The Hidden Curriculum: What Can We Learn From Third-Year Medical Student Narrative Reflections?

Gaufberg, Elizabeth H. MD, MPH; Batalden, Maren MD, MPH; Sands, Rebecca DO; Bell, Sigall K. MD

doi: 10.1097/ACM.0b013e3181f57899
Medical School Education

Purpose: To probe medical students' narrative essays as a rich source of data on the hidden curriculum, a powerful influence shaping the values, roles, and identity of medical trainees.

Method: In 2008, the authors used grounded theory to conduct a thematic analysis of third-year Harvard Medical School students' reflection papers on the hidden curriculum.

Results: Four overarching concepts were apparent in almost all of the papers: medicine as culture (with distinct subcultures, rules, vocabulary, and customs); the importance of haphazard interactions to learning; role modeling; and the tension between real medicine and prior idealized notions. The authors identified nine discrete “core themes” and coded each paper with up to four core themes based on predominant content. Of the 30 students (91% of essay writers, 20% of class) who consented to the study, 50% focused on power–hierarchy issues in training and patient care; 30% described patient dehumanization; 27%, respectively, detailed some “hidden assessment” of their performance, discussed the suppression of normal emotional responses, mentioned struggling with the limits of medicine, and recognized personal emerging accountability in their medical training; 23% wrote about the elusive search for personal/professional balance and contemplated the sense of “faking it” as a young doctor; and 20% relayed experiences derived from the positive power of human connection.

Conclusions: Students' reflections on the hidden curriculum are a rich resource for gaining a deeper understanding of how the hidden curriculum shapes medical trainees. Ultimately, medical educators may use these results to inform, revise, and humanize clinical medical education.

Dr. Gaufberg is assistant professor of medicine and assistant professor of psychiatry, Harvard Medical School, Cambridge Health Alliance, Cambridge, Massachusetts.

Dr. Batalden is instructor in medicine, Harvard Medical School, Cambridge Health Alliance, Cambridge, Massachusetts.

Dr. Sands is clinical fellow in medicine, Harvard Medical School, Cambridge Health Alliance, Cambridge, Massachusetts.

Dr. Bell is assistant professor of medicine, Harvard Medical School, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts.

Correspondence should be addressed to Dr. Gaufberg, Cambridge Health Alliance, 1493 Cambridge St., Cambridge, MA 02139; telephone: (617) 665-1343; fax: (617) 665-1671; e-mail: Elizabeth_gaufberg@hms.harvard.edu.

First published online September 28, 2010

© 2010 Association of American Medical Colleges