Purpose: Instrument development consistent with best practices is necessary for effective assessment and evaluation of learners and programs across the medical education continuum. The author explored the extent to which current factor analytic methods and other techniques for establishing validity are consistent with best practices.
Method: The author conducted electronic and hand searches of the English-language medical education literature published January 2006 through December 2010. To describe and assess current practices, she systematically abstracted reliability and validity evidence as well as factor analysis methods, data analysis, and reported evidence from instrument development articles reporting the application of exploratory factor analysis and principal component analysis.
Results: Sixty-two articles met eligibility criteria. They described 64 instruments and 95 factor analyses. Most studies provided at least one source of evidence based on test content. Almost all reported internal consistency, providing evidence based on internal structure. Evidence based on response process and relationships with other variables was reported less often, and evidence based on consequences of testing was not identified. Factor analysis findings suggest common method selection errors and critical omissions in reporting.
Conclusions: Given the limited reliability and validity evidence provided for the reviewed instruments, educators should carefully consider the available supporting evidence before adopting and applying published instruments. Researchers should design for, test, and report additional evidence to strengthen the argument for reliability and validity of these measures for research and practice.
Dr. Wetzel is director of assessment, Department of Foundations of Education, Virginia Commonwealth University School of Education, Richmond, Virginia. At the time of writing, she was a graduate assistant, Office of Assessment and Evaluation Studies, Virginia Commonwealth University School of Medicine, Richmond, Virginia.
Correspondence should be addressed to Dr. Wetzel, Office of Assessment, Department of Foundations of Education, VCU School of Education, 1015 West Main St., Room 2128, Box 842020, Richmond, VA 23284-2020; telephone: (804) 828-8673; e-mail: email@example.com.