Skip Navigation LinksHome > June 2000 - Volume 75 - Issue 6 > Toward a Normative Definition of Medical Professionalism
Academic Medicine:
Institutional Issues: Articles

Toward a Normative Definition of Medical Professionalism

Swick, Herbert M. MD

Free Access
Article Outline
Collapse Box

Author Information

Dr. Swick is executive director, Institute of Medicine and Humanities, Saint Patrick Hospital and the University of Montana, Missoula, Montana. This article represents work undertaken while the author was a scholar-in-residence at the Association of American Medical Colleges.

Correspondence and requests for reprints should be addressed to Dr. Swick, Institute of Medicine and Humanities, P.O. Box 4587, Missoula, MT 59806; telephone: (406) 329-5662; e-mail: 〈swick@saintpatrick.org〉.

The author gratefully acknowledges Drs. Richard and Sylvia Cruess, of McGill University, and Dr. Michael Whitcomb, of the Association of American Medical Colleges, for their review of early versions of the manuscript and their many helpful suggestions.

Collapse Box

Abstract

In recent years, professionalism in medicine has gained increasing attention. Many have called for a return to medical professionalism as a way to respond to the corporate transformation of the U.S. health care system. Yet there is no common understanding of what is meant by the word professionalism. To encourage dialog and to arrive eventually at some consensus, one needs a normative definition. The author proposes such a definition and asserts that the concept of medical professionalism must be grounded both in the nature of a profession and in the nature of physicians' work. Attributes of medical professionalism reflect societal expectations as they relate to physicians' responsibilities, not only to individual patients but to wider communities as well. The author identifies nine behaviors that constitute medical professionalism and that physicians must exhibit if they are to meet their obligations to their patients, their communities, and their profession. (For example, “Physicians subordinate their own interests to the interests of others.”) He argues that physicians must fully comprehend what medical professionalism entails. Serious negative consequences will ensue if physicians cease to exemplify the behaviors that constitute medical professionalism and hence abrogate their responsibilities both to their patients and to their chosen calling.

If you wish to converse with me, define your terms.—VOLTAIRE

Every definition is dangerous.—ERASMUS

Much attention has been devoted in recent years to the question of professionalism in medical education and practice.1–9 While this attention has been salutary, there is no common understanding of what is meant by medical professionalism. Consequently, many of the discussions have been somewhat amorphous, because the word professionalism carries with it so many connotations, complexities, and nuances. It has virtually lost its meaning because it is so widely used. Different groups have used the word differently and for different purposes. Perhaps professionalism is like pornography: easy to recognize but difficult to define. Yet if professionalism is to remain integral to medical education and medical practice, and if the current, renewed focus on professionalism is to result in meaningful change that benefits both the profession of medicine and the society it serves, it is necessary to understand clearly what medical professionalism entails.

One needs a normative definition that is precise and inclusive, and that can be utilized by a wide variety of groups, including practicing physicians, medical educators, graduate medical education programs, professional organizations, licensing bodies, and regulatory agencies. Such a definition is necessary to enable and encourage dialog and eventually to achieve consensus about the meaning and importance of medical professionalism. In this article I propose such a normative definition. In doing so, I offer a new point of view and a new way to frame considerations of medical professionalism. I have attempted to create a persuasive definition based upon refined reflection about the nature of professions and the nature of physicians' work.

Back to Top | Article Outline

THE NATURE OF A PROFESSION

To understand professionalism, it is necessary to understand the nature of a profession. The medical community seems almost intuitively to grasp what the word profession means when applied to medicine, but it is important also to have a more structured understanding about what a profession is. To gain that understanding, it is neither necessary nor appropriate to craft a definition de novo. An extensive body of knowledge about professions exists in disciplines such as sociology and philosophy. In this article I make no attempt to review that body of knowledge. To understand the origins and meaning of professionalism, it is sufficient to recognize that certain common characteristics distinguish all professions, including medicine. A brief review of these characteristics is germane to understanding the origins and meaning of professionalism.

Eliot Freidson defined professions within a sociologic framework, using medicine as representative of all professions. In his seminal body of work, he argued that a profession is a specific type of occupation, one that performs work with special characteristics while competing for economic, social, and political rewards.10 Because a profession holds something of a monopoly over its work, it enjoys relative autonomy that derives from the nature of the work performed and from the relationship of the profession to institutions external to it, such as a sovereign state.10 That autonomy can be preserved only so long as the profession meets the responsibilities expected of it. From the sociologic perspective, professions exist without there being any necessary attention to whether the work has inherent ethical or moral value.

The concept of a profession has often transcended this rather narrow view to consider the moral or social value of the work performed. Justice Louis Brandeis alluded to a moral perspective when he noted that professional work was pursued primarily for others and not for oneself, and that success was measured by more than the amount of financial return.11 More recently, William Sullivan has emphasized the importance of the social value of professional work.12 There must be a balance between professional privileges and the public's perception that the profession is serving the public welfare: “Historically, the legitimacy, authority and the legal privileges of the most prestigious professions have depended heavily on their claims (and finally their demonstration) of civic performance, especially social leadership in the public interest.”13 Professions serve as guardians of social values,8 and professionals are expected to articulate and hold those values publicly. A profession, then, becomes a way of life with a moral value. It is in this sense that a profession becomes a calling, not simply an occupation.

Professions always reflect the particular social and cultural milieus in which they operate. Rapid advances of knowledge during the past 30–40 years have changed the natures of all professions, but none more dramatically than medicine. Professions have become more closely connected to the application of expert knowledge and less closely linked to functions central to the good of the public they serve. The rise of this “expert professionalism” has paralleled a decline in the older sense of “social-trustee professionalism.”14 The control and application of a specialized body of knowledge has come more and more to characterize a profession, as knowledge in all fields has grown and become more complex. But to rely solely on expertise is to diminish the special nature of a profession, especially insofar as it addresses societal needs. Steven Brint argues that “without a strong sense of the public and social purposes served by professional knowledge, professionals tend to lose their distinctive voice in public debate.”14 In many ways, that is the position in which the profession of medicine now finds itself: it has become distracted from its public and social purposes and thus lost its distinctive voice. In recent years, the debate about health care has been dominated not by physicians, individually or collectively, but by business, economic, and political interests. Strengthening medical professionalism becomes one way to restore medicine's distinctive voice.

Back to Top | Article Outline

THE NATURE OF PHYSICIANS' WORK

Medical professionalism is exemplified through what physicians actually do—how they meet their responsibilities to individual patients and to communities. Any definition must therefore be clearly grounded in the nature of the physician's work. The values and behaviors that individual physicians demonstrate in their daily interactions with patients and their families, and with physicians and other professional colleagues, become the foundation on which medical professionalism rests.

In this article, I do not attempt to provide a comprehensive account of the range of professional activities that can constitute physicians' work; the breadth of possibilities is too great, even for an individual physician. However, certain elements that characterize the nature of medical practice are key to providing a contextual understanding of medical professionalism. At the core of medical practice is the need to create and nurture a healing dyadic relationship between physician and patient. Other elements of medical professionalism reflect broader responsibilities that the physician has to society and the profession, to family and self.

The practice of medicine traditionally has embodied a set of values that limn the nature of medical work.6 Those values include, among others, a commitment to service, advocacy, and altruism. Physicians have long recognized a duty to individual patients and to larger groups, such as their communities. That duty now often extends to health plans or employers. The nature of the physician's work is active and, to a large extent, self-directed. It involves the application of a specialized body of knowledge and the need constantly to enlarge that knowledge. The work has inherent moral value and provides a societal good. It recognizes the worth of all human individuals. For example, the Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC), in the first report of its Medical School Objectives Project (MSOP),15 identified four major attributes that medical students should have demonstrated by the time of graduation and that physicians should possess for the practice of medicine. The report stated that physicians should be altruistic, knowledgeable, skillful, and dutiful. Since 1994 the American Board of Internal Medicine (ABIM) has required that those seeking board certification demonstrate that they have acquired the values of professionalism, which “aspires to altruism, accountability, excellence, duty, service, honor, integrity and respect for others.”16 While aspires connotes an important sense of striving, it is incorrect to assume that the goals to which one aspires cannot be reached or that aspirations cannot be grounded in specific actions. Indeed, both the MSOP objectives and the ABIM requirements speak to the nature of physicians' work. The explication of these attributes—particularly those relating to altruism, service, and duty—addresses essential elements of medical professionalism.

Back to Top | Article Outline

A DEFINITION OF MEDICAL PROFESSIONALISM

From the arguments in the preceding sections, one can appreciate that the key to understanding medical professionalism is not to be found in a simple dictionary definition. Rather, the concept of medical professionalism must account for the nature of the medical profession and must be grounded in what physicians actually do and how they act, individually and collectively. Bearing this in mind, I assert that medical professionalism consists of those behaviors by which we—as physicians—demonstrate that we are worthy of the trust bestowed upon us by our patients and the public, because we are working for the patients' and the public's good. Failure to demonstrate that we deserve that trust will result in its loss, and, hence, loss of medicine's status as a profession.

Medical professionalism, then, comprises the following set of behaviors:

Physicians subordinate their own interests to the interests of others. Medical professionalism reflects the physician's open willingness to subordinate his or her interests to best meet the needs of patients. It manifests the physician's fiduciary relationship with patients and the physician's duty to serve as the patient's advocate. The expectation that a professional will subordinate self-interest has long been a hallmark of professions, and hence is the sine qua non of professionalism. Because physicians have responsibilities to many others as well, they will not infrequently confront conflicts of interest, such as those arising between the health system that employs them and the individual patient seeking care. When such conflicts arise, the patient's legitimate interests and needs must remain paramount. The MSOP objectives state that physicians must demonstrate “a commitment to advocate at all times the interests of one's patients over one's own interests,” as well as “an understanding of the threats to medical professionalism posed by the conflicts of interest inherent in various financial and organizational arrangements for the practice of medicine.”15

Physicians adhere to high ethical and moral standards. The concept that professional work has a moral value compels the physician to behave ethically in his or her personal and professional life. Long embedded in the ethos of medicine are principles of beneficence and nonmaleficence. Physicians have a duty to do right and to avoid doing wrong. Patients have a right to expect no less.

Physicians respond to societal needs, and their behaviors reflect a social contract with the communities served. Any profession—not just the medical profession—best meets its obligations when it attends actively to its duty to address community and societal needs. Sullivan's concept of civic professionalism stresses the importance of social leadership by the professions.12 The MSOP objectives state that a physician will demonstrate “knowledge of the important non-biological determinants of poor health and of the economic, psychological, social, and cultural factors that contribute to the development and/or continuation of maladies,” as well as “a commitment to provide care to patients who are unable to pay and to be advocates for access to health care for members of traditionally underserved populations.”15

Physicians evince core humanistic values, including honesty and integrity, caring and compassion, altruism and empathy, respect for others, and trustworthiness. Some might argue that humanistic values are not requisite to professional behavior, that a physician can exemplify professionalism without humanism. Yet values such as compassion, altruism, integrity, and trustworthiness are so central to the nature of the physician's work, no matter what form that work takes, that no physician can truly be effective without holding deeply such values. The practice of medicine is a human endeavor. To address the needs of their patients, physicians must ensure that humanistic values remain central to their professional work. Wynia and colleagues argue that respect for human worth and trustworthiness are “particular obligations.”8 Physicians must demonstrate “compassionate treatment of patients” as well as “honesty and integrity in all interactions with patients' families, colleagues and others.”15 To evince humanistic values speaks directly to the ABIM's expectation that physicians will aspire to altruism, honor, and integrity, among other attributes.16

Physicians exercise accountability for themselves and for their colleagues. Implicit in the relative autonomy granted to a profession is that its members will set and enforce standards of practice. Demonstrating true accountability is key to maintaining the privilege of autonomy that medicine has long enjoyed but which many now feel has been eroded. That erosion is due, in part, to a perception by many that physicians have not always been willing to exercise accountability for themselves or their colleagues. The loss of autonomy relates directly to Freidson's observation that autonomy is a privilege granted by external authorities.10 Professional work has always been, at its best, a collegial endeavor rather than an entrepreneurial enterprise. Collegial interactions have traditionally typified a profession, but such collegiality should be used neither to mask ineffective or inappropriate practice nor to protect incompetent physicians. Meaningful peer evaluation becomes one mechanism to enforce standards of practice and hence to exercise accountability.

Physicians demonstrate a continuing commitment to excellence. Competency is an important professional quality. Professions are based upon intellectual work, a specialized body of knowledge, and expertise. The demands of intellectual work require that physicians maintain the highest standards of excellence through the continuing acquisition of knowledge and the development of new skills. The exponential growth in biomedical knowledge makes it imperative that physicians be able to retrieve and use information efficiently, whether to make clinical decisions about individual patients or to address questions of a community's health. Excellence is internally focused. It is the individual physician's commitment to expand his or her knowledge and to keep abreast of the rapid changes in biomedical science and clinical practice. A commitment to excellence makes life-long learning fundamental to professionalism. The MSOP objectives ask that physicians demonstrate “the capacity to recognize and accept limitations in one's knowledge and clinical skills, and a commitment to continuously improve one's knowledge and ability.”15

Physicians exhibit a commitment to scholarship and to advancing their field. If commitment to excellence has an internal focus, then a commitment to scholarship has an external focus. It is the desire to share one's knowledge for the benefit of others, whether patients, other physicians, or the community. The nature and the goals of medicine should commit physicians to advance the body of knowledge in their discipline, whether from cutting-edge research or from assuring that a practice setting is most conductive to cost-effective and efficient patient care. Physicians should support the efforts of their colleagues and the profession to improve the health not only of individual patients but also of communities.

Physicians deal with high levels of complexity and uncertainty. Uncertainty and ambiguity have long characterized the practice of medicine, and they will continue to do so despite advances in technology and in biomedical knowledge. Work that is simple and repetitive, or that does not involve a great deal of judgement, does not require the independent decision making that is a hallmark of professions.17 The physician must be able to exercise independent judgement in order to make appropriate decisions in the face of complex, often unstable circumstances, and usually with incomplete information.

Physicians reflect upon their actions and decisions. Professionals must be able to reflect dispassionately upon decisions made and actions taken, not only to improve their knowledge and skills, but also to bring balance to their professional and personal lives. Reflection becomes one mechanism to stimulate a commitment to excellence and enable accountability, but it goes beyond that. The ability to think reflectively and critically is important to deductive reasoning, and physicians must demonstrate “the ability to reason deductively in solving clinical problems.”15 Reflection and deductive reasoning are thus central to clinical decision making.

Back to Top | Article Outline

THE IMPORTANCE OF HAVING A NORMATIVE DEFINITION

Many individuals and groups have become keenly interested in the state of medical professionalism. Individual physicians have become alarmed about what is happening to their practices in the face of the corporate transformation of the U.S. health care system. Professional associations such as the American Medical Association have been concerned about the changes this transformation has wrought in physicians' time-honored responsibilities toward patients. Medical educators have been concerned for years about the impact that physicians' behaviors have on the professional development of medical students and residents. Hence the recent calls for a renewed focus on professionalism. Dialog among these many individuals and groups must continue, but it is imperative to heed Voltaire's plea: “If you wish to converse with me, define your terms.” The normative definition presented in this article is meant to encourage a dialog grounded in a common understanding of professionalism, with a goal of eventually achieving a degree of consensus sufficient to enable the medical community to strengthen professionalism in medical education and medical practice.

Professionalism must be considered on two levels: individual and collective. The nine elements in my normative definition represent a spectrum of behaviors that individual physicians should demonstrate if they are to successfully meet their obligations to their patients and to their communities. Together, they encompass the essentials of professionalism as it is demonstrated by individual physicians. But many of these elements apply equally well to the profession of medicine as a collective body. The profession—through its academic and practice leadership, as well as its organized bodies—must sustain the covenant of trust that has long characterized the relationship between medicine and those it serves. As a profession, medicine has been criticized by the public and by payers for resisting change and for a perceived unwillingness to address such important social goals as access or cost-effective medical care. Such reluctance can be considered a breach of social-trustee, or civic, professionalism. Relman has noted that “medical professionalism… is being seriously challenged by the industrialization of medicine.”4 In an industrial model of health care, adhering to professional values and behaviors—practicing professionalism—can help maintain the distinction between medicine as a profession and medicine as a commodity. If that distinction is to remain sharp, it will be important that physicians, individually and collectively, understand what professionalism means, not only in the abstract but also in the very real “humdrum, day-in, day-out, everyday work that is the real satisfaction of the practice of medicine.”18

While definitions can be dangerous, as Erasmus noted, it is nonetheless important that physicians comprehend fully what medical professionalism entails, both for an individual practice and for the profession. Serious negative consequences will ensue if physicians cease to exemplify the behaviors that constitute medical professionalism and hence abrogate their responsibilities both to their patients and to their chosen calling.

Back to Top | Article Outline

REFERENCES

1. Blumenthal D. The vital role of professionalism in health care reform. Health Aff. 1994;13(Part I):252–6.

2. Cruess SR, Cruess RL. Professionalism must be taught. BMJ. 1997;315:1674–7.

3. Hensel WA, Dickey NW. Teaching professionalism: passing the torch. Acad Med. 1998;73:865–70.

4. Relman AS. Education to defend professional values in the new corporate age. Acad Med. 1998;73:1229–33.

5. Reynolds PP. Reaffirming professionalism through the education community. Ann Intern Med. 1996;120:609–14.

6. Swick HM. Academic medicine must deal with the clash of business and professional values. Acad Med.1998;73:751–5.

7. Swick HM, Simpson DE, Van Susteren TJ. Fostering the professional development of medical students. Teach Learn Med. 1995;7:55–60.

8. Wynia MK, Latham SR, Kao AC, Berg JW, Emanuel LL. Medical professionalism in society. N Engl J Med. 1999;341:1612–6.

9. Association of American Medical Colleges. Professionalism in Contemporary Medical Education: An Invitational Colloquium. Washington, DC: Association of American Medical Colleges, 1998.

10. Freidson E. Profession of Medicine: A Study of the Sociology of Applied Knowledge. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, 1988.

11. Brandeis LD. Business—A Profession. Boston, MA: Small, Maynard, 1914.

12. Sullivan WM. Work and Integrity: The Crisis and Promise of Professionalism in America. New York: Harper Collins, 1995.

13. Sullivan WM. Professionalism after managed care? In: Professionalism in Contemporary Medical Education: An Invitational Colloquium. Washington, DC: Association of American Medical Colleges, 1998.

14. Brint S. In an Age of Experts: The Changing Role of Professionals in Politics and Public Life. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1994.

15. The Medical School Objectives Writing Group. Learning objectives for medical student education—guidelines for medical students: report I of the Medical School Objectives Project. Acad Med. 1999;74:13–8.

16. American Board of Internal Medicine. Project Professionalism. Philadelphia, PA: American Board of Internal Medicine, 1995.

17. Southon G, Braithwaite J. The end of professionalism? Soc Sci Med. 1998;46:23–8.

18. Williams WC. The practice. In: Coles R: William Carlos Williams: The Doctor Stories. New York: New Directions Books, 1984.

Cited By:

This article has been cited 124 time(s).

Bangladesh Journal of Pharmacology
Professionalism of future medical professionals in Universiti Sultan Zainal Abidin, Malaysia
Salam, A; Yousuf, R; Islam, MZ; Yesmin, F; Helali, AM; Alattraqchi, AG; Rao, USM; Haque, M
Bangladesh Journal of Pharmacology, 8(2): 124-130.
10.3329/bjp.v8i2.14158
CrossRef
Journal of the Pakistan Medical Association
Professionalism in medical students at a private medical college in Karachi, Pakistan
Sobani, ZU; Mohyuddin, MM; Farooq, F; Qaiser, KN; Gani, F; Bham, NS; Raheem, A; Mehraj, V; Saeed, SA; Sharif, H; Sheerani, M; Zuberi, RW; Beg, MA
Journal of the Pakistan Medical Association, 63(7): 935-939.

Medical Education
Analysing the hidden curriculum: use of a cultural web
Mossop, L; Dennick, R; Hammond, R; Robbe, I
Medical Education, 47(2): 134-143.
10.1111/medu.12072
CrossRef
Medical Teacher
Building a professionalism framework for healthcare providers in China: A nominal group technique study
Pan, H; Norris, JL; Liang, YS; Li, JN; Ho, MJ
Medical Teacher, 35(): E1531-E1536.
10.3109/0142159X.2013.802299
CrossRef
Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal
Physicians' Strikes and the Competing Bases of Physicians' Moral Obligations
MacDougall, DR
Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal, 23(3): 249-274.

Australian Occupational Therapy Journal
Towards a definition of professionalism in Australian occupational therapy: Using the Delphi technique to obtain consensus on essential values and behaviours
Aguilar, A; Stupans, I; Scutter, S; King, S
Australian Occupational Therapy Journal, 60(3): 206-216.
10.1111/1440-1630.12017
CrossRef
Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia Teaching and Learning Congress 2011, Vol II
A pilot study on professionalism of future medical professionals in Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia (UKM) Medical Centre
Salam, A; Song, CO; Mazlan, NF; Hassin, H; Lee, LS; Abdullah, MH
Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia Teaching and Learning Congress 2011, Vol II, 60(): 534-540.
10.1016/j.sbspro.2012.09.419
CrossRef
Journal of the American Podiatric Medical Association
Podiatric Medical Students' Perceptions of Professionalism in the Clinical Setting A Qualitative Analysis
Parsley, NL; Harris, IB
Journal of the American Podiatric Medical Association, 102(6): 434-445.

Medical Education Online
Decline of medical student idealism in the first and second year of medical school: a survey of pre-clinical medical students at one institution
Morley, CP; Roseamelia, C; Smith, JA; Villarreal, AL
Medical Education Online, 18(): -.
ARTN 21194
CrossRef
Social Science & Medicine
Medical professionalism among clinical physicians in two tertiary hospitals, China
Chen, J; Xu, J; Zhang, CM; Fu, XQ
Social Science & Medicine, 96(): 290-296.
10.1016/j.socscimed.2012.09.044
CrossRef
Jcpsp-Journal of the College of Physicians and Surgeons Pakistan
Effectiveness of Reflective Exercises for Obstetrics and Gynaecological Residents
Khanum, Z
Jcpsp-Journal of the College of Physicians and Surgeons Pakistan, 23(7): 468-471.

Journal of Family Therapy
Reflexivity in the medical encounter: contributions from post-modern systemic practice
Ingrassia, A
Journal of Family Therapy, 35(2): 139-158.
10.1111/j.1467-6427.2011.00534.x
CrossRef
Health Affairs
Professionalism, regulation, and the market: Impact on accountability for quality of care
Pawlson, LG; O'Kane, ME
Health Affairs, 21(3): 200-207.

Medical Journal of Australia
Professionalism for medicine: opportunities and obligations
Cruess, SR; Johnston, S; Cruess, RL
Medical Journal of Australia, 177(4): 208-211.

Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics
Where is the virtue in professionalism?
Doukas, DJ
Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics, 12(2): 147-154.

Teaching and Learning in Medicine
"Profession": A working definition for medical educators
Cruess, SR; Johnston, S; Cruess, RL
Teaching and Learning in Medicine, 16(1): 74-76.

Archives of Internal Medicine
Characteristics associated with physician discipline - A case-control study
Kohatsu, ND; Gould, D; Ross, LK; Fox, PJ
Archives of Internal Medicine, 164(6): 653-658.

American Journal of Public Health
Ethical challenges in preparing for bioterrorism: Barriers within the health care system
Wynia, MK; Gostin, LO
American Journal of Public Health, 94(7): 1096-1102.

Physical Therapy
Factor analysis as a tool for survey analysis using a professional role orientation inventory as an example
Swisher, LL; Beckstead, JW; Bebeau, M
Physical Therapy, 84(9): 784-799.

Perspectives in Biology and Medicine
Beyond the physician charter - reflections on medical professionalism
Swick, HM; Bryan, CS; Longo, LD
Perspectives in Biology and Medicine, 49(2): 263-275.

Canadian Journal of Diabetes
Should Publication Ethics be Taught in the Professional Curriculum for Health Science Students?
Dean, HJ; Barakat, S
Canadian Journal of Diabetes, 32(3): 165-166.

Medical Education
Sociological interpretations of professionalism
Martimianakis, MA; Maniate, JM; Hodges, BD
Medical Education, 43(9): 829-837.
10.1111/j.1365-2923.2009.03408.x
CrossRef
Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics
Fostering professionalism: The Loyola model
Kuczewski, MG; Bading, E; Langbein, M; Henry, B
Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics, 12(2): 161-166.

Postgraduate Medical Journal
Dismembering the ethical physician
Genuis, SJ
Postgraduate Medical Journal, 82(): 233-238.
10.1136/pgmj.2005.037754
CrossRef
Medical Teacher
From calling to a scheduled vocation: Swedish male and female students' reflections on being a doctor
Johansson, EE; Hamberg, K
Medical Teacher, 29(1): E1-E8.
10.1080/01421590601044992
CrossRef
Pediatrics
Ethics and Professionalism in the Pediatric Curriculum: A Survey of Pediatric Program Directors
Lang, CW; Smith, PJ; Ross, LF
Pediatrics, 124(4): 1143-1151.
10.1542/peds.2009-0658
CrossRef
American Journal of Bioethics
Toward the operationalization of professionalism: A commentary
Hafferty, F
American Journal of Bioethics, 4(2): 28-31.

Wiener Klinische Wochenschrift
Medical ethics teaching
Buyx, AM; Maxwell, B; Supper, H; Schone-Seifert, B
Wiener Klinische Wochenschrift, 120(): 655-664.
10.1007/s00508-008-1097-z
CrossRef
American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education
A system to assess the achievement of doctor of pharmacy students
Winslade, N
American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education, 65(4): 363-392.

Medical Education
Perceptions of professionalism in medicine: a qualitative study
Jha, V; Bekker, HL; Duffy, SRG; Roberts, TE
Medical Education, 40(): 1027-1036.
10.1111/j.1365-2929.2006.02567.x
CrossRef
Academic Medicine
Viewpoint: Professionalism and humanism beyond the academic health center
Swick, HM
Academic Medicine, 82(): 1022-1028.

Australian Family Physician
Professionalism and the quality framework
Flynn, J; Booth, B; Portelli, R
Australian Family Physician, 36(): 16-18.

Perspectives in Biology and Medicine
EXPECTATIONS AND OBLIGATIONS profession olism and meclicine's social contract with society
Cruess, RL; Cruess, SR
Perspectives in Biology and Medicine, 51(4): 579-598.

Journal of General Internal Medicine
Community Volunteerism of US Physicians
Grande, D; Armstrong, K
Journal of General Internal Medicine, 23(): 1987-1991.
10.1007/s11606-008-0811-x
CrossRef
Medical Teacher
Measuring professionalism in residency training programs in Iran
Aramesh, K; Mohebbi, M; Jessri, M; Sanagou, M
Medical Teacher, 31(8): E356-E361.
10.1080/01421590802638022
CrossRef
Academic Medicine
Using standardized patients to assess medical students' professionalism
Prislin, MD; Lie, D; Shapiro, J; Boker, J; Radecki, S
Academic Medicine, 76(): S90-S92.

Health Care Analysis
HIV/AIDS and bioethics: Historical perspective, personal retrospective
Bryan, CS
Health Care Analysis, 10(1): 5-18.

Human Pathology
Ethical and professional issues in pathology: A survey of current issues and educational efforts
Domen, RE
Human Pathology, 33(8): 779-782.
10.1053/hupa.2002.127446
CrossRef
Medical Education
Faculty development for teaching and evaluating professionalism: from programme design to curriculum change
Steinert, Y; Cruess, S; Cruess, R; Snell, L
Medical Education, 39(2): 127-136.
10.1111/j.1365-2929.2004.02069.x
CrossRef
Journal of Cancer Education
A most important competency: Professionalism. What is it?
O'Donnell, JF
Journal of Cancer Education, 19(4): 202-203.

Annals Academy of Medicine Singapore
Assessing professionalism in early medical education: Experience with peer evaluation and self-evaluation in the gross anatomy course
Bryan, RE; Krych, AJ; Carmichael, SW; Viggiano, TR; Pawlina, W
Annals Academy of Medicine Singapore, 34(8): 486-491.

Medical Education
Professionalism in medical education, an American perspective: from evidence to accountability
Cohen, JJ
Medical Education, 40(7): 607-617.
10.1111/j.1365-2929.2006.02512.x
CrossRef
Journal of Cancer Education
Professionalism: Why now, what is it, how do we do something?
Talbott, JA
Journal of Cancer Education, 21(3): 118-122.

Annals of Internal Medicine
Professionalism in medicine: Results of a national survey of physicians
Campbell, EG; Regan, S; Gruen, RL; Ferris, TG; Rao, SR; Cleary, PD; Blumenthal, D
Annals of Internal Medicine, 147(): 795-U60.

Medical Teacher
Assessment of professionalism in undergraduate medical students
O'Sullivan, AJ; Toohey, SM
Medical Teacher, 30(3): 280-286.
10.1080/01421590701758640
CrossRef
Academic Medicine
The journey to creating a campus-wide culture of professionalism
Smith, KL; Saavedra, R; Raeke, JL; O'Donell, AA
Academic Medicine, 82(): 1015-1021.

Medical Teacher
Questionnaire survey for challenging cases of medical professionalism in Japan
Tokuda, Y; Barnett, PB; Norisue, Y; Konishi, R; Kudo, H; Miyagi, S
Medical Teacher, 31(6): 502-507.
10.1080/01421590802203488
CrossRef
British Journal of Hospital Medicine
Professionalism: what it means to doctors today
Nicholson, S; Raval, D
British Journal of Hospital Medicine, 70(8): 470-474.

Medical Teacher
AMEE Medical Education Guide No. 24: Portfolios as a method of student assessment
Ben David, MF; Davis, MH; Harden, RM; Howie, PW; Ker, J; Pippard, MJ
Medical Teacher, 23(6): 535-551.

Acta Neurochirurgica
Professionalism endangered
Antunes, JL
Acta Neurochirurgica, 145(1): 3-4.
10.1007/s00701-002-1049-8
CrossRef
Medical Education
Fostering students' personal and professional development in medicine: a new framework for PPD
Gordon, J
Medical Education, 37(4): 341-349.

Medical Education
Understanding medical professionalism: a plea for an inclusive and integrated approach
Cruess, SR; Cruess, RL
Medical Education, 42(8): 755-757.
10.1111/j.1365-2923.2008.03134.x
CrossRef
Journal of Health Politics Policy and Law
Professionalism: The third logic
Hafferty, F
Journal of Health Politics Policy and Law, 28(1): 133-158.

Australian & New Zealand Journal of Obstetrics & Gynaecology
Medical professionalism and continuing professional development for medical specialists
White, P
Australian & New Zealand Journal of Obstetrics & Gynaecology, 44(3): 186-190.

Medical Teacher
Teaching professionalism: general principles
Cruess, RL; Cruess, SR
Medical Teacher, 28(3): 205-208.
10.1080/01421590600643653
CrossRef
Academic Medicine
The professionalism mini-evaluation exercise: A preliminary investigation
Cruess, R; Mcllroy, JH; Cruess, S; Ginsburg, S; Steinert, Y
Academic Medicine, 81(): S74-S78.

Journal of General Internal Medicine
Do doctors vote?
Grande, D; Asch, DA; Armstrong, K
Journal of General Internal Medicine, 22(5): 585-589.
10.1007/s11606-007-0105-8
CrossRef
Academic Medicine
Faculty development as an instrument of change: A case study on teaching professionalism
Steinert, Y; Cruess, RL; Cruess, SR; Boudreau, JD; Fuks, A
Academic Medicine, 82(): 1057-1064.

Medical Teacher
Assessing professional behaviour and medical error
Cohen, R
Medical Teacher, 23(2): 145-151.

Annals Academy of Medicine Singapore
The challenge of teaching professionalism
Beauchamp, G
Annals Academy of Medicine Singapore, 33(6): 697-705.

Journal of Clinical Anesthesia
Teaching professionalism during anesthesiology training
Edelstein, SB; Stevenson, JM; Broad, K
Journal of Clinical Anesthesia, 17(5): 392-398.
10.1016/j.jclinane.2004.10.006
CrossRef
Clinical Medicine
Clinical Medicine - Introduction
[Anon]
Clinical Medicine, 5(6): S7-S40.

Clinical Medicine
Medical professionalism: the trainees' views
Chard, D; Elsharkawy, A; Newbery, N
Clinical Medicine, 6(1): 68-71.

Clinical Anatomy
Medical professionalism and the clinical anatomist
Swick, HM
Clinical Anatomy, 19(5): 393-402.
10.1002/ca.20258
CrossRef
Clinical Anatomy
Medical students speak: A two-voice comment on learning professionalism in medicine
Krych, EH; Vande Voort, JL
Clinical Anatomy, 19(5): 415-418.
10.1002/ca.20302
CrossRef
Academic Medicine
Competing professionalism values among community-based family physicians
Ellsbury, KE; Carline, JD; Wenrich, MD
Academic Medicine, 81(): S25-S29.

Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research
Teaching professionalism - Theory, principles, and practices
Cruess, RL
Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research, (): 177-185.
10.1097/01.blo.0000229274.28452.cb
CrossRef
Journal of the European Academy of Dermatology and Venereology
Patient satisfaction after removal of skin lesions
Rissin, Y; Fodor, L; Ishach, H; Oded, R; Ramon, Y; Ullmann, Y
Journal of the European Academy of Dermatology and Venereology, 21(7): 951-955.
10.1111/j.1468-3083.2007.02146.x
CrossRef
Academic Medicine
Institutional leadership and faculty response: Fostering professionalism at the University of Pennsylvania school of medicine
Wasserstein, AG; Brennan, PJ; Rubenstein, AH
Academic Medicine, 82(): 1049-1056.

Advances in Health Sciences Education
Medical students' attitudes toward underserved patients: A longitudinal comparison of problem-based and traditional medical curricula
Crandall, SJS; Reboussin, BA; Michielutte, R; Anthony, JE; Naughton, MJ
Advances in Health Sciences Education, 12(1): 71-86.
10.1007/s10459-005-2297-1
CrossRef
Academic Medicine
Viewpoint: Linking professionalism to humanism: What it means, why it matters
Cohen, JJ
Academic Medicine, 82(): 1029-1032.

Medical Care Research and Review
Consequences of Participating in Multidisciplinary Medical Team Meetings for Surgical, Nonsurgical, and Supporting Specialties
Molleman, E; Broekhuis, M; Stoffels, R; Jaspers, F
Medical Care Research and Review, 67(2): 173-193.
10.1177/1077558709347379
CrossRef
Mount Sinai Journal of Medicine
Professionalism and the teaching of clinical medicine: Perspectives of teachers and students
Nierman, DM
Mount Sinai Journal of Medicine, 69(6): 410-411.

Medical Education
The structure of reflective practice in medicine
Mamede, S; Schmidt, HG
Medical Education, 38(): 1302-1308.
10.1111/j.1365-2929.2004.01917.x
CrossRef
Revista Medica De Chile
The social meaning of medical professionalism
Campos, N
Revista Medica De Chile, 134(4): 520-524.

Perspectives in Biology and Medicine
MOVING BEYOND NOSTALGIA AND MOTIVES towards a complexity science view of medical professionalism
Hafferty, FW; Levinson, D
Perspectives in Biology and Medicine, 51(4): 599-615.

Journal of General Internal Medicine
High Quality Care and Ethical Pay-for-Performance: A Society of General Internal Medicine Policy Analysis
Wharam, JF; Paasche-Orlow, MK; Farber, NJ; Sinsky, C; Rucker, L; Rask, KJ; Figaro, MK; Braddock, C; Barry, MJ; Sulmasy, DP
Journal of General Internal Medicine, 24(7): 854-859.
10.1007/s11606-009-0947-3
CrossRef
Yonsei Medical Journal
What Qualities Do Medical School Applicants Need to Have? - Secondary Publication
Hur, Y; Kim, S
Yonsei Medical Journal, 50(3): 427-436.
10.3349/ymj.2009.50.3.427
CrossRef
Medical Education
Professionalism: a shared responsibility for a rich and enduring tapestry
Chauvin, SW
Medical Education, 36(5): 410-411.

Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery-American Volume
Teaching professionalism in orthopaedic residency
Cornwall, R
Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery-American Volume, 83A(4): 626-628.

Physical Therapy
Construct validation of a model for professional behavior in physical therapist students
Jette, DE; Portney, LG
Physical Therapy, 83(5): 432-443.

Anatomical Sciences Education
Comparative Efficacy of Group and Individual Feedback in Gross Anatomy for Promoting Medical Student Professionalism
Camp, CL; Gregory, JK; Lachman, N; Chen, LP; Juskewitch, JE; Pawlina, W
Anatomical Sciences Education, 3(2): 64-72.
10.1002/ase.142
CrossRef
Mount Sinai Journal of Medicine
What medical students know about professionalism
Hafferty, FW
Mount Sinai Journal of Medicine, 69(6): 385-397.

Medical Education
Achievement of non-cognitive goals of undergraduate medical education: perceptions of medical students, residents, faculty and other health professionals
Mann, KV; Ruedy, J; Millar, N; Andreou, P
Medical Education, 39(1): 40-48.
10.1111/j.1365-2929.2004.02031.x
CrossRef
Lancet
Medical professionalism in Laos
Gordon, G; Chu, V
Lancet, 367(): 1302-1304.

Medical Education
Defining medical professionalism: a qualitative study
Wagner, P; Hendrich, J; Moseley, G; Hudson, V
Medical Education, 41(3): 288-294.
10.1111/j.1365-2929.2006.02695.x
CrossRef
Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research
Definitions of professionalism - A search for meaning and identity
Hafferty, FW
Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research, (): 193-204.
10.1097/01.blo.0000229273.20829.d0
CrossRef
Medical Teacher
The use of a video interview to enhance gross anatomy students' understanding of professionalism
Kostas, TR; Jones, DB; Schiefer, TK; Geske, JB; Carmichael, SW; Pawlina, W
Medical Teacher, 29(): 264-266.
10.1080/01421590701299280
CrossRef
Academic Medicine
Reasoning when it counts: Students' rationales for action on a professionalism exam
Ginsburg, SR; Regehr, G; Mylopoulos, M
Academic Medicine, 82(): S40-S43.

Perspectives in Biology and Medicine
MEDICAL PROFESSIONALISM crossing a generational divide
Walsh, C; Abelson, HT
Perspectives in Biology and Medicine, 51(4): 554-564.

Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics
Conflict of Interest Policies Among Institutions and Organizations Offering Chiropractic Continuing Education
Funk, MF; Lisi, AJ
Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics, 32(4): 303-308.
10.1016/j.jmpt.2009.03.013
CrossRef
Revista Medica De Chile
Professionalism of physicians from the point of view of physicians and students
Fasce, E; Echeverria, M; Matus, O; Ortiz, L; Palacios, S; Soto, A
Revista Medica De Chile, 137(6): 746-752.

Journal of Veterinary Medical Education
Professionalism in the health sciences: Lessons learned from its definition, evaluation, and teaching in a medical school
Talbott, JA
Journal of Veterinary Medical Education, 32(2): 237-241.

Clinical Anatomy
Using gross anatomy to teach and assess professionalism in the first year of medical school
Swartz, WJ
Clinical Anatomy, 19(5): 437-441.
10.1002/ca.20331
CrossRef
Medical Education
Professionalism and the basic sciences: an untapped resource
Macpherson, C; Kenny, N
Medical Education, 42(2): 183-188.
10.1111/j.1365-2923.2007.02967.x
CrossRef
Medical Education
Exploring perceptions and attitudes of senior medical students and interns to academic integrity
Elzubeir, MA; Rizk, DEE
Medical Education, 37(7): 589-596.

Medical Education
Defining professionalism in anaesthesiology
Kearney, RA
Medical Education, 39(8): 769-776.
10.1111/j.1365-2929.2005.02233.x
CrossRef
Medical Teacher
Assessing professionalism: theory and practice
Parker, M
Medical Teacher, 28(5): 399-403.
10.1080/01421590600625619
CrossRef
Kaohsiung Journal of Medical Sciences
Developing the "why" facet of medical professionalism
Nomura, H
Kaohsiung Journal of Medical Sciences, 24(1): 31-34.

Best Practice & Research in Clinical Rheumatology
How to achieve and enhance professionalism in rheumatology
Woolf, AD
Best Practice & Research in Clinical Rheumatology, 23(2): 127-144.
10.1016/j.berh.2009.03.002
CrossRef
Medical Teacher
Assessment of matriculating medical students' knowledge and attitudes towards professionalism
Blue, AV; Crandall, S; Nowacek, G; Luecht, R; Chauvin, S; Swick, H
Medical Teacher, 31(): 928-932.
10.3109/01421590802574565
CrossRef
Perspectives in Biology and Medicine
MEDICAL EDUCATION AS MORAL FORMATION an Aristotelian account of medical professionalsim
Kinghorn, WA
Perspectives in Biology and Medicine, 53(1): 87-105.

New Zealand Medical Journal
Reaffirming professionalism in medicine
Bagshaw, P; Begg, E; Moller, P; Nicholls, G; Toop, L; Winterbourn, C
New Zealand Medical Journal, 114(): 347-348.

Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics
Educating for professionalism: What counts? Who's counting?
Surdyk, PM
Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics, 12(2): 155-160.

Teaching and Learning in Medicine
e-Professionalism: A New Frontier in Medical Education
Kaczmarczyk, JM; Chuang, A; Dugoff, L; Abbott, JF; Cullimore, AJ; Dalrymple, J; Davis, KR; Hueppchen, NA; Katz, NT; Nuthalapaty, FS; Pradhan, A; Wolf, A; Casey, PM
Teaching and Learning in Medicine, 25(2): 165-170.
10.1080/10401334.2013.770741
CrossRef
Medical Teacher
Teaching professionalism in medical education: A Best Evidence Medical Education (BEME) systematic review. BEME Guide No. 25
Birden, H; Glass, N; Wilson, I; Harrison, M; Usherwood, T; Nass, D
Medical Teacher, 35(7): E1252-E1266.
10.3109/0142159X.2013.789132
CrossRef
Pakistan Journal of Medical Sciences
Academic misconduct among students in Medical Colleges of Karachi, Pakistan
Hafeez, K; Khan, MLUZ; Jawaid, M; Haroon, S
Pakistan Journal of Medical Sciences, 29(3): 699-702.
10.12669/pjms.293.3300
CrossRef
American Heart Journal
Rescuing clinical trials in the United States and beyond: A call for action
Eapen, ZJ; Vavalle, JP; Granger, CB; Harrington, RA; Peterson, ED; Califf, RM
American Heart Journal, 165(6): 837-847.
10.1016/j.ahj.2013.02.003
CrossRef
Academic Medicine
Viewpoint: Professionalism in Modern Medicine: Does the Emperor Have Any Clothes?
Kinghorn, WA; McEvoy, MD; Michel, A; Balboni, M
Academic Medicine, 82(1): 40-45.
10.1097/01.ACM.0000249911.79915.4d
PDF (54) | CrossRef
Academic Medicine
What Students Learn About Professionalism From Faculty Stories: An “Appreciative Inquiry” Approach
Quaintance, JL; Arnold, L; Thompson, GS
Academic Medicine, 85(1): 118-123.
10.1097/ACM.0b013e3181c42acd
PDF (60) | CrossRef
Academic Medicine
Observation, Reflection, and Reinforcement: Surgery Faculty Members' and Residents' Perceptions of How They Learned Professionalism
Park, J; Woodrow, SI; Reznick, RK; Beales, J; MacRae, HM
Academic Medicine, 85(1): 134-139.
10.1097/ACM.0b013e3181c47b25
PDF (58) | CrossRef
Academic Medicine
The Increasing Complexities of Professionalism
Hafferty, FW; Castellani, B
Academic Medicine, 85(2): 288-301.
10.1097/ACM.0b013e3181c85b43
PDF (896) | CrossRef
Academic Medicine
The Role of Social and Community Service in Medical Education: The Next 100 Years
Muller, D; Meah, Y; Griffith, J; Palermo, A; Kaufman, A; Smith, KL; Lieberman, S
Academic Medicine, 85(2): 302-309.
10.1097/ACM.0b013e3181c88434
PDF (247) | CrossRef
Academic Medicine
Professional Formation: Extending Medicine's Lineage of Service Into the Next Century
Rabow, MW; Remen, RN; Parmelee, DX; Inui, TS
Academic Medicine, 85(2): 310-317.
10.1097/ACM.0b013e3181c887f7
PDF (252) | CrossRef
Academic Medicine
A New Way to Integrate Clinically Relevant Technology into Small-Group Teaching
Silk, H; Agresta, T; Weber, CM
Academic Medicine, 81(3): 239-244.

PDF (67)
Academic Medicine
“Once When I was On Call…,” Theory versus Reality in Training for Professionalism
Eggly, S; Brennan, S; Wiese-Rometsch, W
Academic Medicine, 80(4): 371-375.

PDF (60)
Academic Medicine
A Blueprint to Assess Professionalism: Results of a Systematic Review
Wilkinson, TJ; Wade, WB; Knock, LD
Academic Medicine, 84(5): 551-558.
10.1097/ACM.0b013e31819fbaa2
PDF (73) | CrossRef
Academic Medicine
Evaluating Physicians' Professionalism and Humanism: The Case for Humanism “Connoisseurs”
Misch, DA
Academic Medicine, 77(6): 489-495.

PDF (116)
Academic Medicine
Assessing Professional Behavior: Yesterday, Today, and Tomorrow
Arnold, L
Academic Medicine, 77(6): 502-515.

PDF (168)
Academic Medicine
Promoting Reflection on Professionalism: A Comparison Trial of Educational Interventions for Medical Students
Baernstein, A; Fryer-Edwards, K
Academic Medicine, 78(7): 742-747.

PDF (82)
Academic Medicine
The “Pyramid of Professionalism”: Seven Years of Experience With an Integrated Program of Teaching, Developing, and Assessing Professionalism Among Medical Students
Parker, M; Luke, H; Zhang, J; Wilkinson, D; Peterson, R; Ozolins, I
Academic Medicine, 83(8): 733-741.
10.1097/ACM.0b013e31817ec5e4
PDF (267) | CrossRef
Academic Medicine
Developing an OSTE to Address Lapses in Learners’ Professional Behavior and an Instrument to Code Educators’ Responses
Srinivasan, M; Litzelman, D; Seshadri, R; Lane, K; Zhou, W; Bogdewic, S; Gaffney, M; Galvin, M; Mitchell, G; Treadwell, P; Willis, L
Academic Medicine, 79(9): 888-896.

PDF (103)
Anesthesiology
Assessment of Competency in Anesthesiology
Tetzlaff, JE
Anesthesiology, 106(4): 812-825.
10.1097/01.anes.0000264778.02286.4d
PDF (422) | CrossRef
Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine
Occupational Medicine Residency Graduate Survey: Assessment of Training Programs and Core Competencies
Baker, BA; Katyal, S; Greaves, IA; Rice, HR; Emmett, EA; Meyer, JD; He, W
Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine, 49(12): 1325-1338.
10.1097/JOM.0b013e318159b48f
PDF (288) | CrossRef
Back to Top | Article Outline

© 2000 Association of American Medical Colleges

Login

Article Tools

Share