs assessment and utilization of counseling services
Journal of College Student Development, 47(3):
Annals of Internal Medicine
Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students
Annals of Internal Medicine, 149(5):
Mayo Clinic Proceedings
Burnout, depression, and quality of life in medical students
Mayo Clinic Proceedings, 82(2):
Mayo Clinic Proceedings
A multicenter study of burnout, depression, and quality of life in minority and nonminority US medical students
Mayo Clinic Proceedings, 81():
Journal of Affective DisordersPersistence of mental health problems and needs in a college student populationJournal of Affective Disorders
Journal of Consulting and Clinical PsychologyObstacles for rural American Indians seeking alcohol, drug, or mental health treatmentJournal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology
Academic MedicineMedical Students and DepressionAcademic Medicine
The Journal of Nervous and Mental DiseaseStress and Depressive Symptoms/Dysphoria Among US Medical Students: Results From a Large, Nationally Representative SurveyThe Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease
© 2002 Association of American Medical Colleges